How to

How to spot fake I-9 documents: the "reasonably appears genuine" test, what to do and what never to ask

On this page
  1. What does "reasonably appears to be genuine and to relate to the person" mean?
  2. How do you examine Form I-9 documents, step by step?
  3. What should you do in each situation?
  4. What must you never do when you suspect a fake?
  5. What does E-Verify add?
  6. What about remote examination?
  7. What if you learn after hire that a document was false?
  8. Who examines documents when a staffing agency places the worker?
  9. Where can HR get training or answers?
  10. What to say when you reject a document
  11. A checklist for every examiner
  12. Questions people ask

When a Form I-9 document looks fake, the rule is short: you must accept documentation that "reasonably appears to be genuine and relates to the person presenting it," and you must not accept documentation that does not, but you then have to let the employee present other acceptable documents of their own choosing. You are not expected to be a document expert, you may never tell the employee which document to bring instead, and you must apply the same standard to every new hire whatever their citizenship or national origin. That is USCIS's position in its Handbook for Employers (M-274) and on I-9 Central, as of November 2026.

This page is about the examination itself: what the test means, how to examine documents step by step, what to do when one fails, and what to do if you learn after hire that a document was false. What each list contains is in I-9 List A, B and C documents, and the discrimination side is covered in depth in I-9 document abuse.

Not legal advice. This summarizes the Form I-9 (edition 01/20/25, expiring 05/31/2027) and its Lists of Acceptable Documents; the Handbook for Employers (M-274) Section 4.0, Section 4.5, Section 11.4, Section 13.0 and Section 14.0; I-9 Central's Examining Documents page (last reviewed September 18, 2026); 8 CFR 274a.1(l) and 274a.2(b)(1)(ii); and 8 U.S.C. 1324a, as checked in November 2026. If ICE has served a Notice of Inspection, call immigration counsel first.

What does "reasonably appears to be genuine and to relate to the person" mean?

It is two questions, and a document has to pass both. Is the document itself genuine on its face? And is it this person's document? The regulation tells the employer to physically examine the documentation and "ensure that the documents presented appear to be genuine and to relate to the individual" (8 CFR 274a.2(b)(1)(ii)(A)). I-9 Central puts the standard plainly: "The standard is reasonableness. You are not expected to be a document expert."

The statute builds the same limit into the employer's duty. Under 8 U.S.C. 1324a(b)(1)(A), an employer has complied with the examination requirement "if the document reasonably appears on its face to be genuine," and once the employee has produced a sufficient document or combination, nothing requires the employer "to solicit the production of any other document." Section 1324a(a)(3) then gives a good-faith defense to an employer that complied with the verification rules. In other words, the law asks for a careful look, not a forensic test.

How do you examine Form I-9 documents, step by step?

  1. Hand over the Lists, not a request. The employee chooses one List A document, or one List B plus one List C document. M-274 Section 4.0 says you "cannot specify which documentation an employee will present."
  2. Examine originals in the employee's presence. Photocopies are not acceptable for physical examination, except a certified copy of a birth certificate (M-274 Section 14.0, question 6). If you use the DHS alternative procedure, see the remote section below.
  3. Check that it is on the Lists and unexpired. A document that is not on the Lists fails before genuineness comes up; M-274 Section 14.0 gives the example of a restricted Social Security card, which "you must reject" because it is not an acceptable Form I-9 document. Expiration has its own exceptions, covered in expired documents on Form I-9.
  4. Ask whether it looks genuine. Compare it with what an ordinary document of that type looks like. M-274 Section 13.0 shows samples of many acceptable documents, but warns that it "does not provide all of the variations of a particular document, and new versions of a document may become available," so unfamiliar is not the same as fake.
  5. Ask whether it relates to this person. Compare the photo, name and any description with the person in front of you and with what they entered in Section 1.
  6. Decide, and apply the same standard to everyone. Accept it, or reject that document and invite the employee to present other acceptable documentation. Record accepted documents in Section 2 as described in Section 2 instructions.
  7. Write a short note of what you saw if you reject a document or accept one with a name difference (I-9 Central suggests attaching a memo for name discrepancies), then keep it with your Form I-9 records.

What should you do in each situation?

What you seeWhat to doSource
A photocopy, a photo on a phone or a scan, during in-person examinationNot acceptable; ask for an original acceptable document of the employee's choice (a certified birth certificate copy is the one exception)M-274 14.0, Q6
A document that is not on the Lists, such as a restricted Social Security cardReject it and ask the employee to choose a different document from List A or List CM-274 14.0
A document that does not reasonably appear genuine (for example, it does not look like the issuing agency's document or looks altered)Do not accept it; give the employee the chance to present other documents from the ListsM-274 14.0, Q5; I-9 Central
The photo is not the person presenting itIt does not relate to the person: reject that document and invite other acceptable documentationI-9 Central; 8 CFR 274a.2(b)(1)(ii)(A)
A slight spelling difference from Section 1Ask why; if the explanation is reasonable and the document otherwise appears genuine, you may accept itM-274 14.0, Q9; I-9 Central
A substantially different nameAsk the reason; if you are satisfied it relates to the employee, you may accept it and attach a memo; see name changes on Form I-9I-9 Central
An unfamiliar version or new designDo not reject it only because it is unfamiliar; check M-274 13.0, or call the IER employer hotline, 1-800-255-8155M-274 13.0; IER
A valid document with a future expiration dateAccept it; do not refuse because it will expireM-274 11.4
No acceptable documentation within three business days of the first day of work for payYou may terminate the employee (receipts have their own rules)M-274 4.0; I-9 Central

Receipts follow separate rules, covered in the I-9 receipt rule.

What must you never do when you suspect a fake?

The rule against accepting false documents and the rule against document abuse sit side by side. M-274 Section 11.4 says you "must reject documents that do not reasonably appear to be genuine or to relate to the person presenting them, regardless of their citizenship status or national origin." The trouble starts when suspicion is applied unevenly:

  • Do not ask for a particular document instead, such as a green card or a U.S. passport, and do not ask for more documents than the rules require.
  • Do not look harder at some people. The regulation says knowledge that an employee is unauthorized "may not be inferred from an employee's foreign appearance or accent," and that nothing in the knowledge rule permits an employer to refuse "documents tendered that on their face reasonably appear to be genuine" (8 CFR 274a.1(l)(2)).
  • Do not ask to see documents before hire because someone looks or sounds "foreign," and do not ask for specific documents to create an E-Verify case or because of a mismatch (M-274 11.4).
  • Do not ask the employee to run Self Check or show proof that they did (M-274 11.4).

The Justice Department's Immigrant and Employee Rights Section (IER) enforces these rules under 8 U.S.C. 1324b(a)(6); its page notes, for example, that employers must not "require U.S. citizens who appear 'foreign' to produce a birth certificate." Penalties and the charge process are in I-9 document abuse.

What does E-Verify add?

  • Photo matching runs when the employee presents a U.S. passport or passport card, a Permanent Resident Card or an Employment Authorization Document. E-Verify's photo matching page tells the employer to compare the photo E-Verify displays with the photo on the document, "not with the actual employee." If they do not match, E-Verify asks for copies of the document, and the case can end in a mismatch the employee may contest. More in E-Verify photo matching.
  • Driver's license verification. E-Verify's driver's license page says this check "helps reduce identity document-based fraud by validating the information on certain identity documents."
  • Photo rule for List B. E-Verify employers may accept a List B document only if it contains a photograph (M-274 Section 14.0).

None of this replaces the examination. E-Verify starts from the information on the Form I-9 the employer has already completed.

What about remote examination?

E-Verify employers in good standing that use the DHS alternative procedure apply the same test in two steps. Under M-274 Section 4.5, they examine copies "to ensure that the documentation presented reasonably appears to be genuine," then hold a live video interaction in which the employee presents the same documents "to ensure that the documentation reasonably appears to be genuine and related to the individual." The procedure and its conditions are in Form I-9 remote verification; identity checks beyond Form I-9 for remote starters are in confirming a remote hire's identity on day one.

What if you learn after hire that a document was false?

Accepting a good-looking fake is not the violation; ignoring what you later learn can be. The regulation defines "knowing" to include knowledge "which may fairly be inferred through notice of certain facts and circumstances which would lead a person, through the exercise of reasonable care, to know about a certain condition" (8 CFR 274a.1(l)(1)), and 8 U.S.C. 1324a(a)(2) makes it unlawful to continue to employ someone knowing they are, or have become, unauthorized.

  1. Do not act on a hunch or a tip alone. Look at the facts you actually have. A wage-reporting mismatch, for example, is not a finding about work authorization; see SSA no-match letters.
  2. Talk to immigration counsel before you contact the employee, and before any suspension.
  3. Give the employee a fair chance to respond and to present valid documentation of their choice, the same way for anyone in the same situation.
  4. If ICE is involved, its Form I-9 inspection fact sheet (updated August 31, 2026) describes a Notice of Suspect Documents: HSI has determined that documentation does "not relate to the employee(s) or are otherwise not valid for employment," gives the employer and employee a chance to show valid authorization if they believe the finding is wrong, and warns of penalties for continuing to employ unauthorized workers. See ICE Notice of Inspection.

The person who presents a false document takes the criminal risk: using an identification document "knowing (or having reason to know) that the document is false" to satisfy the Form I-9 requirement is punishable by up to five years in prison under 18 U.S.C. 1546(b). The employer's job is a reasonable, even-handed examination, not an investigation.

Who examines documents when a staffing agency places the worker?

For temps on the agency's payroll, the agency is the employer and completes Form I-9; the client does not re-examine those documents (see Form I-9 for staffing agencies). If a branch recruiter or an authorized representative examines documents for the agency, the agency still answers for the result, so train every examiner on the same standard. A client that suspects a placed worker's identity should raise it with the agency, which decides what to do under its own process.

Where can HR get training or answers?

  • IER runs a free employer hotline (1-800-255-8155) and free employer webinars on its webinars page.
  • ICE's IMAGE program is a voluntary partnership whose members get "trainings and guidance in topics such as anti-discrimination, fraudulent documents, forced labor"; members are subject to a Form I-9 audit (ice.gov/image, updated October 22, 2026).
  • E-Verify lists free webinars on its webinars page, which I-9 Central links as its free training.

What to say when you reject a document

"I'm not able to accept this document for Form I-9 because
[it's a photocopy / it isn't on the list / it doesn't appear to be
genuine / the photo doesn't appear to match]. You can present any
other document or combination from the Lists of Acceptable Documents,
your choice: one from List A, or one from List B and one from List C.
Here is the list. You have until [date: three business days after
your first day of work for pay]."

Then note the date, the document title, the reason and who examined it. Do not name a document for them to bring.

A checklist for every examiner

[ ] Gave the employee the Lists; did not name or suggest a document
[ ] Examined originals in person (or followed the alternative procedure)
[ ] Document is on the Lists and unexpired (or an exception applies)
[ ] Reasonably appears genuine on its face
[ ] Relates to this person: photo, name, details match Section 1
[ ] Same standard as for every other new hire this week
[ ] If rejected: reason noted, employee invited to choose another
[ ] E-Verify: photo match done for passport, green card or EAD
[ ] Name difference explained and memo attached, if any
[ ] Anything learned after hire: counsel first, no action on a hunch

Not legal advice. USCIS, E-Verify, ICE and IER pages, 8 CFR part 274a and 8 U.S.C. 1324a checked as of November 2026.

Questions people ask

What should I do if a new hire's I-9 document looks fake?

Reject that document, not the person, and give the employee the chance to present other acceptable documentation of their own choosing from the Form I-9 Lists of Acceptable Documents. USCIS's Handbook for Employers says you must accept documentation that reasonably appears to be genuine and to relate to the person presenting it, and must not accept documentation that does not. Apply the same standard to every new hire, write down what you saw, and allow the usual three business days after work for pay begins.

Can I ask for a green card or a passport if I think the employee's document is fake?

No. You may refuse the document that does not reasonably appear genuine, but the employee still chooses what to present next from List A, or from List B plus List C. Asking for a specific document, or for more documents than the rules require, because of citizenship, immigration status or national origin is an unfair documentary practice under 8 U.S.C. 1324b(a)(6), which the Justice Department's Immigrant and Employee Rights Section enforces.

Am I liable if I accepted a fake I-9 document that looked real?

Usually not for the examination itself. Under 8 U.S.C. 1324a(b)(1)(A), an employer has complied with the examination requirement if the document reasonably appears on its face to be genuine, and section 1324a(a)(3) gives a good-faith defense to employers that complied with the verification rules. That changes if you later learn facts that show the employee is not authorized to work: knowledge includes constructive knowledge under 8 CFR 274a.1(l), and continuing to employ someone you know is unauthorized is a separate violation.

Does E-Verify catch fake I-9 documents?

Partly. When an employee presents a U.S. passport or passport card, a Permanent Resident Card or an Employment Authorization Document, E-Verify shows the photo on file so the employer can compare it with the photo on the document, not with the person. E-Verify also says its driver's license verification validates the information on certain identity documents. It does not replace the employer's own examination, and it cannot be used to demand particular documents.

Do I have to report a fake I-9 document to ICE or USCIS?

The USCIS Handbook for Employers and I-9 Central pages tell the employer what to do with the document: reject it and let the employee present other acceptable documentation, and the employer may terminate if the employee cannot do so within three business days. They do not tell employers to report the employee. USCIS does take tips on document fraud at tips.uscis.gov; talk to immigration counsel before reporting an individual worker.