Consular Report of Birth Abroad (FS-240) and Form I-9: a List C document, what to pair it with, and the E-Verify photo rule
On this page
- What is a Consular Report of Birth Abroad?
- Which list is the FS-240 on, and what must go with it?
- How do you record an FS-240 in Section 2?
- Can the employee bring a copy or a replacement?
- Does an FS-240 ever need reverification?
- What changes for E-Verify employers?
- What must employers and recruiters not do?
- How does this work when a staffing agency places the worker?
- An FS-240 checklist
- Questions people ask
Yes. The Form FS-240, Consular Report of Birth Abroad, is an acceptable Form I-9 document, but only for List C: item 2, "Certification of report of birth issued by the Department of State (Forms DS-1350, FS-545, FS-240)." It shows employment authorization, not identity, so the employee must also present one List B identity document, such as a state driver's license, and an E-Verify employer may accept only a List B document with a photograph. The FS-240 must be an original issued by the State Department, not a photocopy, and because it has no expiration date it is never reverified. This reflects the Form I-9 edition dated 01/20/25 and USCIS's Handbook for Employers (M-274), Section 13.3, as of November 2026.
The full lists are in I-9 List A, B and C documents. The rule that the employee, not the employer, chooses the documents is covered in I-9 document abuse, and lost-document receipts in the I-9 receipt rule.
Not legal advice. This summarizes the Handbook for Employers (M-274), Section 13.3, List C Documents (last updated November 19, 2025), and Section 4.0; the Form I-9 and its instructions, edition 01/20/25; 8 CFR 274a.2(b)(1)(v)(C)(2); and the State Department's Foreign Affairs Manual, 7 FAM 1441, as of November 2026.
What is a Consular Report of Birth Abroad?
The State Department's Foreign Affairs Manual describes the FS-240 as "a formal document certifying the acquisition of U.S. citizenship at birth by a person born abroad to a U.S. citizen parent(s)." Under 22 U.S.C. 2705, a report of birth abroad issued by a consular officer has the same force as proof of citizenship as a certificate of naturalization. U.S. noncitizen nationals can also receive one, and USCIS's Who Is Issued This Document? chart (updated September 18, 2026) lists the FS-240 for citizens and noncitizen nationals only.
Three details matter for Form I-9:
- It is not a birth certificate. 7 FAM 1441.1 says the FS-240 "is not a birth certificate" but a consular declaration that the person acquired citizenship at birth. Record it under List C item 2, not as a birth certificate under item 3.
- Older versions still count. The State Department began issuing a redesigned FS-240 on January 17, 2011. The manual says either version "may still be accepted," that the DS-1350 "will no longer be issued," and that consular officers issued the FS-545 before 1990. All three remain on List C item 2.
- It was added to the form in 2017. E-Verify's July 17, 2017 notice says that revision added the FS-240 to List C and combined the FS-545, DS-1350 and FS-240 into selection C#2. Older internal checklists that list only the FS-545 and DS-1350 are out of date.
Which list is the FS-240 on, and what must go with it?
List C. The Form I-9 Lists of Acceptable Documents say employees "may present one selection from List A or a combination of one selection from List B and one selection from List C." An FS-240 alone never completes Section 2.
| What the employee presents | Acceptable? | Why |
|---|---|---|
| FS-240 and an unexpired state driver's license | Yes | List C item 2 plus List B item 1 |
| FS-240 and a school ID card with a photograph | Yes | List C plus List B item 3 |
| FS-240 and a voter's registration card without a photo | Yes, unless the employer uses E-Verify | E-Verify employers may accept only List B documents with a photograph |
| FS-240 on its own | No | List C shows employment authorization only; an identity document is also needed |
| U.S. passport, with an FS-240 offered as well | Record the passport only | A List A document completes Section 2; the instructions say not to ask for List B and C documents as well |
| Photocopy of an FS-240 | No | The instructions accept no photocopies except certified copies of birth certificates |
| A foreign country's birth certificate | No | List C item 3 covers only birth certificates issued by a U.S. state, county, municipal authority or territory |
| Receipt for a replacement of a lost, stolen or damaged FS-240 | Yes, temporarily | A List C receipt, valid 90 days under M-274 Section 4.4 |
Under-18 employees who have no standard List B document may pair the FS-240 with a school record, report card, clinic, doctor or hospital record, or day-care record, or use the parent procedure, unless the employer uses E-Verify; see Form I-9 for minors.
How do you record an FS-240 in Section 2?
- Section 1 is the employee's. Someone with an FS-240 will usually check "A citizen of the United States" (or "A noncitizen national of the United States"). The instructions say employers "cannot ask employees for documentation to verify information entered in Section 1."
- Examine the original. M-274 Section 13.3 says these documents "may vary in color and paper used. All will include a raised seal of the office that issued the document, and may contain a watermark and raised printing." Accept it if it reasonably appears genuine and relates to the person.
- List B column. Record the identity document: title, issuing authority, number and expiration date.
- List C column. Enter "Form FS-240" as the document title (the abbreviation in M-274 Appendix A; "Form DS-1350" and "Form FS-545" for the older forms), the U.S. Department of State as issuing authority, and the document number if it has one. It has no expiration date.
- Leave List A blank, enter the first day of employment, and sign and date the certification within three business days of that first day.
- Return the original. If your company copies Form I-9 documents, copy this one too, as it would for any employee; see photocopying I-9 documents.
The same field-by-field rules apply to every Section 2 entry, whatever the document.
Can the employee bring a copy or a replacement?
A photocopy is not acceptable. The Form I-9 instructions say "Photocopies, except for certified copies of birth certificates, are not acceptable," and the FS-240 is not a birth certificate. A replacement issued by the State Department is a different matter: 7 FAM 1441 says the Passport Services Vital Records Section "issues certified replacements of the Form FS-240, which are available in multiple copies." A replacement the State Department issued is its own document with its seal, not a copy the employee made.
If the FS-240 was lost, stolen or damaged and the employee has applied for a replacement, the application receipt is a List C receipt. It is valid for 90 days from the first day of employment, and USCIS says accepting a second receipt when that period ends "is not permissible." By then the employee shows the replacement or any other acceptable List C document, or a List A document, as they choose. An example with illustrative dates: an employee starts on Monday, March 1, 2027 with a state ID and a replacement receipt; USCIS counts Tuesday as day one, so the receipt period ends at the end of May 2027, and a reminder in late April gives time to follow up.
Does an FS-240 ever need reverification?
No. The FS-240 has no expiration date, and the Form I-9 instructions say "You should not reverify the employment authorization of U.S. citizens and noncitizen nationals." Reverification never applies to List B documents either, so an expiring driver's license presented with the FS-240 does not trigger Supplement B. When the employee is rehired within three years, you may update the existing form on Supplement B with the rehire date instead of completing a new one.
What changes for E-Verify employers?
- The List B document needs a photo. The instructions say E-Verify employers "must only accept List B documentation that contains a photograph," including for minors and people with disabilities. You may explain that rule, but you still cannot name the document.
- The FS-240 is selectable. E-Verify's 2017 notice says users can select Form FS-240 when creating a case for an employee who presented it.
- No photo matching for the FS-240. E-Verify's photo matching page says photo matching applies to the Permanent Resident Card, Employment Authorization Document, U.S. passport and passport card, and that other documents with photos "will not activate photo matching." The copying requirement tied to photo matching does not apply to an FS-240 and driver's license combination.
- The Social Security number is required in Section 1, and the case is created by the third business day after the employee starts work for pay; see E-Verify photo matching for the passport side of the same choice.
What must employers and recruiters not do?
- Do not ask for a passport instead. Someone who mentions being born abroad may still choose an FS-240 and a driver's license. The instructions say employers "cannot ... specify which acceptable documentation employees must present."
- Do not reject it for looking unfamiliar. Versions differ by year, and the older DS-1350 and FS-545 remain valid. Reject a document only if it does not reasonably appear genuine or relate to the person, and then let the employee present other acceptable documents.
- Do not ask for proof of citizenship. Employees "do NOT need to prove their citizenship, immigration status, or national origin," the instructions say.
- Keep it out of the interview. Recruiters should ask only the two standard work authorization questions; see work authorization questions in interviews. Requesting proof or a specific document based on citizenship, immigration status or national origin "may be illegal," the Form I-9 instructions warn.
How does this work when a staffing agency places the worker?
USCIS's Exceptions page says that when a company uses a temporary or staffing agency, the agency "completes Form I-9 for each worker they provide," because the workers are the agency's employees. The agency's onboarding team, not the client, examines the FS-240, and the M-274 lets staffing agencies use either the date the employee is assigned to the first job or the date they enter the assignment pool as the first day of employment. The client should not ask the placed worker for documents again.
An FS-240 checklist
- Original FS-240, DS-1350 or FS-545 with a raised seal; no photocopies.
- Recorded under List C item 2 as "Form FS-240," issuing authority U.S. Department of State, not as a birth certificate.
- One List B identity document with it; a photo List B document if you use E-Verify.
- Nothing in List A, and nothing asked beyond the two documents.
- No reverification date diaried for the FS-240.
- A 90-day reminder if a replacement receipt was presented instead.
- The same copying policy applied as for every other employee.
Questions people ask
Is a Consular Report of Birth Abroad (FS-240) acceptable for Form I-9?
Yes. The FS-240 is List C item 2 on the Form I-9 Lists of Acceptable Documents, under certifications of report of birth issued by the Department of State. It proves employment authorization only, so the employee must also present a List B identity document such as a state driver's license. It must be an original issued by the State Department, not a photocopy.
Is the FS-240 a List A document like a U.S. passport?
No. A U.S. passport or passport card is List A because it proves identity and employment authorization. The FS-240 proves only employment authorization, so it is List C and needs a List B identity document with it. If the employee chooses to present a U.S. passport instead, you record the passport alone under List A.
Does a DS-1350 or FS-545 still work for Form I-9?
Yes. Both are listed with the FS-240 in List C item 2. The State Department's Foreign Affairs Manual says it no longer issues the DS-1350 and that consular officers issued the FS-545 before 1990, but previously issued reports and certifications of birth remain valid unless revoked.
Does an FS-240 need reverification on Form I-9?
No. The FS-240 has no expiration date, and the Form I-9 instructions say employers should not reverify U.S. citizens or noncitizen nationals. Reverification also never applies to the List B identity document presented with it.