Quebec Law 25 and automated decisions in hiring (2026): the section 12.1 notice, explanation and review
On this page
- What does section 12.1 require, step by step?
- When is a hiring decision "based exclusively on automated processing"?
- What other Quebec privacy duties apply to AI screening?
- How is section 12.1 enforced?
- How does Quebec compare with Ontario and the GDPR?
- What should staffing agencies do?
- A copy-ready notice for an automated decision
- Checklist for recruiters hiring in Quebec
- Questions people ask
Since September 22, 2023, section 12.1 of Quebec's Act respecting the protection of personal information in the private sector (CQLR c. P-39.1), added by Law 25 (S.Q. 2021, c. 25), requires any enterprise that uses personal information "to render a decision based exclusively on an automated processing of such information" to tell the person no later than when it informs them of the decision. On request, it must also give the personal information used, "the reasons and the principal factors and parameters that led to the decision," and the right to have that information corrected, and it must let the person submit observations to a staff member who can review the decision. Quebec's Commission d'accès à l'information (CAI) applies this to hiring: its example is software that automatically rejects applications. Section 12.1 adds a notice, explanation and review duty; unlike the GDPR, it does not forbid automated decisions. This is the position as of November 2026.
Which privacy law covers which Canadian employer, and Quebec's rules on recording interviews, are on recording interviews in Canada. This page is the detailed answer for automated screening and AI decisions in Quebec hiring.
Not legal advice. This summarizes CQLR c. P-39.1 as consolidated on LegisQuébec, the Charter of human rights and freedoms (CQLR c. C-12), and the CAI's pages on recruitment, Law 25 and sanctions, read on November 17, 2026. Some CAI pages are only in French; quoted French is our translation. Ask Quebec counsel how the rules apply to your tools.
What does section 12.1 require, step by step?
| Duty | When | What it means in hiring | Source |
|---|---|---|---|
| Tell the candidate the decision was exclusively automated | No later than when the decision is communicated | Say so in the rejection or advancement message | s. 12.1, first paragraph |
| Disclose the personal information used | On the candidate's request | For example, the resume fields, answers or test scores the tool used | s. 12.1(1) |
| Explain the reasons, principal factors and parameters | On request | Why this candidate was screened out and which criteria weighed most | s. 12.1(2) |
| Tell the candidate they can have the information corrected | On request | A route to fix a misread resume or a wrong answer | s. 12.1(3) |
| Opportunity to submit observations to a reviewer | After the decision | A recruiter "in a position to review the decision" reads what the candidate sends | s. 12.1, second paragraph |
The CAI's page for individuals adds that people "also have the right to ask that the decision be reviewed by a person" (CAI, our translation). Law 25's coming-into-force provision puts most of the Act, including the amendment that enacted section 12.1, in force on September 22, 2023 (text of the Act as passed, in French).
When is a hiring decision "based exclusively on automated processing"?
The Act does not define the phrase. The CAI's recruitment guidance does: a decision made "without human intervention, such as the automatic rejection of certain applications by sorting software" (our translation). In that case, the CAI says, the employer must tell candidates no later than when it informs them of the decision, give them additional information and offer them the right to ask for a review. Applied to common setups, our reading is:
| Setup | Section 12.1 triggered? | Why |
|---|---|---|
| Knockout question or match score below a cutoff auto-rejects, nobody looks | Yes | The CAI's own example: rejection by sorting software with no human intervention |
| AI interview or assessment score automatically advances or declines candidates | Yes | Both outcomes are decisions taken on the output alone |
| Tool ranks everyone; a recruiter reads each profile and decides | No | A person makes the decision; other duties below still apply |
| Tool ranks; recruiter opens only the top 20 and the rest are auto-declined | Likely yes, for those never reviewed | For them, no person intervened before the decision |
| Transcription or summaries read by the interviewer before scoring | No | The interviewer decides |
The CAI itself has said the rule is narrow. In its January 27, 2025 brief to the Ministère du Travail, "L'IA au travail : pour un meilleur encadrement", it listed the gaps: organizations need not disclose at collection that data will feed fully automated decisions, the provisions do not apply to decisions that are not fully automated, they set no criteria for what counts as a "decision," and the person must ask to get the explanation. It recommended, among other things, that the intent to use partially or fully automated decisions at work be disclosed as soon as it is confirmed. Those are recommendations, not law, as of November 2026.
What other Quebec privacy duties apply to AI screening?
- Notice at collection (s. 8). Tell candidates the purposes and means of collection, their access and correction rights, where applicable the third persons or categories of third persons who receive the information, and "the possibility that the information could be communicated outside Québec."
- Profiling technology (s. 8.1). Before collecting information with technology that can identify, locate or profile a person, inform them of the technology and how to activate those functions. The Act defines profiling as assessing characteristics, "in particular for the purpose of analyzing that person's work performance," among other traits. Scoring candidates is close to that definition.
- Privacy impact assessment (s. 3.3). Required for any project to acquire, develop or overhaul an information system involving personal information. The CAI's recruitment page says that before using an AI system "the employer must carry out" a privacy impact assessment (our translation).
- Data leaving Quebec (s. 17). Before communicating personal information outside Quebec, for example to a US screening vendor, conduct a privacy impact assessment and sign a written agreement that reflects it.
- Accuracy and retention (s. 11). Information used to make a decision must be up to date and accurate, and "is kept for at least one year following the decision." Keep the inputs and outputs of each automated decision for a year so you can answer a section 12.1 request.
- Only what is necessary. The CAI's recruitment guidance says an employer may collect only what is necessary to assess candidates, even with consent, and that AI use "should be communicated to candidates from the start of the process" (our translation).
Quebec's Charter of human rights and freedoms adds a hiring rule of its own: section 18.1 bars requiring, "in an employment application form or employment interview," information on any ground in section 10 (including race, sex, gender identity, pregnancy, sexual orientation, civil status, age, religion, language, ethnic or national origin, social condition and handicap), unless it is useful for applying section 20 or an existing affirmative action program. A screening tool that asks for, or infers, those traits raises that issue as well.
How is section 12.1 enforced?
Section 90.1(5) lists, as a failure open to a monetary administrative penalty, not informing a person of a decision based exclusively on automated processing or not giving them an opportunity to submit observations. Under section 90.12, the maximum is $50,000 for a natural person and, for others, $10,000,000 or 2% of worldwide turnover for the preceding fiscal year, whichever is greater. Separately, section 91 makes collecting or using personal information in contravention of the law an offence, with fines for enterprises of $15,000 to $25,000,000 or, if greater, 4% of worldwide turnover for the preceding fiscal year. The CAI's sanctions page says it can bring penal proceedings within five years of an offence, and that an enterprise can enter an undertaking with the CAI to remedy a failure.
How does Quebec compare with Ontario and the GDPR?
| Rule | Trigger | What it requires | Our page |
|---|---|---|---|
| Quebec, s. 12.1 | Decision based exclusively on automated processing | Notice by the time of the decision; explanation and correction on request; observations to a reviewer | This page |
| Ontario, ESA s. 8.4 | AI used to screen, assess or select applicants for a public posting (employers with 25+ employees) | A statement in the posting; no explanation duty | Ontario job posting requirements |
| EU GDPR, Article 22 | Decision based solely on automated processing with legal or similarly significant effects | Prohibited unless an exception applies, then human intervention, the right to contest and meaningful information about the logic | GDPR Article 22 in recruitment |
An employer hiring in Quebec and Ontario from one posting needs both: the Ontario AI statement in the ad, and the Quebec notice and review route if any step rejects candidates automatically.
What should staffing agencies do?
The CAI's recruitment guidance sets three extra duties for placement agencies (our translation): identify themselves to candidates and explain how their personal information will be used; obtain candidates' consent to keep their information for a secondary use; and tell candidates who the employer is as soon as possible or, if the employer does not want to be named early, send the employer anonymized applications. For section 12.1, the enterprise that renders the automated decision gives the notice, so if the agency's tool auto-rejects candidates for a client, agree in writing who sends the notice, who answers requests and who reviews observations.
A copy-ready notice for an automated decision
Example only: adapt with Quebec counsel and prepare a French version
Subject: Your application for [job title]
Your application was assessed by an automated system, without human
intervention, and was not selected for the next stage.
You may ask us for:
- the personal information used to make this decision;
- the reasons and the principal factors and parameters that led to it;
- the correction of any information that is inaccurate.
You may also send us your observations. A member of our recruiting
team who can review the decision will read them and reply.
Contact: [name or title], [email]. Our person in charge of the
protection of personal information: [title], [contact details].
Wider AI disclosure wording for postings and application forms is in our AI disclosure templates, and how screening vendors explain rejections is covered in AI screening tools that explain rejections.
Checklist for recruiters hiring in Quebec
- Map every step where software rejects, advances or ranks candidates, and mark the ones with no human decision.
- For each exclusively automated step, add the section 12.1 notice to the decision message.
- Prepare the explanation: inputs used, principal factors and parameters, and how to correct data. Get it from the vendor in writing.
- Name the reviewers who receive observations and give them authority to change the outcome.
- Do a privacy impact assessment before deploying any AI system, and another before data leaves Quebec.
- Tell candidates about AI use at the start of the process, and about profiling technology before collection.
- Keep decision inputs and outputs for at least one year after each decision.
- Remove questions and inferred features tied to Charter section 10 grounds.
Questions people ask
What does Quebec Law 25 require for automated decisions?
Section 12.1 of Quebec's Act respecting the protection of personal information in the private sector, in force since September 22, 2023, requires an enterprise that uses personal information to make a decision based exclusively on automated processing to tell the person no later than when it informs them of the decision. On request it must disclose the personal information used, the reasons and principal factors and parameters behind the decision, and the right to have the information corrected, and it must let the person submit observations to a staff member who can review the decision.
Does an AI resume screener trigger Quebec's section 12.1?
It does if the tool rejects or advances candidates without any human intervention. Quebec's Commission d'accès à l'information gives the automatic rejection of applications by sorting software as its example of a decision based exclusively on automated processing. If a recruiter reviews the output and makes the decision, section 12.1 does not apply, but the notice, profiling and privacy impact assessment duties still do.
Do Quebec employers have to tell candidates they use AI in hiring?
Section 12.1 requires notice only for exclusively automated decisions, at the latest when the decision is communicated. Separately, section 8.1 requires notice before collecting information with technology that can identify, locate or profile a person, and the Commission d'accès à l'information says the use of AI in hiring should be communicated to candidates from the start of the process.
What is the penalty for not giving a Quebec automated decision notice?
Failing to inform a person of an exclusively automated decision, or not giving them the opportunity to submit observations, is one of the failures listed in section 90.1 for which the Commission d'accès à l'information may impose a monetary administrative penalty. Under section 90.12 the maximum is $50,000 for a natural person and, for an enterprise, $10,000,000 or 2% of worldwide turnover for the preceding fiscal year, whichever is greater.