Consent and compliance

Photocopying Form I-9 documents: optional, all-or-nothing, and required for E-Verify photo matching and remote review

On this page
  1. Do employers have to photocopy I-9 documents?
  2. What is the difference between copies you make and copies an employee hands you?
  3. If you copy, what are the rules?
  4. What does E-Verify add?
  5. What does the remote alternative procedure require?
  6. Can you start or stop copying?
  7. Should you copy when you do not have to?
  8. How should staffing agencies handle copies?
  9. A copy-ready copying policy
  10. Common copying mistakes
  11. Questions people ask

Copying Form I-9 documents is optional. Under 8 CFR 274a.2(b)(3), an employer "may, but is not required to, copy or make an electronic image of a document" the employee presents. If you do copy, three rules follow: copy for every new hire and reverified employee, regardless of national origin or citizenship; return the originals; and keep the copies with the Form I-9 or the employee's records, available at an inspection, for as long as you keep the form. Copying becomes mandatory in two cases: E-Verify employers must copy a U.S. passport, passport card, Permanent Resident Card or Employment Authorization Document used for photo matching, and employers using the DHS remote alternative procedure must keep front and back copies of every document. A copy never replaces a completed Section 2. This reflects USCIS guidance as of November 2026.

How to store the copies electronically is covered in electronic I-9 storage requirements, and scanning old paper files in how to convert paper I-9s to electronic. This page covers the decision to copy and the rules that come with it.

Not legal advice. This summarizes the Handbook for Employers (M-274), Section 4.1, Retaining Copies of Documents Your Employee Presents, Section 10.2, Section 4.5 and Section 14.0; 8 CFR 274a.2(b)(3) and (b)(4); the I-9 Central Questions and Answers (updated December 2, 2025); E-Verify's photo matching guidance; and the Form I-9 instructions, edition 01/20/25, as of November 2026.

Do employers have to photocopy I-9 documents?

SituationCopyingSource
Documents examined in person, employer not in E-VerifyOptional; if you copy, copy for everyone8 CFR 274a.2(b)(3); M-274 4.1
E-Verify employer; employee presents a U.S. passport, passport card, Permanent Resident Card or EADRequired: the front and back of the card, or for a passport the Passport ID page and the Passport Barcode pageM-274 4.1; E-Verify photo matching
E-Verify employer; any other document, such as a driver's licenseOptional; apply one policy to all employeesM-274 4.1
E-Verify employer using the DHS remote alternative procedureRequired: clear, legible front and back copies of all documents examined remotelyM-274 4.5
Reverification on Supplement BFollow the same policy as at hireM-274 4.1 ("all new hires and reverified employees")
Copies already made under a policy you have since droppedKeep them; do not shredI-9 Central Q&A

What is the difference between copies you make and copies an employee hands you?

They are different rules. Copies an employee brings are not acceptable documents. The Form I-9 instructions say "Photocopies, except for certified copies of birth certificates, are not acceptable for Form I-9," and M-274 Section 14.0 says employers examining documents in person "may only accept original documentation." Under the remote alternative procedure, the employee sends copies first, but the employer must then see the same originals in a live video interaction. Copies you make after examining the originals are a record-keeping choice, governed by the rest of this page.

If you copy, what are the rules?

  1. Examine the originals and complete Section 2 from them. M-274 Section 4.1: "You must always complete Section 2 by reviewing original documentation, even if you copy an employee's document(s)." The regulation says copying "does not relieve the employer from the requirement to fully complete section 2."
  2. Return the originals. The instructions say you "must return the original documentation to the employee."
  3. Copy consistently. Copies "should be made consistently for all new hires and reverified employees, regardless of national origin, citizenship, or immigration status, or you may violate anti-discrimination laws" (M-274 4.1). The regulation adds that copying "only the documents of individuals of certain national origins or citizenship statuses" may violate section 274B of the Immigration and Nationality Act.
  4. Keep the copies with the form or the employee's record. 8 CFR 274a.2(b)(3) says copies must be "retained with the Form I-9 or stored with the employee's records," retrievable under the electronic standards in paragraphs (e) through (i).
  5. Keep them as long as the form. The instructions tie the copies to the Form I-9's retention period: while the person works for you, then the later of three years after hire or one year after employment ends; see I-9 retention rules.
  6. Produce them at an inspection. Copies must be available to DHS, the Department of Labor or the Justice Department's Immigrant and Employee Rights Section (M-274 4.1 and 10.2).
  7. Use them only for Form I-9 purposes. 8 CFR 274a.2(b)(4) says information in or appended to Form I-9, "including copies or electronic images of documents," may be used only to enforce the immigration act and specified federal criminal statutes. Do not reuse them for payroll, badge photos or marketing.

What does E-Verify add?

  • Photo matching documents must be copied. E-Verify's photo matching page says that when an employee presents a Permanent Resident Card, EAD, U.S. passport or passport card, employers "must copy the front and back of the document (or in the case of a U.S. passport, copy the Passport ID page and the Passport Barcode page)" and keep the copies with the Form I-9. See E-Verify photo matching.
  • A mismatch needs uploads. If you indicate the photos do not match, E-Verify prompts you to attach copies of the front and back of the document.
  • Missed copy found in a self-audit. The I-9 Central Q&A says that if an employer failed to copy a photo-match document and it is no longer available, the employer "should attach a note to the employee's Form I-9 explaining the discrepancy," signed and dated.
  • Other documents stay optional. An E-Verify employer that copies more than the required documents "should apply this policy consistently with respect to Form I-9 completion for all employees" (M-274 4.1).

What does the remote alternative procedure require?

Employers enrolled in E-Verify in good standing may examine documents remotely. M-274 Section 4.5 lists the steps: examine copies (front and back) of the documents, hold a live video interaction in which the employee presents the same documents, check the alternative procedure box on Form I-9, and "Retain a clear and legible copy of the documentation (front and back if the documentation is two-sided)." If you offer the procedure at a hiring site, you must offer it consistently there, though you may limit it to remote hires. The full procedure is in I-9 remote verification.

Can you start or stop copying?

Yes. The I-9 Central Q&A says employers "may choose to begin or end the practice of keeping copies of documents at any time, as long as you do so for all employees." It also says: "Do not shred previously retained copies of documents." Write the change down with its effective date, apply it to every site and to reverifications, and keep earlier copies until each form's own retention period ends.

Should you copy when you do not have to?

USCIS leaves the choice to the employer and does not recommend either way. The trade-off is practical. Copies let an internal auditor check that Section 2 matches what was presented, and they make the E-Verify copying rule part of one routine instead of an exception. They also hold Social Security numbers, birth dates and immigration details, so they add records to protect, retain and produce, and an inspector who reviews them will see the same thing your auditor sees. Whichever way you decide, decide once for the whole company, or per site with a reason that has nothing to do with who the employees are.

How should staffing agencies handle copies?

The regulation applies to "an employer, or a recruiter or referrer for a fee." For temporary staffing, the agency is the employer that completes Form I-9, so its policy governs and the client does not need its own copies. Agencies with many branches should set one written rule, because a branch that copies only the EADs of the workers it places is the pattern the regulation warns against. Copies should be stored where the agency's I-9 records are kept, not in a recruiter's inbox or a client's onboarding folder.

A copy-ready copying policy

An example to adapt with counsel:

Form I-9 document copying policy (effective [date])
1. After examining original documents and completing Section 2,
   [Company] [does / does not] copy the documents presented.
2. This applies to every new hire and every reverification at every
   site, regardless of national origin, citizenship or immigration status.
3. E-Verify sites: we always copy a U.S. passport (ID and barcode pages),
   passport card, Permanent Resident Card or EAD used for photo matching.
4. Remote examination (E-Verify sites only): we keep clear front and back
   copies of all documents examined.
5. Copies are stored with the Form I-9 in [system], with access limited to
   [roles], kept for the Form I-9 retention period and used only for
   Form I-9 purposes.
6. Copies made under any earlier policy are kept until the related
   Form I-9 may be destroyed.

Common copying mistakes

MistakeWhat the rules say
Copying only the documents of noncitizens or of employees with foreign-sounding namesMay violate section 274B (8 CFR 274a.2(b)(3))
Keeping a copy and leaving Section 2 incompleteCopies do not take the place of completing Form I-9 (M-274 10.2)
Keeping the employee's original documentOriginals must be returned
Skipping the copy of an EAD or passport at an E-Verify siteRequired for photo-match documents; attach a signed, dated note if found later
Shredding old copies after dropping the practiceCopies already made must be kept with the form or record
Accepting a photocopy as the employee's documentOnly certified copies of birth certificates are acceptable

Questions people ask

Do employers have to make copies of Form I-9 documents?

Not in general. 8 CFR 274a.2(b)(3) says an employer may, but is not required to, copy or make an electronic image of the documents an employee presents. Copies are required only in two situations: E-Verify employers must copy a U.S. passport, passport card, Permanent Resident Card or EAD used for photo matching, and employers using the DHS remote alternative procedure must keep front and back copies of every document examined.

If we copy one employee's I-9 documents, do we have to copy everyone's?

Yes. USCIS's Handbook for Employers says copies should be made consistently for all new hires and reverified employees, regardless of national origin, citizenship or immigration status, or the employer may violate anti-discrimination laws. The regulation itself warns against copying only the documents of people of certain national origins or citizenship statuses.

Can we stop photocopying I-9 documents?

Yes, at any time, as long as the change applies to all employees. USCIS's I-9 Central Q&A says employers may begin or end the practice whenever they choose, but must not shred copies already made, because the regulations require copies to be kept with the Form I-9 or the employee's records.

Can an employee give us a photocopy of their document for Form I-9?

No, unless it is a certified copy of a birth certificate. Employers examining documents in person may accept only originals. An E-Verify employer using the remote alternative procedure receives copies first but must then see the original documents in a live video interaction.

Does making copies replace filling in Section 2 of Form I-9?

No. The regulation says copying documents does not relieve the employer of the requirement to fully complete Section 2, and the Handbook says making copies does not take the place of completing Form I-9.