Concierge screening questions: local knowledge, impossible requests, vendor relationships and discretion
On this page
Concierge screening questions should test what a guest or resident actually relies on a concierge for: current local knowledge, a network of people who will pick up the phone, judgment when the request is difficult or inappropriate, and discretion. Every candidate will say they love helping people. The screen should find out whether they can get a table at a fully booked restaurant tonight, and whether they know when to say no.
This page covers lobby concierges in hotels and resorts, residential building concierges, and corporate or lifestyle concierge roles. For front desk agents and night auditors, use hotel front desk screening questions; for the general structure of hospitality interviews, see the interview guide for hospitality roles.
Which concierge role
| Setting | What the job really is | Ask the candidate |
|---|---|---|
| Luxury or upscale hotel | Reservations, tickets, transport, special occasions, VIP arrivals, sometimes in several languages | "What was the hardest request you filled last month?" |
| Resort | Activities, excursions, on-property bookings, outside vendors | "Which outside vendors did you book, and how did you vet them?" |
| Residential building | Packages, visitors and access, residents' service requests, building rules, deliveries | "How did you handle visitors and deliveries for residents who were away?" |
| Corporate or lifestyle | Errands, travel, events and personal requests for employees or members | "How did you track requests and confirm they were done?" |
Knockout questions
| Question | What a strong answer sounds like | Red flags |
|---|---|---|
| How long have you lived or worked in this city, and which neighborhoods do you know best? | Specific neighborhoods, recent openings and closings, and honest about gaps. | Relocating next month and plans to "look things up." |
| The desk runs [early mornings, late evenings, weekends and holidays]. Can you work that? | Yes, or a clear limit. | Only weekday daytime, for a hotel desk. |
| This role is [hourly plus tips, or salaried] and the property's policy on vendor commissions is [policy]. Does that work for you? | Asks a good question about the policy. | Expects commissions from vendors the property does not allow. |
| The role needs [Spanish, Mandarin, or another language] with guests. How comfortable are you using it at work? | Describes real use: calls, bookings, written confirmations. | Lists a language they cannot use on the phone. Ask only when the job requires the language. |
Local knowledge tests
Give two or three realistic requests and ask for specific answers. You do not need to know the city as well as they do; listen for names, reasons and a plan.
-
"A couple wants a quiet anniversary dinner tonight, walking distance, no tasting menu."
- Strong answer: two or three named restaurants with a reason each fits, which one they would call first and who they would ask for, and a backup if all are full.
- Red flags: only the most famous restaurants, or a booking app.
-
"A family with two young kids has one free day and no car."
- Strong answer: a realistic plan with timing, transit or a car service, places that work for small children, and a rainy-day alternative.
- Red flags: a list of attractions without timing or transport.
-
"A guest's suit needs pressing and a button replaced before a 9 a.m. meeting, and it is 10 p.m."
- Strong answer: the property's own valet or laundry service and its cutoff, a named outside tailor or the housekeeping team for the button, and confirming delivery time with the guest.
- Red flags: "Nothing is open now."
Hard requests and judgment
| Scenario to ask | What a strong answer sounds like | Red flags |
|---|---|---|
| "A guest wants a table at a restaurant that is fully booked for weeks." | Calls a contact there, asks about the bar or a late seating, offers comparable alternatives, and never promises before it is confirmed. | Promises the table and hopes. |
| "A guest asks you to get them something illegal or arrange something you are uncomfortable with." | Declines politely, follows the property's policy, informs a manager or security if needed. | Treats it as a tip opportunity. |
| "You booked a car service and it does not show." | Calls the vendor, sends a backup car or taxi, covers the guest's time, follows up and decides whether to keep using that vendor. | Blames the vendor to the guest and stops there. |
| "A resident's package went missing from the package room." | Checks logs and footage as the building allows, informs the manager and carrier, documents it, and reviews the process. | Says packages are not their responsibility. |
| "A guest is rude to you in front of other guests." | Stays calm, moves the conversation aside, solves what can be solved, involves a manager when needed. | Argues, or tells the story with obvious resentment. |
Vendors, commissions and tips
Concierges work with restaurants, car services, tour operators and ticket brokers, and some of those vendors offer commissions or gifts. Ask how the candidate chose which vendors to recommend, whether their last property allowed vendor commissions and how they disclosed them, and what they would do if a vendor offered them money to steer guests. A strong answer puts the guest's interest first and follows the property's written policy.
As of October 2026, not legal advice. Under the federal Fair Labor Standards Act, the U.S. Department of Labor's Fact Sheet #15 says an employer, including managers and supervisors, may not keep employees' tips, and sets rules for tip pools. States may add their own rules. If the property pays a tip credit or runs a tip pool, confirm it with the employer before quoting pay to a candidate.
Professional background questions
- "Which systems did you use to log requests?" Strong: the property's concierge or guest request software, the PMS, or a shared log, and how requests were handed over between shifts.
- "Are you a member of Les Clefs d'Or, or working toward it?" Membership is a mark of experience, not a legal requirement. As of October 2026, Les Clefs d'Or USA lists five years in a hotel front office setting, including at least three years as a full-time lobby concierge, with the final year continuous. Verify a claimed membership with the association.
- "How do you keep your knowledge current?" Strong: visits new places, keeps in touch with contacts, attends vendor familiarization visits, follows local news.
- "Tell me about a guest you still remember." Listen for detail and warmth, and for discretion: a strong concierge does not name famous guests on a screening call.
Residential concierge specifics
Building concierges sit closer to property management and security. Ask how they managed visitor access and keys, deliveries for absent residents, move-ins and elevator bookings, contractor sign-in, and incident reports. If the role includes security duties such as patrols or controlling access as a guard, check whether the state requires a security license for that work and use the questions in security guard screening questions. For buildings managed by an outside firm, the property manager screening questions show what the concierge's manager will expect.
Discretion and guest information
A concierge sees room numbers, travel plans, credit card holds, visitors and sometimes medical or family situations. Ask three questions here. "Someone calls asking whether a named guest is staying with you. What do you say?" A strong answer follows the property's privacy policy, typically neither confirming nor denying, and offers to take a message. "A resident's ex-partner arrives and asks to be let up." Strong: does not admit anyone who is not on the resident's approved list, calls the resident, and involves security or management if the visitor will not leave. "How do you store notes about guests' preferences?" Strong: in the property's system, factual and respectful, never on a personal phone or in a personal notebook taken home. These answers matter more than polish; a single lapse can cost the property a long-standing guest.
How concierge experience gets overstated
- Front desk agents who answered occasional recommendation questions describing themselves as concierges. Ask what share of their shift was concierge work.
- "Connections everywhere" with no names. Ask who they would call for three specific requests.
- Golden keys claimed without membership. Verify with the association.
- Celebrity stories. Discretion is part of the job; a candidate who shares private details about guests will share yours.
Scoring
Pass or fail
- Current local knowledge for the property's area.
- Schedule and pay structure accepted, including the vendor commission policy.
- Any language the role requires, usable on the phone.
Scored 0 to 2 each (10 possible)
- Specificity of recommendations.
- Network of contacts.
- Recovery when something goes wrong.
- Judgment and ethics (inappropriate requests, vendor money).
- Discretion and tone.
In the submittal, include the neighborhoods and categories they know best, the systems used, languages used at work, any association membership (verified or not, and say which), and one example request in their own words. Do not ask about national origin to judge a language; ask about the skill the job needs.
Questions people ask
What makes a good concierge candidate?
Deep, current local knowledge, a network of contacts they can call, calm problem-solving when the request seems impossible, and discretion with guests' or residents' private information. Polished manners matter, but a screen should test the knowledge and the network with specific questions.
What is Les Clefs d'Or and does a concierge need it?
Les Clefs d'Or is the professional association of hotel lobby concierges, whose members wear the crossed golden keys. It is a membership, not a license, and no job legally requires it. As of October 2026, Les Clefs d'Or USA says applicants must have worked five years in a hotel front office setting, including at least three years as a full-time lobby concierge, with the final year continuous before applying.
Can a hotel keep part of a concierge's tips?
Under the federal Fair Labor Standards Act, the U.S. Department of Labor says an employer, including managers and supervisors, may not keep employees' tips; valid tip pools among eligible employees are allowed under specific rules, and state law may add more. A property's policy on vendor commissions is a separate question to settle with the employer.
How do you test local knowledge on a phone screen?
Ask for three specific, current recommendations for a realistic request, such as a quiet anniversary dinner within walking distance or a last-minute table at a fully booked restaurant, and ask how they would actually get it. Strong candidates name places, people and the reason each fits the guest.