Templates

Interview scorecard for executive assistants, with anchors for each competency

On this page
  1. The six competencies this scorecard covers
  2. The scorecard at a glance: weights and anchors
  3. The scorecard template
  4. Anchors for each competency
  5. Two work samples to use in the interview
  6. A filled example
  7. Adjusting for seniority and setting
  8. Mistakes specific to scoring executive assistants
  9. Where this fits in the hiring process
  10. Questions people ask

An executive assistant interview scorecard should score six things that separate a strong EA from a good general assistant: calendar and priority judgment, decisions made under delegated authority, discretion, writing on the executive's behalf, running events such as board meetings and offsites, and managing who gets the executive's time. Below is a copy-ready scorecard with a weight for each competency, what a 1, 3 and 5 look like on a 1–5 scale, two work samples and a filled example. Must-haves such as the schedule, travel or a required certification are pass/fail lines, never part of the weighted score.

The five points follow the definitions in the 1–5 interview rating scale: 1 is no evidence or evidence of the opposite, 3 is a clear example that meets the bar for the role, and 5 is rare by design. The general layout comes from the interview scorecard template; what is specific here is the rows and anchors, written for someone who supports one or more senior executives. If your team prefers four points, the free scorecard builder prints a 1–4 version: start from its general preset and paste in these rows.

The six competencies this scorecard covers

  • Calendar and priority judgment. Can they decide what moves, what stays and what only the executive can decide, using the executive's priorities rather than first-come order?
  • Judgment under delegated authority. Do they know where their authority ends, act inside it without asking, and tell the executive afterward?
  • Discretion. Do they protect sensitive information through habits (access, storage, who is told), and do they avoid revealing a former executive's business in the interview itself?
  • Writing on the executive's behalf. Can they draft an email, a decline or a briefing note the executive could send with little or no editing?
  • Project and event coordination. Can they run a board meeting, offsite or multi-leg trip end to end, with a timeline, owners and a fallback?
  • Managing access and relationships. Can they say no to senior people, protect the executive's time and keep those relationships intact?

The scorecard at a glance: weights and anchors

Weights are an example for an assistant to one C-level executive. Agree yours with the executive at intake and lock them before the first interview.

CompetencyWeight1 looks like3 looks like5 looks like
Calendar and priority judgment25%Every conflict goes to the executive, or conflicts are settled first-come, first-served with no reference to priorities.A real week of conflicts, a triage method (who is affected, what can move, what the executive cares about most), a decision they made and how they told everyone.All of a 3, plus a standing system they built (protected focus time, a weekly priorities check-in, rules on who may book what) that stopped the next pile-up.
Judgment under delegated authority20%Asks permission for everything, or acted beyond their authority and does not see the problem.Names a decision made alone within agreed limits (moved a meeting, declined a request, approved a booking), states the limit, and told the executive afterward.Explains how they and the executive set the limits, and gives an example of the limits changing after a mistake or a change in the role.
Discretion15%Shares identifiable confidential details from a current or past employer during the interview.Describes concrete habits (restricted folders, need-to-know distribution, neutral calendar titles) without revealing the information itself.Describes a sensitive situation (a reorganization, a deal, a personal matter) in which they also stopped someone else learning more than they should, still without details.
Writing on the executive's behalf15%The draft is unclear, wrong in tone for a senior reader, or has errors the candidate does not catch.The draft is short, correct and sendable after light edits, and the candidate can explain their choices.Needs no edits, fits the recipient's seniority, and the candidate flags what they would confirm with the executive before sending.
Project and event coordination15%Events described only as attended or "helped with"; no plan, dates or owner.Walks through one event they owned: timeline, budget, vendors, materials, what went wrong and the fix.Owns recurring high-stakes events and built a run sheet or checklist that others now use.
Managing access and relationships10%Gatekeeping described as blocking people, or no example of saying no to anyone senior.Declined or redirected a senior person's request, can give the wording used, and the relationship stayed intact.Changed how a group requests the executive's time (an intake form, office hours, a delegate) and can describe the result.

Two rules sit on top of the weights. A 1 on discretion is a no whatever the total, because it is not coachable on a hiring timeline. And must-haves (evening availability, travel, on-site days, a required certification) are checked as pass/fail before the scored rows. Weighting itself is covered in weighted interview scorecard.

The scorecard template

Candidate: [name]                     Role: [EA to (title)], [one or several executives]
Interviewer: [name]                   Stage: [screen / panel / working session with executive]

Pass/fail (checked before scoring)
  Schedule, travel and on-site days as stated in the job description: [ ] meets  [ ] does not
  Required certification, verified with the issuer (if any):           [ ] yes    [ ] n/a

Calendar and priority judgment (25%)        Score 1-5: [ ]
Evidence: [the week described, what they decided themselves]

Judgment under delegated authority (20%)    Score 1-5: [ ]
Evidence: [the decision made alone, the limit they named]

Discretion (15%) - a 1 is a no              Score 1-5: [ ]
Evidence: [habits described; note if any confidential detail was shared]

Writing on the executive's behalf (15%)     Score 1-5: [ ]
Evidence: [the drafting sample; edits it would need]

Project and event coordination (15%)        Score 1-5: [ ]
Evidence: [event owned, timeline, fallback]

Managing access and relationships (10%)     Score 1-5: [ ]
Evidence: [request declined or redirected, wording used]

Weighted score: sum of (weight x score) / sum of weights scored = [   ]
Recommendation: [Strong yes / Yes / No / Strong no]
Open question for the next round: [one line]

Anchors for each competency

The table gives the 1, 3 and 5. These are the question that tests each row and what a 2 and a 4 sound like in between.

Calendar and priority judgment

Ask: "Tell me about the most crowded week your executive had in the last six months. What moved, who decided, and how did people find out?"

  • 2: Describes the week clearly, but the decisions were the executive's; the candidate carried them out.
  • 4: Made the calls themselves with a reason tied to the executive's priorities, and checked afterward that nothing important was dropped.

Judgment under delegated authority

Ask: "What can you decide for your executive without asking first, and how do you know where that line is?"

  • 2: The limits are vague ("I just use common sense") or the only example is trivial.
  • 4: Clear limits and a real example of acting at the edge of them, then telling the executive the same day.

Discretion

Ask: "Without names or details, tell me about information you handled that most of the company did not know. What did you do to keep it that way?" More questions are in interview questions for discretion.

  • 2: Says they "always keep things confidential" but describes no habits.
  • 4: Specific habits plus one near miss they caught, such as an invite with a revealing title or a reply-all to the wrong list.

Writing on the executive's behalf

Ask: use the drafting sample below.

  • 2: The content is right, but the draft is too long or too casual for the reader and needs real editing.
  • 4: Sendable with a word or two changed; the tone fits the recipient.

Project and event coordination

Ask: "Walk me through the last board meeting, offsite or complex trip you ran, starting from the day you got the request."

  • 2: Owned a part (booked the venue, built the deck) but not the whole, and cannot describe the timeline.
  • 4: Owned it end to end and can name the fallback they had ready and whether they used it.

Managing access and relationships

Ask: "Tell me about a time someone senior insisted on time your executive did not have."

  • 2: Gave the time anyway, or passed every case up to the executive.
  • 4: Offered an alternative (a delegate, a written update, a later slot) that the requester accepted.

Two work samples to use in the interview

Both are invented, the same for every candidate and short enough that nobody could mistake them for free work. The calendar and time-zone questions are already in executive assistant screening questions, so these test writing and event planning instead. Under 29 CFR 1630.14(a), an employer may ask an applicant "to describe or to demonstrate how, with or without reasonable accommodation, the applicant will be able to perform job-related functions" (checked November 2026). Tell candidates about the exercise in advance and how to ask for an adjustment; see ADA accommodations in interviews.

Drafting sample (15 minutes, in the interview). "Your executive, the CFO, cannot attend a vendor's quarterly business review next Tuesday and does not want to send a deputy. Write the decline to the vendor's regional vice president. Then write a three-line note to the CFO listing what needs a decision from them this week." Give three invented items for the note: a conference invitation with a Friday deadline, a request to move the monthly forecast review, and an expense report waiting for approval.

What to look for: a decline that is polite and specific and offers an alternative (a written update, a later date) without committing the CFO to anything; a note that leads with the decisions and deadlines rather than background; and a candidate who says what they would confirm with the CFO before sending. This scores writing and access, and gives a second data point on judgment.

Offsite planning conversation (15 minutes). "The CEO wants a two-day leadership offsite for 12 people in six weeks. A budget is approved and nothing is booked. What do you do in the first week, and what do you need from the CEO?"

What to listen for: questions before bookings (the purpose, must-attend people, dates that cannot move, attendees' accessibility or dietary needs); a timeline worked backward from the date; the decisions the CEO must make and by when; cancellation terms checked before signing; and a plan for travel disruption. This scores project coordination and judgment.

A filled example

A made-up candidate for an EA role supporting the CFO of a mid-size company, scored after a panel interview and both work samples:

Calendar and priority judgment — 4. Described a quarter-end week when audit committee preparation collided with an investor visit; moved two internal one-to-ones and a vendor call on their own, protected the CFO's preparation time, and sent one summary of the changes.

Judgment under delegated authority — 3. Clear limits ("I can decline anything internal under director level; anything external goes to the CFO first") and one solid example.

Discretion — 4. Described an acquisition that only four people knew about: meetings booked under a neutral code name and documents kept in a restricted folder, with no company names given in the interview.

Writing on the executive's behalf — 3. The decline was sendable after two small edits; the note to the CFO put the conference deadline first.

Project and event coordination — 2. Had helped with offsites but never owned one; the first-week plan booked a venue before asking the CEO about dates or attendees.

Managing access and relationships — 3. Redirected a sales leader's repeated requests to a fortnightly written update the CFO reviewed.

Weighted score: 3.25 ((4×25 + 3×20 + 4×15 + 3×15 + 2×15 + 3×10) ÷ 100). Recommendation: Yes, with event ownership probed in the final round through a reference who saw them run an event, since the role includes two board meetings a year.

Adjusting for seniority and setting

The anchors describe behavior, not years of experience. Change the scope of the questions and the weights, not the wording of the anchors.

SettingAdjustment
EA to a CEO, or a chief-of-staff hybridAdd a seventh row for running the leadership team's operating rhythm (agendas, action tracking, follow-up) and raise delegated authority to 25%.
Supporting several executivesRaise calendar judgment to 30% and add conflicts between principals to its anchors: a 3 has a rule for whose request wins and tells both people.
First EA role, or a step up from team administratorKeep the anchors and shrink the scope: a 3 can come from supporting a manager or a team rather than a C-level executive.
Remote or hybrid EAAdd evidence about shared calendars and document permissions to the discretion and coordination rows.
Private or family-office EARaise discretion to 25% and add personal logistics to project coordination. Expect NDAs and never ask for details.

Mistakes specific to scoring executive assistants

MistakeWhy it failsFix
Scoring polish or "presence"Rewards self-presentation, and drifts toward accent, age or appearance, none of which predicts calendar or writing skillScore only against the anchors; there is no presence row
Asking about children or child care to test availabilityThe EEOC lists child care arrangements and plans for children among inquiries that may be regarded as evidence of intent to discriminateState the hours and travel from the job description and ask every candidate whether they can meet them
Enjoying stories about a famous former bossConfidential detail shared to impress is the opposite of discretionScore it a 1 on discretion and note what was shared in neutral terms
Letting the executive's chemistry override the scoresOne impression outweighs five rows of evidenceThe executive scores the same rows after the working session
Counting software lists as skill"Advanced in all productivity tools" is not evidenceAsk for one task in the tool the role uses, and score it inside the relevant row
Scoring a certificationIt double-counts a pass/fail factCheck it with the issuer as a must-have, outside the weighted score

If the role does require a certification, check it with the issuer. IAAP's CAP handbook (updated June 2024, checked November 2026) says its Certification Directory is a searchable database of active and recently revoked Certified Administrative Professional designees, and that designees recertify every three years. Other issuers' routes are in how to verify a candidate's certifications.

Where this fits in the hiring process

The executive assistant phone screen covers the knockouts and a first read on calendar judgment and discretion. The panel and the two work samples above fill in the six rows, and a short working session with the executive gives them a chance to score the same rows themselves. The full loop for administrative and executive support roles, with an in-basket exercise and a decision rule, is in the interview guide for administrative roles. Keep the rows consistent with the must-haves in the executive assistant job description template, and reuse the scores to set the first quarter's focus in the 30-60-90 day plan for executive assistants.

If you interview with Interview Signal, the desktop app we make, these rows can become its scorecard areas: each area takes a weight of 1, 2 or 3 and rubric lines for what a 1–3, 5–6 and 9–10 answer looks like on its 1–10 scale, and every score carries the candidate's own quotes, checked word for word against the transcript, as described in how the scorecard with verified quotes works. Whatever tool you use, each interviewer should score before reading anyone else's ratings, then compare in an interview calibration session if the scores spread by two points or more.

Questions people ask

What should an executive assistant interview scorecard include?

Five or six competencies that are specific to supporting an executive: calendar and priority judgment, decisions made under delegated authority, discretion, writing on the executive's behalf, running events such as board meetings and offsites, and managing access to the executive. Each needs a weight and a written anchor for what a 1, 3 and 5 sound like, plus pass/fail lines for must-haves such as the schedule and any required certification.

Should the executive score the executive assistant candidate too?

Yes, on the same rows as everyone else, after a short working session in which the candidate does a realistic task with the executive. The executive's view of fit matters, but it should be written as evidence against the anchors, not as a separate vote of chemistry that overrides the scorecard.

How do you score an executive assistant who cannot share details because of an NDA?

Score the habits, not the secrets. Ask how they protected the information and what they would do in a situation you describe, and score the specificity of the method. A candidate who refuses to reveal confidential details is showing exactly the discretion the role needs; a candidate who shares them should score a 1 on discretion.

Does a CAP certification add points on an executive assistant scorecard?

No. If the job requires a certification such as IAAP's Certified Administrative Professional, check it as a pass/fail line through the issuer and keep it out of the weighted score. The scored rows measure what the candidate does with a calendar, a draft or an event, which a certification does not show on its own.