Consent and compliance

Individualized assessment of criminal history: where the law requires one and how to run it (2026)

On this page
  1. Where is an individualized assessment required?
  2. What factors does each law require you to weigh?
  3. How do you run one, step by step?
  4. What may you never require or do?
  5. How does it fit with the FCRA and federal law?
  6. What changes for staffing agencies?
  7. An individualized assessment worksheet (example)
  8. Questions people ask

An individualized assessment is a written, case-by-case review of whether a person's specific conviction is related to the duties of the specific job, done before an employer withdraws an offer or takes other adverse action because of criminal history. As of November 2026 no federal statute requires one for private employers, but state and city fair chance laws do, including California, New York State and New York City, Illinois, Washington, the District of Columbia, Philadelphia, Los Angeles and Los Angeles County. Each lists the factors it requires; all of them include the seriousness of the offense, the time since it and the duties of the job.

This page is the procedure across those laws: where it applies, what each law requires you to weigh, how to run and document it, and a worksheet. It does not repeat the city and state pages linked below. A one-company policy with its own assessment form is on the fair chance hiring policy template, and the notice that delivers your preliminary decision is on the pre-adverse action notice.

Not legal advice. This summarizes the statutes, ordinances and regulations linked below as we read them in November 2026. Coverage thresholds, exemptions and jobs that another law requires to be screened vary; confirm with counsel where the job is performed.

Where is an individualized assessment required?

JurisdictionThe test the record must meetSource
California (5+ employees)A "reasoned, evidence-based determination" of whether the conviction history has "a direct and adverse relationship with the specific duties of the job"2 CCR § 11017.1(c)(1); our California page
New York State (private employers with 10+ employees)No denial unless there is a "direct relationship" between the offense and the job or the employment would involve an "unreasonable risk," after considering eight listed factorsCorrection Law §§ 752, 753
New York City (4+ employees)The state test, applied through a written Fair Chance analysis shared with the applicant before any decisionNYC Commission on Human Rights; our NYC page
Illinois (1+ employees in Illinois for 20 weeks)A "substantial relationship" (whether the job offers the opportunity for the same or a similar offense and whether the circumstances will recur) or an "unreasonable risk"775 ILCS 5/2-103.1
Washington State (15+ employees from July 1, 2026; all from January 1, 2027)A "legitimate business reason," documented against six listed factorsRCW 49.94.005(6), 49.94.010(5); our Washington page
District of Columbia (more than 10 employees in DC)A "legitimate business reason" that is reasonable in light of six listed factorsD.C. Code § 32-1342(d)
PhiladelphiaA reasonable person would conclude employment poses a "specific unacceptable risk," exclusion is compelled by business necessity, after an individualized assessment of listed factorsCode § 9-3504(3), Bill 250373-A; our Philadelphia page
Los Angeles (10+ employees)A written assessment that "effectively links" specific aspects of the criminal history with risks inherent in the job's dutiesBCA rules
Unincorporated Los Angeles County (5+ employees)A written initial assessment of whether the history has a "direct, adverse and negative bearing" on the duties, then a second assessment after any responseCounty Code 8.300.050(G), (J)
HawaiiThe conviction must bear "a rational relationship to the duties and responsibilities of the position"; no assessment form or notice procedure is set in the sectionHRS § 378-2.5

San Francisco's Fair Chance Ordinance also requires notice and a chance to respond before adverse action; see our San Francisco page.

What factors does each law require you to weigh?

"Yes" means the law names the factor; a dash means it is not named, although you may still consider it where it is job-related. The Green column is the three factors from Green v. Missouri Pacific Railroad, the 1975 Eighth Circuit case.

FactorGreenCANYILWADCPhila.LA County
Nature, gravity or seriousness of the offenseYesYesYesYesYesYesYesYes
Time since the offense or sentenceYesYesYesYesYes (excluding incarceration)YesYesYes
Duties of the jobYesYesYesIn the testYes, plus place and mannerYesYesYes
Age when the offense occurred—YesYesYes—Yes—Yes
Number or frequency of convictions———YesYesYes——
Rehabilitation and evidence the person provides—YesYesYesYesYesYesYes
Work history before and after—Yes——Yes—Yes—
Certificate or licence counts in the person's favor—LicenceCertificate presumption———LicenceLicence presumption

California's regulation goes furthest on context. Under "nature and gravity" it lists whether the harm was to property or people, its degree and permanence, the context, the person's age, and whether a disability (including past drug addiction) or trauma, domestic or dating violence, sexual assault, stalking, human trafficking or duress contributed (§ 11017.1(c)(1)(B)(i)). New York adds the state's public policy of encouraging the employment of people with convictions and the employer's legitimate interest in protecting property and safety (§ 753(1)(a), (h)).

How do you run one, step by step?

  1. Confirm the record is one you may consider. Remove anything the local law excludes before you start: arrests without conviction, diversion, sealed and dismissed convictions and juvenile matters in California; arrest records (other than adult arrests pending trial) and juvenile conviction records in Washington; summary offenses and convictions older than the seven and four year limits in Philadelphia. The seven-year rule page lists state lookback limits.
  2. Write down the job's duties first. Take them from the job description: access to people, money, vehicles, drugs, data, unsupervised settings. Writing them before reading the record keeps the analysis about the job.
  3. Describe the conduct, not the label. What happened, whether the harm was to people or property, how serious it was. California notes the conduct "may significantly predate the conviction itself."
  4. Count the time. From the conduct and from the end of the sentence or release; Washington excludes periods of incarceration from the time elapsed.
  5. Test the link. Would this job give the opportunity for the same or a similar offense, and are the circumstances likely to recur in this workplace? That is Illinois's definition of a substantial relationship and part of Los Angeles County's job factor, and a useful question everywhere.
  6. Weigh what the person has provided. Rehabilitation, work since, training, references, bonding, certificates. Consider it if offered; do not demand it.
  7. Make and record a preliminary decision. If the record is not disqualifying, hire and close the file. If it may be, send the pre-adverse notice with the assessment where the law requires it, and hold the job open for the required time.
  8. Reassess in writing after any response, then send the final notice (adverse action notice) with the local items it requires.
  9. Keep the file. Los Angeles requires assessments and related records for three years from the application.

What may you never require or do?

  • California: refuse evidence the person offers at any stage; require rehabilitation evidence or a specific document such as a police report; require disclosure of survivor status; require medical records or disclosure of a disability (§ 11017.1(c)(2)(D)(iii)).
  • Washington: use a policy that automatically or categorically excludes people with a criminal record, or reject someone for not disclosing a record before a conditional offer (RCW 49.94.010(3)).
  • Everywhere: apply a stricter standard to some candidates than others for reasons tied to a protected characteristic. California's regulation names this disparate treatment (§ 11017.1(e)), and Title VII reaches it too.

How does it fit with the FCRA and federal law?

If a screening company prepared the report, the FCRA's pre-adverse action notice is still required, and the assessment belongs in that window, before the final decision. Federally, the EEOC rescinded its 2012 arrest and conviction records guidance on October 28, 2026. Title VII still applies, including its disparate impact provision (42 U.S.C. § 2000e-2(k)), and weighing the Green factors remains a sound way to make and document a decision where no local law applies. Some local rules, such as Los Angeles's, still refer to the EEOC's factors; the rescission does not change those rules. The two theories of liability are explained on disparate treatment vs disparate impact.

What changes for staffing agencies?

California's regulation is the most explicit (§ 11017.1(d)): agencies and clients are governed the same way; an agency must complete the assessment and notices before declining to admit or refer a worker from a pool, judged against the duties of the jobs the worker may be assigned to; a later re-check cannot disqualify a worker on history already found not disqualifying unless something material changed; and a client may not tell an agency to refer only workers without conviction records unless the position is exempt. Decide in the client contract who assesses, who signs the notices and who keeps the file.

An individualized assessment worksheet (example)

An example to adapt with counsel. Where an agency publishes its own form, use it or keep every item it contains: California's CRD assessment and reassessment forms, New York City's Fair Chance Notice, the Los Angeles BCA form, and the Los Angeles County forms.

INDIVIDUALIZED ASSESSMENT                         Confidential
Person: [name]   Job: [title]   Work location: [city, state]
Laws applied: [e.g. CA FCA + LA County FCO]   Reviewer: [name]
Conditional offer: [date]   Report received: [date]

A. RECORDS EXCLUDED BEFORE REVIEW (and why)
   [ ] arrests / diversion / sealed / juvenile / outside lookback

B. JOB DUTIES (from the job description, written first)
   1. [duty]  2. [duty]  3. [duty]  Setting: [place and manner]

C. EACH CONVICTION CONSIDERED
   Offense and date: [ ]   Conduct described: [ ]
   Harm (people / property), degree, permanence: [ ]
   Age at the time: [ ]   Number of convictions: [ ]
   Time since conduct: [ ]  since sentence ended or release: [ ]

D. LINK TO THE JOB
   Does the job offer the opportunity for similar conduct? [ ]
   Are the circumstances likely to recur here? [ ]
   Direct relationship / unreasonable risk / legitimate business
   reason (the test the law uses): [yes / no, and why]

E. INFORMATION FROM THE PERSON (optional for them)
   Rehabilitation, work since, training, references, bonding,
   certificate or licence: [ ]

F. PRELIMINARY DECISION: [hire / notice sent (date), due (date)]
G. RESPONSE RECEIVED: [date, summary]   REASSESSMENT: [ ]
H. FINAL DECISION AND REASON: [ ]   Date: [ ]   Second reviewer: [ ]

Questions people ask

What is an individualized assessment in a background check?

It is a written, case-by-case review of whether a person's specific conviction history is related to the duties of the specific job, done before an employer withdraws an offer or takes other adverse action. California's regulation describes it as a reasoned, evidence-based determination of whether the conviction history has a direct and adverse relationship with the specific duties of the job.

Is an individualized assessment required by federal law?

No federal statute requires one for private employers. The EEOC rescinded its 2012 guidance on arrest and conviction records on October 28, 2026, but Title VII still applies, including its disparate impact provision, and weighing the Green factors from the 1975 Eighth Circuit case (the nature and gravity of the offense, the time since it and the nature of the job) remains a sound way to make and document a decision. State and city laws, such as California's, Illinois's, New York's and Philadelphia's, do require one.

What factors go into an individualized assessment of a criminal record?

Every state and city law we checked that lists factors includes the nature or seriousness of the offense, the time since it, and the duties of the job. Most add evidence of rehabilitation the person provides, and several add the person's age at the time (California, New York, Illinois, the District of Columbia, Los Angeles County) or the number of convictions (Illinois, Washington, the District of Columbia). New York gives a certificate of relief from disabilities or of good conduct a presumption of rehabilitation.

Can an employer require a candidate to provide rehabilitation documents?

Not in California. The Fair Chance Act regulation says evidence of rehabilitation or mitigating circumstances is optional, and an employer may not require any of it, require a specific type of document, require the person to disclose survivor status or require medical records. The employer must accept and consider evidence the person chooses to provide at any stage.

Does a staffing agency have to do an individualized assessment?

In California, yes. The regulation says labor contractors and client employers are governed the same way, an agency must follow the assessment and notice steps before declining to admit or refer a worker from a pool, and the assessment must consider the duties of the jobs the person may be assigned to. Other fair chance laws cover employment agencies too; check the law where the job is performed.