Illegal interview questions in New York (2026): what employers can't ask
On this page
- What does New York add to federal interview law?
- Which interview questions are illegal in New York?
- What does New York City add?
- What if a candidate volunteers protected information?
- What should you leave out of interview notes?
- Can you record a New York interview?
- How is the law enforced, and what are the deadlines?
- What do staffing agencies need to know?
- Checklist for New York interviewers
- Questions people ask
New York's interview rules come from the New York State Human Rights Law, Article 15 of the Executive Law, enforced by the New York State Division of Human Rights. It applies to every employer in the state regardless of size (Executive Law 292(5)), and section 296(1)(d) bans the question itself: any "inquiry in connection with prospective employment" that expresses a limitation based on a protected trait. Beyond federal law, New York protects age from 18, citizenship or immigration status, marital and familial status, military status, predisposing genetic characteristics, gender identity or expression, and status as a victim of domestic violence (section 296). The rules employers most often miss, as of November 2026, are the salary history ban (Labor Law 194-a), the ban on asking about favorably ended or sealed cases (section 296(16)), and the protection for legal off-duty cannabis use (Labor Law 201-d). New York City adds its own list on top.
This page is the New York layer on top of the federal rules in illegal interview questions. New York topics that have their own page are summarized in a line and linked.
Not legal advice. Checked as of November 2026 against the Executive Law, Labor Law, Correction Law and General Business Law sections on the New York State Senate's site and the NYC Commission on Human Rights's summary of the city law. Coverage depends on the job, where it is done and, in New York City and for Article 23-A, employer size. Confirm what applies with HR or a New York employment lawyer before relying on this for a specific decision.
What does New York add to federal interview law?
- Every employer. Section 292(5) says the term employer "shall include all employers within the state." A five-person business is covered; federal Title VII starts at 15.
- The question is the violation. Section 296(1)(d) makes it unlawful to "use any form of application for employment" or make "any inquiry in connection with prospective employment" that expresses a limitation based on a protected trait, unless it is a bona fide occupational qualification. Employment agencies are covered by the same subdivision.
- A longer list. Section 296(1)(a) covers age, race, creed, color, national origin, citizenship or immigration status, sexual orientation, gender identity or expression, military status, sex, disability, predisposing genetic characteristics, familial status, marital status and status as a victim of domestic violence. Age protection starts at 18 (296(3-a)).
- Topic statutes. Separate laws ban salary history questions, limit the use of convictions, bar requests for personal account passwords, bar voice stress tests and, since April 18, 2026, bar most uses of consumer credit history.
Which interview questions are illegal in New York?
Each row was checked against the linked statute. "Federal rule applies" means New York State has no separate rule on the topic; New York City rules are noted where they differ. The alternatives are examples: ask them of every candidate, and only when the requirement is real.
| Topic | Can you ask in New York? | The rule and its source | A lawful alternative question |
|---|---|---|---|
| Age, date of birth, graduation year | No limiting inquiry | Age protected from 18; inquiries expressing an age limitation barred unless a bona fide occupational qualification (Exec. Law 296(3-a)); see age discrimination in hiring | If a law sets a minimum age: "Are you at least 18?" Otherwise nothing. |
| Marital status, children, childcare | No | Marital and familial status are protected (296(1)(a)); familial status includes a person who "is pregnant or has a child" (292) | "The role travels two nights a month. Can you meet that?" |
| Pregnancy or plans for children | No | Sex and familial status (296(1)(a), 292) | Nothing. |
| Religion | No | Creed is protected (296(1)(a)); see religious discrimination in hiring | "The schedule includes Saturdays. Can you work it?" Accommodation requests go to HR. |
| National origin, accent | No | National origin is protected (296(1)(a)) | If a language is required: "Can you do a short call exercise in Spanish?" |
| Citizenship, visa, immigration status | Only the standard work authorization questions | Citizenship or immigration status is a protected trait (296(1)(a), (d)); the lawful route is the federal pair (DOJ IER FAQs); see citizenship status discrimination | "Are you legally authorized to work in the United States?" and "Will you now or in the future require visa sponsorship?" |
| Disability, medical history, medications | No, before an offer | Disability is protected (296(1)(a)); the ADA bars pre-offer disability inquiries (42 U.S.C. 12112(d)(2)) | "Can you perform [essential functions], with or without reasonable accommodation?" |
| Genetic information, genetic tests | No | Predisposing genetic characteristics are protected; 296(19) bars soliciting, requiring or administering a genetic test as a condition of employment, with narrow exceptions | Nothing. |
| Arrests not pending, sealed records, youthful offender findings | No | 296(16), with narrow exceptions; see New York fair chance rules | Nothing. |
| Convictions | Statewide, yes, but use is limited; NYC, not before a conditional offer | Correction Law Article 23-A (752) for private employers with ten or more employees, enforced through 296(15); see NYC Fair Chance Act | Outside NYC, only through the written process; in NYC, nothing before the offer. |
| Salary history | No, any employer | Labor Law 194-a; see New York's salary history ban | "What are you looking for in base pay?" |
| Credit history | No, with eight exceptions | General Business Law 380-b(d); see New York's credit check ban and NYC's | Nothing in the interview. |
| Cannabis use | No (legal off-duty use) | Labor Law 201-d(2)(b), with exceptions; NYC bars most pre-employment marijuana tests (Admin. Code 8-107(31)); see New York drug testing laws | "The role requires [any test the law requires for it]. Any questions about that process?" |
| Other lawful off-duty conduct | Avoid | 201-d also protects legal off-duty political activities, recreational activities and use of legal consumable products | Nothing. |
| Sexual orientation, gender identity or expression | No | Both protected (296(1)(a)) | "Tell me about leading a team through a disagreement." |
| Height and weight | Statewide, federal rule applies; NYC, no | NYC protects height and weight (NYC Commission on Human Rights); see height and weight discrimination | "The job requires lifting 50 pounds several times an hour. Can you do that, with or without accommodation?" |
| Hairstyle | No | Race includes "traits historically associated with race, including but not limited to, hair texture and protective hairstyles" (292(37)); see CROWN Act | Nothing; state any genuine safety rule to every candidate. |
| Military status | No limiting questions | Military status is protected (296(1)(a)); federal 38 U.S.C. 4311 | If they listed service: "What from that role applies here?" |
| Domestic violence victim status | No | Protected (296(1)(a), 296(22)) | Nothing. |
| Social media passwords | No | Labor Law 201-i bars requesting a personal account login, access in the employer's presence, or reproducing its content; see social media password laws | Nothing. |
| Lie detector and voice stress tests | No | Labor Law 735 bars requiring, requesting or suggesting a psychological stress evaluator examination (a class B misdemeanor); polygraphs fall under the federal EPPA (lie detector tests) | Nothing. |
| Unemployment status | Statewide, federal rule applies; NYC, no | NYC protects unemployment status; see unemployment status | "Walk me through your most recent work." |
What does New York City add?
The NYC Human Rights Law, Title 8 of the Administrative Code, applies to employers with four or more employees and adds employment protections the state law does not have. The NYC Commission on Human Rights lists, among others, arrest or conviction record, caregiver status, credit history, pre-employment marijuana testing, unemployment status, sexual and reproductive health decisions, salary history, pay transparency, height and weight, and status as a victim of domestic violence, stalking and sex offenses. Each of the hiring-stage rules has its own page:
- NYC Fair Chance Act: no criminal history questions or searches until after a conditional offer, then the Fair Chance Process.
- NYC credit check law: eight narrow exemptions and an exemption log.
- NYC salary transparency law: a good-faith range in every ad for work done at least in part in the city.
- NYC Local Law 144: a bias audit and candidate notices before using an automated employment decision tool.
What if a candidate volunteers protected information?
If a candidate mentions a pregnancy, a disability, a visa, their current pay or a sealed case, acknowledge it, do not follow up, do not write it down and go back to the job:
"Thanks for telling me. That isn't part of what we consider, so I won't
note it. Let's get back to the role: tell me about [the last time you
handled X]."
On pay, the safe habit under 194-a is to share the range and ask about expectations rather than build on a figure the candidate offered; the salary history page covers what the statute says about volunteered numbers.
What should you leave out of interview notes?
Age clues, family and pregnancy, health, religion, origin, citizenship or visa details, sealed or favorably ended cases, off-duty cannabis use, and anything about domestic violence. Because the New York statute bans the inquiry itself, a note that records the answer is evidence the question was asked. See what not to write in interview notes.
Can you record a New York interview?
New York is a one-party consent state, so a participant may record their own interview under New York law, but the candidate's state may require everyone's consent; see New York recording consent law for interviews. For AI screening tools used on New York City roles, Local Law 144 applies.
How is the law enforced, and what are the deadlines?
- Agency: the New York State Division of Human Rights; in New York City, also the NYC Commission on Human Rights.
- Deadline: a complaint with the Division "must be so filed within three years after the alleged unlawful discriminatory practice" (Executive Law 297(5)).
- Court instead: a person may sue in court for damages, including punitive damages in employment cases against private employers, unless they already filed with the Division or a local commission (297(9)).
- Remedies at the Division: compensatory damages, punitive damages in private-employer employment cases, and civil fines and penalties of up to $50,000, or up to $100,000 for an act found to be willful, wanton or malicious (297(4)(c)).
What do staffing agencies need to know?
New York names employment agencies in the same rules that bind employers. Section 296(1)(d) covers any "employer or employment agency," Labor Law 201-d covers "any employer or employment agency," and the state's salary history page explains why recruiters count as employers under 194-a. In practice:
- Never ask a question for a client that the client could not lawfully ask, and never accept a job order that states an age, family, citizenship or origin preference.
- Strip volunteered protected information, including current pay, from submittals.
- For New York City roles, keep criminal history and credit questions out of the process until the stage the city allows.
- If a client insists on a "U.S. citizens only" requirement, ask for the law, regulation or government contract behind it.
Checklist for New York interviewers
- Written questions, the same for every candidate, each tied to a stated job requirement.
- No age (from 18), graduation year, marital, family or pregnancy questions.
- No citizenship or visa questions beyond the two standard work authorization questions.
- No medical, disability or genetic questions before an offer.
- No salary history; share the range and ask about expectations.
- No questions about favorably ended, sealed or youthful offender cases; NYC: no criminal history before a conditional offer.
- No off-duty cannabis questions, no personal account passwords, no voice stress tests.
- Credit history only where a GBL 380-b(d) exception applies.
- NYC rules checked for height, weight, unemployment and caregiver status.
- Volunteered protected information left out of notes and submittals.
Hiring in other states? Compare California, Pennsylvania, Illinois, Texas and Florida, or see hiring employees in New York and New York background check laws for the rest of the process.
Questions people ask
Can you ask a candidate's age in a New York interview?
You should not. New York's Human Rights Law protects anyone 18 or older from age discrimination, not only people over 40, and Executive Law section 296 bars any inquiry in connection with prospective employment that expresses a limitation based on age unless it is a bona fide occupational qualification. It applies to every employer in the state, whatever its size. Ask only whether the candidate meets a legal minimum age where one applies.
Is it illegal to ask about salary history in New York?
Yes. Labor Law section 194-a bars every New York employer from seeking, requesting or requiring a candidate's wage or salary history, orally or in writing, as a condition of being interviewed or considered, and from asking a current or former employer for it. New York City has its own ban on top. Ask what pay the candidate is looking for instead.
Can a New York employer ask about arrests or sealed records?
No. Executive Law section 296(16) makes it unlawful to ask about an arrest or criminal accusation that is not pending and ended in the applicant's favor, an adjournment in contemplation of dismissal, a youthful offender adjudication or a sealed conviction, with narrow exceptions. Convictions may be asked about statewide, but Correction Law Article 23-A limits how they are used, and New York City bars criminal history questions until after a conditional offer.
Can you ask a New York candidate about marijuana use?
Generally no. Labor Law section 201-d bars employers and employment agencies from refusing to hire someone because of legal off-duty cannabis use, with exceptions such as actions required by state or federal law. In New York City, Administrative Code section 8-107(31) also bars most pre-employment marijuana tests. Questions about impairment at work and legally required testing are separate matters.
Does New York law protect citizenship or immigration status in hiring?
Yes. Citizenship or immigration status is one of the protected characteristics in Executive Law section 296, so questions about a candidate's citizenship, visa type or green card are risky. The lawful route is the pair the Justice Department describes: whether the candidate is legally authorized to work in the United States and whether they will need visa sponsorship, asked of every candidate.