Interview note-taking tips for recruiters: 15 habits for screens and submittals
On this page
The best interview notes for recruiters are short, structured by the job's must-haves, and written in the candidate's own words wherever a client might later ask "did they actually say that?" Capture pay, notice period and motivation exactly as stated, mark what you verified versus what the candidate claimed, write down what you did not get to, and turn the notes into an ATS note and a submittal within the hour. If you use an AI note taker, write your own judgment and check the numbers; the tool records the conversation, not your recommendation.
The habits below are for recruiters running phone screens and first interviews, where the notes have to serve three readers: you next month, your colleagues in the ATS, and a client or hiring manager. If you interview only occasionally as a hiring manager, start with how to take interview notes as a hiring manager, which also has a shorthand you can borrow.
What should you set up before the call?
1. Build the page around the must-haves
A blank page produces a transcript in your handwriting. A page with the requisition's three to five must-haves as headings sorts the notes while you take them, and shows a gap the moment a heading stays empty. The recruiter phone screen template is laid out in call order with these fields already in place.
2. Pre-fill what the resume already says
Current employer, title, dates and location go in before you dial. The call is for what the resume cannot tell you: scope, results, reasons and constraints. Pre-filling also exposes the questions worth asking, such as an eight-month gap or a title that does not match the responsibilities.
3. Put the client's first three questions at the top
Most hiring managers read a submittal looking for the same few things: can they do the job, what do they want to be paid, and when can they start. Put those fields at the top of your page so they never get missed on a call that wanders.
What should you write down during the call?
4. Write their words, not your adjectives
"Strong communicator" is your opinion. "Runs the weekly ops review for the regional VP, 12 sites" is evidence. Save exact phrases for claims, results and anything surprising, and put quotation marks only around words the candidate actually said.
5. Capture numbers with their conditions
Numbers without their qualifiers cause the most client-facing errors. A few examples of the difference:
| Weak note | Useful note |
|---|---|
| Wants 95k | Asking $95,000 base, flexible to $90,000 if fully remote (stated) |
| 4 weeks notice | 4 weeks contractual; thinks manager would release in 2 (not confirmed) |
| Managed a team | Manages 6 direct reports; hired 3 of them in the last year |
| Big budget | Owns a $1.2M annual software budget, approves vendor renewals |
| Can start soon | Available from [date]; booked vacation [dates], wants to keep it |
On pay, ask only what local law allows. Several states and cities restrict questions about salary history, and expectations are a different question from history.
6. Mark stated versus verified
Use one mark for "the candidate said so" and another for "I have checked". Team sizes, revenue numbers and certifications are claims until verified, and a submittal that presents a claim as a fact is the recruiter's problem when it turns out wrong.
7. Record motivation in their words
"Why are you looking?" and "Why this role?" produce the most persuasive line in a submittal and the earliest warning of a counteroffer. Write the answer close to verbatim. "My manager left and the new one is restructuring" says something very different from "I want to move into a bigger market."
8. Note other processes and timelines
Other interviews, final rounds elsewhere, offers pending and the date they need an answer. On an agency desk this decides how fast you need to move, and it is the field most often missing when a candidate accepts somewhere else.
9. Write down what you did not cover
"Did not get to: shift flexibility, driving license." A gap you do not write down becomes a gap nobody remembers, and the next interviewer assumes you covered it.
10. Timestamp the moments you will want to find again
If the call is recorded or transcribed, jot the rough minute next to a key answer, such as "min 14: outage story". It turns a 40-minute transcript into a two-minute check.
How should you take notes alongside an AI note taker?
An AI note taker changes what you write, not whether you write. Recruiters who stop writing anything tend to send notes that are accurate about the conversation and silent about the recruiter's view, which is the part a client pays for. The wider set of workflows is covered in how recruiters use AI note takers.
11. Write your three lines of judgment yourself
Your recommendation, the main risk, and what the next interviewer should probe. No transcript contains these, and they are what makes a submittal worth reading.
12. Check five things against the transcript
- Pay figures, and whether they are base or total.
- Notice period and start date.
- Employer names, titles and dates.
- Every phrase in quotation marks, word for word.
- "I" versus "we": a summary that turns "we migrated" into "led the migration" overstates the candidate.
Some tools help with the last two. Interview Signal, for example, labels the recruiter's microphone as the interviewer and the meeting sound as the candidate, and removes any scorecard quote that does not appear in the transcript. Whatever you use, the check is yours.
13. Cut before you paste
A full AI summary pasted into the ATS is long, and long notes do not get read. Keep what the next reader needs and delete the rest.
What should you do after the call?
14. Write three versions within the hour
The same call produces notes for different readers, and each needs different things:
| Reader | What they need | What to leave out |
|---|---|---|
| You and your team, in the ATS | Searchable facts: skills, pay, notice, location, availability, status, next step | Long narrative; anything you would not want the candidate to read |
| The client or hiring manager | Why this person, evidence against the must-haves, pay and start date, your view of the risk | Internal comments, other clients, fee talk |
| The next interviewer | What was covered, what to probe, open questions | Your overall verdict, so they form their own |
For the ATS version, how to write candidate notes in your ATS has a stage-by-stage template written for search. For the client version, the candidate submittal template has a filled example. If you are comparing several screened candidates for one role, the candidate comparison matrix template has a screening version.
15. Take out what does not belong
Before saving, reread for anything about health, family, age, religion, appearance or other personal matters the candidate mentioned in passing, and for shorthand like "not a fit" without a job-related reason. What not to write in interview notes has a rewrite table for each.
What does a good set of screen notes look like?
An invented example for an invented role, a warehouse operations supervisor, written the way the habits above suggest. It takes about the same time to write as a paragraph of impressions, and every line can be checked.
SCREEN: [candidate], Operations Supervisor, [client] [date], 25 min
Told candidate I was taking notes: yes Transcript: yes
MUST-HAVES
Leads a shift team Leads night shift, 14 pickers + 2 leads (stated)
"I do the schedule and the write-ups myself"
WMS experience Used [system] 3 yrs; was super-user in cutover (min 9)
Safety record x did not give site incident numbers; asked twice
PAY / NOTICE / START
Asking $68,000 base (stated); open to $65,000 with day shift
Notice: 2 weeks; no vacation booked
Start: from [date]
MOTIVATION
"Nights for four years. I want days and a site that is growing."
OTHER PROCESSES
Second round at [another company] next week; no offer yet
NOT COVERED Forklift certification, weekend rotation
RISK Day-shift preference is the main driver; counteroffer
likely if current site offers days
NEXT Submit today; client to probe safety numbersNotice what is missing: no adjectives, no guesses about personality, nothing about the candidate's family reasons for wanting days. The client gets facts, the candidate's own words on the two lines that matter most, and the recruiter's view of the risk, clearly labeled as such.
What small habits make the biggest difference?
- Tell the candidate you are taking notes. One sentence at the start explains the pauses and the typing.
- Mute while you type on phone screens; keyboard noise reads as distraction.
- Use a headset. It keeps your hands free and, if you transcribe, the audio clean.
- Leave ten minutes between screens. Back-to-back calls are where two candidates' details get swapped.
- Use the same template every time. Consistency across a desk is what makes notes comparable a month later, by you or anyone else.
- Read your notes as the client would. If a line would embarrass you when forwarded, rewrite it now.
Questions people ask
Should recruiters type or handwrite notes during phone screens?
Either works if the notes end up structured by must-have and saved the same hour. Typing is faster to move into an ATS but can be heard on the call, so mute while typing or use a quiet keyboard. Handwriting is quieter but has to be retyped, which is where many notes lose detail.
What should a recruiter write down about salary expectations?
Write the number exactly as the candidate said it, whether it is base or total pay, whether it is a range or a floor, the currency and pay period, and any condition attached, such as more flexibility for remote work. Mark it as stated by the candidate, and follow your local salary history rules about what you may ask.
Do I still need to take notes if I use an AI note taker?
Yes, but fewer. The tool captures what was said; you still need to write your own judgment, such as your recommendation and the risks, and check pay, notice period, dates, employer names and any quotes against the transcript before the notes are saved or sent.
How soon after a screen should recruiters write up notes?
Within the hour, and ideally before the next call. Detail fades quickly, and a recruiter running back-to-back screens will merge candidates in memory by the afternoon. Block ten minutes after each screen for the write-up.