Consent and compliance

Birth certificate for Form I-9: when it counts as List C, the Puerto Rico rule, and what must go with it

On this page
  1. Can a new hire use a birth certificate for Form I-9?
  2. Which birth certificates are not acceptable?
  3. What is the Puerto Rico rule?
  4. What else does the new hire need to bring?
  5. How do you record a birth certificate in Section 2?
  6. Does the name on the birth certificate have to match?
  7. Can you ask a new hire to bring a birth certificate?
  8. What if the birth certificate was lost or damaged?
  9. What should staffing agencies watch for?
  10. A worked example
  11. A birth certificate checklist
  12. Questions people ask

Yes, a birth certificate can be used for Form I-9, but only as a List C document and only if it is an original or certified copy issued by a U.S. state, county, municipal authority or territory that bears an official seal. It proves employment authorization, not identity, so the new hire must also present a List B identity document (one with a photo, if you use E-Verify), or may choose a List A document instead. Puerto Rico birth certificates count only if they were issued on or after July 1, 2010. Those are the USCIS rules as of November 2026.

This page covers what makes a birth certificate acceptable, the Puerto Rico rule, how to record it, and what you cannot ask. The full lists are in I-9 List A, B and C documents.

Not legal advice. This summarizes the Form I-9 Lists of Acceptable Documents (edition 01/20/25, expiring 05/31/2027), the Handbook for Employers (M-274) Section 13.3, List C documents, M-274 Sections 4.0, 4.4 and 14.0, and the E-Verify User Manual Section 2.1, as checked in November 2026.

Can a new hire use a birth certificate for Form I-9?

Yes. List C, item 3 on the 01/20/25 form reads: "Original or certified copy of birth certificate issued by a State, county, municipal authority, or territory of the United States bearing an official seal." The regulation says the same thing in slightly different words (8 CFR 274a.2(b)(1)(v)(C)(3)). M-274 Section 13.3 adds that "versions will vary by state and year of birth," so do not reject a certificate only because it looks different from one you have seen before. What matters is who issued it and whether it carries the official seal.

It is also the one document on the lists that can be a copy. The Form I-9 instructions say "Photocopies, except for certified copies of birth certificates, are not acceptable for Form I-9." A certified copy from a vital records office is acceptable; a photocopy of that certified copy is not.

Which birth certificates are not acceptable?

What the employee offersAcceptable as List C?Why
Original or certified copy from a state, county or city vital records office, with an official sealYesList C, item 3
Birth certificate from a U.S. territory (for example Guam or the U.S. Virgin Islands), with an official sealYesThe list includes territories; M-274 13.3 says "outlying possession of the United States"
Puerto Rico birth certificate issued before July 1, 2010NoM-274 13.3: only those issued on or after July 1, 2010
Hospital-issued or souvenir certificateNoNot issued by a state, county, municipal authority or territory
Plain photocopy, scan or phone photoNoOnly certified copies are accepted in person
Foreign birth certificateNoNot on the lists
Department of State Consular Report of Birth Abroad (FS-240), DS-1350 or FS-545Yes, but as List C item 2A separate List C entry; M-274 13.3 says they carry a raised seal

The hospital row trips up summer hiring most. A clinic, doctor or hospital record is a List B identity document, but only for someone under 18 who cannot present another List B document, and never for an E-Verify employer. See Form I-9 for minors.

What is the Puerto Rico rule?

M-274 Section 13.3 says, in so many words: "You may only accept a Puerto Rico birth certificate issued on or after July 1, 2010." The rule comes from a Puerto Rico law. In an October 4, 2010 technical assistance letter, the Justice Department's office that enforces the anti-discrimination rules (then the Office of Special Counsel, now the Immigrant and Employee Rights Section) explained that Puerto Rico Act No. 191 "invalidates certain birth certificates issued before July 1, 2010," and quoted USCIS that they would "no longer be acceptable as Form I-9 List C documents beginning October 30, 2010."

  • Check the issue date, not the birth date. The letter says the employer "is required to look at the date on which the birth certificate was issued." A person born in 1985 with a certificate issued in 2015 is fine.
  • Apply it to everyone. The same letter says that if an employer consistently rejects Puerto Rico birth certificates issued before July 1, 2010, "without regard to citizenship status or national origin," it is unlikely to be found in violation of the anti-discrimination provision. The point is consistency, not extra scrutiny of employees born in Puerto Rico. People born in Puerto Rico are U.S. citizens (M-274 Section 14.0), and you must not treat them differently in the process.
  • Let the employee choose the fix. If the certificate is too old, the employee may present any other List C document, or a List A document. Do not tell them they must order a new Puerto Rico certificate.

What else does the new hire need to bring?

A List B identity document, because List C proves only employment authorization. The Form I-9 instructions say that if an employee presents acceptable List B and List C documentation, you do not ask for List A documentation. Common List B pairings are a state driver's license or ID card (see driver's license for Form I-9), a school ID with a photo, or a U.S. military card (see military ID for Form I-9). The employee may also skip the pair and present one List A document, such as a U.S. passport.

E-Verify adds a condition on the List B side, not the birth certificate side. The E-Verify User Manual, Section 2.1, says "Any List B document presented to employers participating in E-Verify must contain a photo," and that if an employee objects to providing a photo document for religious reasons, the employer should call E-Verify at 888-464-4218. A birth certificate does not trigger photo matching and E-Verify does not require you to copy it.

How do you record a birth certificate in Section 2?

  1. Record the List B identity document in the middle column.
  2. In the List C column, enter the document title. M-274 Appendix A suggests "Birth Certificate" for an original or certified copy of a U.S. birth certificate bearing an official seal.
  3. Enter the issuing authority (the state, county or city office named on the certificate), the document number if it has one, and the expiration date if it has one. Most birth certificates do not expire.
  4. Leave the List A column blank, enter the first day of employment, and complete the certification block within three business days of the first day of employment.
  5. Return the original to the employee. If you keep copies of I-9 documents, copy them for every new hire, as M-274 Section 4.1 advises, so the practice does not differ by national origin or citizenship status.

The field-by-field guide is in Form I-9 Section 2 instructions.

Does the name on the birth certificate have to match?

Not exactly. Birth certificates often show a name the employee no longer uses. M-274 Section 14.0 says you may accept a document with a different name than the one in Section 1 "if the document reasonably relates to the employee," you may attach a brief memo explaining the discrepancy, and the employee may provide documentation of the name change "but is not required to do so." For a slight spelling variation, the document is acceptable if the employee has a reasonable explanation and it otherwise appears genuine and relates to them. See name changes and Form I-9 for the E-Verify side, where the name must match Social Security records.

Can you ask a new hire to bring a birth certificate?

No. The anti-discrimination notice on the Form I-9 instructions says employers cannot "specify which acceptable documentation employees must present" and that "Employees do NOT need to prove their citizenship, immigration status, or national origin." A birth certificate is often requested informally as "proof you are a citizen." That is exactly what the form says you cannot do, and employers cannot ask for documentation to verify the citizenship box in Section 1 either.

Requests for more or different documents, or for a particular document, can be unfair documentary practices under 8 U.S.C. 1324b(a)(6) when made because of citizenship, immigration status or national origin. See I-9 document abuse. Recruiters should keep document talk out of interviews entirely; the lawful questions are in work authorization questions in interviews.

What if the birth certificate was lost or damaged?

The employee may present a receipt for the replacement of a lost, stolen or damaged List C document. Under M-274 Section 4.4, it is valid for 90 days from the date of hire, it cannot be used for a job lasting less than three business days, and a second receipt at the end of the period is not permissible. If the replacement does not arrive, "the employee can present a List A document or another List C document instead." E-Verify employers wait to create the case until the replacement or other documents are presented. Details are in the I-9 receipt rule.

What should staffing agencies watch for?

  • Branch staff who complete Form I-9 for the agency need the Puerto Rico rule in writing, applied to every worker, so one office does not reject certificates another accepts.
  • A client may not tell the agency that its temps must bring a birth certificate, or a passport, or any other particular document.
  • Agencies that use E-Verify must remind branch staff that the identity document paired with a birth certificate needs a photo.

Who completes the form in each staffing arrangement is in Form I-9 for staffing agencies.

A worked example

The details are illustrative. An E-Verify employer hires a warehouse associate who was born in Ponce. On day two she presents a state driver's license with a photo and a Puerto Rico birth certificate. HR checks the issue date printed on the certificate: 2008.

  • The license is an acceptable List B document with a photo.
  • The certificate was issued before July 1, 2010, so it is not an acceptable List C document.
  • HR explains that this certificate cannot be accepted, hands her the Lists of Acceptable Documents, and says she may bring any List C document, or a List A document, by the third business day. HR does not name one.
  • The next day she brings an unrestricted Social Security card. HR records it under List C, completes Section 2, and creates the E-Verify case.

A birth certificate checklist

  • Issued by a U.S. state, county, municipal authority or territory, with an official seal.
  • Original or certified copy; no plain photocopies, scans or hospital certificates.
  • Puerto Rico: issued on or after July 1, 2010, checked the same way for everyone.
  • Paired with a List B identity document (with a photo for E-Verify employers), or replaced by a List A document if the employee prefers.
  • Recorded under List C as "Birth Certificate," with issuing authority and number.
  • Never requested by name, and never used to "prove" citizenship.

Questions people ask

Can a new hire use a birth certificate for Form I-9?

Yes, as a List C document that shows employment authorization. It must be an original or certified copy issued by a U.S. state, county, municipal authority or territory and bear an official seal. Because List C does not prove identity, the employee must also present a List B identity document, or may choose a single List A document instead.

Is a Puerto Rico birth certificate acceptable for Form I-9?

Only if it was issued on or after July 1, 2010. USCIS's Handbook for Employers, Section 13.3, says you may only accept a Puerto Rico birth certificate issued on or after that date. The test is the date the certificate was issued, not the person's date of birth.

Is a photocopy of a birth certificate acceptable for Form I-9?

Only a certified copy. The Form I-9 instructions say photocopies are not acceptable except for certified copies of birth certificates, and the List C entry requires a birth certificate issued by a state, county, municipal authority or territory that bears an official seal. An ordinary photocopy does not qualify.

Can a hospital birth certificate be used for Form I-9?

Not as a List C birth certificate, because List C requires one issued by a U.S. state, county, municipal authority or territory with an official seal. A clinic, doctor or hospital record can be a List B identity document only for someone under 18 who has no other List B document, and E-Verify employers cannot accept it because it has no photo.

Can an employer ask a new hire for a birth certificate?

No. Employees choose which acceptable documents to present, and the Form I-9 instructions say employees do not need to prove their citizenship. Requesting a specific document because of citizenship, immigration status or national origin can be an unfair documentary practice under 8 U.S.C. 1324b(a)(6).