Consent and compliance

Investigative consumer reports for employers: when a reference check becomes one, the three-day disclosure, and the nature-and-scope request

On this page
  1. What makes a report "investigative"?
  2. Which background checks are investigative?
  3. What must an employer do before ordering one?
  4. What goes in the nature-and-scope answer?
  5. What limits apply to the screening company?
  6. What if you reject the candidate because of it?
  7. Which states have their own investigative report rules?
  8. How should staffing agencies handle it?
  9. A copy-ready investigative report disclosure
  10. An investigative report checklist
  11. Questions people ask

An investigative consumer report is a background report, or part of one, built from personal interviews. In it, a screening company gathers information on a person's "character, general reputation, personal characteristics, or mode of living" from "neighbors, friends, or associates" or others who know them (15 U.S.C. § 1681a(e)). In hiring, that usually means a screening company asking references or former employers about performance or conduct. Confirming dates and titles does not count. Before ordering one, an employer needs the standard FCRA disclosure and authorization. Under § 1681d, it also needs a written notice delivered within three days of requesting the report, with the Summary of Your Rights, and a written answer within five days if the candidate asks about the "nature and scope" of the investigation. These are the rules as of November 2026.

The standard form is covered in the FCRA disclosure and authorization form, the summary in the FCRA Summary of Rights, and the full sequence in the FCRA background check process. This page is about the investigative report alone: what makes a report investigative, the extra notices, the limits on the screening company, and the state versions.

Not legal advice. This summarizes 15 U.S.C. §§ 1681a(e) and (y), 1681b(b), 1681d and 1681l, the FTC's July 2011 staff report on the FCRA (comments 603(e), 604(b)(2), 604(b)(3) and 606), and the state statutes linked below, as of November 2026. FTC staff comments are guidance, not regulations. Have counsel approve your forms.

What makes a report "investigative"?

Two things together: the information is about character, reputation, personal characteristics or mode of living, and it comes from personal interviews with people other than the candidate. The definition excludes "specific factual information on a consumer's credit record obtained directly from a creditor." The FTC staff report fills in the edges:

  • Interviews can be remote. "Personal interviews" include interviews "conducted by mail, telephone or electronic means, as well as in person."
  • The candidate's own words do not count. A report built only on interviews with the person themselves "is not an 'investigative consumer report.'"
  • Fact-checking is not an interview. A screening company confirming "the time and/or duration of employment, job titles/and or salaries" with a former employer is not interviewing them.
  • Evaluation is. A former employer's account of job performance "that goes beyond fact-checking," such as "whether the applicant had been disciplined on the job or terminated for cause," is an interview, and the report becomes investigative.
  • Unsolicited opinions count. If a source volunteers opinions and the screening company includes them, the report becomes investigative "despite the fact that the CRA did not originally intend to obtain the information."

Which background checks are investigative?

CheckInvestigative consumer report?WhySource
Screening company confirms dates, titles and salary with former employersNoFact-checking is not an interviewFTC comment 603(e)-3B
Screening company asks former managers about performance, discipline or a for-cause terminationYesEvaluation beyond fact-checkingFTC comment 603(e)-3B
Screening company interviews the references the candidate named about strengths and working styleYesPersonal characteristics gathered from associates§ 1681a(e)
Your own recruiter calls referencesNo, and the FCRA does not applyNo consumer reporting agency prepares a reportFTC comment 606(a)-2B
Criminal record, driving record or credit report with no interviewsNo, but still a consumer reportNo personal interviews§ 1681a(d), (e)
Third-party investigation of suspected workplace misconduct that meets § 1681a(y)NoExcluded from "consumer report," so it cannot be investigative§ 1681a(y); FTC comment 606(a)-1

The last row has its own notice. After adverse action based on such an investigation, the employer "shall disclose to the consumer a summary containing the nature and substance of the communication," although sources need not be named (§ 1681a(y)(2)). Reference platforms vary, so if a vendor collects references' opinions and sends them to you, ask it in writing whether it treats its reports as consumer reports. Our reference check template covers calls your own team makes.

What must an employer do before ordering one?

  1. Give the standard disclosure and get written authorization. The FTC says the § 1681b(b)(2) disclosure "must be made before a consumer report — including an investigative consumer report... — is requested," even though § 1681d adds another. You may include "a very limited notice of intent to procure an investigative consumer report" in that document. You may not put the nature-and-scope description in it, "because it would likely overshadow" the required disclosure (comment 604(b)(2)-3C).
  2. Send the investigative report disclosure. It must be "made in a writing mailed, or otherwise delivered, to the consumer, not later than three days after the date on which the report was first requested." It must say clearly that the report may include information on "character, general reputation, personal characteristics, and mode of living." It must include "a statement informing the consumer of his right to request the additional disclosures... and the written summary of the rights of the consumer" (§ 1681d(a)(1)). FTC staff add that it should say the report "involves personal interviews with sources such as neighbors, friends, or associates."
  3. Certify to the screening company. You certify that you made the disclosure and will answer a scope request (§ 1681d(a)(2)). The agency "shall not prepare or furnish" the report without that certification (§ 1681d(d)(1)).
  4. Answer a written request for the nature and scope. Give "a complete and accurate disclosure of the nature and scope of the investigation requested," in writing, "not later than five days after the date on which the request for such disclosure was received from the consumer or such report was first requested, whichever is the later" (§ 1681d(b)).
  5. Keep the proof. An employer is not liable for a violation of (a) or (b) if it "maintained reasonable procedures to assure compliance" (§ 1681d(c)). Dated copies of each notice are those procedures in practice.

What goes in the nature-and-scope answer?

FTC staff comment 606(b)-1 says it must include "a complete and accurate description of the types of questions asked, the types of persons interviewed, and the name and address of the investigating agency." It also says "a report user that provides the consumer with a blank copy of the form used to transmit the report from the agency to the user complies." You do not have to name sources or give a copy of the report at this stage. You may combine the scope description with the initial § 1681d disclosure, but only "where the employer is able to describe with sufficient specificity the nature and scope of any such investigation that might be requested in the future."

What limits apply to the screening company?

  • No inquiries that break equal employment law. The agency may not make an inquiry for employment purposes if the inquiry by the employer "would violate any applicable Federal or State equal employment opportunity law or regulation" (§ 1681d(d)(2)).
  • Fresh public records. Arrest, conviction, civil judgment, tax lien or judgment records in an investigative report must be verified "during the 30-day period ending on the date on which the report is furnished," except as § 1681k allows (§ 1681d(d)(3)).
  • Corroborated interview information. Adverse information from a neighbor, friend or associate needs confirmation "from an additional source that has independent and direct knowledge," unless the person interviewed "is the best possible source" (§ 1681d(d)(4)).
  • No recycling. Adverse non-public information from an earlier investigative report may not go into a later report unless re-verified or received within the preceding three months (§ 1681l).

What if you reject the candidate because of it?

The usual two-step process applies. First, the pre-adverse notice with "a copy of the report" and the summary of rights. Then, after a wait, the final notice. FTC staff comment 604(b)(3)-6A says an employer using an investigative report "may not redact references to investigative sources if those sources are included in the report." Screening companies "may provide employers with reports that do not specifically identify sources." See the pre-adverse action notice and the adverse action notice. When the reference concerns a criminal record, the local fair chance steps apply as well; see individualized assessment.

Which states have their own investigative report rules?

StateWhat the state requiresStatute
MassachusettsWritten disclosure before the report is requested, including "the precise nature and scope of the investigation requested and the right to have a copy of the report upon request," plus the candidate's written permissionM.G.L. c. 93, § 53
New YorkNotice and authorization before the report. On written request, whether a report was requested and which agency. For a job offer, a copy of Correction Law Article 23-A with the noticeGBL 380-c
MinnesotaWritten disclosure before the report, saying it may include information from personal interviews, with a check box for a free copy. The screening company discloses the nature and scope within five days of a written requestMinn. Stat. 13C.02
WashingtonThree-day written disclosure that includes "the written summary of the rights of the consumer prepared under RCW 19.182.080(7)." Nature and scope within five days of a written requestRCW 19.182.050
KansasThree-day written disclosure. Nature and scope within five daysK.S.A. 50-705
MarylandThree-day written disclosure. Nature and scope within five daysCom. Law § 14-1204
New HampshireThree-day written disclosure. Nature and scope within five daysRSA 359-B:6
MontanaThree-day written disclosure. On request, "the nature, scope, and substance of the investigation" within five daysMCA 31-3-113

Two cautions on that table. Several state statutes still exempt reports "to be used for employment purposes for which the consumer has not specifically applied": Kansas, Maryland, New Hampshire and Washington. Montana's text exempts reports for employment "for which the consumer applied." The federal statute dropped its version of that exemption in 1996 (Pub. L. 104-208), so the federal three-day disclosure applies to applicants either way. California has a separate Investigative Consumer Reporting Agencies Act with its own definition and forms, covered in California background check laws. Detail for other states is on New York, Massachusetts and Washington.

How should staffing agencies handle it?

The party that orders the report gives the notices. If the agency orders reference interviews through a screening company before submitting a candidate, the agency sends the § 1681d disclosure and answers any scope request. If the client orders its own, the client does. Agree in writing who orders which check and who sends which notice. Do not forward an investigative report to a client without counsel's view of whether the FCRA's permissible-purpose rules, and any state dissemination limits, allow it. See background checks for staffing agencies.

A copy-ready investigative report disclosure

An example to review with counsel and your screening company, not a finished legal form:

Notice of investigative consumer report

[Company] has requested, or may request, an investigative consumer report about you from [screening company name, address, phone] in connection with your application for [position]. This report may include information about your character, general reputation, personal characteristics and mode of living, obtained through personal interviews with people such as former employers, references and associates.

You have the right to request, in writing, a complete and accurate disclosure of the nature and scope of the investigation. Send your request to [name, email, address]; we will respond in writing within five days of receiving it or of requesting the report, whichever is later.

A copy of "A Summary of Your Rights Under the Fair Credit Reporting Act" is enclosed. [Add state notices where the job is located, for example New York Correction Law Article 23-A.]

An investigative report checklist

  • Decide whether the check involves interviews beyond fact-checking. If it does, treat it as investigative.
  • Standard disclosure and authorization signed before ordering, as a stand-alone document.
  • § 1681d disclosure and the Summary of Rights delivered no later than three days after the request.
  • Certification given to the screening company.
  • Scope requests diaried and answered in writing within five days.
  • State add-ons checked (Massachusetts timing and permission, New York Article 23-A, Minnesota check box).
  • Pre-adverse packet includes the unredacted report as received, and the summary.

Questions people ask

What is an investigative consumer report?

Under 15 U.S.C. 1681a(e), it is a consumer report, or part of one, in which information on a person's character, general reputation, personal characteristics or mode of living is obtained through personal interviews with neighbors, friends, associates or others who know the person. In hiring, it usually means a screening company interviewing references or former employers about the candidate's performance or conduct, rather than only confirming dates and titles.

Is a reference check an investigative consumer report?

It depends on who runs it and what is asked. FTC staff said that when an employer's own staff call a candidate's references, the FCRA does not apply because no consumer reporting agency prepares a report. When a screening company only confirms dates of employment, job titles or salary, the report is not investigative; when it asks a former employer whether the person was disciplined or terminated for cause, it is.

What disclosure is required for an investigative consumer report?

In addition to the standard FCRA disclosure and written authorization, 15 U.S.C. 1681d(a) requires a written disclosure, mailed or otherwise delivered no later than three days after the report is first requested, that the report may include information on character, general reputation, personal characteristics and mode of living. It must state the right to request more information about the nature and scope of the investigation and include the written Summary of Your Rights Under the FCRA.

What must an employer tell a candidate who asks about the nature and scope of an investigative report?

Within five days of the written request, or of first requesting the report if that is later, the employer must give a complete and accurate written disclosure of the nature and scope of the investigation. FTC staff said this means the types of questions asked, the types of people interviewed, and the screening company's name and address; a blank copy of the form used for the report complies. The names of sources and a copy of the report are not required at that stage.

Do state laws add rules for investigative consumer reports?

Yes, several do. California has its own Investigative Consumer Reporting Agencies Act. Massachusetts requires the disclosure, including the precise nature and scope and the right to a copy, before the report is requested, plus written permission. New York requires notice and authorization first and a copy of Correction Law Article 23-A when the report relates to an offer of employment. Kansas, Maryland, Montana, New Hampshire and Washington mirror the federal three-day and five-day timing.