Consent and compliance

Expired documents and Form I-9: the unexpired rule, the extensions that count, and the ones that do not

On this page
  1. What does "unexpired" mean on Form I-9?
  2. Which expired-looking documents are still acceptable?
  3. Which "extensions" do not count?
  4. What do you do when a new hire shows an expired document?
  5. What if you already accepted an expired document?
  6. How do expiration dates drive reverification?
  7. How should staffing agencies handle expiration dates?
  8. An expired-document checklist
  9. Questions people ask

No, not as a general rule. Federal regulations say "Only unexpired documents are acceptable" for Form I-9, and the Lists of Acceptable Documents print the same rule with one exception: "Documents extended by the issuing authority are considered unexpired." So an expired document counts only when the agency that issued it has extended it, for example an Employment Authorization Document covered by a qualifying renewal notice or a TPS Federal Register notice, or a green card presented with a Form I-797 extension notice. Documents with no expiration date, such as an unrestricted Social Security card or a U.S. birth certificate, are never "expired." As of November 2026, the COVID-era flexibility for expired identity documents is long over, and a state extension that is good for driving only does not count.

The document lists themselves are in I-9 List A, B and C documents. EAD extensions in detail are in EAD automatic extensions, and what to do when a document expires after hire is in I-9 reverification.

Not legal advice. This summarizes 8 CFR 274a.2(b)(1)(v), the Form I-9 and its instructions (edition 01/20/25), and the Handbook for Employers (M-274), Section 5.0 (last updated July 7, 2026), Section 7.1 and Section 7.7, with USCIS's Employment Authorization Extensions page (updated September 18, 2026), as of November 2026. Extensions change often; check that page and the USCIS notice before relying on one.

What does "unexpired" mean on Form I-9?

  • Unexpired on the day you examine it. M-274 Section 4.0 says Section 2 is completed by examining "original, acceptable, and unexpired documentation, or an acceptable receipt."
  • Extended counts as unexpired. Section 4.0 also says "An automatically extended document is considered unexpired for Form I-9."
  • No expiration date means nothing to check. A Social Security card, a U.S. birth certificate or a Consular Report of Birth Abroad has no date to pass; see the FS-240 and Form I-9.
  • Expiring soon is not expired. The instructions say "Employers should not reject acceptable documentation due to a future expiration date."

Which expired-looking documents are still acceptable?

Document combinationWhen it counts as unexpiredListReverify later?Source
EAD past its "Card Expires" date, with a Form I-797C for a renewal received before October 30, 2025 in the same eligible categoryUp to 540 days from the card date, or until USCIS decides, whichever is earlierAYes, when the extension endsM-274 5.1
TPS-based EAD covered by a Federal Register noticeThrough the date in the notice for that countryAYesM-274 5.3; USCIS TPS page
EAD with category A11 and a "Card Expires" date of Feb. 5, 2023 or Feb. 5, 2025 (DED for certain Hong Kong residents)Through Feb. 5, 2027AYes, after Feb. 5, 2027I-9 Central
Expired or expiring green card with a Form I-797 receipt for Form I-9036 months from the card's dateANeverI-9 Central; M-274 7.1
Expired or expiring green card with a Form I-797C for Form N-400 that contains an extensionFor the period stated on the noticeANeverM-274 7.1
Expired green card with a Form I-797 for Form I-751 or I-829 that extends itFor the period stated on the noticeC, with a List B documentYes, before the extension endsM-274 7.1
Expired OPT EAD with a Form I-20 endorsed for cap-gap or a pending STEM OPT extensionThrough the cap-gap, or up to 180 days for STEM OPTAYesI-9 Central Q&A

For an existing nonimmigrant employee whose employer timely filed an extension petition, M-274 Section 7.7 lets them keep working for up to 240 days while USCIS decides, and you write "240-day Ext." and the filing date in the Additional Information box in Section 2. The green card rules are explained in Form I-9 for green card holders; for TPS, check the country's page on the USCIS TPS site before relying on an extension.

Which "extensions" do not count?

  • EAD renewals filed on or after October 30, 2025. M-274 Section 5.0 says that from that date the validity of an expiring EAD "is not automatically extended by the timely filing" of a renewal, "unless otherwise provided by law or through a Federal Register notice." DHS published the change as an interim final rule (90 FR 48799) and finalized it on October 14, 2026 (91 FR 65306).
  • State extensions limited to driving. USCIS said on September 15, 2025 that North Carolina Class C licenses kept valid up to two years past their printed date "for driving purposes only" are not acceptable: "Employers should not accept expired North Carolina driver's licenses."
  • The COVID-19 expired List B policy. It ran from May 1, 2020 and ended on May 1, 2022; E-Verify's notice says that from that date employers "must only accept unexpired List B documents," and forms completed with expired List B documents had to be updated by July 31, 2022.
  • A receipt for renewing a document that simply expired. USCIS's Receipts page says you "can only accept" the receipts it lists: replacements of lost, stolen or damaged documents, the ADIT-stamped I-94, the refugee I-94 and certain parolee I-94s. A receipt for a first-time EAD is also excluded.
  • Invalid documents that are not expired. Puerto Rico birth certificates issued before July 1, 2010 are not acceptable at all (M-274 13.3), and an EAD that DHS has invalidated is not acceptable even if its date has not passed; E-Verify employers find those through its Status Change Report.

What do you do when a new hire shows an expired document?

  1. Check for an extension first. Look for a notice that goes with the document (a Form I-797 or I-797C, a TPS or DED notice) and compare it with the Employment Authorization Extensions page.
  2. If there is none, decline that document only. Explain that Form I-9 requires unexpired documents and hand over the Lists of Acceptable Documents.
  3. Let the employee choose the replacement. Any List A document, or any List B and List C pair. Do not suggest a passport or a green card; naming a document can be document abuse (see I-9 document abuse).
  4. Accept a temporary license if it qualifies. The I-9 Central Q&A says a state-issued temporary driver's license is a List B document if it has a photo or identifying information, and that conditions on it, "such as that the expired license must accompany the temporary driver's license," must be followed.
  5. Watch the deadline. Section 2 is due within three business days of the first day of work, and M-274 Section 4.0 says you may terminate an employee who fails to present acceptable documentation or an acceptable receipt within that time.

An example with illustrative dates: a warehouse hire starts on a Monday and on day two brings a driver's license that expired two weeks earlier and a Social Security card. The license cannot be accepted. On Wednesday she brings an unexpired state ID card instead, which completes List B; the Social Security card covers List C, and nothing is diaried for reverification because neither document is reverified.

What if you already accepted an expired document?

M-274 Section 9.0 says you may complete a new Form I-9 when the form has substantial errors, including when "you completed Section 2 based on unacceptable documents," and attach a written explanation. Ask the employee to present acceptable, unexpired documents of their choice, record them, and do not backdate, erase or use correction fluid. The steps for each kind of error are in Form I-9 corrections. Apply the same review to every employee whose form has the same problem, not only to noncitizens.

How do expiration dates drive reverification?

  • Reverify by the earlier date. The instructions say to reverify by the earlier of the authorization expiration date in Section 1 or the expiration date of the List A or List C document in Section 2.
  • Never reverify List B. An identity document that expires after hire does not matter for Form I-9.
  • Never reverify U.S. citizens, noncitizen nationals or permanent residents who presented a green card, and never reverify a document that does not expire, such as an unrestricted Social Security card.
  • The employee chooses again. "Employees are not required to show the same type of document they presented previously," the instructions say.

How should staffing agencies handle expiration dates?

The agency that employs the worker completes Form I-9 and owns the dates, even when the worker moves between client sites. Keep expiration and extension end dates in one central tracker rather than at each branch, record extension notices in Section 2's Additional Information field as the M-274 directs, and train recruiters not to tell a candidate that a document is "about to expire" as a reason to bring something else.

An expired-document checklist

  • Every document with a date is unexpired on the day it is examined, or covered by an extension you can point to.
  • Extension notices recorded in Additional Information, with the new end date diaried.
  • No EAD renewal receipt filed on or after October 30, 2025 treated as an extension without a law or Federal Register notice.
  • No "driving purposes only" state extensions accepted.
  • No document rejected because it will expire soon.
  • Forms completed with expired documents corrected under M-274 Section 9.0, with an explanation attached.

Questions people ask

Can an employee use an expired driver's license for Form I-9?

Not as a rule. Form I-9 requires unexpired documents, and the COVID-19 policy that let employers accept expired List B documents ended on May 1, 2022. A license counts as unexpired only if the issuing authority extended it for that purpose; USCIS said in September 2025 that North Carolina licenses extended for driving purposes only are not acceptable.

Is an expired green card acceptable for Form I-9?

Only with a USCIS notice that extends it. An expired or expiring Permanent Resident Card presented with a Form I-797 receipt for Form I-90 is a List A document that USCIS says extends the card for 36 months from its Card Expires date, and a Form I-797C for Form N-400 that contains an extension works the same way. On its own, an expired card is not acceptable at hire.

Can I accept an expired EAD with a renewal receipt notice?

Only if the renewal qualifies for an automatic extension. As of November 2026, an EAD renewal filed before October 30, 2025 in an eligible category may extend the card for up to 540 days, but a renewal filed on or after that date does not extend it unless a law or Federal Register notice, such as a TPS notice, says otherwise.

Can an employer reject a document because it expires soon?

No. The Form I-9 instructions say employers should not reject acceptable documentation due to a future expiration date. If the document is unexpired on the day you examine it and reasonably appears genuine, you accept it and, for List A or List C employment authorization documents, reverify when it expires.