How to

How to verify a competing job offer: what you may ask, what to document and when to stop

On this page
  1. Can you legally ask about a competing offer?
  2. What can you actually check, and how?
  3. Should you ask to see the offer letter?
  4. Can you call the other employer to confirm?
  5. How should a competing offer change your offer?
  6. What if you suspect the offer is invented?
  7. What should staffing agencies do?
  8. What can you say on the call?
  9. What should the record say?
  10. Questions people ask

You cannot independently verify a competing job offer the way you verify a license or a degree: there is no registry, and the other employer has no duty to talk to you. What you can do, lawfully and respectfully, is ask the candidate about the offer (the role, the total pay, the deadline), invite them to share the written offer if they choose, never demand documents or contact the other employer without their consent, and then decide what the job is worth to you. Asking is generally allowed even where salary history questions are banned: the New York City Commission on Human Rights says employers "can ask an applicant about competing offers and counter offers that the applicant has received and the value of those offers." If you raise your offer because of it, write down why, and treat every candidate's competing offer the same way. Rules below are as of November 2026.

This page is about an offer from another employer. A counteroffer from the candidate's current employer is covered in the counteroffer conversation script and handling a counteroffer after acceptance; deadline pressure is covered in what is an exploding offer.

Not legal advice. Sources: the NYC Commission on Human Rights salary history FAQ, the EEOC Compliance Manual section on compensation discrimination, and the California Commission on the Status of Women and Girls' pay equity guidance, read in November 2026. State and city laws differ; check the law where the job is.

Can you legally ask about a competing offer?

In general, yes, and the clearest official statement is from New York City, which has one of the stricter salary history laws. The Commission's salary history FAQ answers the question directly: "Yes, a prospective employer can ask an applicant about competing offers and counter offers that the applicant has received and the value of those offers."

The reason is that salary history laws target current and past pay. Washington's law, for example, bars seeking "the wage or salary history of an applicant" (RCW 49.58.100), and New York State's bars seeking "the wage or salary history from an applicant" (Labor Law 194-a). An offer from another company is neither. Two cautions follow:

  • Do not slide from the offer to current pay. "So what are you making now?" is the question these laws ban. The jurisdictions and their exceptions are listed in salary history ban states, and the related question of whether you can check past pay at all is in can employers verify a candidate's past salary.
  • Read your own state's definitions. NYC's answer is official for New York City. Other laws are worded differently, and only some agencies have addressed competing offers in writing.

Asking about the candidate's expectations is the other safe question, and the one that matters most; see salary expectation questions.

What can you actually check, and how?

What you want to knowLawful, respectful way to learn itWhat not to do
Whether the offer existsAsk: "Is it a written offer or a verbal one, and is it final?"Demand proof as a condition of your offer
Its valueAsk for the base, variable pay, equity and sign-on as the candidate understands them; NYC expressly allows asking the valueAsk what they earn today, or ask for pay stubs or a W-2 "to compare"
The roleAsk the title, level, scope and location of the other jobAssume the jobs are comparable
The deadlineAsk when they must answer, and tell them honestly when you can respondInvent your own deadline to force a choice
The written offerInvite them to share it if they wish, with anything they prefer redactedRequire it, keep it longer than needed, or forward it
Whether the other employer stands behind itNothing; take the candidate's account at face valueCall or email the other employer without written consent

Should you ask to see the offer letter?

You may invite it; do not require it. Offer letters can contain things the candidate has every reason to keep private, and making your offer depend on seeing a competitor's paperwork turns a negotiation into an audit. If the candidate volunteers it:

  1. Tell them they may redact anything, including the other employer's name.
  2. Look only for what you need: the pay components, the start date and the deadline.
  3. Do not forward it to a client or a colleague who is not part of the decision, and do not file it in the candidate's record longer than your retention policy allows.
  4. If the letter shows the candidate's current pay (some offers reference it), do not use that number; in salary history ban locations you should not rely on it.

Can you call the other employer to confirm?

Not without the candidate's written consent, and there is rarely a reason to ask for it. Calling would tell another company that the candidate is weighing offers, which they may not want known, and the other employer has no obligation to confirm anything to you. In salary history ban locations there is a second problem: some laws bar seeking pay information from third parties (Washington's, for example, from "a current or former employer"), so a call that drifts into pay is the wrong habit to build. Treat the candidate as the source.

How should a competing offer change your offer?

A competing offer is information about the market, not a number you must match. Two official sources describe how to use it without creating a pay equity problem:

  • The EEOC. Its Compliance Manual section on compensation discrimination gives the example of an accounting firm that paid a man more because he "received other job offers at the higher salary" and used them "as a bargaining tool"; the EEOC found a factor other than sex because the firm started both candidates at the same opening offer and treated them the same in negotiation. The same section says investigators should consider "whether the employer bargains differently with men than with women."
  • California. The California Commission on the Status of Women and Girls' guidance on starting compensation lists a competing offer among factors an employer may consider, says it "may justify making a higher counteroffer," and suggests asking whether the competing offer is for "a role that is substantially similar," whether the candidate's qualifications support the higher pay, and whether incumbents' pay should be adjusted too.

In practice:

  1. Start from your range for the job, set before you heard about the other offer. If your state requires posted ranges, check the rules in pay transparency laws by state before you go outside yours.
  2. Compare the roles, not just the numbers: level, scope, location, variable pay and equity.
  3. Decide whether the candidate's job-related qualifications justify moving within or above your range.
  4. Respond the same way to every candidate who brings a competing offer for the same job.
  5. Write the reason down (the template is below), including what the candidate told you and what you did not verify.

What if you suspect the offer is invented?

Vague details, numbers that change between calls, or a deadline that keeps moving can mean many things, including a verbal offer the candidate is understandably unsure of. None of it proves the offer is false, and you do not need to settle the question. Make the offer the job is worth, explain it, and let the candidate decide. If a candidate states something you later learn was false, handle it as you would any other misstatement; see how to handle a candidate who lies in an interview. Do not accuse, and do not treat candidates differently based on assumptions about who "really" has offers.

What should staffing agencies do?

  • Get the candidate's permission before telling the client about the competing offer or its value, and pass on only what they agree to. NYC's FAQ says agents may disclose a candidate's salary history in negotiations only with the candidate's consent and recommends written confirmation; applying the same discipline to competing-offer details avoids surprises.
  • Keep the client's decision with the client. Present the facts and the deadline; the client decides whether to move its offer and owns the pay equity analysis.
  • Do not let the client ask the candidate's current pay through you in salary history ban locations; the agency can be liable too (NYC's FAQ says the law has no exemption for headhunters, who may be liable as employment agencies or agents of an employer, or for aiding and abetting a violation).
  • Check your contract for anything it says about fee calculation on a raised offer.

What can you say on the call?

A copy-ready script; adjust the bracketed parts:

"Thanks for telling me about the other offer. It helps me
represent you well. Could you tell me the role and level,
the base, any bonus or commission and equity, and when you
need to answer? You don't need to send me the letter. If
you'd like to share it, feel free to black out anything,
including the company name.

Our range for this role is [range]. I'll take what you've
told me to [hiring manager / the client] and come back to
you by [date/time]. I won't contact the other company."

What should the record say?

Competing offer record
Candidate: [name]       Job: [title, requisition]
Reported by candidate on: [date]
Other role (title, level, location): [ ]
Reported value (base / variable / equity / sign-on): [ ]
Written or verbal: [ ]   Deadline: [ ]
Letter shared voluntarily: [no / yes, redacted, not retained]
Other employer contacted: no
Our range for the job: [ ]   Decision: [no change / moved to ___ ]
Job-related reason for any change: [ ]
Same approach used for other candidates for this job: [yes]
Decided by: [name], on [date]

For the call itself, the offer call script for recruiters covers presenting the final number. For sales candidates who cite a competing offer built on big quota claims, see how to verify sales quota attainment.

Questions people ask

Can I ask a candidate about a competing job offer?

Generally yes. For example, the New York City Commission on Human Rights says a prospective employer can ask an applicant about competing offers and counteroffers and the value of those offers, even though the city bans salary history questions. Keep the question to the offer itself and do not use it as a route to the candidate's current or past pay, which salary history bans in many states and cities restrict. This is not legal advice.

Can I ask to see the competing offer letter?

You can invite the candidate to share it, but do not require it or make your offer depend on it. Say they may redact anything they prefer, such as the other employer's name, and keep only what you need. If they decline, decide on the information you have and your own pay range.

Should I call the other company to confirm the offer?

No, not without the candidate's written consent, and in practice even with consent there is rarely a reason to. Contacting the other employer can reveal the candidate's job search and the other company has no duty to answer you. Base your decision on what the candidate tells you and on your own range for the job.

Is it legal to pay a candidate more because of a competing offer?

A competing offer can be a legitimate reason for a higher offer, but pay equity laws still apply. The EEOC's compliance manual treats an employer that bargained with a candidate who used other job offers as a bargaining tool as having a factor other than sex, provided it negotiated the same way with everyone; California's pay equity guidance suggests asking whether the competing role is substantially similar and whether the candidate's qualifications support the higher pay. Document the reason.

What if I think the candidate made the competing offer up?

You do not need to prove it either way. Decide what the job is worth to you within your range, make that offer, and let the candidate choose. Accusing a candidate of inventing an offer rarely helps, and a firm, fair offer protects you whether the competing offer is real or not.