Continuous criminal monitoring of employees: FCRA consent, acting on an alert, and the state and city limits (2026)
On this page
Continuous criminal monitoring means checking current employees for new criminal records after they are hired, either by re-running background checks on a schedule or by subscribing to a service that alerts the employer when a new record appears. When a screening company supplies the results, each one is a consumer report under the Fair Credit Reporting Act, so the employer needs a stand-alone disclosure and a written authorization that clearly cover reports during employment, and it must send pre-adverse and adverse action notices before acting on an alert. As of November 2026, California, Illinois, Massachusetts, New York City, Philadelphia and unincorporated Los Angeles County add limits that reach current employees.
This page is about checks after hire. The steps for a pre-hire check are on the FCRA background check process, the policy clause on rechecks is in the background check policy template, and ongoing driving record checks are on MVR checks in hiring.
Not legal advice. This summarizes the federal statute, agency guidance and the state and city laws linked below as published when we checked them in November 2026. Union contracts, industry rules and other state laws can add more; confirm your program with counsel before you start it.
What counts as continuous criminal monitoring?
- Scheduled re-screening. The same criminal searches run again for a role every year or every few years.
- Alert-based monitoring. A screening company watches the sources it has access to and notifies the employer when a new record that may match an employee appears. Ask the vendor in writing which sources it watches, how it confirms identity, and whether it verifies an alert at the court before reporting it.
- Government programs for specific roles. The FBI's Rap Back service "allows authorized agencies to receive notification of activity on individuals who hold positions of trust (e.g. school teachers, daycare workers)," replacing repeated fingerprint checks (FBI, Next Generation Identification). Access runs through authorized agencies, not ordinary private employers.
- Required periodic checks. Some roles carry their own: the HHS Office of Inspector General tells health care entities to "routinely check the list to ensure that new hires and current employees are not on it" (OIG exclusions), and motor carriers must review CDL drivers' records every year (see MVR checks).
Does the FCRA allow it, and what consent do you need?
Yes. The FCRA defines "employment purposes" as evaluating a consumer "for employment, promotion, reassignment or retention as an employee" (15 U.S.C. § 1681a(h)), so a report on a current employee is covered in the same way as a report on a candidate. Before any report is procured, the employee must receive a clear and conspicuous written disclosure "in a document that consists solely of the disclosure" and authorize the procurement in writing (§ 1681b(b)(2)).
One authorization can cover the whole job, if it says so:
- The FTC and EEOC's joint guide says: "If you want the authorization to allow you to get background reports throughout the person's employment, make sure you say so clearly and conspicuously" (Background Checks: What Employers Need to Know).
- The FTC's 2011 staff report says an employer may use a one-time blanket disclosure, that the disclosure must state clearly and conspicuously that it covers reports obtained while the person is an employee, and that a valid disclosure and consent "remain effective throughout the duration of employment" (40 Years of Experience with the FCRA).
If the form an employee signed at hire did not mention reports during employment, give a new stand-alone disclosure and get a new authorization before the first monitoring report. The same staff report says the FCRA does not prohibit adverse action against an employee who refuses to authorize a report, but does not specifically authorize it either, so treat a refusal as a policy and state-law question for counsel.
An example sentence for the disclosure, to adapt with counsel (keep the document free of other terms):
[Employer name] may obtain consumer reports about you from a consumer
reporting agency for employment purposes, including hiring, promotion,
reassignment and retention. If you are hired, [Employer name] may
obtain such reports at any time during your employment, including
periodic criminal record checks and ongoing criminal record monitoring
for [role or role family].
What must you do when an alert comes in?
Treat every alert as a new consumer report. The pre-adverse action notice (a copy of the report and the summary of rights) is due "before taking any adverse action based in whole or in part on the report" (§ 1681b(b)(3)), and the adverse action notice follows the decision (§ 1681m(a)). Suspension, reassignment and termination are all decisions to run through those steps. An example workflow:
- Route the alert to one trained reviewer, not the employee's manager or the team.
- Confirm identity and status at the source. The screening company must follow reasonable procedures for "maximum possible accuracy" (§ 1681e(b)) and report public records complete and up to date or notify the person (§ 1681k). Ask it to confirm the court record before you act; a booking is not a charge, and a charge is not a conviction.
- Check the state and city rule for where the employee works (table below).
- Assess the record against the job. The EEOC rescinded its 2012 guidance on arrest and conviction records on October 28, 2026, but Title VII still applies, and weighing the Green factors from the 1975 Eighth Circuit case (the nature and gravity of the offense, the time since it and the nature of the job) remains a sound way to decide and document. Where a state or city sets its own factors, use them.
- Send the pre-adverse action notice with the report and summary of rights, plus any state or city notice, and wait for the response.
- Decide, then send the adverse action notice if the decision stands. Record each step.
One narrow exception: communications from a third party to an employer in an investigation of "suspected misconduct relating to employment" or of compliance with laws or the employer's written policies are excluded from the definition of a consumer report if they meet the statute's conditions, and after acting on one the employer must give the employee a summary of its nature and substance (§ 1681a(y)). It is written for investigations; do not assume it covers a standing monitoring subscription.
Which state and city rules limit monitoring of current employees?
Each row was checked in the official text in November 2026. The list covers the rules we confirmed, not every state.
| Where | Rule for current employees | Source |
|---|---|---|
| California | For the Fair Chance Act regulations, "applicant" includes an existing employee "subjected to a review and consideration of criminal history because of a change in ownership, management, policy, or practice," so starting a monitoring program brings the Act's assessment and notice steps. Labor contractors that re-check workers in a pool must follow them too, and may not drop a worker over history already found not disqualifying unless something material has changed. | 2 CCR 11017.1(d)(3), (j)(1); California page |
| Illinois | No use of an arrest record as a basis for discipline or discharge. Acting on a conviction requires a substantial relationship to the job or an unreasonable risk, consideration of six factors, a written preliminary notice with the report, at least 5 business days to respond, and a final written notice. | 775 ILCS 5/2-103; 5/2-103.1 |
| Massachusetts | A CORI Acknowledgment Form is valid for one year or until employment ends, whichever comes first; a new request within the year is allowed only if the form said so; after a year a new form is needed. Before adverse action against an employee based on CORI or other criminal history: notice, a copy, the source, the part relied on, a chance to dispute, and DCJIS's correction information. | 803 CMR 2.11(7)-(8), 2.13, 2.20 |
| New York State | Article 23-A protects employment "held by an individual," not just applications: no adverse action over a prior conviction unless there is a direct relationship to the job or an unreasonable risk. | Correction Law § 752; New York page |
| New York City | A pending case or a conviction during employment requires the Fair Chance Process (written analysis, a copy, at least five business days to respond) before adverse action; the employee may be placed on paid or unpaid leave meanwhile, presumed for no more than five business days. | 47 RCNY 2-04; NYC page |
| Philadelphia | An employer may ask about a pending charge only with reasonably reliable information that it relates to the job's duties, may require self-reporting only under a written policy listing reportable offenses, and may act on a pending charge only where continued employment would be an unacceptable risk and exclusion is compelled by business necessity. | Code 9-3503(2), Bill 250373-A; Philadelphia page |
| Los Angeles County (unincorporated) | "Adverse action" includes discharge, discipline, reassignment, lay-off and termination due to criminal history, so the ordinance's assessment and notice steps apply to employees, not only applicants. | County Code 8.300.040(A); LA County page |
Federal reporting limits apply to monitoring too: under 15 U.S.C. § 1681c, arrests that did not lead to a conviction generally drop out of reports after seven years unless the job pays $75,000 or more, and several states are stricter (see the seven-year rule).
How should you set up a monitoring program?
- Pick the roles by risk, in writing. Access to vulnerable people, money or safety systems is the kind of duty that can justify it; apply the same rule to everyone in the role.
- Fix the consent. Update the disclosure and authorization, and in Massachusetts the CORI Acknowledgment Form, before the first report.
- Tell employees in advance which roles are monitored and what happens on an alert. In California, plan for the Fair Chance Act steps when a new policy subjects existing staff to review.
- Write the alert workflow above into the policy, with one reviewer and a decision log.
- Add a self-reporting rule only if you need one, and in Philadelphia only as a written policy that lists the reportable offenses.
- Review results by group. Track who is flagged and who is let go after an alert, so an adverse impact shows up in your own data before it shows up in a charge.
For a staffing agency that keeps workers in a pool, re-checks before a new assignment are monitoring too; see background checks for staffing agencies for the agency and client split.
Questions people ask
Is continuous criminal monitoring of employees legal?
Federal law allows it, with conditions. When a screening company supplies the results, each report is a consumer report used for retention as an employee under the FCRA, so the employer needs a stand-alone written disclosure and the employee's written authorization that clearly say reports may be obtained during employment, and it must send pre-adverse and adverse action notices before acting on a result. Several states and cities, including California, Illinois, Massachusetts, New York City, Philadelphia and unincorporated Los Angeles County, add limits for current employees.
Can one background check authorization cover checks during employment?
Yes, if it says so clearly. The FTC and EEOC's joint employer guide says that if you want the authorization to allow background reports throughout the person's employment, you must say so clearly and conspicuously, and the FTC's 2011 staff report says a valid disclosure and consent remain effective throughout the duration of employment. If the form signed at hire did not say this, get a new stand-alone disclosure and authorization before the first monitoring report.
Can an employer fire an employee because a monitoring service reports an arrest?
Acting on an arrest alone is risky and in some places unlawful. Illinois bars employers from using an arrest record as a basis for discipline or discharge, Philadelphia limits action on a pending charge to cases where the offense makes continued employment an unacceptable risk, and New York City requires its Fair Chance Process before acting on a pending case. Federal law still requires the FCRA pre-adverse action notice, and Title VII applies even though the EEOC rescinded its 2012 arrest and conviction guidance on October 28, 2026.
How often can a Massachusetts employer re-run a CORI check?
Under 803 CMR 2.11, a CORI Acknowledgment Form is valid for one year from the employee's signature or until employment ends, whichever comes first, and the employer may submit a new request within that year only if the form told the employee a CORI may be requested at any time within that year. After a year, the employer needs a newly completed form, and before any adverse decision it must follow the steps in 803 CMR 2.20.