Consent and compliance

Social Security card for Form I-9: when it counts as List C, the restricted cards that do not, and the reverification rule

On this page
  1. Can a Social Security card be used for Form I-9?
  2. Which Social Security cards are not acceptable?
  3. Is a laminated or unsigned card acceptable?
  4. What must the employee present with the card?
  5. How do you record a Social Security card in Section 2?
  6. Does an unrestricted card work at reverification?
  7. What if the card is lost or stolen?
  8. Can you require a new hire to show the card?
  9. What changes if you use E-Verify?
  10. What should staffing agencies watch for?
  11. A worked example
  12. A Social Security card checklist
  13. Questions people ask

Yes, a Social Security card can be used for Form I-9 if it is the original and unrestricted. It is a List C document, so it shows employment authorization only, and the new hire must pair it with a List B identity document or choose a List A document instead. Cards that say "NOT VALID FOR EMPLOYMENT," "VALID FOR WORK ONLY WITH INS AUTHORIZATION" or "VALID FOR WORK ONLY WITH DHS AUTHORIZATION" are not acceptable, and USCIS says the card must not be laminated. An unsigned card is fine. Those are the USCIS rules as of November 2026.

This page covers which cards qualify, how to record one, how the card works at reverification, and what you cannot ask. If the new hire has no number yet, see Form I-9 without a Social Security number.

Not legal advice. This summarizes the Form I-9 Lists of Acceptable Documents (edition 01/20/25, expiring 05/31/2027), the Handbook for Employers (M-274) Section 13.3, List C documents, M-274 Sections 3.0, 4.4, 6.1 and 14.0, I-9 Central's questions and answers, and the Social Security Administration's card pages, as checked in November 2026.

Can a Social Security card be used for Form I-9?

Yes. List C, item 1 on the 01/20/25 form is "A Social Security Account Number card, unless the card includes one of the following restrictions," followed by the three legends. The regulation describes it as a card "other than one that specifies on the face that the issuance of the card does not authorize employment in the United States" (8 CFR 274a.2(b)(1)(v)(C)(1)). M-274 Section 13.3 puts it in one line: a "U.S. Social Security card that is unrestricted. The card must not be laminated."

The card shows employment authorization only. On its own it does not complete Section 2.

Which Social Security cards are not acceptable?

The Social Security Administration's Types of Social Security Cards page says it issues three types, and that people who are not U.S. citizens or lawful permanent residents "may have a work restriction listed" on the card. The table matches each type to the Form I-9 rule.

CardWho SSA issues it toAcceptable for List C?Source
Name and number only, no restrictionU.S. citizens and people lawfully admitted on a permanent basisYesSSA card types; M-274 13.3
"VALID FOR WORK ONLY WITH DHS AUTHORIZATION"People lawfully admitted on a temporary basis who have DHS authorization to workNoSSA card types; M-274 13.3
"VALID FOR WORK ONLY WITH INS AUTHORIZATION" (the older wording)Not described on SSA's current pageNoM-274 13.3
"NOT VALID FOR EMPLOYMENT"People without DHS work authorization who need a number for a non-work reason or a federal benefitNoSSA card types; M-274 13.3
Laminated cardAny cardholderNoM-274 13.3
Photocopy of a cardAny cardholderNoForm I-9 instructions

A restricted card does not mean the person cannot work. Someone with a "DHS AUTHORIZATION" card is often authorized and simply needs a different document, such as an Employment Authorization Document (List A) or another List C document. M-274 Section 4.0 tells you what to do: because the restricted card is not acceptable, "ask the employee to provide a different document from List C or List A." The employee chooses which. If you use E-Verify, USCIS's acceptable documents page adds that you "must still enter the Social Security number when creating the case," even though the restricted card itself is not a Form I-9 document.

Is a laminated or unsigned card acceptable?

  • Laminated: no. M-274 Section 13.3 says the card "must not be laminated." SSA's own FAQ tells cardholders "Do not laminate your card. Lamination prevents detection of many security features," and adds that a removable plastic cover that does not damage the card is fine. If the card is laminated, the employee may present another List C document, a List A document, or a receipt for a replacement card.
  • Unsigned: yes. I-9 Central's questions and answers say a signature "is not required for the card to be valid," so you may accept an unsigned card that reasonably appears genuine and relates to the person.
  • Worn or old designs. The test is the same as for any document: whether it reasonably appears genuine and relates to the person presenting it. If it does not, reject it and let the employee present other acceptable documents (M-274 Section 14.0).

What must the employee present with the card?

A List B identity document, such as a state driver's license or ID card (see driver's license for Form I-9), a school ID with a photo, or a U.S. military card. If you participate in E-Verify, the Form I-9 instructions say you "must only accept List B documentation that contains a photograph," including for minors and people with disabilities. The employee may instead present a single List A document, such as a U.S. passport, and then you do not ask for the card at all.

How do you record a Social Security card in Section 2?

  1. Record the List B document in the middle column.
  2. In the List C column, enter the document title. M-274 Appendix A suggests "SS Card" for a Social Security account number card without restriction, and the Form I-9 instructions give "SSA" as an abbreviation for the Social Security Administration.
  3. Enter the card number as the document number. There is no expiration date to record.
  4. Leave List A blank, enter the first day of employment, and sign within three business days of that date.
  5. Check that the number in Section 1 matches the card if the employee entered one. If it does not, ask the employee to correct Section 1; employers may not correct Section 1 themselves.

Does an unrestricted card work at reverification?

Yes, and this surprises many HR teams. When an employee's employment authorization expires, M-274 Section 6.1 says they must present "any documentation from List A or C, including an unrestricted Social Security card." Section 14.0 answers the follow-up directly: if the employee presents an unrestricted card, "the employee does not also need to present a current DHS document." A restricted card must be rejected, and the employee asked to choose a different List A or List C document. The full process is in I-9 reverification.

What if the card is lost or stolen?

A receipt showing the employee applied to replace a lost, stolen or damaged card stands in for List C for 90 days from the date of hire (M-274 Section 4.4). It cannot be used for a job lasting less than three business days, and you cannot accept a second receipt when the 90 days end. If the replacement does not arrive, the employee may present a List A document or another List C document.

SSA's replacement card page says the replacement is free and arrives by mail "in 5 to 10 business days" after SSA completes the request, and that the local office "cannot print one for you." The same page notes that most people do not need the physical card if they know their number, which is true for payroll but not for Form I-9 if the employee has chosen the card as their List C document. E-Verify employers wait to create the case until the replacement or other documents arrive; see the I-9 receipt rule.

Can you require a new hire to show the card?

Not for Form I-9. M-274 Section 3.0 says: "You cannot ask employees to provide a specific document with their Social Security number on it. To do so may constitute unlawful discrimination." Asking for more or different documents than the form requires, or for a particular document, can be an unfair documentary practice under 8 U.S.C. 1324b(a)(6) when done because of citizenship, immigration status or national origin; see I-9 document abuse.

Payroll is a separate track. Payroll needs the number for wage reporting and may ask to see the card for that purpose, but it cannot turn the card into the employee's required I-9 document. How the two fit together, including the IRS wording, is in Form I-9 without a Social Security number.

What changes if you use E-Verify?

  • The employee must enter their Social Security number in Section 1; the field is voluntary only for employers that do not use E-Verify (M-274 Section 3.0).
  • A Social Security card does not trigger photo matching, and E-Verify does not require you to copy it. The four documents that trigger photo matching are all List A documents; see E-Verify photo matching.
  • If the name or number does not match SSA's records, the case can return a Tentative Nonconfirmation (Mismatch). Follow the E-Verify steps in E-Verify tentative nonconfirmation; a mismatch is not a reason to reject the card itself.

What should staffing agencies watch for?

  • Onboarding checklists that say "bring your Social Security card" are a common source of document abuse charges. Send the Lists of Acceptable Documents instead.
  • Train branch staff on the three legends and on lamination, so cards are rejected or accepted the same way at every office.
  • For long-term temps on EADs, remember that an unrestricted card is a valid choice at reverification.

Agency roles in Form I-9 are covered in Form I-9 for staffing agencies.

A worked example

The details are illustrative. A company hired a technician three years ago who presented an Employment Authorization Document. Since then he has become a permanent resident. His EAD is about to expire, and HR asks him to complete Supplement B, telling him he may choose any List A or List C document.

  • He presents a new, unrestricted Social Security card. HR enters the document title ("SS Card") and the number in Supplement B, as M-274 Section 6.1 describes, then signs and dates it.
  • HR does not ask for his Permanent Resident Card as well. Section 14.0 says an unrestricted card is enough.
  • If the card had carried "VALID FOR WORK ONLY WITH DHS AUTHORIZATION," HR would have rejected it and asked him to choose a different List A or List C document.

A Social Security card checklist

  • Original card; no photocopies; not laminated.
  • None of the three restrictive legends; unsigned is fine.
  • Paired with a List B document (with a photo for E-Verify employers), or not needed at all if the employee chose a List A document.
  • Recorded under List C as "SS Card," with the number and no expiration date.
  • Accepted at reverification if unrestricted.
  • Never required by name, for Form I-9 or for onboarding paperwork.

Questions people ask

Can a Social Security card be used for Form I-9?

Yes, an original, unrestricted Social Security card is a List C document that shows employment authorization. Because it does not prove identity, the employee must also present a List B identity document, such as a state driver's license, or may choose a List A document instead.

Which Social Security cards are not acceptable for Form I-9?

Cards bearing NOT VALID FOR EMPLOYMENT, VALID FOR WORK ONLY WITH INS AUTHORIZATION or VALID FOR WORK ONLY WITH DHS AUTHORIZATION are restricted and are not acceptable List C documents. USCIS also says the card must not be laminated. The employee may then choose a different List C document or a List A document.

Is a laminated Social Security card acceptable for Form I-9?

No. USCIS's Handbook for Employers, Section 13.3, says the card must not be laminated. The Social Security Administration also tells cardholders not to laminate the card because lamination prevents detection of many security features, though a removable plastic cover is fine.

Can an employee use a Social Security card for I-9 reverification?

Yes, if it is unrestricted. USCIS says that during reverification the employee chooses a List A or List C document, and if they present an unrestricted Social Security card they do not also need to present a current DHS document. A restricted card must be rejected.

Can an employer require a new hire to show their Social Security card?

Not for Form I-9. Employees choose their documents, and USCIS's Handbook for Employers says you cannot ask employees to provide a specific document with their Social Security number on it, because that may be unlawful discrimination. Payroll may ask for the number, but that request is separate from Form I-9.