When a candidate disputes a background check: the FCRA reinvestigation and what the employer does meanwhile (2026)
On this page
- What happens when a candidate disputes a background check?
- Where does the candidate file the dispute?
- What must the screening company do, and by when?
- What should the employer do while the dispute is open?
- What if the record belongs to someone else?
- What happens when the reinvestigation ends?
- What if you already made the final decision?
- What about records you found yourself?
- Who handles the dispute on a staffing placement?
- A dispute acknowledgment email (example)
- Summary
- Questions people ask
When a candidate disputes a background check, the dispute goes to the screening company, not the employer. Under 15 U.S.C. § 1681i the screening company must reinvestigate free of charge and correct, delete or confirm the item within 30 days of receiving the dispute (up to 45 if the candidate sends relevant information during the first 30), and send the candidate the results. Meanwhile the employer holds its decision inside the pre-adverse action window, considers what the candidate provides, and reassesses on the corrected report; as of November 2026, California, New York City, Illinois and Washington add rules for that window.
This page is the dispute itself: where it is filed, what the screening company must do and by when, what you do while it runs, and what happens at the end. The notice that starts the window is on the pre-adverse action notice, the local minimum waiting periods are on how long a background check takes, and the final letter is on the adverse action notice.
Not legal advice. This summarizes the Fair Credit Reporting Act, FTC staff guidance and the state and city rules linked below as we read them in November 2026. Confirm the rules where the job is performed with counsel.
What happens when a candidate disputes a background check?
Two things run side by side, on different clocks:
- The screening company's reinvestigation, governed by § 1681i: a fixed federal timetable that starts when the company receives the dispute.
- Your hiring decision, governed by § 1681b(b)(3) and local fair chance laws: you may not take adverse action until you have given the pre-adverse notice and a reasonable period has passed, and you must weigh what the candidate tells you in that time.
The pre-adverse notice exists for this moment. The FTC and EEOC joint employer guide says that by giving it in advance, "the person has an opportunity to review the report and explain any negative information" (Background Checks: What Employers Need to Know).
Where does the candidate file the dispute?
- With the screening company that prepared the report, directly or through a reseller, and free of charge (§ 1681i(a)(1)(A)). Your final notice must give that company's name, address and telephone number and tell the candidate of the right to dispute (§ 1681m(a)(3)–(4)); putting the same details in the pre-adverse notice saves days.
- A free copy of the file is available if the candidate asks within 60 days of an adverse action notice, and once in any 12 months to a person who certifies they are unemployed and intend to apply for work within 60 days (§ 1681j(b), (c)(1)).
- If the record came from identity theft, the candidate can ask for a block instead: with proof of identity, an identity theft report and a statement that the item is not theirs, the screening company must block it within four business days (§ 1681c-2(a)).
The employer cannot file the § 1681i dispute for the candidate, because the duty is triggered by the consumer's dispute. You can, under your service contract, ask the screening company to recheck a record you think is wrong.
What must the screening company do, and by when?
| Step | Deadline | Section |
|---|---|---|
| Reasonable reinvestigation, free of charge: record the current status of the item or delete it | 30 days from receiving the dispute; up to 15 more if the candidate sends relevant information during the 30 days (not if the item is already found inaccurate or unverifiable) | § 1681i(a)(1) |
| Notify the person or source that supplied the item, with all relevant information from the candidate | 5 business days from receiving the dispute | § 1681i(a)(2) |
| Consider all relevant information the candidate submits | During the reinvestigation | § 1681i(a)(4) |
| Delete or modify an item found inaccurate, incomplete or unverifiable; reinsert it only if the source certifies it is complete and accurate, with written notice to the candidate | Promptly; reinsertion notice within 5 business days | § 1681i(a)(5) |
| Send the candidate the results, a revised report, and notice of the right to add a statement and to have past recipients notified | 5 business days after finishing | § 1681i(a)(6) |
| If the dispute is treated as frivolous or irrelevant, tell the candidate why and what information is needed | 5 business days after that determination | § 1681i(a)(3) |
| Reseller that receives a dispute: check its own errors and correct them, or pass the dispute to the company that supplied the information | 5 business days to decide; 20 days to correct its own error | § 1681i(f)(2) |
FTC staff describe a reasonable reinvestigation as, at a minimum, checking with the original or other reliable sources, telling them what the consumer submitted, and asking whether they confirm the item, qualify it or accept the consumer's explanation; repeating the same question to the same source may not be enough, and a screening company "must assume a consumer's dispute is bona fide, unless there is evidence to the contrary" (FTC staff report, July 2011, pp. 76–77). For criminal records, that usually means going back to the court file.
What should the employer do while the dispute is open?
- Do not make the decision final. Federal law sets no fixed waiting period; FTC staff say "some reasonable period of time must elapse" after the pre-adverse notice (FTC staff report, p. 52). A known, open dispute is a strong reason to keep waiting.
- Acknowledge the dispute in writing and say how long you will hold the decision (an example email is below). Decide the hold period in your policy, not case by case, so every candidate gets the same time.
- Keep the job open where a local law requires it. New York City requires the position to be held for at least five business days after the candidate receives the inquiry and your Fair Chance Analysis, and Washington requires at least two business days for the person to "correct or explain the record" (NYC CCHR guidance; RCW 49.94.010(5)(b)).
- Apply the extra local time. In California, if the candidate notifies you in writing within the response period that they dispute the accuracy of the conviction history and are taking specific steps to obtain evidence, they get "no fewer than five additional business days" before the decision becomes final (2 CCR § 11017.1(c)(2)(F)). Illinois requires your preliminary notice to say the response may include "evidence challenging the accuracy of the conviction record," with at least five business days to respond (775 ILCS 5/2-103.1(C)).
- Consider what the candidate sends you directly, such as a certified court disposition or proof of identity. California requires the employer to consider any information the applicant submits before a final decision (§ 11017.1(c)(3)).
- Reassess on the corrected record. New York City's Commission says that when an applicant identifies an error, the employer must redo its Fair Chance Analysis on the corrected information and, if it still intends to act, give the corrected inquiry, the analysis and at least five more business days to respond.
- Keep a file: the dates of the notice, the dispute, each message and the outcome.
What if the record belongs to someone else?
Mixed files (a record matched to the wrong person) are the classic dispute. The screening company must "follow reasonable procedures to assure maximum possible accuracy" (§ 1681e(b)), and when it reports public records for employment it must either notify the candidate at the time or keep "strict procedures" so the record is complete and up to date (§ 1681k(a)). The CFPB withdrew its 2021 advisory opinion on name-only matching and its 2024 advisory opinion on background screening on May 12, 2025 (90 FR 20084); the statute did not change. The industry accreditation standard asks screening companies to match at least two identifiers, a full name plus one more such as date of birth, Social Security number or driver's license number, or to use a procedure shown to be as effective (PBSA U.S. Employment Screening Standard, version 3.0, clause 2.15). If a hit was matched on name alone, say so to the screening company.
What happens when the reinvestigation ends?
| Outcome | What the screening company does | What you do |
|---|---|---|
| Item deleted or corrected | Sends the candidate a revised report; at the candidate's request, notifies anyone they name who received a report for employment purposes in the past two years (§ 1681i(d)) | Get the revised report and reassess on it; if nothing disqualifying remains, proceed with the hire |
| Item confirmed | The candidate may file a brief statement of dispute (the company may limit it to 100 words); later reports must note the dispute (§ 1681i(b), (c)) | Run or finish the individualized assessment, then decide |
| Dispute treated as frivolous | Tells the candidate why and what information it needs (§ 1681i(a)(3)) | Consider any evidence the candidate gives you directly before deciding |
If you still decide not to hire, send the final adverse action notice. If the record is confirmed but the candidate shows rehabilitation or that the record is unrelated to the job, the individualized assessment is where that is weighed.
What if you already made the final decision?
The FCRA does not require you to reopen a decision when a later reinvestigation deletes an item. But if the deleted item was the reason for the decision, reopening is usually the fair and lower-risk course. In California, the final notice must describe any procedure you have for the applicant to challenge the decision or request reconsideration, and the right to file a complaint with the Civil Rights Department (§ 11017.1(c)(4)), so have a procedure to describe.
What about records you found yourself?
Section 1681i covers reports from screening companies. A court search your own staff ran, or a news article, is not reinvestigated by anyone, so your process has to do the work. California requires notice and "a reasonable opportunity to present evidence that the information is factually inaccurate" for conviction history obtained from a source other than the applicant, such as "internally generated research," and if the person shows it is inaccurate, "that information cannot be considered" (§ 11017.1(f)(4)(E)). Washington's chance to "correct or explain the record" applies whatever the source.
Who handles the dispute on a staffing placement?
The party that ordered the report is the user: it gives the notices, receives the candidate's response and decides. If the agency ordered the check, the agency handles the dispute and tells the client only what the contract allows; if the client ordered it, the client does. Write the dispute route into the client contract, and see background checks for staffing agencies for the rest of the split.
A dispute acknowledgment email (example)
An example to adapt with counsel; replace the bracketed items.
Subject: Your background check: we have received your dispute
Dear [name],
Thank you for telling us on [date] that you dispute [item] in the
background report prepared by [screening company].
What happens next:
- To have the report itself corrected, contact [screening company]
at [address, phone, web form]. It must reinvestigate free of charge
and normally finish within 30 days.
- You may also send us anything that shows the record is wrong or not
yours, such as a certified court disposition, or anything else you
want us to consider. Send it to [contact] by [date].
- We will not make a final decision before [date]. [If you need more
time to get documents, tell us before then.]
We will review the corrected report or your documents before deciding
and will tell you our decision in writing.
[Name, title, contact details]
Summary
| Item | The rule, as of November 2026 | Source |
|---|---|---|
| Where to dispute | With the screening company, free; directly or through a reseller | § 1681i(a)(1) |
| Reinvestigation time | 30 days, plus up to 15 if the candidate sends relevant information | § 1681i(a)(1) |
| Results | Within 5 business days after finishing, with a revised report | § 1681i(a)(6) |
| Telling past recipients | At the candidate's request, employers who received a report in the past two years | § 1681i(d) |
| Employer's wait | A reasonable period after the pre-adverse notice; longer local minimums apply | § 1681b(b)(3); FTC staff report p. 52 |
| California dispute extension | At least 5 more business days; inaccurate information cannot be considered | 2 CCR § 11017.1(c)(2)(F), (f)(4)(E) |
| New York City | Redo the Fair Chance Analysis on the corrected record | CCHR guidance |
Questions people ask
What happens if a candidate disputes their background check?
The candidate tells the screening company, which must reinvestigate free of charge and correct, delete or confirm the item within 30 days of receiving the dispute, or up to 45 days if the candidate sends relevant information during the first 30 (15 U.S.C. 1681i(a)(1)). Meanwhile the employer should hold its decision, consider what the candidate sends, and reassess on the corrected report before deciding.
Does an employer have to wait for a background check dispute to finish before deciding?
Federal law does not say the employer must wait for the reinvestigation to end; it requires a pre-adverse action notice and a reasonable period before the final decision. Some local laws add time or rules: in California a candidate who says in writing that they dispute the record and are getting evidence gets at least five more business days, and information shown to be factually inaccurate cannot be considered. Many employers choose to hold the job until the screening company reports back.
Can an employer dispute a background check on the candidate's behalf?
The FCRA reinvestigation is triggered by the consumer's own dispute, made to the screening company directly or through a reseller (15 U.S.C. 1681i(a)(1)(A)). The employer can tell the candidate how to dispute, consider documents the candidate sends, and ask its screening company under the service contract to recheck a record, but the formal dispute belongs to the candidate.
How long does a background check company have to fix an error?
Thirty days from receiving the dispute, extendable by up to 15 days if the candidate provides relevant information during that period; the extension does not apply if the item is found inaccurate or unverifiable within the 30 days. The company must notify the source of the information within five business days and send the candidate the results within five business days after it finishes.
Will the employer be told if a background check is corrected?
Only if someone tells it. Under 15 U.S.C. 1681i(d), after deleting an item or noting a dispute, the screening company must, at the candidate's request, notify anyone the candidate names who received a report on them for employment purposes in the previous two years. Candidates can also send the employer the revised report the screening company must provide with its results.