Interview scorecard for administrative assistants, with anchors for each competency
On this page
- The six competencies this scorecard covers
- The scorecard at a glance: weights and anchors
- The scorecard template
- Anchors for each competency
- Two work samples to use in the interview
- A filled example
- Adjusting for setting and level
- Mistakes specific to scoring administrative assistants
- Where this fits in the hiring process
- Questions people ask
An administrative assistant interview scorecard should score six things: prioritizing requests from several people, accuracy, software skills shown on a real task, phone and front desk service, coordinating meetings, travel, expenses and supplies, and discretion with information. Below is a copy-ready scorecard with a weight for each row, what a 1, 3 and 5 look like on a 1–5 scale, two short work samples and a filled example. Must-haves such as the hours, on-site days and any physical task the job description lists are pass/fail lines, kept out of the weighted score.
The five points follow the 1–5 interview rating scale: 1 is no evidence or evidence of the opposite, 3 is a clear example that meets the bar, 5 is rare. The layout comes from the interview scorecard template. This page is for an assistant who supports a team or an office; if one executive's calendar and correspondence are the job, use the interview scorecard for executive assistants instead. The scorecard builder prints a 1–4 version from its general preset if your team uses four points.
The six competencies this scorecard covers
- Prioritizing requests from several people. When three managers want something by noon, do they sort it by deadline and impact, tell people what to expect, and ask for a priority call when they genuinely cannot do it all?
- Accuracy and attention to detail. Do they check their own work before it leaves their desk, and catch errors in other people's?
- Software skills shown on a task. Can they actually do the tasks the job needs in the tools the office uses, not just list the tools?
- Phone, front desk and email service. Does a caller or visitor leave with an answer or a clear next step, and does the message reach the right person intact?
- Office coordination. Can they keep meetings, travel bookings, expense reports, supplies and vendor requests moving without reminders?
- Discretion with information. Do they know what not to share, with visitors, callers and colleagues, and say so politely?
The scorecard at a glance: weights and anchors
Weights are an example for an assistant supporting three or four managers. Set yours with the hiring manager at intake and lock them before the first interview.
| Competency | Weight | 1 looks like | 3 looks like | 5 looks like |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Prioritizing requests from several people | 25% | Works in the order requests arrive, or describes missing a deadline without telling anyone. | A real example of competing requests: sorted by deadline and impact, told each requester what to expect, asked for a priority call when needed, and closed the loop. | All of a 3, plus a system they set up (a shared request list, a standing rule agreed with the managers) that cut the conflicts. |
| Accuracy and attention to detail | 20% | Misses most planted errors in the work sample, or describes an error a client or manager found with no change afterward. | Finds most planted errors and describes a checking habit (re-reading against the source, totals that must tie, a second look at dates and names). | Finds every planted error, explains how, and describes a check they added to a shared process after catching someone else's mistake. |
| Software skills shown on a task | 15% | Lists tools but cannot do the basic task asked in them. | Completes the task in the office's tools with ordinary methods and can explain the steps. | Completes it quickly, suggests a faster or less error-prone method, and has built a template or shortcut others use. |
| Phone, front desk and email service | 15% | The caller or visitor leaves with no answer and no next step, or the message is wrong. | Greets, finds out what is needed, takes an accurate message (name, number, reason, urgency) and says what happens next. | Handles an upset or confused caller calmly, solves it without passing it on where they can, and follows up to confirm. |
| Office coordination | 15% | Bookings, expenses or supplies described as things that happen when someone reminds them. | Owns a recurring task (expense reports, a meeting series, supply orders) with deadlines and a way to track it. | Spotted a recurring problem (late expense reports, double-booked rooms) and fixed the process, with the result described. |
| Discretion with information | 10% | Shares confidential details from a past job in the interview, or would give out a colleague's personal number. | Describes what they did not share and how they redirected the request politely. | Describes catching a near miss (a visible screen, a document left on a printer) and the habit or rule they put in place. |
A 1 on discretion is a no whatever the total. Must-haves come first: the schedule and on-site days, and any physical task the written job description lists as an essential function, such as lifting deliveries or staffing a reception desk. The ADA regulations define essential functions as "the fundamental job duties of the employment position" and count written job descriptions "prepared before advertising or interviewing applicants" as evidence of them (29 CFR 1630.2(n), checked November 2026). Ask every candidate whether they can perform those functions with or without reasonable accommodation, and never score how someone looks, moves or sounds.
The scorecard template
Candidate: [name] Role: [administrative assistant, team / office supported]
Interviewer: [name] Stage: [screen / interview / work samples]
Pass/fail (checked before scoring)
Hours and on-site days as stated in the job description: [ ] meets [ ] does not
Essential physical functions listed in the job description,
with or without reasonable accommodation: [ ] meets [ ] n/a
Required certification, verified with the issuer (if any): [ ] yes [ ] n/a
Prioritizing requests from several people (25%) Score 1-5: [ ]
Evidence: [the competing requests, the order chosen, who was told]
Accuracy and attention to detail (20%) Score 1-5: [ ]
Evidence: [errors found in the expense sample: _ of 3; checking habit]
Software skills shown on a task (15%) Score 1-5: [ ]
Evidence: [task completed, method, time]
Phone, front desk and email service (15%) Score 1-5: [ ]
Evidence: [example or role-play; message accuracy]
Office coordination (15%) Score 1-5: [ ]
Evidence: [recurring task owned, tracking method]
Discretion with information (10%) - a 1 is a no Score 1-5: [ ]
Evidence: [what they declined to share and how]
Weighted score: sum of (weight x score) / sum of weights scored = [ ]
Recommendation: [Strong yes / Yes / No / Strong no]
Anchors for each competency
The table gives the 1, 3 and 5. Here is the question that tests each row and what a 2 and a 4 sound like.
Prioritizing requests from several people
Ask: "Tell me about a morning when two or three people you supported all needed something urgently. What did you do first, and what did you tell the others?" More in interview questions for prioritization.
- 2: Got everything done but cannot explain the order, or nobody was told about the wait.
- 4: Clear order with a reason, everyone told, and one task renegotiated with its owner rather than done late.
Accuracy and attention to detail
Ask: "Tell me about a mistake you made in a document, booking or report. How did you find out, and what do you do differently now?" Then use the expense sample below.
- 2: Finds one of the three planted errors; the checking habit is "I'm just careful".
- 4: Finds all three, or two plus a sensible question about the third, and describes a habit that would have caught their own past mistake.
Software skills shown on a task
Ask: use the attendee-list task below, in the tools the office actually uses.
- 2: Finishes with help, or by hand where the tool would do it (deleting duplicates row by row).
- 4: Finishes unaided using the tool's own features (sort, remove duplicates, a count by group) and checks the result.
Phone, front desk and email service
Ask: "A caller asks to speak to a manager who is in back-to-back meetings and says it is urgent. Take me through the call."
- 2: Polite, but the message is missing the reason or a callback time.
- 4: Finds out what "urgent" means, offers another person who can help if one exists, and tells the caller when to expect a reply.
Office coordination
Ask: "What recurring task did you own end to end in your last role, and how did you keep track of it?"
- 2: Owned a task but relied on others' reminders to meet the deadline.
- 4: Owned several recurring tasks with a tracking method and can name one deadline they protected under pressure.
Discretion with information
Ask: "A colleague from another department asks you for a manager's personal mobile number, saying it is urgent. What do you do?" More in interview questions for discretion.
- 2: Would not share it, but offers no way to get the message through.
- 4: Declines, offers to pass the message on or reach the manager now, and follows the office's rule if there is one.
Two work samples to use in the interview
The screening questions already include a five-minute inbox exercise, and the interview guide for administrative roles has a full in-basket and a front desk call. These two short samples test accuracy and software skill instead. Both are invented and the same for every candidate. Tell candidates in advance and how to ask for an adjustment; see ADA accommodations in interviews.
Expense report check (15 minutes). Hand over a one-page expense report for a manager's two-day trip with eight lines, the receipts, and a one-paragraph invented policy (for example, "receipts required for any item over $25"). Plant three problems: one meal entered twice, a hotel night dated a day outside the trip, and a taxi fare over the receipt threshold with no receipt. Task: "Get this ready for the manager to approve. List anything you fixed and anything you need to ask about."
What to look for: how many of the three problems they find; whether they fix what they can (the duplicate) and ask about what they cannot (the missing receipt) rather than guessing; and whether totals are re-checked after the fix. This scores accuracy and coordination.
Attendee-list task (10 minutes). A spreadsheet of 30 invented names for a training day, with four duplicates and inconsistent capitalization. Task: "Remove the duplicates, sort by department, and tell me how many people are coming from each department." Use the spreadsheet tool the office uses.
What to look for: the tool's own features rather than manual work, a check that the final count is right, and a sensible question about any name that might or might not be a duplicate. This scores software skills and a second data point on accuracy.
A filled example
A made-up candidate for an assistant role supporting three sales managers in a regional office:
Prioritizing requests from several people — 3. Described a Monday when a client meeting room, a manager's travel change and a weekly report all fell due by 10 a.m.; did the room first, messaged the other two managers with times, and finished both by 11.
Accuracy and attention to detail — 4. Found the duplicate meal and the hotel date, and asked whether the taxi needed a receipt under the policy. Re-added the total afterward.
Software skills shown on a task — 3. Used the built-in remove-duplicates and sort features; counted by department with a filter rather than a formula. Correct result.
Phone, front desk and email service — 4. In the urgent-caller question, asked what the issue was, found that another manager could approve it, and offered a transfer.
Office coordination — 3. Ran monthly expense submissions for a team of eight with a shared checklist and reminder dates.
Discretion with information — 3. Would not give out the personal number; offered to text the manager the message instead.
Weighted score: 3.35 ((3×25 + 4×20 + 3×15 + 4×15 + 3×15 + 3×10) ÷ 100). Recommendation: Yes. Solid on every row and strong on accuracy and service; no row needs a follow-up before references.
Adjusting for setting and level
| Setting | Adjustment |
|---|---|
| Front desk or receptionist-heavy role | Raise phone and front desk service to 25% and add visitor sign-in and deliveries to the coordination row. |
| Team assistant for five or more people | Raise prioritizing to 30%; a 3 needs a rule for whose request wins, agreed with the managers. |
| Healthcare, legal or HR office | Raise discretion to 20% and write its anchors around the privacy rules the office trains on, without asking candidates to reveal past cases. |
| Entry-level or first office job | Keep the anchors and accept examples from school, volunteer work or retail; score the work samples at full weight. |
| Senior administrator or office manager hybrid | Add a row for vendor and budget management and score coordination on a 5 only when the candidate changed a process. |
Mistakes specific to scoring administrative assistants
| Mistake | Why it fails | Fix |
|---|---|---|
| Scoring friendliness as service | A warm candidate who takes a wrong message is worse at the job than a reserved one who gets it right | Score the message, the next step and the follow-up against the anchors |
| Scoring accent or voice on the phone row | Neither is a job requirement, and the EEOC treats national origin as a protected basis | Score clarity and accuracy of the call, not how the candidate sounds |
| A typing-speed cutoff as a weighted row | Double-counts a pass/fail fact and can screen out people for no job reason | Keep it pass/fail and only if the job needs it; the rules are in the administrative interview guide |
| Asking about children to judge reliability | The EEOC lists child care arrangements among questions that may be regarded as evidence of intent to discriminate | State the hours and ask every candidate whether they can work them |
| Giving everyone a 3 on software | A list of tools on a resume is not evidence | Score the task, not the resume line |
Certifications such as IAAP's Certified Administrative Professional or a Microsoft Office Specialist certification are pass/fail checks if the job requires them, verified with the issuer (see how to verify Microsoft certifications), and never points on the scorecard.
Where this fits in the hiring process
The administrative assistant phone screen covers knockouts and a first read on prioritizing and software. The interview and the two work samples above fill in the six rows. Keep the rows consistent with the must-haves in the administrative assistant job description template, and carry the weakest scored row into the first month of the 30-60-90 day plan for administrative assistants.
If you interview with Interview Signal, the desktop app we make, these rows can become the scorecard areas in its kit, each with a weight of 1, 2 or 3 and its own rubric lines on a 1–10 scale. Every score then carries the candidate's own quotes, checked word for word against the transcript, and an area with no quote is capped and marked "Probe further"; see how the scorecard with verified quotes works. However you capture notes, have each interviewer submit before reading the others, then compare in a calibration session.
Questions people ask
What competencies should an administrative assistant scorecard include?
Five or six that match the job: prioritizing requests from several people, accuracy and attention to detail, software skills shown on a real task, phone and front desk service, coordinating meetings, travel, expenses and supplies, and discretion with information. Weight them for the seat, write what a 1, 3 and 5 look like for each, and keep must-haves such as the schedule as pass/fail lines.
Should typing speed be a scored row on an administrative assistant scorecard?
Only if the job genuinely needs a minimum speed, and then as a pass/fail must-have rather than a weighted score. Most administrative work depends far more on accuracy and judgment than on words per minute, and a cutoff the job does not need can screen people out for no business reason.
How do you score an administrative assistant's phone manner fairly?
Score what the caller would experience: whether the candidate greeted the caller, found out what they needed, took an accurate message with a name, number and reason, and said what would happen next. Do not score accent, voice or how formal the candidate sounds, which are not job requirements and can drift into national origin bias.
What is the difference between an administrative assistant scorecard and an executive assistant scorecard?
An administrative assistant usually serves several people and the office itself, so the scorecard weights prioritizing competing requests, accuracy and front desk service. An executive assistant scorecard weights judgment under delegated authority, writing in one executive's voice and running board meetings or offsites.