School ID card for Form I-9: the List B photo rule, college IDs, and how it differs from a school record
On this page
- Is a school ID card acceptable for Form I-9?
- Does a college or university ID count?
- School ID card, school record or report card: what is the difference?
- What changes if you use E-Verify?
- How do you record a school ID card in Section 2?
- Is a school ID card ever reverified?
- What if the student has lost the card?
- What can you not ask about school IDs?
- What should campus employers and staffing agencies watch for?
- A worked example
- A school ID card checklist
- Questions people ask
Yes, if it has a photograph. "School ID card with a photograph" is List B, item 3, on the Form I-9 Lists of Acceptable Documents (edition 01/20/25), so it proves identity only and must be paired with a List C document, such as an unrestricted Social Security card, unless the employee chooses a List A document instead. The card must be the original, unexpired if it carries an expiration date, and it must reasonably appear genuine and relate to the person presenting it. The photo is part of the document's own description, so a school ID without one is not acceptable at any employer, and a school ID with one also meets the E-Verify rule that List B documents must have a photo. Those are the USCIS and E-Verify rules as of November 2026.
This page covers the school ID card only: what qualifies, how it differs from a school record or report card, how to record it, and what you may not ask. The full lists are in I-9 List A, B and C documents, and the parent procedure for teenagers without any identity document is in Form I-9 for minors.
Not legal advice. This summarizes the Form I-9 and its Lists of Acceptable Documents (edition 01/20/25, expiration date 05/31/2027), 8 CFR 274a.2(b)(1)(v)(B), the Handbook for Employers (M-274) Section 13.2, List B documents (last updated July 15, 2025), M-274 Sections 4.0, 4.2, 4.4 and 6.0 and Appendix A, and E-Verify's published guidance, as checked in November 2026.
Is a school ID card acceptable for Form I-9?
Yes. The current form's List B, item 3, reads "School ID card with a photograph," and the regulation lists "School identification card with a photograph" among the documents that establish identity only (8 CFR 274a.2(b)(1)(v)(B)(1)(ii)). Five conditions decide whether a particular card works:
- It has a photograph. The driver's license and government ID items on List B may be accepted without a photo if they show identifying information such as name, date of birth and address. The school ID item has no such alternative: the photo is part of its description.
- It is unexpired. USCIS's Form I-9 Acceptable Documents page (updated October 5, 2026) says "Employees may present one of the following unexpired List B documents." A card with no expiration date has nothing to check. See expired documents and Form I-9.
- It is the original. The Form I-9 instructions say "Photocopies, except for certified copies of birth certificates, are not acceptable for Form I-9." A photo of the card on a phone is not the card.
- It reasonably appears genuine and relates to the person. This is the same test as for every document; you do not need to be an expert in school ID designs.
- It comes with a List C document. The Acceptable Documents page says "Employees who choose to present a List B document must also present a document from List C for Section 2."
Does a college or university ID count?
The list says "School ID card" and nothing more. Neither the Lists of Acceptable Documents nor M-274 Section 13.2 limits it to high schools or to any level of education, so a photo ID card from a college, university or community college fits the words as well as a high school card does. That is our reading of the text; neither the lists nor the M-274 defines "school" for Form I-9.
Two questions USCIS does not answer as of November 2026:
- Schools outside the United States. List B, item 1 is limited to licenses and ID cards from U.S. states and outlying possessions, and item 9 names Canadian driver's licenses specifically. The school ID item names no country, and neither the lists nor M-274 Section 13.2 addresses IDs from foreign schools. The test that does apply is whether the card reasonably appears genuine and relates to the person.
- Age. The regulation lists the school ID under a heading that reads "For individuals 16 years of age or older." The current Lists of Acceptable Documents and M-274 Section 13.2 list it with no age condition, and M-274 Section 4.2 says minors can complete Form I-9 "by presenting a List A document or a combination of List B and C documents."
School ID card, school record or report card: what is the difference?
The three school documents on List B follow different rules. The school record and report card sit in a group the list introduces with "For persons under age 18 who are unable to present a document listed above."
| Document | Who may use it | Photo needed? | E-Verify employer? | Source |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| School ID card with a photograph | Any employee | Yes, by the list's own words | Yes | List B, item 3 |
| School record or report card | Under 18 and unable to present items 1 to 9 | No | No | List B, item 10; E-Verify FAQ |
| Day-care or nursery school record | Under 18 and unable to present items 1 to 9 | No | No | List B, item 12 |
| Student ID card with no photo | Nobody | Not applicable | No | List B, item 3 |
| Expired school ID card | Nobody, unless the issuing authority extended it | Not applicable | No | Acceptable Documents page |
| "Individual under age 18" entry by a parent or guardian | Minors with no List B document at all | Not applicable | No | M-274 Section 4.2 |
The practical difference shows up at E-Verify employers. A teenager who brings a report card can complete Form I-9 at an employer that does not use E-Verify, but not at one that does; a school ID card with a photograph works at both.
What changes if you use E-Verify?
- The photo rule is already met. The Form I-9 instructions tell E-Verify employers: "You must only accept List B documentation that contains a photograph. This applies to individuals under the age of 18 and individuals with disabilities." E-Verify's FAQ says the same, "including documents presented by minors." A school ID card with a photograph satisfies this.
- The Social Security number is required. E-Verify needs the SSN to create a case. If a new hire has applied for a number but not received it, the E-Verify User Manual, Section 2.1, says to attach an explanation to the Form I-9, let the employee keep working and create the case as soon as the number is available. See Form I-9 without a Social Security number.
- Enter it as the lists name it. I-9 Central's Section 2 page (updated September 18, 2026) says "You must enter your employee's documentation in E-Verify as it appears on Form I-9 Lists of Acceptable Documents."
- No photo matching. E-Verify's photo matching page says only the U.S. passport, passport card, Permanent Resident Card and Employment Authorization Document trigger it, and "Other documents with photos (such as a driver's license) will not activate photo matching." See E-Verify photo matching.
- Religious objections to photos. The User Manual, Section 2.1, says that if an employee objects to providing a photo document for religious reasons, call E-Verify at 888-464-4218.
How do you record a school ID card in Section 2?
- Under List B, enter the document title. M-274 Appendix A suggests the abbreviation "School ID" for "School ID card with photograph."
- Enter the issuing authority: the school that issued the card.
- Enter the document number if the card has one; the field reads "Document Number (if any)."
- Enter the expiration date if the card has one; the field reads "Expiration Date (if any)."
- Record the List C document in the right-hand column and leave List A blank.
- Enter the first day of employment and complete Section 2 within three business days of it, or by the first day if the job lasts less than three business days (see Form I-9 timing in hiring).
- Return the card. Copying is optional, but I-9 Central's questions and answers say that if you copy documents you must do so "for all employees, regardless of national origin or citizenship status."
Field-by-field help is in Form I-9 Section 2 instructions.
Is a school ID card ever reverified?
No. M-274 Section 6.0 says reverification is never required when List B documents expire. A student whose card expires at the end of the academic year does not need to show a new one for Form I-9, and you should not ask for one each term. Reverification depends on the employee's employment authorization and their List A or List C document, never on the identity document; see I-9 reverification.
What if the student has lost the card?
A receipt for the replacement of a lost, stolen or damaged List B document can stand in for it. M-274 Section 4.4 makes the receipt valid for 90 days from the date of hire. If the replacement card does not arrive in time, "the employee may choose to present a document from List A instead, or a different List B document." Receipts are not accepted when employment will last less than three business days. Details are in the I-9 receipt rule.
What can you not ask about school IDs?
- Do not ask for a school ID by name. M-274 Section 4.0 says "You cannot specify which documentation an employee will present from the Form I-9 Lists of Acceptable Documents." Requesting more or different documents, or refusing documents that reasonably appear genuine, can be an unfair documentary practice under 8 U.S.C. 1324b(a)(6) when done because of citizenship, immigration status or national origin. See I-9 document abuse.
- Do not ask for proof of enrollment for Form I-9. Transcripts, enrollment letters and class schedules are not on the lists. A school record is a List B option only for people under 18.
- Do not read immigration status into a student ID. It proves identity only. For F-1 students working on campus, I-9 Central's questions and answers say the student "is only required to present an unexpired foreign passport and an I-94 indicating F-1 nonimmigrant status." Off-campus work is in Form I-9 for F-1 OPT students.
- Do not reject a card because the school is unfamiliar. Reject a document only if it does not reasonably appear genuine or relate to the person, and then let the employee present other acceptable documents.
What should campus employers and staffing agencies watch for?
- Student hiring waves. Campus employers that onboard many students at once should train hiring staff that the photo is the only extra condition on a school ID, and that a List C document still has to be presented.
- Short event jobs. A staffing agency placing students at a one-day event must complete Sections 1 and 2 by the first day of employment, and a receipt is not acceptable for a job of less than three business days.
- Onboarding messages. "Bring your student ID and Social Security card" turns a choice into a requirement. Send the Lists of Acceptable Documents instead and let the student choose. More on agency roles is in Form I-9 for staffing agencies.
- Mixed E-Verify sites. If some hiring sites use E-Verify, the photo rule applies there and not elsewhere; a school ID card works at both. See E-Verify requirements by state for where E-Verify is mandatory.
A worked example
The details are illustrative. A university bookstore that uses E-Verify hires two students in August.
- A 19-year-old sophomore presents her university photo ID card, which shows no expiration date, and an unrestricted Social Security card. HR records "School ID," the university as issuing authority and the card number under List B, leaves the expiration date blank, and records the Social Security card under List C. In E-Verify, no photo matching step appears.
- A 17-year-old high school senior working weekends presents his report card and a certified copy of his birth certificate. The report card is a valid List B document for a minor, but not at an E-Verify employer. HR explains that any List B document must have a photo and hands him the Lists of Acceptable Documents. He returns the next day with his high school photo ID card, within the three-business-day window.
- Neither card will be reverified, and HR does not set a reminder for the cards' renewal.
A school ID card checklist
- The card has a photograph, and it is the original.
- Unexpired if it carries an expiration date, unless the issuing authority extended it.
- Reasonably appears genuine and relates to the person.
- Paired with a List C document, or not needed because the employee chose List A.
- Recorded as "School ID," with the school as issuing authority, and the number and expiration date if any.
- Never required by name, never reverified, and copied only if you copy for every employee.
Questions people ask
Is a student ID acceptable for Form I-9?
Yes, if it has a photograph. A school ID card with a photograph is List B, item 3, on the Form I-9 Lists of Acceptable Documents. It proves identity only, so the employee must also present a List C document, such as an unrestricted Social Security card or a U.S. birth certificate, unless they choose a List A document instead. A school ID without a photo is not acceptable for any employer.
Can an E-Verify employer accept a school ID card?
Yes. E-Verify employers may only accept List B documents that contain a photograph, and a school ID card is acceptable only with a photograph in the first place, so it meets the rule. It does not trigger E-Verify photo matching, which applies only to the U.S. passport, passport card, Permanent Resident Card and Employment Authorization Document.
Is a report card the same as a school ID for Form I-9?
No. A school record or report card is a separate List B item reserved for people under 18 who cannot present any of the standard List B documents, and it needs no photo. E-Verify employers cannot accept it, because their List B documents must contain a photograph. A school ID card with a photograph can be used by anyone, at any employer.
Does a school ID need an expiration date to be used for Form I-9?
No. Section 2 asks for the expiration date only if the document has one. If the card shows an expiration date, it must not have passed on the day you examine it, unless the issuing authority extended it. A school ID is never reverified when it expires after hire, because reverification never applies to List B documents.
Can a college student use a university ID and a Social Security card for Form I-9?
Yes, if the university ID has a photograph and the Social Security card is unrestricted. A card marked NOT VALID FOR EMPLOYMENT, VALID FOR WORK ONLY WITH INS AUTHORIZATION or VALID FOR WORK ONLY WITH DHS AUTHORIZATION is not an acceptable List C document, and the card must not be laminated. The student chooses the documents; the employer cannot ask for a university ID by name.