30-60-90 day plan for claims adjusters
On this page
A claims adjuster is where an insurance policy meets the person who bought it. Every file has deadlines that come from state law, a coverage question that has to be answered from the policy language, a reserve that finance relies on and a claimant who will remember how they were treated. A new adjuster who closes files quickly but documents poorly creates exposure in market conduct exams and bad faith claims that shows up much later. A 30-60-90 day plan for claims adjusters should cover licensing and state claim rules first, build habits on a reduced desk under file review and then hand over a full pending with settlement authority.
This plan is for the claims manager or supervisor hiring a staff desk or field adjuster for personal or commercial property and casualty claims. The sales side of the same policies is in the 30-60-90 day plan for insurance agents, and the general structure is in the 30-60-90 day plan template for new hires.
Licensing and fair claims settlement rules
Adjuster licensing is set by each state, and requirements differ; some states do not license adjusters. Check the insurance department in every state the adjuster will handle. Claim handling standards also come from state law, and many states base them on the NAIC's Unfair Claims Settlement Practices Act and its model regulations. As an example of what those rules look like, the NAIC's Unfair Property/Casualty Claims Settlement Practices Model Regulation, which does not cover workers' compensation and counts days as calendar days, provides that:
- An insurer acknowledges a claim notice within 15 days unless payment is made within that time, and replies within 15 days to other pertinent communications that reasonably suggest a response is expected.
- An insurer responds to an insurance department inquiry about a claim within 21 days.
- A first party claimant is told whether the claim is accepted or denied within 21 days after the insurer receives properly executed proofs of loss. If more time is needed, the insurer says so within those 21 days, and sends a letter with the reasons every 45 days while the investigation remains incomplete.
- A denial based on a policy provision, condition or exclusion must refer to it, be given in writing and be documented in the claim file.
- Payment is tendered within 30 days of affirming liability when the amount is determined and not in dispute.
- Each claim file contains enough documentation to reconstruct the insurer's activities on the claim.
These are model provisions, not the law in any particular state, and states change the deadlines and add their own. Use the regulation in each state the adjuster handles, as of October 2026, and confirm with the company's compliance team. This is not legal advice.
The 30-60-90 day plan
30-60-90 day plan — [Name], Claims Adjuster, [company]
Reports to: [claims supervisor] Start: [date]
Lines: [auto / property / general liability]
States handled: [list] License: [states / not required]
Systems: [claims system / estimating] Authority: [see letter]
DAYS 1-30 — Licensed, trained and shadowing
Goals:
- License confirmed in each state handled, where required
- Learn the claim rules for those states: acknowledgment,
decision and payment deadlines, and denial letters
- Learn the claims system, diary, reserving and
estimating tools
- Shadow first notice of loss, coverage calls and
settlement discussions
- Handle a reduced pending of simple claims (example:
auto physical damage) with each file reviewed
Deliverables by day 30:
- File review findings logged by type
- State deadline sheet in the adjuster's own words
Check-in: day 30, with [supervisor]
DAYS 31-60 — Growing desk
Goals:
- Step the pending up as reviews show habits holding
- Add claim types with coverage questions
- Set and update reserves with supervisor review
- Write reservation of rights and denial letters
for review before they go out
Deliverables by day 60:
- No missed state deadlines on the desk
- Reserve changes explained in file notes
Check-in: day 60
DAYS 61-90 — Full desk
Goals:
- Carry the standard pending within an authority letter
- Settle within authority; refer above it
- Monthly file audit on a sample
Deliverables by day 90:
- Standard desk with clean audits
- Authority letter confirmed or widened
Check-in: day 90 — full reviewWhat to measure
The legal deadlines are requirements, not targets. The other standards below are examples only; set them from how past new adjusters on your team progressed.
| Measure | Why it matters | Example standard (example only) |
|---|---|---|
| Acknowledgment and decision letters on time | Required by state rules; examined in market conduct reviews | No missed deadlines on any audited file |
| Initial contact with insured and claimant | Early contact shapes the claimant's experience | Within the team's own standard |
| Diary compliance | Files without a next step drift | Every open file has a current diary date |
| Reserve accuracy | Finance relies on reserves | Large reserve changes explained in notes |
| File audit score | Covers coverage analysis, documentation and letters | Rising from the first audit to the third |
A filled example
Claims adjuster: Hannah Weiss (invented), newly licensed, previously a customer service representative at an auto insurer, joining a regional carrier's auto claims desk.
Day 30: License confirmed for her home state; a nonresident license for a neighboring state was still pending, so those claims stayed with others. Reviews showed good contact notes but missing coverage verification on two files. She wrote her own deadline sheet for both states.
Day 60: Her pending grew and she added bodily injury claims with supervisor review. She drafted her first reservation of rights letter, which her supervisor revised for policy language.
Day 90: Carried the standard desk with authority for physical damage settlements. Her third audit was clean on deadlines and diary, with one finding on reserve notes.
What "on track" looks like
| Checkpoint | On track | Worth a direct conversation |
|---|---|---|
| Day 30 | Licensed where required; state rules learned; reviews improving | Handling claims in states without the license required |
| Day 60 | No missed deadlines; reserves explained | Letters sent without required review |
| Day 90 | Full desk; clean audits | Files closed quickly with thin documentation |
Documentation that holds up
A claim file is read later by people who were not there: a supervisor, an auditor, a regulator or a court. Teach the new adjuster to write notes that let a stranger reconstruct the claim: what was reported, what coverage applies and why, who was contacted and when, what was decided and on what basis. Review a sample of notes at every check-in, the same way you review payments and reserves. The interview guide for insurance roles covers how to test for this habit before hiring.
Reserving habits
Reserves are the company's estimate of what each claim will cost, and finance, reinsurance and actuarial work all depend on them. New adjusters tend either to set a low reserve and raise it in steps as bills arrive, or to set a high one and leave it. Teach the department's reserving philosophy in the first month with examples from closed files. Ask the adjuster to explain every reserve in the file notes: what is known, what is expected and why the number changed. Review reserve changes over the authority threshold together until day 90, and compare paid amounts with the reserves set on closed files to show where their estimates run high or low.
What the company owes the new adjuster
- A written state rules sheet for every state on the desk.
- A staged pending and a written authority letter.
- Prompt file reviews with specific findings.
- Letter templates reviewed by compliance for each state.
Common mistakes
| Mistake | Result | Fix |
|---|---|---|
| A full desk from week two | Missed deadlines and thin files | Staged pending tied to review findings |
| One deadline sheet for all states | Late letters where rules differ | A sheet for each state handled |
| Denials without the policy language | Complaints and regulatory findings | Reviewed denial letters citing the provision |
| Reserves set once and left | Surprise reserve jumps | Reserve review at every major development |
Adapting the plan
- Field and property adjusters: add inspections with a senior adjuster, estimating software sign-off and catastrophe deployment rules.
- Independent adjusters: add each carrier's guidelines and reporting formats.
- Workers' compensation: replace the property and casualty rules with the state's workers' compensation statute and its benefit timelines.
If you are still hiring, the claims adjuster screening questions cover licensing and judgment, and the 30-60-90 day plan for underwriters shows how the company onboards the people who write the policies adjusters handle.
Questions people ask
What claim handling deadlines should a new adjuster learn first?
The ones in the states they handle. Many states base their rules on NAIC models; the NAIC's property and casualty model regulation, for example, sets 15 days to acknowledge a claim notice, 21 days after proof of loss to accept or deny a first party claim or explain why more time is needed, and a letter every 45 days while the investigation stays open. State rules differ, so use the state's own regulation. This is not legal advice.
Does every state license claims adjusters?
No. Licensing requirements vary by state, and some states do not license adjusters at all. Check the insurance department in each state where the adjuster will handle claims, including any requirements for nonresident or independent adjusters.
How big should a new adjuster's pending be?
Smaller than the standard desk, with simpler claim types, growing in steps as file reviews show diary, contact and documentation habits holding. Write the steps into the plan and decide each one on review findings, not on the calendar alone.
How do you measure a claims adjuster's first 90 days?
With file quality first: timely acknowledgment and contact, documented coverage analysis, diary compliance, reserve accuracy and clear written denials. Cycle time and closure counts matter later and should be compared with how past new adjusters ramped.