When a new hire refuses to complete Form I-9 or cannot present documents: deadlines, what they may decline, and when you may end employment
On this page
- Does a new hire have to complete Form I-9?
- What may a new hire lawfully leave blank or decline?
- What are the deadlines?
- Is it "won't" or "can't"? Check these first
- What should you do when a new hire refuses, step by step?
- A message to send (example to adapt)
- What if a current employee refuses reverification or a correction?
- What must the employer not do?
- How does this work for staffing agencies?
- A refusal checklist
- Questions people ask
Form I-9 is not optional for anyone you hire, U.S. citizens included: the employee must complete and sign Section 1 by the first day of work for pay and present acceptable documents within three business days. If a new hire refuses to complete Section 1, or does not present acceptable documents or an acceptable receipt by the end of the third business day, USCIS's Handbook for Employers says you "may terminate" the employee, and keeping them on the payroll without a completed form is itself a violation. Before you get there, find out exactly what they are refusing: several things they may lawfully decline, such as giving a Social Security number to an employer that does not use E-Verify, listing an email address or phone number, or showing a specific document you asked for. Apply the same deadline to every new hire and write down what happened. This reflects the Form I-9 edition dated 01/20/25 and USCIS guidance as of November 2026.
The clock itself is covered in Form I-9 timing in hiring, and lost documents in the I-9 receipt rule. This page is the decision guide for the moment a new hire says no, or cannot produce what the form needs.
Not legal advice. This summarizes the Handbook for Employers (M-274), Section 3.0 (last updated April 2, 2025), Section 4.0 (July 15, 2025), Section 4.4 (October 9, 2024), Section 6.1 (October 8, 2026), Section 9.0 and Sections 10.0 and 14.0; the Form I-9 and its instructions, edition 01/20/25; 8 CFR 274a.2(b); and 8 U.S.C. 1324a and 1324b, as checked in November 2026. State law, union agreements and employment contracts can add steps before any termination; check them too.
Does a new hire have to complete Form I-9?
Yes. USCIS's Form I-9 page says "All U.S. employers must properly complete Form I-9 for every individual they hire for employment in the United States. This includes citizens and aliens." The statute, 8 U.S.C. 1324a(a)(1)(B), makes it unlawful "to hire for employment in the United States an individual without complying with the requirements of subsection (b)," the verification system. And the regulation puts the duty on the employer: it "must ensure that the individual properly" completes Section 1 and presents documents within the time limits (8 CFR 274a.2(b)(1)(i)).
The form's own DHS Privacy Notice tells the employee the consequence plainly: "The information employees provide is voluntary. However, failure to provide the requested information, including your Social Security number (if applicable), and any requested evidence, may result in termination of employment." People who are not employees for Form I-9 purposes, such as unpaid volunteers and true independent contractors, do not complete it; see Form I-9 for independent contractors.
What may a new hire lawfully leave blank or decline?
Many "refusals" are not refusals at all. The employee has real choices on the form, and an employer that treats a lawful choice as a refusal creates its own problem.
| Item | May the employee decline? | Source |
|---|---|---|
| Social Security number | Yes, unless you use E-Verify; E-Verify employers' employees must provide it | Instructions, Section 1 Step 1; M-274 Section 3.0 |
| Email address and telephone number | Yes | M-274 Section 3.0 |
| Completing Section 1 before accepting the job offer | Yes; you "may not ask" them to | M-274 Section 3.0 |
| Showing a specific document you name, such as a passport or green card | Yes; they choose from the Lists | Instructions; M-274 Section 4.0 |
| Proving their citizenship or the information in Section 1 | Yes; you "cannot ask" | Instructions, Anti-Discrimination Notice |
| Name, address and date of birth | No; "All employees must provide" them | Instructions, Section 1 Step 1 |
| Checking one status box and signing the attestation | No; "You must select one box" | Instructions, Section 1 Steps 2 and 3 |
| Presenting one List A document, or one List B and one List C document (or an acceptable receipt) | No, within three business days of the first day of work | Instructions, Step 5; 8 CFR 274a.2(b)(1)(i)(B) |
| Correcting a confirmed error in Section 1 | No; "The employee must correct any confirmed errors" | M-274 Section 3.0 |
The most common flashpoint is the Social Security number. A new hire who has applied for one but not received it "may work while awaiting their Social Security number," per M-274 Section 3.0, and adds it when it arrives; see Form I-9 without a Social Security number.
What are the deadlines?
- Section 1: "no later than the employee's first day of employment" (M-274 Section 3.0), and not before the offer is accepted.
- Documents and Section 2: within three business days of the first day of work. USCIS's example: an employee who starts on Monday must present documentation "on or before the Thursday of that week."
- Jobs of less than three business days: everything by the first day, and receipts are not accepted (8 CFR 274a.2(b)(1)(iii)); see Form I-9 for jobs lasting less than three days.
- Receipts: a receipt for replacing a lost, stolen or damaged document is valid for 90 days from the date of hire (M-274 Section 4.4). USCIS says "Accepting a second receipt at the end of the initial receipt validity period is not permissible," and a receipt for an initial grant of employment authorization or an initial EAD is not acceptable (M-274 Section 14.0).
Is it "won't" or "can't"? Check these first
Before treating a missing document as a refusal, check whether the form already has an answer for the situation:
| Situation | What the rules allow | Read more |
|---|---|---|
| Document lost, stolen or damaged | A receipt for the replacement application, valid 90 days | Receipt rule |
| Minor with no List B identity document | A parent or legal guardian completes Section 1 and Supplement A, and the minor presents only a List C document | Form I-9 for minors |
| Employee with a disability in a special placement, with no List B document | A representative, parent or guardian completes Section 1 and Supplement A; the employee presents only List C | Employees with disabilities |
| Employee cannot read or write English, or cannot write their name | A preparer or translator helps with Section 1 and completes Supplement A; the employee may sign with a mark | Supplement A |
| Name on a document differs after marriage or another change | Accept it if it reasonably relates to the employee; a memo may explain the discrepancy | Form I-9 name changes |
| Document has expired | Not acceptable, unless extended by the issuing authority; the employee chooses another | Expired documents |
What should you do when a new hire refuses, step by step?
- Ask what the obstacle is. Is it one field, such as the Social Security number, or the whole form? Is it a missing document, a privacy worry, or a misunderstanding about who must complete it?
- Give them the instructions and the Lists of Acceptable Documents. Employers must make both available. Explain that they choose which documents to present, and do not name one.
- Put the deadlines in writing, using the same message you would send any new hire (a template is below). Name the first day of work and the third business day.
- Check the situations above for a receipt, a minor, a special placement, a preparer or a name change.
- Do not fill the gap yourself. HR may not complete Section 1 for the employee except as a preparer or translator with a Supplement A certification, and "Employees who use a preparer and/or translator to complete the form must still sign or make their mark" (M-274 Section 3.0).
- If the deadline passes, decide under your written policy. M-274 Section 4.0: "You may terminate an employee who fails to present acceptable documentation (or an acceptable receipt for a document) within three business days after the date employment begins." Apply the same practice to everyone.
- Document it. Keep a dated note of what was requested, when, and what the employee said, and keep any partly completed Form I-9. M-274 Section 10.0 says the retention requirement "applies even if the employee ends employment shortly after the date of hire"; see I-9 retention rules.
A message to send (example to adapt)
This is an example to review with counsel, not a required notice. Send the same text to every new hire who has not completed the form.
Subject: Your Form I-9, due [date] Federal law requires every new employee, including U.S. citizens, to complete Form I-9, Employment Eligibility Verification. 1. Please complete and sign Section 1 no later than your first day of work, [date]. The Social Security number field is [voluntary / required because we use E-Verify]. Email and phone fields are optional. 2. By [date: third business day after your first day of work], please present original, unexpired documents of your choice: one document from List A, or one from List B and one from List C. The lists and instructions are attached. We cannot tell you which documents to bring. 3. If a document was lost, stolen or damaged, a receipt showing you applied to replace it can be used for now. If the form is not completed by these dates, we may not be able to continue your employment, as USCIS's Handbook for Employers allows. If something is stopping you, please tell us now so we can check the options the form provides. [Name, title, phone]
What if a current employee refuses reverification or a correction?
- Reverification. When an employee's employment authorization or List A or C document expires and reverification is required, M-274 Section 6.1 says: "You cannot continue employing a person who does not provide proof of current employment authorization." The employee may choose any List A or List C document. Do not reverify U.S. citizens, noncitizen nationals, or lawful permanent residents who presented a Permanent Resident Card; a demand to reverify them is not a refusal you can act on. See I-9 reverification.
- Section 1 corrections. "Only employees, or their preparer and/or translator, may correct errors or omissions made in Section 1" (M-274 Section 9.0). If the employee will not make a confirmed correction, do not make it yourself; Section 9.0 says to "attach a written explanation of why information was missing or needed correcting." See Form I-9 corrections.
What must the employer not do?
- Do not demand specific or extra documents. Requesting more or different documents, or rejecting documents that reasonably appear genuine, can be an unfair documentary practice under 8 U.S.C. 1324b(a)(6); see I-9 document abuse. The instructions add that employers "should not reject acceptable documentation due to a future expiration date."
- Do not apply the deadline unevenly. The Justice Department's Immigrant and Employee Rights Section says federal law "requires employers to follow Form I-9 and E-Verify rules consistently, regardless of an employee's citizenship, immigration status, or national origin." Extending one person's deadline informally and not another's invites a charge.
- Do not retaliate against someone who objects to an unlawful document request; 1324b(a)(5) bars intimidation, threats and retaliation for exercising rights under the anti-discrimination provision.
- Do not backdate or sign for the employee, and do not let a person work for weeks "until the paperwork catches up." Missing or late forms are paperwork violations; see Form I-9 penalties.
How does this work for staffing agencies?
USCIS's Exceptions page says the agency "completes Form I-9 for each worker they provide," so a refusal is the agency's to handle, not the client's. M-274 Section 4.0 lets staffing agencies use "either the date an employee is assigned to the employee's first job or the date the new employee is entered into the assignment pool" as the first day of employment, which sets the three-day clock. Do not place a worker whose form is incomplete past the deadline, and give recruiters the same message template so every candidate hears the same rule. More in Form I-9 for staffing agencies.
A refusal checklist
- Identify the exact field or document in question; voluntary fields left blank are fine.
- Instructions and Lists provided; no document named by the employer.
- Receipts, minors, special placements, preparers and name changes checked.
- Written deadlines: Section 1 by the first day of work; documents by the third business day.
- Same message and same deadline for every new hire.
- If the deadline passes: decision under a written policy, a dated note, and the partial form retained.
- For current employees: reverification only where required; Section 1 corrections only by the employee, with an explanation memo if they decline.
Questions people ask
What happens if an employee refuses to fill out Form I-9?
The employer cannot keep them on the payroll without a completed form. Federal law makes it unlawful to hire anyone without completing the verification, and Section 1 is due by the first day of work for pay. As of November 2026, USCIS's Handbook for Employers, Section 4.0, says an employer may terminate an employee who does not present acceptable documents or an acceptable receipt within three business days of starting work. First find out which part they object to, because some fields are voluntary.
Can I fire an employee who does not bring I-9 documents within three days?
USCIS says you may. Section 4.0 of the Handbook for Employers says you may terminate an employee who fails to present acceptable documentation, or an acceptable receipt for a document, within three business days after employment begins. Apply that rule the same way to every new hire, check whether a receipt or the minor or disability rules apply first, and document what happened. State law and any contract may add their own requirements.
Can a new hire refuse to give their Social Security number on Form I-9?
Yes, unless the employer participates in E-Verify. The Form I-9 instructions say providing the Social Security number is voluntary unless the employer uses E-Verify, in which case the employee must provide it. A new hire who has applied for a number but not received it may still work if they can complete the rest of the form, and adds the number later.
What if a new hire lost their documents and cannot present them within three days?
If a document was lost, stolen or damaged, the employee may present a receipt for the application to replace it within the three business days, and the receipt is valid for 90 days from the date of hire, according to USCIS's Handbook for Employers, Section 4.4. A receipt for an initial application, such as a first Employment Authorization Document, is not acceptable, and no receipt is allowed for a job lasting less than three business days.
Does a U.S. citizen have to complete Form I-9?
Yes. USCIS's Handbook for Employers, Section 14.0, says citizens and noncitizen nationals are automatically eligible for employment but they too must present the required documents and complete Form I-9. Being a U.S. citizen is not a reason to skip the form, and an employer should not treat it as one.