Interview scorecard for line cooks, with anchors for each competency
On this page
- Which competencies should a line cook scorecard cover?
- The scorecard: weights and what a 1, 3 and 5 look like
- Copy-ready line cook scorecard
- What should the chef watch for, and ask?
- Which work samples produce scoreable evidence?
- A filled example
- How do you adjust it for the kitchen and the level?
- Mistakes specific to scoring line cooks
- Where does this scorecard fit in the hiring process?
- Questions people ask
A line cook interview scorecard should score six lines separately: cooking and plating to the spec card, food safety and allergen handling, managing tickets in a push, mise en place and knife work, communication on the line, and taking correction and keeping the station clean. Weight station execution, food safety and the push highest, and score most lines from a short paid trial on the actual station, because what a cook says in an interview and what they do with twelve tickets on the rail are different evidence. A food handler card, where the law requires one, is a pass or fail check, not a score.
The scale is the 1–5 interview rating scale and the layout follows the interview scorecard template. The phone screen knockouts and the food safety answer key are in line cook screening questions; this scorecard is for the chef or sous chef who runs the trial and the short sit-down interview.
Which competencies should a line cook scorecard cover?
- Station execution and plating to spec. Cooks each dish to the spec card's doneness, portion and plate, the same way the tenth time as the first.
- Food safety and allergen handling. Temperatures checked, no bare hands on ready-to-eat food, glove and hand-washing habits, and a clean setup for an allergy ticket.
- Ticket management in a push. Reads the rail, fires in the right order so a table's plates come up together, and says early when something is running out.
- Mise en place, knife work and organization. Sets the station to par in a consistent order, with clean, even cuts and labeled, dated containers.
- Communication and teamwork on the line. Calls back tickets, says "behind," "hot" and "sharp," and helps the next station without being asked.
- Coachability, cleanliness and closing. Takes a correction once and applies it, keeps the station clean during service, and breaks it down properly.
The food safety line uses the numbers in the FDA Food Code 2026 (as of November 2026): hot holding at 135°F or above and cold holding at 41°F or below (§ 3-501.16), poultry cooked to 165°F (§ 3-401.11), and no bare-hand contact with ready-to-eat food, using utensils, deli tissue or single-use gloves instead (§ 3-301.11). Its definition of a major food allergen (§ 1-201.10(B)) covers milk, eggs, fish (including crustacean shellfish), tree nuts, wheat, peanuts, soybeans and sesame. Your state or county may enforce an earlier edition, so write your local numbers into the anchors.
Score only the physical tasks the job description lists as essential (standing through service, lifting stock pots, working near heat). You may ask every applicant whether they can perform those job-related functions, with or without reasonable accommodation, but not about disabilities or medical history (42 U.S.C. 12112(d)(2)).
The scorecard: weights and what a 1, 3 and 5 look like
Example weights for a sauté or grill cook in a full-service restaurant. Adjust them for the station and lock them before the first trial.
| Competency | Weight | 1 looks like | 3 looks like | 5 looks like |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Station execution and plating to spec | 25% | Ignores the spec card; doneness and portions vary plate to plate | Every plate matches the card on doneness, portion and placement; asks when unsure | Consistent under pressure and catches a plate that is off before it reaches the pass |
| Food safety and allergen handling | 20% | Guesses doneness, touches ready-to-eat food bare-handed, or ignores the allergy flag | Probes proteins, checks the cold well, changes gloves and washes after raw meat, clean pan and tools for the allergy ticket | Spots a problem nobody asked about (a warm lowboy, a mislabeled container) and tells the chef at once |
| Ticket management in a push | 20% | Cooks tickets one at a time in arrival order; tables come up split | Groups and fires by table timing, calls out a low item before running out, keeps the rail moving | Stays ahead in the push and helps expo recover a refire without slowing the other tickets |
| Mise en place, knife work and organization | 15% | Sets up from memory, misses items, uneven cuts, unlabeled containers | Sets to par in a consistent order, even cuts at a steady pace, labels and dates everything | Station reset during service without being told; prep notes for the next shift |
| Communication and teamwork on the line | 10% | Silent; no call-backs; no "behind" or "hot" in a tight line | Calls back every ticket, uses line calls, asks for help early | Notices a neighboring station going down and helps without leaving their own tickets |
| Coachability, cleanliness and closing | 10% | Argues with a correction during service; station messy | Applies a correction the first time, wipes and sanitizes as they go | Asks for feedback after the trial and shows they used it before the end |
A 2 shows part of the 3 behavior, or only after a reminder; a 4 shows the 3 behavior and part of the 5. Mark a line "not assessed" if the trial did not test it. Score communication on whether the line could understand and act on it, never on accent or which language the cook learned the calls in.
Copy-ready line cook scorecard
Candidate: [name] Station: [saute / grill / fry / garde manger / flat-top]
Scored by: [chef or sous] Stage: [trial (paid, length) / sit-down interview]
Competency Weight Score (1-5 or N/A) Evidence (what you watched or heard)
Station execution and plating to spec 25% [ ] [plates vs spec card; consistency on repeats]
Food safety and allergen handling 20% [ ] [probe used? cold well checked? allergy setup?]
Ticket management in a push 20% [ ] [firing order; tables together; called low items]
Mise en place, knife work, organization 15% [ ] [setup order; cuts; labels and dates]
Communication and teamwork on the line 10% [ ] [call-backs; line calls; asked for help]
Coachability, cleanliness and closing 10% [ ] [correction applied? clean as they go?]
Requirements (pass/fail, not scored): [food handler card or training if required locally, verified]
[can work the scheduled shifts, including close]
Stop rule: [serious food safety or allergen slip ends the trial; note it]
Weighted score: [ ] Open questions: [ ] Recommendation: [Strong yes / Yes / No / Strong no]
What should the chef watch for, and ask?
Station execution and plating to spec
Give the spec cards for three dishes from the station and ask for each twice, at different points in the trial. Score the second plate against the first. Ask afterward: "Which of those would you change if you had more time, and why?" A cook who can say what was off is easier to coach than one who cannot see it.
Food safety and allergen handling
Plant one problem: a cold well thermometer that reads above 41°F, or a garnish container with no date. A 3 notices or checks without prompting and tells the chef. In the sit-down, ask: "A server tells you table 12 has a sesame allergy and the dish has a sesame garnish. Walk me through it." Listen for a clean pan, clean tools, washed hands and fresh gloves, no garnish, and a call to the expo so the plate is flagged.
Ticket management in a push
Use the push scenario below, either live in the trial or talked through. Score the order and the calls, not only how fast the plates came.
Mise en place, knife work and organization
Start the trial with setup from the station's par sheet and one knife task (for example, dice two onions and mince shallots for service). Score order, consistency and labeling; speed matters only once the cuts are even.
Communication and teamwork on the line
Listen through the whole trial. A cook who calls back each ticket and says "behind" without being told is showing the habit. See interview questions for composure under pressure for sit-down probes.
Coachability, cleanliness and closing
Give one correction early ("tighter sear on the scallops, less oil"). Score whether it shows on the next order. End the trial with station breakdown: wrap, label, date, sanitize.
Which work samples produce scoreable evidence?
The station trial (paid, 60–90 minutes). Setup to par, one knife task, then three dishes from the spec cards, each cooked twice, during real or simulated service. Include one allergy-flagged ticket and one planted food safety problem. Give every candidate for the station the same dishes, the same time and the same planted problem. Set it up with how to run a job trial day, and see what is a working interview for when the time must be paid.
What to watch: spec adherence on the repeat plates, probing, glove and hand-washing habits, the allergy setup, labels and dates, and whether the station looks the same at the end as at the start.
The push (5 minutes, talked through or live). "It is 7:45 on a Saturday. You have twelve tickets on the rail, two of them for a six-top that has to come up together. You just ran out of prepped mushrooms for the risotto, and expo calls a refire on a strip steak sent back as overcooked. What do you do?"
What to listen for: telling the sous or expo about the mushrooms right away (not after the next risotto order fires); refiring the steak to the right temperature at once; timing the six-top so the plates come up together; and keeping the other tickets moving. A cook who goes quiet and works faster scores 2 at most.
A filled example
A made-up candidate for the sauté station at a 120-seat restaurant, scored on a 75-minute paid trial:
Station execution and plating to spec: 4 (25%). All six plates matched the cards; caught an under-reduced sauce on the second pasta and fixed it before plating.
Food safety and allergen handling: 3 (20%). Probed the chicken, changed gloves after raw shrimp, set up a clean pan for the allergy ticket; did not notice the cold well at 46°F until asked.
Ticket management in a push: 3 (20%). Called the mushrooms out immediately and refired the steak first; the six-top came up one plate short by a minute.
Mise en place, knife work and organization: 4 (15%). Set up from the par sheet in a clear order; even dice; labeled and dated without a reminder.
Communication and teamwork on the line: 3 (10%). Called back every ticket and used line calls; did not ask for help when the push peaked.
Coachability, cleanliness and closing: 2 (10%). Took the sear correction but the next scallops were the same; left the station unwiped during the push.
Weighted score: 3.3 of 5. (0.25 x 4 + 0.2 x 3 + 0.2 x 3 + 0.15 x 4 + 0.1 x 3 + 0.1 x 2.) Recommendation: Yes, with temperature checks and clean-as-you-go as goals for the first two weeks.
How do you adjust it for the kitchen and the level?
| Kitchen or level | What changes |
|---|---|
| High-volume or chain kitchen | Weight spec adherence and the push higher; score ticket times against the kitchen's own standard, not a guess. |
| Scratch or fine dining | Add a tasting and seasoning line (the chef tastes each sauce); raise technique within station execution. |
| Breakfast and brunch | Rewrite the trial around eggs to order, a flat-top full of tickets and holding times. |
| Fry or garde manger station | Fry: oil care and holding; garde manger: ready-to-eat handling and plating speed. Weight food safety higher for cold stations. |
| Prep cook moving to the line | Use the prep evidence they already have (see prep cook screening questions) and scale the push. |
| Lead line cook | Add a line for running the line and training others; compare sous chef screening questions. |
Mistakes specific to scoring line cooks
| Mistake | Why it fails | Fix |
|---|---|---|
| A trial with no spec cards | Scores the cook's own style, not your menu | Hand over the cards and score against them |
| Scoring speed alone | Fast plates off spec or undercooked cost more than slow ones | Score speed only alongside spec and safety |
| Averaging away a serious food safety slip | One allergen mistake can hurt a guest | Use a stop rule and record why |
| Different trials for different candidates | The busiest night makes anyone look worse | Same dishes, time and planted problem for each candidate |
| Asking about health, injuries or illness before an offer | Disability-related questions are not job evidence | Ask about the essential functions; the illness reporting policy comes after hire |
Where does this scorecard fit in the hiring process?
Write the rows from the must-haves in the line cook job description template, screen with the knockouts, and check any required card with the program that issued it (see how to verify a food handler card). Then run the paid trial and a short sit-down with this scorecard, the chef and sous scoring separately before they talk. The wider loop for kitchens and front of house is in the interview guide for hospitality roles.
If you hold the sit-down part on a video call with Interview Signal, our desktop app, you can enter these competencies as the role's scorecard areas: it scores each area from 1 to 10 during the call with the candidate's own quotes as evidence, deletes any quote not found word for word in the transcript, and caps an area with no surviving quote at 5, marked "Probe further" (see how the verified-quote scorecard works). The trial itself is scored by the chef watching it.
Questions people ask
What should a line cook interview scorecard include?
Score six lines: cooking and plating to the spec card, food safety and allergen handling, managing tickets in a push, mise en place and knife work, communication on the line, and taking correction and keeping the station clean. Weight station execution, food safety and the push highest, and score most of it from a short paid trial on the station you are hiring for.
How do you score food safety in a line cook trial shift?
Watch for habits, not answers: probing proteins instead of guessing, checking the cold well temperature, using tongs or gloves on ready-to-eat food, changing gloves and washing hands after raw meat, and setting up a clean pan and board for an allergy ticket. Treat a serious slip, such as plating a sesame garnish on a sesame-allergy ticket, as a stop for the trial rather than a low score to average out.
Should a line cook trial shift be paid?
Treat it as paid work. A candidate cooking food that your kitchen serves is generally doing work, so pay at least the applicable minimum wage for the hours, keep it short and tell the candidate in advance what they will do. Federal and state rules differ in the details, so check them before you schedule trials.
Does a food handler card count toward a line cook's score?
No. Where your state or city requires a food handler card or training, it is a pass or fail requirement with its own deadline, verified with the program that issued it. The scorecard measures how the cook works on the station, which a card does not show.