Templates

Candidate fraud policy template: identity checks by stage, escalation, reporting and records

On this page
  1. What do you need to decide before writing the policy?
  2. The candidate fraud policy template
  3. Which law or guidance does each clause answer to?
  4. How do you fill in Appendix A, the checks by role tier?
  5. What mistakes make a candidate fraud policy backfire?
  6. How do you roll the policy out?
  7. Questions people ask

A candidate fraud policy is the company document that says how you confirm that the person you hire is the person who applied and interviewed, and what happens when they are not: which identity checks run at each hiring stage, that every candidate for the role gets the same check, how third-party checks follow the Fair Credit Reporting Act, who a concern goes to and how fast, how the candidate is told, when fraud is reported and to whom, and which records are kept. Below is a copy-ready template with [bracketed] fields, labelled as an example to review with counsel, the decisions to make first, and the federal rules behind each clause as of November 2026.

This page is the policy. The stage-by-stage checks in detail are in the candidate identity verification checklist, and where to file in how to report candidate fraud.

Example only, not legal advice. The template reflects federal rules and FBI guidance linked below as of November 2026. State and city laws on biometrics, recording, background checks and monitoring change it. Have counsel review it for every place you hire before you adopt it.

What do you need to decide before writing the policy?

DecisionOptionsA common default
Which roles get which checksOne standard for all; tiers by riskTiers: remote roles with system access get the most checks, since FBI warnings center on them
How the live ID check is doneInterviewer on video; an ID and selfie verification tool; in personInterviewer on video for most roles; a tool only after biometric consent rules are checked
Whether there is an in-person stepNone; drug test or fingerprinting; office visitOne in-person step for remote roles with access, as the FBI's July 2025 guidance suggests "when possible"
Who owns a concernRecruiter; HR; a named fraud leadA named lead in HR with security and legal on call
Who decides to reportRecruiter; HR; legalHR and legal together, on documented facts
Agency placementsAgency checks; client checks; bothWritten split in the client agreement

The candidate fraud policy template

Copy it into your own document and replace everything in square brackets.

CANDIDATE FRAUD PREVENTION AND RESPONSE POLICY (EXAMPLE)
[Organization]     Version [x]     Effective [date]
Owner: [name, role]     Legal review: [date]     Next review: [date]

1. PURPOSE AND SCOPE
1.1 This policy sets out how [Organization] confirms that each person
    hired is the person who applied and interviewed, and how suspected
    candidate fraud is handled, escalated, reported and recorded.
1.2 It applies to applicants for [all roles / roles listed in
    Appendix A] in [locations], including candidates submitted by
    staffing agencies, and to new hires until [day 90].
1.3 Candidate fraud includes: using another person's identity (stolen,
    rented or synthetic); a different person attending an interview or
    doing the work; altered or manipulated video or voice; false
    documents, credentials or employers; and equipment or pay routed
    to someone other than the employee. Use of AI during interviews is
    covered by [the interview conduct policy], not this policy.

2. PRINCIPLES
2.1 Every candidate for the same role receives the same checks at the
    same stage. No one may add or skip a check for an individual.
2.2 No check is triggered, and no decision is made, because of a
    candidate's name, accent, appearance, national origin, citizenship
    or immigration status, or school or employer abroad.
2.3 Concerns are decided on documented facts from these checks.
2.4 Any candidate may ask for an accommodation or an alternative way
    to complete a check. Requests go to [role].

3. IDENTITY CHECKS BY STAGE (details in Appendix A)
3.1 Application: contact details and resume text are compared with
    existing records in [ATS] for duplicates.
3.2 First live interview: video with camera on and photo ID held to
    the camera, [by the interviewer / through (tool)]. The ID is not
    recorded or copied.
3.3 Every later round: the interviewer confirms it is the same person.
3.4 Before offer: employment and education claims are verified using
    contacts found independently, never those supplied by the
    candidate. Licenses and certifications are checked on the issuer's
    own lookup.
3.5 After offer: background check under section 4; [in-person step].
3.6 Onboarding: Form I-9 completed under the employer's I-9 procedure;
    [E-Verify case created as required by our MOU]. Equipment is
    shipped only to the address on the identity documents the employee
    presents, with signature on delivery. Pay goes only to an account
    in the employee's name. No system access until the background
    check is complete.
3.7 First [90] days: managers report changes of address or bank
    account requested soon after start, and any sign that a different
    person is doing the work, to [role].

4. THIRD-PARTY CHECKS
4.1 Checks by a consumer reporting agency or verification service are
    ordered only after the candidate receives a standalone written
    disclosure and signs a written authorization.
4.2 Before any decision based in whole or in part on such a report,
    the candidate receives a pre-adverse action notice, a copy of the
    report and the summary of rights, and [5 business days] to
    respond; then an adverse action notice if the decision stands.
4.3 Biometric verification tools are used only after [the notice and
    written release required by applicable law].

5. WHAT COUNTS AS A CONCERN
5.1 A failed or refused identity check; a different person between
    rounds; documents that do not reasonably appear genuine or relate
    to the person; employers, degrees or licenses that cannot be
    verified; contact details or bank accounts shared with other
    candidates or employees; equipment requested at another address.
5.2 Signals from interview software are prompts for a follow-up
    question, never evidence of fraud on their own.

6. ESCALATION
6.1 Anyone with a concern records the facts in [system] and tells
    [fraud lead] within [1 business day]. They do not confront the
    candidate or discuss the concern with other candidates.
6.2 If the person has any system access or equipment, [fraud lead]
    informs Security at once.
6.3 [Fraud lead] arranges one re-verification through an independent
    channel, using the same script used for every candidate.

7. DECISION AND COMMUNICATION
7.1 HR [and the hiring manager] decide on the documented facts.
7.2 The candidate is told neutrally that the process cannot continue,
    without accusing them. FCRA steps in section 4 apply where a report
    was used.
7.3 Offers are withdrawn and employment ended only with HR [and
    Legal] approval.

8. REPORTING
8.1 Legal and HR decide whether to report. Typical routes: the FBI
    (ic3.gov or a field office) for stolen identities, proxies,
    deepfakes or laptop farms; the state licensing board for false
    licenses; SSA's Office of the Inspector General for Social Security
    number misuse; [others].
8.2 We do not keep blocklists of names. We may block specific phone
    numbers, emails, devices, documents and addresses tied to an
    incident.
8.3 Possible payments to sanctioned persons go to Legal immediately.

9. RECORDS
9.1 We keep the incident record, checks performed, results, the
    decision and the reason for at least [one year] from the decision,
    or longer if a charge, claim or legal hold applies.
9.2 Form I-9 and attached documents stay in the I-9 file under the
    I-9 procedure and are shared only as Legal directs.
9.3 Interview recordings or transcripts are kept only if made with
    consent under [the interview recording policy].

10. STAFFING AGENCIES AND CLIENTS
10.1 Each agency agreement states who performs each check in
     section 3, who orders background reports and sends FCRA notices,
     how the agency documents its checks for us, and who reports.
10.2 Agencies provide their identity-check records for submitted
     candidates on request.

11. TRAINING AND REVIEW
11.1 Interviewers and recruiters are trained on this policy [yearly].
11.2 [Owner] reviews outcomes, including false alarms, every [6]
     months and updates the checks.

Appendix A: Checks by role tier   Appendix B: State and city rules
Appendix C: Re-verification script   Appendix D: Incident record form

Which law or guidance does each clause answer to?

ClauseRule or source
2.1, 2.2 Same checks for all; no national origin or citizenship screeningTitle VII (42 U.S.C. 2000e-2); the INA's anti-discrimination provision, which also bars document abuse (8 U.S.C. 1324b); see citizenship status discrimination in hiring
2.4 Accommodation for checksThe ADA's reasonable accommodation duty (42 U.S.C. 12112(b)(5))
3.2 Video and photo ID; 3.6 shipping, pay and accessFBI guidance: video with an unobscured background, ship equipment "only to the address listed in the employee's identification documents," and "do not grant access to any systems until the background check is completed" (FBI, July 23, 2025)
3.1 Duplicate checks in the ATSThe FBI says to "cross-check HR systems for other applicants with the same resume content and/or contact information" (FBI, January 23, 2025)
3.6 Form I-9 and E-VerifyThe Form I-9 (edition 01/20/25) and its anti-discrimination notice; E-Verify never before an offer is accepted (E-Verify three-day rule)
4.1, 4.2 Third-party checksFCRA disclosure and authorization and pre-adverse action (15 U.S.C. 1681b(b)); adverse action (15 U.S.C. 1681m); see FCRA process
4.3 Biometric toolsState biometric laws such as Illinois BIPA; see BIPA and hiring tools
8.2 No name blocklistsThe FBI warns that ban lists or name filtering "risks negatively impacting potential victims of identity theft" (FBI, October 13, 2026)
8.3 SanctionsOFAC "may impose civil penalties for sanctions violations on a strict liability basis" (Treasury, March 12, 2026)
9.1 One-year retentionEEOC: application and hiring records kept one year from the record or the action, whichever is later, and until final disposition if a charge is filed (29 CFR 1602.14)
9.2 Form I-9 handlingThe form may be used only for immigration enforcement and specified fraud statutes (8 U.S.C. 1324a(b)(5)); I-9 retention rules

How do you fill in Appendix A, the checks by role tier?

TierTypical rolesChecks beyond the standard
1On-site roles, no system access before day oneStandard checks; the Form I-9 document review happens in person
2Remote roles with ordinary system accessLive photo ID check on video; independent employment verification; shipping and payroll rules
3Remote roles with privileged access, source code, financial systems or regulated dataTier 2 plus an in-person step, a second live ID check before the offer, and security review of the first 90 days

Write the tiers by role, not by candidate. Clause 2.1 means a recruiter cannot move one candidate into tier 3 because something "felt off"; they record the concern under section 6 instead.

What mistakes make a candidate fraud policy backfire?

  • Checks for some candidates only. Selective checks are where discrimination claims start. The policy's value is that everyone gets the same treatment.
  • Asking for specific Form I-9 documents to "be sure." That is document abuse; the employee chooses.
  • Using SSA's SSNVS to screen applicants. SSA limits it to employees and wage reporting; see can employers use SSNVS to screen applicants.
  • Recording interviews without consent to build a case; state consent laws apply (is it legal to record a job interview).
  • Treating tool signals as proof. A flag from interview software is a reason to ask another question. Interview Signal, which we make, works this way: its private answer check flags answers that read as AI-written or read out and suggests a question to try, never changes a score and never goes in the submittal; it does not verify identity.
  • No owner. A concern that sits in a recruiter's inbox is how a proxy gets hired.

How do you roll the policy out?

  1. Tell candidates up front. Add a line to the interview invitation: "For this role we confirm identity on video with a photo ID at the first interview. If you need another way to do this, tell us."
  2. Train interviewers on section 2 and section 6: what to record, whom to tell, and what not to say.
  3. Update agency agreements under section 10 before the next requisition opens.
  4. Align with neighbouring policies: the background check policy, the policy on candidates using AI in interviews and your interview recording policy.
  5. Review false alarms. If the checks keep stopping real candidates, fix the checks, not the candidates.

Example template; not legal advice. Sources checked as of November 2026.

Questions people ask

What should a candidate fraud policy include?

It should say which identity checks happen at each hiring stage and that every candidate for the role gets the same check, how third-party checks follow the FCRA, what counts as a concern, who it is escalated to and how fast, how the candidate is told, when and where fraud is reported, which records are kept and for how long, and who does what when a staffing agency places the worker. It should also state that suspicion is never based on a name, accent, nationality or citizenship.

Can a company require a video identity check for every candidate?

Generally yes, if it applies the check to every candidate at the same stage, explains it in advance, offers an accommodation or alternative for anyone who needs one, and handles any biometric technology under laws such as Illinois' Biometric Information Privacy Act. The FBI's July 2025 guidance on remote hiring fraud recommends requiring video with an unobscured background and scrutinizing identity documents.

How long should we keep records about suspected candidate fraud?

At least one year under the EEOC's recordkeeping rule, 29 CFR 1602.14, which requires employers to keep application and hiring records for one year from the record or the decision, whichever is later, and longer if a discrimination charge is filed. Keep Form I-9 material separately under its own retention rules, and follow any legal hold counsel issues.

Should we keep a blocklist of fraudulent candidates' names?

Not of names. The FBI warned in October 2026 that relying on ban lists or filtering names can block qualified applicants and harm identity theft victims, because the name used is often a real person's stolen identity. Block the specific phone numbers, emails, devices, documents and addresses tied to the incident instead.