What is a stay interview? How it differs from an exit interview, and how to run one
On this page
- How does a stay interview work?
- How is a stay interview different from an exit interview and other check-ins?
- Why do employers use stay interviews?
- What legal points apply to stay interviews?
- What should a manager do with what they hear?
- How do you tell whether stay interviews are working?
- Do staffing agencies use stay interviews?
- A copy-ready stay interview record
- Questions people ask
A stay interview is a planned one-on-one conversation in which a manager asks a current employee what keeps them in the job, what might make them leave, and what would make the work better, so problems can be fixed before the person resigns. It differs from an exit interview, which asks a departing employee why they are leaving after the decision is made; a stay interview asks the same kind of questions while the answer can still change the outcome. It is not a performance review, and it carries a few legal cautions: during a union organizing campaign, soliciting grievances can imply a promise of benefits under the National Labor Relations Act unless the employer did it regularly before, and a request for change tied to a medical condition can be an accommodation request (as of November 2026).
How does a stay interview work?
- Choose who asks. Usually the direct manager, who controls most of what employees say matters (workload, development, recognition, schedule). Use HR or a skip-level manager where the relationship with the manager is the issue.
- Pick the moment. Not in the same meeting as a performance or pay review. Common points are a few months into a new role, once a year, and after a big change such as a reorganization, a new manager or a missed promotion.
- Invite plainly. Say what it is and what it is not: "I want to hear what keeps you here and what I could do better. This isn't a review and nothing you say changes your rating."
- Ask a few open questions and follow the answers; the full question bank is on stay interview questions.
- Listen more than you explain. Do not defend, promise or diagnose in the meeting.
- Agree actions and a date. One or two things the manager will do, and what cannot change and why.
- Follow up on the date. Report back on each action, including the ones that did not work out.
How is a stay interview different from an exit interview and other check-ins?
| Conversation | Who and when | Purpose | What it cannot do |
|---|---|---|---|
| Stay interview | Current employee, usually with their manager, on a planned schedule | Find and fix reasons someone might leave | Guarantee openness if trust is low |
| Exit interview | Departing employee, usually with HR or someone outside their line | Learn why people leave and spot urgent issues; see exit interview questions | Keep that person |
| Engagement survey | Everyone, usually anonymous, once or twice a year | Measure patterns across teams | Tell you what one person needs |
| Performance review | Manager rates the employee's work | Assess performance and set goals | Invite candor about leaving, because ratings are at stake |
| Regular one-on-one | Manager and employee, weekly or biweekly | Current work and blockers | Step back to the bigger "why do you stay" question without a deliberate prompt |
The two interviews work best as a pair. Exit interview themes tell you which stay interview questions to ask, and stay interviews test whether the fixes worked before more people leave; how to read the exit side is on how to analyse exit interview data.
Why do employers use stay interviews?
Because people keep leaving jobs voluntarily, and the exit interview comes too late to change any one decision. The Bureau of Labor Statistics counted 3.4 million quits in September 2026, a quits rate of 2.1 percent (Job Openings and Labor Turnover Survey, released November 3, 2026). A stay interview turns retention from a statistic into a list of specific, fixable things for one person on one team. It also surfaces internal moves: an employee who says the next step is "nowhere here" is describing an internal mobility gap the manager can act on, for example by pointing them to internal postings or a short internal project.
What legal points apply to stay interviews?
A stay interview is an ordinary management conversation, but four rules can turn a careless one into a problem. All as of November 2026, and not legal advice:
| Issue | The rule | What to do | Source |
|---|---|---|---|
| Union organizing | The NLRB lists, as interference, to "imply a promise of benefits by soliciting grievances from employees during a union organizing campaign," with an exception where the employer regularly solicited grievances before; it also lists coercively questioning employees about union activities | Make stay interviews a routine practice well before any campaign; never ask about union views; get labor counsel if a campaign starts | NLRB, Section 8(a)(1) |
| Disability accommodation | An employee may request accommodation in "plain English" and "need not mention the ADA"; requests need not be in writing | Treat "I can't keep doing nights because of my condition" as a possible request and pass it to HR | EEOC enforcement guidance, questions 1 and 3 |
| Retaliation | Protected activity includes "communicating with a supervisor or manager about employment discrimination, including harassment," and asking about pay "to uncover potentially discriminatory wages" | Escalate any discrimination or harassment concern the same day; never let it affect assignments or reviews | EEOC on retaliation |
| Notes | What a manager writes can be read later in a dispute | Record job-related facts and the employee's words; leave out health details, family plans and guesses about motives | What not to write in interview notes |
Confidentiality is the other trap. A manager cannot promise to keep a harassment or safety report private, so say at the start that most of the conversation stays between you, except anything the company must act on.
What should a manager do with what they hear?
| What you heard | Example | Response |
|---|---|---|
| Fixable by the manager | Unclear priorities, no feedback, a schedule clash | Agree a change and a date; report back |
| Needs someone else | Pay below range, a promotion process, tools or budget | Say who decides, take it to them, report the answer |
| Must be escalated now | Harassment, discrimination, safety, a medical limitation | Tell HR the same day, following policy |
| Wants a different role | "I'd like to move into analytics" | Map the route: internal postings, a gig, a mentor; see internal job posting template |
| Cannot change | Fully remote work in an on-site role | Explain honestly why; do not hint at a change you will not make |
The retention action plan that turns these into tracked work is on stay interview questions; this page does not repeat it.
How do you tell whether stay interviews are working?
Track whether they happen, whether actions close, and what happens to retention, without claiming more than the data shows. Example only: a department with 40 employees holds 36 stay interviews in a quarter (90 percent completion); managers agree 52 actions and close 39 within the agreed date (75 percent); over the following year, voluntary turnover among the 36 is compared with the department's previous year. A drop is encouraging, but stay interviews are rarely the only change, so read the result as a signal, not proof. We found no original, methodologically described benchmark for these rates as of November 2026.
Do staffing agencies use stay interviews?
- With long-assignment temps: the agency is the employer, so the agency's recruiter or account manager holds the conversation, not the client's supervisor; issues about the client's site go back to the client through the agency.
- With their own recruiters: desk recruiters leave for the same reasons other employees do, and their book of business often leaves with them.
- Accommodation and complaints: a temp who raises a medical limitation or harassment at the client's site needs the agency's HR process; see joint employer liability for why both may be responsible.
A copy-ready stay interview record
STAY INTERVIEW RECORD (example)
Employee: ____________ Role: ____________ Date: __/__/____
Held by: ____________ [ ] manager [ ] skip-level [ ] HR
What keeps you here (their words): ______________________________
What might make you leave (their words): ________________________
One thing that would make the work better: _______________________
Career interest (role, skills, timing): __________________________
Escalated to HR today? [ ] no [ ] yes: harassment / safety /
discrimination / accommodation (details in HR file only)
Actions agreed:
1. ________________ Owner: ______ Due: __/__/____
2. ________________ Owner: ______ Due: __/__/____
Cannot change, and why (as told to employee): ____________________
Follow-up meeting: __/__/____
The record is an example to adapt. Keep it short and factual, and store anything medical or about a complaint in the HR file, not in the manager's notes.
Questions people ask
What is the difference between a stay interview and an exit interview?
A stay interview is held with a current employee, usually by their own manager, to learn what keeps them and what might make them leave while there is still time to act. An exit interview is held with someone who has already resigned, usually by HR or someone other than their manager, to learn why they are leaving and what the organization should change. One aims to keep the person; the other learns from their departure.
Who should conduct a stay interview?
Usually the employee's direct manager, because the manager controls most of what an employee says would make them stay or leave, such as workload, development, recognition and schedule. Where the manager is the problem, or the employee is unlikely to speak openly, HR or a skip-level manager can hold it instead.
How often should you do stay interviews?
There is no legal or standard frequency. Many employers hold one after the first few months in a role and then about once a year, plus after a major change such as a reorganization, a new manager or a missed promotion. Keep them separate from performance reviews so the conversation is not about ratings.
Can a stay interview create legal problems?
It can if handled carelessly. During a union organizing campaign, soliciting grievances can imply a promise of benefits, which the NLRB lists as interference, unless the employer regularly did so before the campaign. An employee who describes a needed change related to a medical condition may be requesting accommodation, and a complaint of discrimination raised in the meeting is protected from retaliation. Route those to HR.
What should a manager do after a stay interview?
Write down what the employee said in their words, agree one or two actions with dates, and say plainly what cannot change and why. Escalate anything about harassment, safety, discrimination or accommodation to HR the same day. Then follow up on the agreed date; a stay interview with no follow-up tells the employee nobody was listening.