Consent and compliance

E-Verify when a new hire is still waiting for a Social Security number: the hold, the late case and the E-Verify+ route

On this page
  1. What does E-Verify say to do?
  2. What do you do on the first day?
  3. How do you create the case when the number arrives?
  4. Which reason for delay fits?
  5. A copy-ready explanation for the Form I-9
  6. How does it work in E-Verify+?
  7. What must you not do?
  8. What if the new number produces a mismatch?
  9. How do you keep pending cases from slipping?
  10. What should staffing agencies do?
  11. Summary table
  12. Questions people ask

E-Verify cannot run a case without a Social Security number, so when a new hire has applied for one but not yet received it, the case waits and the job does not. As of November 2026, E-Verify's guidance is to complete Form I-9 on the normal timeline with the number left blank, attach an explanation to the form, set it aside, let the employee keep working, and create the case as soon as the number is available. If that is after the third business day after the employee started work for pay, select Awaiting Social Security Number as the reason for the delay. E-Verify+ users follow a separate route: close the first E-Verify+ case as "pending SSN," then create a standard E-Verify case when the number arrives.

The Form I-9 and payroll side of a hire without a number, including the ITIN rule and Form W-2, is covered in Form I-9 without a Social Security number. This page is the E-Verify procedure: what to do on day one, how to file the late case, how E-Verify+ differs, and how to keep pending cases from slipping.

Not legal advice. This summarizes E-Verify's FAQ on employees awaiting a Social Security number (updated January 11, 2024), E-Verify User Manual Sections 2.1 and 2.2, the E-Verify+ information sheet for a pending Social Security number (revised July 2026), the Form I-9 instructions (edition 01/20/25), Handbook for Employers (M-274) Section 3.0 and the E-Verify memorandum of understanding, as of November 2026.

What does E-Verify say to do?

The FAQ is short and direct: "A case cannot be created in E-Verify without an SSN." It then gives the procedure, repeated almost word for word in Section 2.1 of the User Manual: if a newly hired employee "has applied for, but has not yet received his or her SSN (e.g., the employee is a newly arrived immigrant), attach an explanation to the employee's Form I-9 and set it aside. Allow the employee to continue to work and create a case in E-Verify using the employee's SSN as soon as it is available."

The Form I-9 instructions say the same from the employee's side. For E-Verify employers, the employee "must provide" the number in Section 1, but someone who has applied and not received it "should leave the field blank until you receive the number," then update it and "initial and date the notation," and "may begin working while waiting" if they can present acceptable documents.

What do you do on the first day?

  1. Section 1, blank number. The employee completes everything else by the first day of work for pay and leaves the Social Security number field empty. Never let anyone write in an ITIN or a made-up number.
  2. Section 2 as usual. Within three business days of the first day of employment, examine the documents the employee chooses from the Lists of Acceptable Documents. A Social Security card is only one List C option, and the employee does not need one to finish Section 2. As an E-Verify employer, accept a List B document only if it has a photo.
  3. Attach the explanation. A short dated note on or with the Form I-9 (a template is below).
  4. Set the form aside. Put it in a "pending SSN" file or tracker, not back in the general drawer.
  5. Let the employee work. Do not delay the start date, change the schedule or hold pay because the case is waiting.

How do you create the case when the number arrives?

  1. Update Section 1. The employee enters the number and initials and dates the entry.
  2. Create the case the same day if you can. From Cases, Create New Case, enter the Section 1 information, then the citizenship status and the documents from Section 2.
  3. Use the real first day of employment. Enter the date recorded in Section 2, not the date you create the case. Section 2.2.1 of the manual defines it as the day the employee began working for wages.
  4. Pick the delay reason. If the case is created three or more days after that date, E-Verify requires a reason; choose Awaiting Social Security Number.
  5. Review and submit. If E-Verify shows "Is the information below correct?", check every field against the Form I-9, especially the new number, before you continue.
  6. Record the result. Write the case number on the Form I-9 or attach the case details page, and close the case when it is complete; see E-Verify closing a case.

Which reason for delay fits?

Section 2.2 lists six choices for a case created three or more days after the first day of employment:

Reason in the drop-downWhen it fits
Awaiting Social Security NumberThe employee applied for a number and you created the case as soon as it arrived
Technical ProblemsE-Verify or your access was not working; the MOU extends the three-day period while E-Verify is unavailable
Audit Revealed that New Hire Was Not RunA self-audit found a missed case; the manual says to create it immediately
Federal Contractor with E-Verify Clause verifying an existing employeeContractor cases for existing staff assigned to a covered contract
Awaiting Response on Case Created with Incorrect InformationAn earlier case for the employee was created with incorrect information
OtherAnything else; E-Verify requires you to type the reason

Pick the reason that is true for the case, and if none fits, choose Other and type it. Timing rules for every other case are in the E-Verify three-day rule.

A copy-ready explanation for the Form I-9

An example to adapt, not prescribed wording:

Employee [name] has applied for a Social Security number and has not yet received it. Form I-9 Sections 1 and 2 completed on [date]; first day of employment [date]. E-Verify case to be created as soon as the number is provided, per the E-Verify User Manual, Section 2.1. Employee told on [date] to bring the number to [HR contact] when it arrives. [Name, title, date]

When you create the case, add a line with the date and the case number. Keep the note with the form for as long as you keep the Form I-9; see I-9 retention rules.

How does it work in E-Verify+?

E-Verify+ has its own steps, set out in the July 2026 information sheet:

  1. You create an E-Verify+ case; the employee gets the email and signs in to myUSCIS.
  2. The employee checks "I have applied for a Social Security number and will enter it upon receipt," then completes the rest of Form I-9, signs and downloads a copy.
  3. When you review, if the number has not been provided, you answer "no" to the question, "which will automatically close this case," select "other," enter "pending SSN" and confirm. The employee keeps working.
  4. When the number arrives, the employee tells you and adds it to their E-Verify+ profile under Account Settings, Personal Information.
  5. You create a new standard E-Verify case, not a second E-Verify+ case. If it is past the third business day, select Awaiting Social Security Number.
  6. You keep the Form I-9 and the required document copies.

What must you not do?

  • No placeholder or ITIN. The Form I-9 instructions say not to enter an Individual Taxpayer Identification Number as a Social Security number, and a case built on a wrong number will not match SSA's records.
  • No case before the hire. Article II.A.9 of the MOU bars creating a case before a firm offer is accepted and Form I-9 is completed, and Article II.A.10 bars pre-employment screening.
  • No demand for a card. M-274 Section 3.0 says you "cannot ask employees to provide a specific document with their Social Security number on it," and that doing so may be unlawful discrimination.
  • No skipping the case. Article II.A.11 says you must use E-Verify for all new employees and may not verify selectively. A pending number delays the case; it does not excuse it.
  • No receipt for a first card. USCIS's table of acceptable receipts in M-274 Section 4.4 covers replacements of lost, stolen or damaged documents, not a first application. See the I-9 receipt rule.

What if the new number produces a mismatch?

A recently issued number is not a red flag in itself. If the case returns a tentative nonconfirmation, Section 3.3 lists the SSA reasons, including a name, number or date of birth that is incorrect in SSA records and a name change never reported to SSA. Notify the employee privately, let them decide whether to take action, and take no adverse action while the case is open; see E-Verify tentative nonconfirmation. If SSA prompts Review and Update Employee Data because of a typo, Section 3.3.4 allows one update, so check the digits against the card before you resubmit.

How do you keep pending cases from slipping?

E-Verify sets no maximum wait. Its guidance says "as soon as it is available," so the risk is forgetting. A simple routine, offered as a suggestion:

  • Keep a tracker with the employee, first day of employment, date the explanation was attached, and the date the number arrived.
  • Check in with each employee on a regular schedule, the same way for everyone.
  • Create the case the day the number comes in, and record the case number in the tracker.
  • Review the tracker in your periodic Form I-9 self-audit; see the I-9 audit checklist.

What should staffing agencies do?

The agency that employs and pays the temporary worker completes Form I-9 and creates the E-Verify case, so the pending-number tracker belongs to the agency, not the client. Two practical points: tell the client the worker may start while the case waits, because the job is not on hold; and keep the tracker running across assignments, since a worker may move to a new client before the number arrives. E-Verify's published guidance does not address a worker who leaves before providing the number, so ask the E-Verify Contact Center (888-464-4218) and note the answer on the explanation attached to the Form I-9. Branch setups and who holds the E-Verify account are in E-Verify for staffing agencies.

Summary table

ItemThe ruleSource
Case without a numberCannot be createdE-Verify FAQ
Section 1Number left blank; added later with initials and dateForm I-9 instructions
Starting workAllowed with acceptable documentsForm I-9 instructions; User Manual 2.1
While waitingExplanation attached; form set asideUser Manual 2.1
Late caseReason: Awaiting Social Security NumberUser Manual 2.2
E-Verify+Close as "pending SSN"; later a standard caseE-Verify+ sheet, July 2026

Questions people ask

Can I create an E-Verify case for a new hire who does not have a Social Security number yet?

No. E-Verify's FAQ says a case cannot be created without a Social Security number. Complete Form I-9 on time, attach an explanation to it, set it aside, let the employee keep working, and create the case as soon as the number is available.

What reason do I pick when the E-Verify case is late because of a missing Social Security number?

Choose Awaiting Social Security Number. When the case is created three or more days after the first day of employment, E-Verify asks for a reason for the delay, and the User Manual lists Awaiting Social Security Number as one of the drop-down choices.

Can the employee start work while waiting for a Social Security number at an E-Verify employer?

Yes. The Form I-9 instructions say an employee who has applied for but not received a number may begin working if they can present acceptable identity and employment authorization documents, and E-Verify's User Manual says to allow the employee to continue to work while the case waits.

How does E-Verify+ handle a new hire without a Social Security number?

The employee checks a box saying they applied for a number and will enter it when it arrives. When you review, you answer no to the completeness question, which closes the E-Verify+ case, and enter pending SSN as the reason. When the number arrives, you create a standard E-Verify case, not a second E-Verify+ case.

Is there a deadline for creating the case once the Social Security number arrives?

E-Verify does not set a number of days. Its guidance says to create the case as soon as the number is available, so build a tracking routine and create the case the day the employee gives you the number.