E-Verify name mismatches: hyphenated names, two surnames, name review and what to do when the name does not match
On this page
- How should names be entered in E-Verify?
- Which screens point to a name problem?
- What do you do at the Review Case prompt?
- How does Request Name Review work?
- What causes a name-related mismatch?
- What if you discover the name was entered wrong after submitting?
- What about documents that show a different name?
- What must you not do?
- A worked example
- A name-entry checklist
- Questions people ask
Most E-Verify name problems come from one of two places: the name was entered differently from the employee's legal name as recorded by the Social Security Administration (SSA) or the Department of Homeland Security (DHS), or those agencies' records were never updated after a name change. As of November 2026, the rule is to enter the name exactly as the employee wrote it in Section 1 of Form I-9, with both surnames in the Last Name field, every hyphen and apostrophe, both given names in the First Name field, and any other last names in the optional Other Last Names Used field. If E-Verify still flags the name, the screen tells you which path you are on: a Review Case prompt, an Employment Authorized result with a Request Name Review option, or a tentative nonconfirmation (mismatch) that the employee may contest. No path allows adverse action before a final result.
This page is about what happens inside E-Verify. Recording a name change on the Form I-9 itself, including Supplement B and documents in a maiden name, is covered in name changes and Form I-9, and the full mismatch timeline is in E-Verify tentative nonconfirmation.
Not legal advice. This summarizes E-Verify User Manual Sections 2.2, 2.2.3, 3.1.1, 3.3 and 3.3.4; E-Verify's FAQ on Other Last Names Used and its tips to prevent a mismatch; Handbook for Employers (M-274) Section 3.0 and Section 14.0; and the Form I-9 instructions (edition 01/20/25), as of November 2026.
How should names be entered in E-Verify?
E-Verify takes the name from Section 1, so the case can only be as good as the form. M-274 Section 3.0 and the Form I-9 instructions set the rules, and E-Verify's tips for employees repeat them:
| Situation | How it is entered | USCIS example |
|---|---|---|
| Two last names (family names) | Both in the Last Name field | Garcia Lopez; De La Cruz |
| Hyphen or apostrophe in a last name | Keep the punctuation | Smith-Johnson; O'Neill |
| Two first names (given names) | Both in the First Name field | Mary Jo; Tae Young |
| Hyphen or apostrophe in a first name | Keep the punctuation | John-Paul; D'Shaun |
| Only one name | That name in Last Name; "Unknown" in First Name | From the Form I-9 instructions |
| Maiden name or other legal last names | Other Last Names Used | Section 1 field of the same name |
| Nickname | Not used; the full legal name is entered | E-Verify's tips: Thomas, not Tommy |
In E-Verify, Section 2.2 of the manual says to press Tab or Enter after each name when you add more than one to Other Last Names Used. The FAQ adds that only First Name and Last Name are required, but employers "are encouraged" to enter the other names, which "will help E-Verify confirm employment authorization and avoid unnecessary Tentative Nonconfirmations." Do not reorder, shorten or drop a surname to make a case go through.
Which screens point to a name problem?
| What E-Verify shows | What it means | What you do | Manual |
|---|---|---|---|
| Review Case: "Is the information below correct?" | The entry did not immediately match records | Compare with Section 1; correct a typing error or confirm the entry matches the form, then continue | 2.2.3 |
| Employment Authorized with a name in a yellow box | Authorized, but DHS records show a name variation | Close the case if the names match; otherwise Request Name Review | 3.1.1 |
| Review and Update Employee Data | SSA found a discrepancy, such as a typo | Review the Form I-9 with the employee, correct it and update the case; you get one update | 3.3.4 |
| DHS or SSA Tentative Nonconfirmation (mismatch) | The information did not match agency records | Notify the employee privately; follow the mismatch steps | 3.3 |
What do you do at the Review Case prompt?
This is the last chance to fix a typing error before the case is submitted. Section 2.2.3 says to review the screen against Section 1 and select whether the information matches the Form I-9; if it does not, correct the field so it matches the form, then click Continue to Case Results. If you need time, Save & Exit keeps the case as a draft, and E-Verify automatically closes drafts not updated within 180 federal government working days. Leaving without choosing either gives the case a status of Case Incomplete.
Correct only what you mistyped. If the form itself has an error, the employee corrects Section 1; the correction rules are in I-9 corrections.
How does Request Name Review work?
- Compare the name in the yellow box, from DHS records, with the name you entered, in the white box.
- If they match, click Close Case.
- If they do not, click Request Name Review, type the specific reason in Comments, and click Continue.
- The case shows E-Verify Needs More Time while DHS reviews it, then returns Employment Authorized or a mismatch.
The employee has nothing to do at this stage. The manual adds a warning: "Do not use this functionality in a discriminatory manner (e.g., based on an individual's race, national origin or ethnicity)." Use it whenever the names differ, not only for some names.
What causes a name-related mismatch?
Section 3.3 lists the reasons a case can come back as a mismatch. Those involving names are:
- SSA: the employee did not report a name change to SSA, or the name in SSA records is incorrect.
- DHS: the name is incorrect in DHS records, or the employee's information was not updated there.
- Either: the employer entered the information incorrectly.
The fix for an agency record belongs to the employee and the agency. After you notify the employee and they decide to take action, you refer the case and give them the referral notice; for an SSA mismatch, the employee contacts SSA by the date on that notice. E-Verify's tips tell employees to inform SSA of a name change and to ask the issuing agency to fix a spelling error on a document. M-274 Section 6.3 says employees "should record their legal name change with the SSA to avoid mismatches in E-Verify." Steps and deadlines, counted in federal government working days, are in E-Verify tentative nonconfirmation; the notice itself is explained in the E-Verify Further Action Notice.
What if you discover the name was entered wrong after submitting?
- SSA asks you to review: use the Review and Update Employee Data prompt. "You may only update a case once," so check the whole name before you save.
- No prompt, and the data was wrong: close the case with the statement "The case is being closed because the data entered is incorrect" and create a new case with the correct data. The manual notes that closing this way does not void the case or change its last result. How duplicate cases are handled is in E-Verify duplicate cases.
- A mismatch already issued: do not quietly re-run the case to avoid the mismatch process. Notify the employee and follow it; the employee may still choose to contest.
What about documents that show a different name?
M-274 Section 14.0 answers the two common cases. A document in a different last name, for example after a recent marriage, may be accepted "if the document reasonably relates to the employee," with an optional memo; the employee may offer proof of the change but is not required to. A slight spelling variation is acceptable if the employee has a reasonable explanation and the document otherwise appears genuine and relates to them. The E-Verify case still uses the Section 1 name, so a document in a maiden name is a reason to make sure that name is also in Other Last Names Used.
What must you not do?
- Do not take adverse action while a case is open. Section 3.3 bars terminating, suspending, delaying training, withholding or lowering pay "or any other adverse action" because of a mismatch.
- Do not ask for different or extra documents because a name looks unfamiliar; see I-9 document abuse.
- Do not "fix" a name to match a guess about the agency's records. Enter what the employee attested to.
- Do not treat compound or non-English names as a reason to scrutinize some employees more than others.
A worked example
The facts are illustrative. Ana Maria Garcia Lopez writes "Garcia Lopez" as her last name and "Ana Maria" as her first name in Section 1, and "Garcia" under other last names used. HR enters "Ana Maria" and "Garcia Lopez" exactly, adds "Garcia" to Other Last Names Used, and submits. The case returns Employment Authorized, with "Ana M Garcia-Lopez" in the yellow box. The names differ, so HR clicks Request Name Review, writes "Two surnames entered as on Form I-9; DHS record hyphenated," and continues. The case returns Employment Authorized and HR closes it. Had it returned an SSA mismatch instead, HR would have notified her privately and followed the mismatch steps.
A name-entry checklist
- Copy the name character for character from Section 1, including spaces, hyphens and apostrophes.
- Both surnames in Last Name; both given names in First Name.
- Every other last name from Section 1 in Other Last Names Used.
- Read the Review Case screen against the form before you continue.
- Request a name review whenever the returned name differs, for every employee alike.
- For a mismatch, notify the employee privately and take no adverse action until the case is final.
Questions people ask
How do I enter a hyphenated last name in E-Verify?
Enter it exactly as the employee wrote it in Section 1 of Form I-9, hyphen included. USCIS's Handbook for Employers gives Smith-Johnson and O'Neill as correctly entered last names, and E-Verify's tips tell employees to include hyphens and apostrophes that are part of their full legal name.
What if my employee has two last names, like Garcia Lopez?
Both names go in the Last Name field, in the order the employee entered them in Section 1. The Handbook for Employers says employees with two last names must include both in that field and lists Garcia Lopez and De La Cruz as examples. Enter any other last names the employee listed, such as a maiden name, in E-Verify's Other Last Names Used field.
E-Verify says Employment Authorized but shows a different name. What do I do?
Compare the name E-Verify returned with the name you entered. If they match, close the case. If they do not, click Request Name Review, explain the reason in the Comments field and continue; the case goes to DHS and comes back as Employment Authorized or as a mismatch. E-Verify warns not to use name review in a discriminatory way.
Can I fire or suspend an employee because of an E-Verify name mismatch?
No. The E-Verify User Manual says employers may not terminate, suspend, delay training, withhold or lower pay, or take any other adverse action because an employee received a mismatch. Only a Final Nonconfirmation, or an employee's choice not to take action, allows termination under the MOU.
Is the Other Last Names Used field required in E-Verify?
No. E-Verify's FAQ says only First Name and Last Name are required, but it encourages employers to enter any other names the employee provided because that helps E-Verify confirm employment authorization and avoid unnecessary mismatches.