Templates

Interview scorecard for interns, with anchors for each competency

On this page
  1. Which competencies should an intern scorecard cover?
  2. The scorecard: weights and what a 1, 3 and 5 look like
  3. Copy-ready intern scorecard
  4. What should each interviewer ask, and what counts as evidence?
  5. Two exercises that produce scoreable evidence
  6. A filled example
  7. How do you adjust it for the program and the intern?
  8. Mistakes specific to scoring interns
  9. Where does this scorecard fit in the hiring process?
  10. Questions people ask

An interview scorecard for interns should score six lines: learning speed and response to feedback, the foundational skill for the internship's track, problem-solving approach, communication, follow-through and interest in the work. Weight learning and the track skill highest, score both from a short task done in two passes with feedback in between, and set the anchors so that a 3 means a solid intern, not an experienced professional. School name, GPA and graduation year are not scored, and evidence can come from class projects, part-time jobs, volunteering or caregiving as well as earlier internships.

The scale is the 1–5 interview rating scale and the layout follows the interview scorecard template. The internship loop itself (application questions, screen, structured interview, return offers) is in the interview guide for internships, and questions for candidates with little work history are in how to interview new graduates. This page gives the anchors, the two-pass task, a filled example and the scoring mistakes specific to interns.

Which competencies should an intern scorecard cover?

  • Learning speed and response to feedback. Applies feedback the second time and understands why it was given.
  • Foundational skill for the track. The one beginner skill the internship needs: writing for marketing, spreadsheets for finance or data, code for engineering, organizing information for operations or HR.
  • Problem-solving approach. Breaks an unfamiliar problem into steps, asks a clarifying question, states an assumption.
  • Communication. Explains their own work plainly and answers the question that was asked.
  • Follow-through. Finishes what they own without being chased and flags a problem early.
  • Interest in the work. A specific reason for this work, backed by something they have done about it.

Learning gets the most weight because an intern's value to you, and their case for a return offer, comes from how fast they improve over ten or twelve weeks. It is also the line most interviews never test, because they ask about learning instead of watching it happen. The task below makes it observable. Background on scoring potential from evidence rather than impressions is in how to interview for potential.

The scorecard: weights and what a 1, 3 and 5 look like

Example weights for a summer intern in a college program. Adjust for the track and lock them before applications open.

CompetencyWeight1 looks like3 looks like5 looks like
Learning speed and response to feedback25%Repeats the same mistake in the second pass, or dismisses the feedback without a reasonApplies the feedback in the second pass and can say what changed and whyApplies it, carries the same lesson to a part of the task the feedback did not mention, and asks a question that shows they understood the reason
Foundational skill for the track25%Task incomplete or wrong in the basics (formulas broken, code does not run, copy ignores the brief)Usable beginner work with minor errors; can explain the approachClean, correct work with a checking step they chose themselves; explains a trade-off they made
Problem-solving approach15%Stalls or guesses; asks nothingBreaks the problem into steps, asks one good clarifying question, states an assumption and works with itTests the assumption, spots an edge case or a better route, and says what they would do with more time
Communication15%Hard to follow; cannot explain their own workExplains their work in plain language and in order; answers the question askedAdjusts the explanation to the listener; writes a short, clear message about the task
Follow-through10%No example of finishing something without being chasedOne specific example (school, a job, a team, caregiving, volunteering) of owning a task to completion through a setbackSeveral examples, a system they use to keep track, and a time they warned someone early that a deadline was at risk
Interest in the work10%"Any internship is fine"; knows nothing about the workA specific reason tied to this work or track, backed by a class, project or readingHas pursued it on their own (a project, a club role, a portfolio) and asks informed questions about the work

A 2 shows part of the 3 behavior, or only with prompting; a 4 shows the 3 behavior and part of the 5. Mark a line "not assessed" if it never came up. Communication is scored on clarity, never on accent or how polished the candidate sounds.

Copy-ready intern scorecard

Candidate: [name]               Track: [marketing / finance / data / engineering / operations / HR]   Program: [summer / co-op]
Interviewer: [name]             Stage: [screen / structured interview / two-pass task / mentor conversation]

Competency                                 Weight  Score (1-5 or N/A)  Evidence (what they said or did)
Learning speed and response to feedback     25%    [ ]                 [what changed between pass one and pass two]
Foundational skill for the track            25%    [ ]                 [task result, errors, their explanation]
Problem-solving approach                    15%    [ ]                 [questions asked, assumption stated]
Communication                               15%    [ ]                 [explanation of the task, written note]
Follow-through                              10%    [ ]                 [example from school, work, team, caregiving]
Interest in the work                        10%    [ ]                 [reason given, what they did about it]

Requirements (pass/fail, not scored): [program eligibility as written]  [available for the program dates]
[work authorization confirmed with the lawful question; Form I-9 at hire for paid interns]
Weighted score: [ ]     Open questions: [ ]     Recommendation: [Strong yes / Yes / No / Strong no]

What should each interviewer ask, and what counts as evidence?

Learning speed and response to feedback

Score it from the two-pass task below: the evidence is the difference between the first and second pass and what the candidate says about it. Add one question: "Tell me about feedback you got on a project or a job that you disagreed with at first. What did you do?" More in interview questions for learning agility and how to interview for coachability.

Foundational skill for the track

Score the task output against the anchors, with every candidate given the same materials, time and tools. A short task is a work sample, so keep it to work an intern would really do; see what a work sample test is.

Problem-solving approach

Watch the first five minutes of the task and ask: "Walk me through how you started." Evidence is whether they asked a question, stated an assumption or made a plan before diving in.

Communication

Ask the candidate to explain the task result in two minutes, then to write a three-line message to a manager about it. Score both.

Follow-through

Ask: "Tell me about something you were responsible for finishing, at school, at work, in a club or at home, where something went wrong partway through." Any setting counts; score what they did.

Interest in the work

Ask: "Why this track, and what have you done about that interest so far?" A class, a personal project or reading all count; a generic answer is a 1 or 2.

Two exercises that produce scoreable evidence

The two-pass task (60 minutes). Pass one, 25 minutes; feedback, 5 minutes; pass two, 20 minutes; discussion, 10 minutes. Write one task per track and one feedback script per task, with the same two specific points for every candidate. Examples, to adapt:

  • Marketing: rewrite a 150-word product description for a stated audience; feedback on the opening line and on one unsupported claim.
  • Finance or data: a 30-row spreadsheet with three planted errors; clean it and state one finding; feedback on one missed error and on how the finding is worded.
  • Engineering: a 30-line function with a bug and no test; fix it and add a test; feedback on one edge case and on naming.
  • Operations or HR: turn a messy email thread into a one-page summary with next steps; feedback on order and on one missing owner.

What to listen for: whether pass two fixes both points, whether the candidate carries the lesson to parts the feedback did not mention, and whether they can explain why the change matters. Offer accommodations on request, such as extra time; the ADA regulations include changes to the application process in reasonable accommodation (29 CFR 1630.2(o)(1)(i)).

The stuck-in-week-two question (10 minutes). "It is your second week. Your manager gave you a task due Friday and is traveling. On Wednesday you realize you do not understand what the finished product should look like. What do you do?"

What to listen for: checking the materials first, asking a teammate, sending the manager a short message with a specific question and a proposed assumption, and carrying on with the parts they can do, rather than waiting silently until Friday or guessing without saying so. Score problem-solving, communication and follow-through from the same answer, on separate lines.

A filled example

A made-up candidate for a summer data analytics internship:

Learning speed and response to feedback: 5 (25%). After feedback on a missed duplicate row, added a duplicate check to the whole sheet and reworded the finding with the number first; asked why the team prefers that order.

Foundational skill for the track: 3 (25%). Found two of the three planted errors in pass one; formulas correct; explained the approach clearly.

Problem-solving approach: 3 (15%). Asked whether blank cells meant zero or missing, stated the assumption and moved on.

Communication: 4 (15%). Clear two-minute explanation; the three-line message led with the finding.

Follow-through: 3 (10%). Example of finishing a group project after a teammate dropped out, with a new plan agreed with the instructor.

Interest in the work: 4 (10%). Built a small analysis of their campus club's attendance data on their own and asked how the team chooses which questions to analyze.

Weighted score: 3.75 of 5. (0.25 x 5 + 0.25 x 3 + 0.15 x 3 + 0.15 x 4 + 0.1 x 3 + 0.1 x 4.) Recommendation: Strong yes for the track; the mentor confirms in the final conversation.

How do you adjust it for the program and the intern?

Program or internWhat changes
High school internLower the track skill to 15% and shorten the task; score learning and follow-through higher. Minors bring work permit and hours rules; see hiring minors and work permits.
College summer internThe weights above.
Co-op (a full-time semester)Track skill and follow-through higher (30% and 15%), because the work runs longer and with less supervision.
Graduate or MBA internScale the anchors toward entry-level professional work; replace the task with a short case and add a line for structuring an ambiguous problem.
Unpaid internshipThe scorecard is the same, but check the program first: the Labor Department's Fact Sheet #71 (updated January 2018) describes the "primary beneficiary test" courts use to decide whether an intern is an employee (DOL Fact Sheet #71, as of November 2026). See unpaid internship rules for employers.
Return offer reviewSame lines, scored from the internship's work, the mentor's notes and how the intern used feedback; see the return-offer rule in the internship guide.

Mistakes specific to scoring interns

MistakeWhy it failsFix
Scoring school name, GPA or brand-name earlier internshipsNone is observable in the interview, and they favor candidates with more access, not more abilityScore the task and the examples; keep any eligibility rule pass or fail
Experienced-hire anchorsEvery student scores 1 or 2 and the scorecard stops separating candidatesWrite the 3 as "a solid intern" and calibrate on two practice candidates
Scoring confidence as competencePolish tracks coaching and background more than skillScore the change between passes and the explanation, not the delivery
Asking graduation year or advertising for "recent graduates"The EEOC's ADEA rule lists "college student" and "recent college graduate" among ad terms that violate the Act unless a statutory exception applies (29 CFR 1625.4(a))Ask whether they meet the program's stated requirements by the start date; have counsel review eligibility wording
Asking about citizenship or visa typeAsking more than the lawful work authorization question risks citizenship discriminationUse the wording in work authorization questions in interviews

Where does this scorecard fit in the hiring process?

Applications and a short screen narrow the pool; finalists do the structured interview and the two-pass task, scored on this sheet by the hiring manager and the intern's future mentor, each before the debrief. Virtual rounds need the same identity checks at the same stage for every candidate; see candidate fraud in campus recruiting. Paid interns complete Form I-9 like any employee; see Form I-9 for interns and volunteers. At the end of the program, the same scorecard drives the return offer.

If you hold the structured interview on a video call with Interview Signal, our desktop app, you can enter these competencies as the role's scorecard areas: it scores each area from 1 to 10 during the call with the candidate's own quotes as evidence, deletes any quote not found word for word in the transcript, and caps an area with no surviving quote at 5, marked "Probe further" (see how the verified-quote scorecard works). The two-pass task is still scored by the person who reviews the work.

Questions people ask

What should an intern interview scorecard measure?

Score learning speed and response to feedback, the foundational skill for the internship's track, problem-solving approach, communication, follow-through and interest in the work. Weight learning and the track skill highest, score both from a short task done in two passes with feedback in between, and calibrate the anchors so that a 3 means a solid intern rather than an experienced professional.

How do you score an intern candidate with no work experience?

Accept evidence from anywhere: class projects, part-time jobs, volunteering, caregiving, sports teams, clubs or military service. Ask for one specific example per competency and score what the candidate did, and use a short work task so that every candidate can show the skill in the room whatever their background.

Should GPA or school name be on an intern scorecard?

No. Neither is a competency you can observe in the interview, and both crowd out the evidence from the task and the answers. If your program has an eligibility rule, such as being enrolled in a degree program, check it once as a pass or fail requirement and keep it off the scored lines.

Can the same scorecard be used for intern return offers?

Yes, and it should be. Score the intern at the end of the program on the same lines, using evidence from their actual work, the mentor's notes and the feedback they received, so the return offer decision rests on the same competencies you hired for rather than on a final presentation or general impression.