Consent and compliance

Voter registration card for Form I-9: a List B document, the E-Verify photo catch, and what it does not prove

On this page
  1. Is a voter registration card acceptable for Form I-9?
  2. Does a voter registration card need a photo?
  3. Does a voter registration card prove citizenship on Form I-9?
  4. How do you record a voter registration card in Section 2?
  5. What changes in E-Verify?
  6. Is a voter registration card ever reverified?
  7. Do poll workers and election judges need a Form I-9?
  8. What can you not do with a voter registration card?
  9. What should staffing agencies and multi-site employers watch for?
  10. A worked example
  11. A voter registration card checklist
  12. Questions people ask

Yes. "Voter's registration card" is List B, item 4, on the Form I-9 Lists of Acceptable Documents (edition 01/20/25), so it proves identity only and must be paired with a List C document, such as an unrestricted Social Security card, unless the employee chooses a List A document instead. Unlike the driver's license and government ID items, the list attaches no photo or identifying-information condition to it, so a voter card without a photo is acceptable at an employer that does not use E-Verify. An E-Verify employer may accept it only if it contains a photograph. On Form I-9 it does not prove citizenship or employment authorization. Those are the USCIS and E-Verify rules as of November 2026.

This page covers the voter registration card only: when it works, the E-Verify difference, how to record it, and the questions it tempts employers to ask. The full lists are in I-9 List A, B and C documents; the most common List B document is covered in driver's license for Form I-9.

Not legal advice. This summarizes the Form I-9, its instructions and Lists of Acceptable Documents (edition 01/20/25, expiration date 05/31/2027), 8 CFR 274a.2(b)(1)(v)(B), the Handbook for Employers (M-274) Section 13.2, List B documents (last updated July 15, 2025), M-274 Sections 4.0, 4.4 and 6.0 and Appendix A, I-9 Central's questions and answers, and E-Verify's published guidance, as checked in November 2026.

Is a voter registration card acceptable for Form I-9?

Yes. List B, item 4 on the current form reads "Voter's registration card," and the regulation lists "Voter's registration card" among the documents that establish identity only (8 CFR 274a.2(b)(1)(v)(B)(1)(iii)). M-274 Section 13.2 adds no conditions beyond the title. The general rules still apply:

  • Identity only. USCIS's Form I-9 Acceptable Documents page (updated October 5, 2026) says "The documents on List B establish only identity. Employees who choose to present a List B document must also present a document from List C for Section 2."
  • Unexpired, if dated. The same page says employees "may present one of the following unexpired List B documents." A card with no expiration date has nothing to check. See expired documents and Form I-9.
  • Original. The Form I-9 instructions say "Photocopies, except for certified copies of birth certificates, are not acceptable for Form I-9." USCIS does not address printouts of online voter records; the list names the card, and you examine the original document.
  • Genuine and related to the person. Without a photo, you are comparing the name, and any other details the card shows, with the person and their Section 1 entries. If it does not reasonably relate, you may reject it and let the employee present other documents from the lists.

Does a voter registration card need a photo?

It depends on whether you use E-Verify. I-9 Central's Special Rules for E-Verify Users page sets the two rules side by side: Form I-9 "Does not require a photo on identity documents (List B)," while E-Verify "Requires a photo on identity documents (List B)." The Form I-9 instructions tell E-Verify employers: "You must only accept List B documentation that contains a photograph. This applies to individuals under the age of 18 and individuals with disabilities."

SituationVoter registration card acceptable?Source
Employer does not use E-Verify; card has no photoYes, with a List C documentForm I-9 List B, item 4
Employer does not use E-Verify; card has a photoYes, with a List C documentForm I-9 List B, item 4
E-Verify employer; card has no photoNo; the employee may choose a List B document with a photo, or a List A documentForm I-9 instructions; E-Verify FAQ
E-Verify employer; card has a photoYes, with a List C documentForm I-9 instructions
Card has an expiration date that has passedNo, unless the issuing authority extended itAcceptable Documents page
Photocopy or screenshot of the cardNoForm I-9 instructions
Receipt for a replacement of a lost, stolen or damaged cardYes, for 90 days from the date of hireM-274 Section 4.4

If you use E-Verify, you can tell new hires before their first day that any List B document must have a photo; the employee instructions say the same thing ("If you present a List B document to your employer, it must contain a photograph"). You still cannot name the document they should bring.

Does a voter registration card prove citizenship on Form I-9?

No. On Form I-9 it does one job, identity, and three things follow from that:

  1. A List C document is still needed. Employment authorization comes from List C (or List A). For a U.S. citizen, List C includes an unrestricted Social Security card, a birth certificate issued by a U.S. state, county, municipal authority or territory bearing an official seal, and the State Department's birth abroad forms. See Social Security card for Form I-9 and birth certificate for Form I-9.
  2. Section 1 is the employee's attestation. The Form I-9 instructions tell employees: "Your employer may not ask for documentation to verify the information you entered in Section 1." A voter card is not a way to check the citizenship box, and its absence says nothing either way.
  3. Do not ask about voter registration. Whether someone is registered to vote has no place in a Form I-9 conversation. Asking for the card, or treating it as proof of citizenship, invites the documentary-practice problems below.

How do you record a voter registration card in Section 2?

  1. Under List B, enter the document title. M-274 Appendix A gives no abbreviation for it, and I-9 Central's Section 2 page says to "Enter your employee's documentation accurately as it appears on the Lists of Acceptable Documents," so "Voter's registration card" is the safe entry.
  2. Enter the issuing authority: the election office named on the card, for example a county board of elections.
  3. Enter the document number if the card shows one; the field reads "Document Number (if any)."
  4. Enter the expiration date only if the card has one; the field reads "Expiration Date (if any)."
  5. Record the List C document in the right-hand column and leave List A blank.
  6. Enter the first day of employment and complete Section 2 within three business days, or by the first day if the job lasts less than three business days.
  7. Return the card. If you copy documents, I-9 Central's questions and answers say to do so "for all employees, regardless of national origin or citizenship status."

What changes in E-Verify?

  • Check the photo first. A card without one cannot complete Section 2 at an E-Verify employer. The employee chooses the replacement document.
  • Enter the documentation as the lists name it. The Section 2 page says "You must enter your employee's documentation in E-Verify as it appears on Form I-9 Lists of Acceptable Documents."
  • No photo matching. E-Verify's photo matching page limits it to the U.S. passport, passport card, Permanent Resident Card and Employment Authorization Document; "Other documents with photos (such as a driver's license) will not activate photo matching." See E-Verify photo matching.
  • The Social Security number is required. The E-Verify User Manual, Section 2.1, says SSNs "are required for employers to create E-Verify cases."

Is a voter registration card ever reverified?

No. M-274 Section 6.0 says reverification is never required when List B documents expire. If the employee moves, re-registers or receives a new card, nothing changes on the Form I-9 because of the card. Supplement B is for reverification, rehires and recording legal name changes; see Form I-9 name changes.

Do poll workers and election judges need a Form I-9?

This question comes up for employers and agencies staffing elections. I-9 Central's questions and answers ask whether "election judges and poll workers" are exempt from completing Forms I-9 under a Justice Department memo dated February 18, 1988, and answer: "Yes, Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) continues to adhere to this policy. For more information, please contact ICE directly." The exemption is about who completes the form, not about the voter card; staff hired for other election-office work follow the ordinary rules.

What can you not do with a voter registration card?

  • Do not require it, or rule it out, by name. M-274 Section 4.0 says "You cannot specify which documentation an employee will present from the Form I-9 Lists of Acceptable Documents." Asking for more or different documents, or refusing documents that reasonably appear genuine, can be an unfair documentary practice under 8 U.S.C. 1324b(a)(6) when done because of citizenship, immigration status or national origin. See I-9 document abuse.
  • Do not refuse a photo-less card at a non-E-Verify site. The photo rule belongs to E-Verify; at a site that does not use it, the card needs no photo.
  • Do not ask for supporting documents. A voter card that reasonably appears genuine and relates to the person must be accepted with an acceptable List C document; you do not ask for a second identity document to back it up.
  • Do not treat it as a citizenship check. See citizenship status discrimination in hiring.

What should staffing agencies and multi-site employers watch for?

  • Keep the photo rule site by site. An agency that uses E-Verify at some branches and not others must apply the rule only where it participates; see E-Verify requirements by state for where it is mandatory.
  • Script the explanation. Branch staff at E-Verify sites need one sentence ("any List B document must have a photo") and the Lists of Acceptable Documents, not a list of preferred documents.
  • Watch receipts on short jobs. M-274 Section 4.4 says receipts are not accepted when employment will last less than three business days, so a lost voter card cannot be replaced by a receipt for a one-day event assignment. More on agency roles is in Form I-9 for staffing agencies.

A worked example

The details are illustrative. A staffing agency hires two warehouse temps on the same Monday at two branches.

  • At a branch that does not use E-Verify, a temp presents a county-issued voter registration card with no photo and an unrestricted Social Security card. The recruiter records "Voter's registration card," the county election office and the voter number under List B, leaves the expiration date blank, and records the Social Security card under List C.
  • At a branch that uses E-Verify, a second temp presents the same two kinds of documents. The recruiter explains that this site can accept only List B documents with a photo and hands over the lists. On Wednesday, within the three-business-day window, the temp presents a state ID card instead, and the branch creates the E-Verify case.
  • Neither recruiter asks either temp whether they are registered to vote, and neither card will be reverified.

A voter registration card checklist

  • The original card, unexpired if it carries an expiration date.
  • A photo only if your site uses E-Verify.
  • Reasonably appears genuine and relates to the person.
  • Paired with a List C document, or not needed because the employee chose List A.
  • Recorded as "Voter's registration card," with the election office as issuing authority.
  • Never required by name, never treated as proof of citizenship, never reverified.

Questions people ask

Is a voter registration card acceptable for Form I-9?

Yes. A voter's registration card is List B, item 4, on the Form I-9 Lists of Acceptable Documents, so it establishes identity only. The employee must also present a List C document, such as an unrestricted Social Security card or a U.S. birth certificate, unless they choose a List A document instead. If your company uses E-Verify, the card must contain a photograph.

Does a voter registration card need a photo for Form I-9?

Not for an employer that does not use E-Verify; the list attaches no photo condition to the voter's registration card. An E-Verify employer, though, may only accept List B documents that contain a photograph, so a voter card without a photo is not acceptable there, and the employee may choose a different List B document with a photo or a List A document.

Does a voter registration card prove U.S. citizenship on Form I-9?

No. On Form I-9 it is an identity document only. Employment authorization comes from the List C document, and the employee's citizenship or immigration status is their own attestation in Section 1. The Form I-9 instructions say an employer may not ask for documentation to verify the information the employee entered in Section 1.

Do poll workers and election judges need a Form I-9?

According to I-9 Central's questions and answers, no: USCIS answers yes to whether election judges and poll workers are exempt from completing Forms I-9 under a Justice Department memo dated February 18, 1988, and says Immigration and Customs Enforcement continues to adhere to that policy. It refers further questions to ICE.

Do you have to reverify a voter registration card?

No. USCIS's Handbook for Employers, Section 6.0, says reverification is never required when List B documents expire, and a change of address or a new voter card after hire is not a Form I-9 event.