E-Verify audit checklist: a self-audit of cases, timing, notices, posters and records
On this page
- How do you run an E-Verify self-audit, step by step?
- Account and access checklist
- Case creation checklist
- Mismatch checklist
- Case closure and records checklist
- How do you fix what the audit finds?
- Who audits what when a staffing agency or employer agent is involved?
- How often should you audit?
- Questions people ask
An E-Verify self-audit checks your account and your cases against the two documents that bind you: the E-Verify memorandum of understanding (MOU) and the current E-Verify User Manual. As of November 2026 that means five areas: account and access (users, points of contact, hiring sites, the two posters), case creation (every new hire, no later than the third business day after work for pay starts, with correct data and photo-matching copies), mismatches (Further Action Notice, employee decision, referral), case closure (every case closed with the right statement), and records (case numbers and notices filed with the Form I-9). E-Verify's own Self-Assessment Guide recommends account maintenance "once or twice a year."
The checklist below is built only from duties in the MOU and the manual, with the section for each line. It is the E-Verify half of a compliance review; the Form I-9 half is in the I-9 audit checklist, and what E-Verify's own reviewers look for is in E-Verify Monitoring and Compliance.
Not legal advice. This checklist summarizes the E-Verify MOU for employers (Articles II.A.1 to II.A.18), the E-Verify User Manual (Sections 1.5, 1.6, 2.1 to 2.3, 3.3, 4.1, 4.2, 5.0, 7.2, 7.3 and 7.4) and the Self-Assessment Guide for E-Verify Direct Access Users, as of November 2026. Federal contractors with the FAR E-Verify clause also follow the Supplemental Guide for Federal Contractors.
How do you run an E-Verify self-audit, step by step?
- Pick the period, for example the last 12 months (an example, not a rule).
- Get the hire list from payroll: name, Social Security number and date of hire or rehire for everyone added in the period. It is the same kind of list E-Verify's desk reviews request.
- Get the case list. Run the Quick Audit Report (User Manual Section 5.0), which gives case data in a .csv file without full Social Security numbers. See E-Verify reports for employers.
- Match the two lists. Every new hire at a participating hiring site should have a case; every case should belong to a new hire.
- Review a sample of files, or all of them if the population is small, against the checklist below.
- Fix what the manual allows, using the table further down, and write down what you changed and why.
- Retrain and repeat. Book the next review before you close this one.
Account and access checklist
| Check | What the rule says | Source |
|---|---|---|
| Every user still works for you and still needs access | Grant access only to current employees who need it and promptly terminate access for anyone who leaves | MOU II.A.3; Manual 7.2.1 |
| Each user has their own login | Do not share login information; browser users sign in through Login.gov | Account Compliance page; Manual 1.6 |
| Every user completed the tutorial and any refresher | Failing a refresher tutorial blocks continued use | MOU II.A.5 |
| At least one program administrator and one current point of contact | Give SSA and DHS your E-Verify contacts and keep them current | MOU II.A.2; Manual 7.3.3 |
| Company profile, employer category and hiring sites are current | A hiring site is where employees are hired and complete Form I-9; every new hire there gets a case | Manual 7.3, 7.3.4 |
| Notice of E-Verify Participation and the Right to Work poster are displayed, in English and Spanish, at hiring sites and online for remote hires | Display both notices clearly to prospective and current employees; digital display and copies with application materials count | MOU II.A.1; Manual 1.5 |
| Careers pages and agency marketing make no "federally approved" claims and use no E-Verify logo without a license | No false or unauthorized claims about participation | MOU II.A.19 to II.A.21 |
Poster details are in E-Verify posters; user roles in E-Verify user roles.
Case creation checklist
| Check | What the rule says | Source |
|---|---|---|
| Every new hire in the period has a case | Use E-Verify for all new employees; no selective verification | MOU II.A.11 |
| No case was created before the offer was accepted and the Form I-9 completed | No pre-employment screening | MOU II.A.9, II.A.10 |
| Each case was created no later than the third business day after work for pay started, or has an accurate reason for delay | Reasons include Awaiting Social Security Number, Technical Problems and Audit Revealed that New Hire Was Not Run | Manual 2.2; see three-day rule |
| The first day of employment in the case matches Section 2 of the Form I-9 | Enter the first day recorded in Section 2 | Manual 2.2, 2.2.1 |
| No cases for existing employees, for employees hired before the MOU took effect, or for anyone hired on or before November 6, 1986 | Only federal contractors with the FAR clause may verify existing employees | MOU II.A.11; Manual 2.2, 2.2.1 |
| Citizenship status, documents and email address match what the employee gave on the Form I-9 | Enter the email address if it was provided; otherwise mark No email address provided | Manual 2.2 |
| Every List B document has a photo, and nobody was asked for a particular document | Only photo List B documents; never specify documents | MOU II.A.6; Manual 1.5, 2.1 |
| No duplicate cases without a valid reason | Review the Duplicate Cases Found alert before continuing | Manual 2.3; see duplicate cases |
| A front-and-back copy (passport ID and barcode pages for passports) of every document that triggered photo matching is with the Form I-9 | Copy U.S. passports, passport cards, Forms I-551 and I-766 and keep the copy with the Form I-9 | MOU II.A.6(b); Manual 2.2.2; see photo matching |
Mismatch checklist
| Check | What the rule says | Source |
|---|---|---|
| The employee was told in private and given the Further Action Notice, with a translation where needed | Notify as soon as possible, within 10 federal government working days after the mismatch was issued | MOU II.A.12; Manual 3.3.1 |
| The employee marked a decision and signed and dated the English notice; they got a copy; the original is with the Form I-9 | Attach the original signed notice to the Form I-9 | Manual 3.3.1 |
| If the employee took action, the case was referred and the Referral Date Confirmation given, with a copy on the Form I-9 | The employee then has eight federal government working days to contact DHS or visit SSA | Manual 3.3.2, 3.3.3 |
| Nothing changed for the employee while the case was pending | No termination, suspension, delayed training, withheld pay or other adverse action because of a mismatch | MOU II.A.13; Manual 3.3 |
| No mismatch sat open with no action past the 10th federal government working day | If no decision by then, close the case | Manual 3.3.1 |
The notice itself is explained in E-Verify Further Action Notice.
Case closure and records checklist
| Check | What the rule says | Source |
|---|---|---|
| The Open Cases to be Closed alert shows only cases still waiting for a result | Every case with a case number must be closed; cases still in process cannot be closed until a final result | Manual 4.1, 4.2.1; October 2021 notice |
| Each closed case used the statement that matches what happened | Select the most appropriate closure statement | Manual 4.1, 4.1.1; see closing a case |
| Anyone kept on after a Final Nonconfirmation was reported to DHS at closure, with the reason | Select the continued-employment statement and give the reason | Manual 4.1; MOU II.A.8 |
| The case number is on each Form I-9, or the case details page is attached | Record the case verification number | MOU II.A.7; Manual 4.1 |
| Expiring work authorization was handled in Supplement B, not with a new case | For reverification, do not create a new E-Verify case | Manual 4.2.3 |
| E-Verify records are stored securely and kept as long as the related Forms I-9 | Safeguard personal information; keep case information for the same time as the Forms I-9 | MOU II.A.15; Manual 1.6, 7.4 |
USCIS deletes E-Verify records over 10 years old each year under its records schedule (Manual Section 1.6), and the Historic Records Report is open to administrators for three months each fall (Section 5.0); see E-Verify records disposal.
How do you fix what the audit finds?
| Finding | What to do | Source |
|---|---|---|
| A new hire was never run | Create the case now and choose Audit Revealed that New Hire Was Not Run as the reason | Manual 2.2 |
| A case was created with wrong data | Close it as "data entered is incorrect" and create a new case with the correct data | Manual 2.2.3, 4.1.1 |
| A case with a final result is still open | Close it with the statement that matches the facts | Manual 4.1 |
| A duplicate case is open | Close it as a duplicate | Manual 2.3, 4.1.1 |
| A case number is missing from a Form I-9 | Look it up in View/Search Cases and record it, or attach the case details page | Manual 4.1, 4.2 |
| A former employee still has a login | Delete the user account | Manual 7.2.1 |
| Posters are missing at a site or online | Display both, in English and Spanish | Manual 1.5 |
| Cases exist for people who were not new hires | Stop creating them; E-Verify publishes no correction step, so ask the E-Verify Contact Center (888-464-4218) how to handle the existing cases | MOU II.A.11; Manual 8.0 |
Two things an audit must not do: run current employees "to be safe" (MOU Article II.A.11 forbids it, outside the federal contractor exception) and ask employees to use Self Check or myE-Verify, which Account Compliance lists among common mistakes. If you never created cases for a long stretch, read the guidance on dormant accounts in E-Verify for existing employees before running anyone.
Who audits what when a staffing agency or employer agent is involved?
The account that creates the cases owns the case-level checks. A staffing agency that employs the workers it places audits its own account; a client of an E-Verify employer agent should ask the agent for a report of its cases and the file evidence, because the agent creates the cases. Who displays the posters in each arrangement is covered in E-Verify posters. See E-Verify for staffing agencies.
How often should you audit?
- Weekly: clear the Open Cases to be Closed and Cases with Updates alerts (Manual 4.2).
- Once or twice a year: account maintenance, as the Self-Assessment Guide recommends, plus a full match of hires against cases.
- Each fall: check whether you need the Historic Records Report before old records are deleted.
- Before any merger, new federal contract or new state: see E-Verify in mergers and acquisitions and E-Verify requirements by state.
Questions people ask
How do I audit my company's E-Verify program?
Pull a list of everyone hired or rehired in the period from payroll, run E-Verify's Quick Audit Report for the same period, and match the two. Then check each case for timing, correct data, photo matching copies, Further Action Notices and Referral Date Confirmations, closure with the right statement, and a case number on the Form I-9. Finish with the account itself: users, points of contact, hiring sites and posters.
How often should an employer do an E-Verify self-audit?
E-Verify's Self-Assessment Guide recommends account maintenance, such as updating contacts and deleting users who left, once or twice a year. Case-level checks work best more often: the Open Cases to be Closed alert in E-Verify shows every case that still needs closing, so many employers review it weekly.
What do I do if an E-Verify audit finds a new hire who was never run?
Create the case now. The User Manual says an employer that learns it missed the third business day should bring itself into compliance immediately by creating a case, and E-Verify's list of reasons for a late case includes Audit Revealed that New Hire Was Not Run. Do not back-date anything, and do not create cases for employees hired before your MOU took effect.
Is an E-Verify audit the same as a Form I-9 audit?
No. A Form I-9 audit checks the forms against USCIS's rules and is what ICE inspects. An E-Verify audit checks the cases and the account against the E-Verify memorandum of understanding and User Manual. They overlap in the Form I-9 file, where E-Verify employers keep the case number, the Further Action Notice and copies of photo-matching documents, so it is efficient to run them together.