For hiring managers

What is an integrity test in pre-employment screening? Overt vs personality-based, and the laws that limit them

On this page
  1. What does an integrity test measure?
  2. What is the difference between overt and personality-based integrity tests?
  3. Is an integrity test a lie detector test?
  4. Which states restrict written integrity tests?
  5. What may an integrity test ask under the ADA?
  6. How should an integrity test fit into a hiring decision?
  7. How is an integrity test different from a polygraph, a background check or interview questions?
  8. What should staffing agencies know?
  9. A copy-ready integrity test review sheet
  10. Questions people ask

A pre-employment integrity test, also called an honesty test, is a written or online questionnaire that estimates how likely an applicant is to be honest, trustworthy and dependable at work, and so how likely they are to engage in counterproductive behavior such as theft or absenteeism. The U.S. Office of Personnel Management calls it "a specific type of personality test," and there are two kinds: overt tests, which ask directly about attitudes toward wrongdoing and the applicant's own past conduct, and personality-based tests, which measure related traits such as conscientiousness. Federal law does not treat a written honesty test as a lie detector, so it is lawful for most U.S. employers, but as of November 2026 Massachusetts bans written honesty examinations, Minnesota bars any test "purporting to test the honesty" of an applicant, and Rhode Island allows them only if the results are not the primary basis for the employment decision.

Not legal advice. This page summarizes the federal regulation, EEOC guidance and the three state statutes linked below, as checked in November 2026. The state list is not complete: check the law where the job is located before using any honesty test, and see lie detector tests in hiring for the states that regulate polygraphs.

What does an integrity test measure?

OPM's integrity and honesty tests page describes the target as "an applicant's tendency to be honest, trustworthy, and dependable," and says a lack of integrity is associated with "theft, violence, sabotage, disciplinary problems, and absenteeism." It makes five points a hiring manager should know before buying one:

  • It overlaps with personality. Integrity tests measure some of the same factors as standard personality tests, "particularly conscientiousness," and perhaps parts of emotional stability and agreeableness.
  • It adds to other tests. Used with a cognitive ability test, an integrity test "can substantially enhance the prediction of overall job performance."
  • Group differences are small. OPM reports "few, if any" average score differences between men and women or between racial and ethnic groups.
  • Age is the exception. Scores on both kinds of test "seem to be correlated with age," with younger applicants scoring lower, so check pass rates by age band as well.
  • It is not a cure. In OPM's words, integrity tests "will not eliminate dishonesty or theft at work."

How integrity tests compare with other methods on average validity and group differences, using the 2022 re-analysis of selection research, is on types of pre-employment assessments. Integrity tests are one kind of psychometric test, and they are judged by the same standards of reliability and validity.

What is the difference between overt and personality-based integrity tests?

The APA Dictionary of Psychology defines integrity testing as procedures to determine whether applicants are likely to engage in counterproductive work behavior, and splits it into the two kinds below. OPM adds that overt tests "make no attempt to disguise the purpose of the assessment."

Overt (clear-purpose) testPersonality-based test
What the items askAttitudes toward dishonest behavior and the applicant's own past involvement in wrongdoing, such as theft or illicit drug use (OPM)Character traits thought to be related to counterproductive behavior, such as dependability and rule-following (APA)
Made-up example item"In the past three years, have you taken merchandise from an employer without paying for it?""I finish my work properly even when no one will check it." (agree / disagree)
Purpose visible to the candidate?YesLess so
Main weaknessTransparency: OPM says "applicant faking is always a concern" and scores "should be interpreted with caution"Items may not look job-related; OPM notes that integrity test items can have low face validity, though strong negative reactions from applicants are rare
Legal flashpointQuestions about drug and alcohol use and about past conduct (see the ADA section below)Any scale designed to identify a mental health condition (an ADA medical exam)

Is an integrity test a lie detector test?

Not under federal law. The Employee Polygraph Protection Act bars most private employers from using lie detectors on applicants, and the Labor Department's rule defines a lie detector as "a polygraph, deceptograph, voice stress analyzer, psychological stress evaluator, or any other similar device" used to give an opinion on honesty. The same rule then excludes "written or oral tests commonly referred to as 'honesty' or 'paper and pencil' tests, machine-scored or otherwise; and graphology tests" (29 CFR 801.2(d)).

One line in that rule matters for newer tools: voice stress analyzers "include any systems that utilize voice stress analysis, whether or not an opinion on honesty or dishonesty is specifically rendered." A questionnaire is outside the Act; an AI interview tool that analyzes a candidate's voice for signs of deception may not be. Have counsel review any such tool, and see lie detector tests in hiring for the Act's exemptions and penalties.

Which states restrict written integrity tests?

The federal Act does not preempt stricter state laws. Three states reach written honesty tests specifically, each checked on the state's official code site in November 2026 (not a complete list):

StateStatuteWhat it says about written honesty testsPenalties and remedies
MassachusettsG.L. c. 149, § 19BA "lie detector test" includes any "written examination" used to detect deception, verify truthfulness or give a diagnostic opinion on honesty; employers may not subject or ask an applicant to take one, and giving it outside the state for a Massachusetts job is no defense. Every application for employment in the state must carry the statutory noticeFine of $300 to $1,000; repeat violations up to $1,500, up to 90 days in jail, or both; civil action within three years for treble damages for lost wages and benefits, at least $500 per violation, plus costs and attorney fees
MinnesotaMinn. Stat. 181.75No employer may "solicit or require a polygraph, voice stress analysis, or any test purporting to test the honesty" of an employee or applicant; no one may knowingly sell or interpret such a test for an employerA misdemeanor for the employer and for anyone knowingly selling, administering or interpreting the test; the Department of Labor and Industry investigates; injured people may sue for damages, costs and attorney fees
Rhode IslandR.I. Gen. Laws 28-6.1-1 and 28-6.1-4The definition of a lie detector test includes a "written examination," but written examinations "may be used as long as the results of the written examinations are not used to form the primary basis for an employment decision"A misdemeanor with a fine of up to $1,000 (28-6.1-2); in a civil action the court may award punitive damages and attorney fees (28-6.1-3)

The Massachusetts notice must appear "in clearly legible print" on every application for employment in the state: "It is unlawful in Massachusetts to require or administer a lie detector test as a condition of employment or continued employment. An employer who violates this law shall be subject to criminal penalties and civil liability." State-by-state interview rules are on Massachusetts, Minnesota and Rhode Island illegal interview questions pages.

What may an integrity test ask under the ADA?

The EEOC's guidance on preemployment disability-related questions and medical examinations says that a test "designed and used to measure only things such as honesty, tastes, and habits" is not a medical examination, so an integrity test may be given before an offer. Every item in it is still a pre-offer question, though, and overt tests often ask about drugs and alcohol. The guidance draws these lines, because past drug addiction and alcoholism can be disabilities:

ItemBefore a conditional offer
"Have you ever used illegal drugs?" "When is the last time you used illegal drugs?" "Have you used illegal drugs in the last six months?"Allowed: the EEOC says these are not likely to reveal past addiction
"How often did you use illegal drugs in the past?" "Have you ever been addicted to drugs?" "Have you ever been treated for drug addiction?"Not allowed: likely to reveal whether the applicant was a past drug addict
Whether the applicant drinks alcohol, or has been arrested for driving under the influenceAllowed
How much alcohol the applicant drinks, or whether they took part in an alcohol rehabilitation programNot allowed: likely to reveal alcoholism

State law can narrow this further. In California, the Civil Rights Department says employers generally "cannot ask a job applicant about their past use of cannabis," citing Government Code 12954(b); the protection does not apply to employers with four or fewer employees or to positions that involve a federal background investigation or security clearance (CRD cannabis FAQ, January 2024). Switch off cannabis items for California roles; the wider rules are on California drug testing laws.

How should an integrity test fit into a hiring decision?

  1. Check the state first. Massachusetts and Minnesota roles: no written honesty test. Rhode Island roles: only as a secondary input.
  2. Review every item against the ADA lines above and any state rules on drug, alcohol or cannabis questions. Ask the vendor for the full item list, not a sample.
  3. Use the same test at the same stage for everyone applying to the role, with an accommodation route in the invitation.
  4. Treat the score as one input. Rhode Island requires it, and it is sound practice everywhere: pair it with structured questions on past behavior (see interview questions for integrity) and reference checks.
  5. Set the decision rule before you look at results: a pass band, or a weighted share of the overall rating.
  6. Monitor pass rates by sex, race, ethnicity and age band, using the four-fifths rule as the first check.
  7. Keep the records: the test version, the item list you approved, the decision rule and each candidate's result.

How is an integrity test different from a polygraph, a background check or interview questions?

MethodWhat it relies onFederal positionRead more
Integrity testThe candidate's own answers to a questionnaireNot a lie detector; state limits applyThis page
Polygraph or voice stress analysisPhysiological or voice signalsBarred for most private employers, with narrow exemptionsLie detector tests
Background checkCourt, employment and education recordsFCRA steps when a consumer reporting agency prepares itFCRA process
Behavioral interview questions on integritySpecific past situations, probed by an interviewerLawful; scored against anchorsIntegrity interview questions
Personality questionnaireBroad work-style traitsNot medical unless designed to identify a mental disorderPersonality tests

What should staffing agencies know?

Agencies that screen for retail, warehouse, security and cash-handling clients are often asked to run an honesty module. The state rules follow the job, not the agency's office: Massachusetts says giving the test outside the state for a Massachusetts job is no defense, and its notice must be on every application for employment there. Minnesota's law reaches anyone who knowingly sells, administers or interprets an honesty test for an employer or its agent, which can include the agency. In Rhode Island, tell the client in writing that the result cannot be the primary basis for the decision. Everywhere else, run the client's module only after the item review above, and send the client a pass or band, not the candidate's item-level answers.

A copy-ready integrity test review sheet

INTEGRITY TEST REVIEW (example; complete before the test goes live)
Test / version: _____________________  Vendor: __________________
Type: [ ] overt  [ ] personality-based  [ ] both
Roles and work states: ______________________________________

State check
1. Any role located in Massachusetts or Minnesota?     [ ] no  [ ] yes -> do not use there
2. Any role in Rhode Island?                           [ ] no  [ ] yes -> secondary input only
3. Other states checked (list): ____________________________

Item review (full item list received [ ])
4. Items on frequency or amount of past drug use,
   addiction, or treatment?                            [ ] none [ ] remove before offer
5. Items on amount of drinking or alcohol rehab?       [ ] none [ ] remove before offer
6. Cannabis items for California roles?                [ ] none [ ] switch off
7. Medication or health items?                         [ ] none [ ] remove
8. Clinical or diagnostic scales?                      [ ] none confirmed by vendor

Use
9. Decision rule: [ ] pass band ____  [ ] weighted ____% of rating
10. Accommodation route in the invitation               [ ] yes
11. Pass rates by sex, race/ethnicity and age reviewed   on __/__/____
Owner: ____________  Counsel: ____________  Date: __/__/____

The sheet is an example to adapt with counsel. Repeat the state check whenever a requisition opens in a new state; the honesty-test rules are about where the job is, not where the test is taken.

Questions people ask

Are integrity tests legal for pre-employment screening?

Under federal law, yes: the Labor Department's polygraph rule says written or oral honesty tests are not lie detectors, so the Employee Polygraph Protection Act does not ban them. Some states differ. Massachusetts defines a lie detector test to include a written examination used to judge honesty, Minnesota bars any test purporting to test an applicant's honesty, and Rhode Island allows written honesty examinations only if the results are not the primary basis for the employment decision.

Is an honesty test the same as a lie detector test?

Not under federal law. A lie detector under the Employee Polygraph Protection Act is a device such as a polygraph or voice stress analyzer, and the Labor Department's rule expressly excludes written or oral honesty tests. But any system that uses voice stress analysis counts as a lie detector, so an AI tool that analyzes a candidate's voice for honesty is a different matter from a questionnaire.

Can a pre-employment integrity test ask about drug use?

Some drug questions are allowed before an offer and some are not. The EEOC says an employer may ask whether an applicant has ever used illegal drugs or used them in the last six months, but not how often they used drugs in the past or whether they were ever addicted or treated for addiction, because past addiction can be a disability. California employers generally may not ask applicants about past cannabis use at all.

What is the difference between an overt and a personality-based integrity test?

An overt, or clear-purpose, integrity test asks directly about attitudes toward dishonest behavior and about the applicant's own past wrongdoing, such as theft or illicit drug use, so its purpose is obvious and faking is a concern. A personality-based integrity test measures character traits linked to counterproductive behavior, such as conscientiousness and dependability, without asking about wrongdoing directly.

Do integrity tests discriminate?

The U.S. Office of Personnel Management reports few, if any, average score differences between men and women or between racial and ethnic groups on integrity tests, which is why they are often paired with tests that show larger differences. OPM also notes that scores tend to correlate with age, with younger applicants scoring lower. Employers should still check pass rates by group on their own applicants.