What is a working interview? The paid trial shift, and when employers must pay for it
On this page
- What happens in a working interview?
- Do employers have to pay for a working interview?
- What does California say about unpaid "try out time"?
- How is a working interview different from a trial day, a work sample and similar steps?
- What are some examples of working interviews?
- What paperwork comes with a paid working interview?
- What should staffing agencies know about working interviews?
- A copy-ready working interview pay check
- Questions people ask
A working interview is a hiring step in which a candidate spends a few hours or a shift doing the actual job at the workplace, such as assisting on patients, cooking during service or cutting hair, before the employer makes an offer; it is also called a paid trial shift, a job tryout or a trial day. Whether the employer must pay depends on what the candidate does, not on the label: under the federal Fair Labor Standards Act, "employ" includes "to suffer or permit to work," and productive work done for a for-profit business is generally paid work time. As of November 2026, the Labor Department's own enforcement record includes a 2018 case against a Nashville dental practice that required unpaid working interviews, and California's labor commissioner accepts unpaid "try out time" only when it tests skills, produces nothing for the business and lasts a reasonable time.
Not legal advice. This page summarizes the federal statute, regulations and Labor Department pages, and California's published enforcement policy, linked below, as checked in November 2026. Other states and cities have their own wage laws; whether a particular trial counts as work depends on the facts. Confirm with counsel or your payroll provider before running one.
What happens in a working interview?
The candidate comes to the workplace and does real tasks alongside the team, usually as the last step after the structured interviews. The term shows up most in hands-on, small-team settings: dental and veterinary practices, restaurants and bars, salons, retail, the trades and light industrial work. What sets it apart from an interview question or a test is that the candidate works on the business's real customers, patients, products or systems, and a manager watches how they do it.
That is also what makes it a wage question. A typing test on a practice document shows a skill; an afternoon assisting the hygienist on booked patients is work the practice would otherwise pay someone to do. How to plan, schedule and score the day is on how to run a job trial day; this page covers what the term means and where the legal line sits.
Do employers have to pay for a working interview?
Under federal law, usually yes, whenever the candidate does productive work. Four sources set the line:
- The definition of employ. The FLSA says "'Employ' includes to suffer or permit to work" (29 U.S.C. 203(g)). The Labor Department's Fact Sheet #22 on hours worked adds: "Work not requested but suffered or permitted to be performed is work time that must be paid for by the employer," and the regulation repeats that "the reason is immaterial" (29 CFR 785.11).
- No volunteering for a business. The department's FLSA Advisor page on volunteers states: "Under the FLSA, employees may not volunteer services to for-profit private sector employers." A candidate's agreement to work for free does not change that.
- The narrow trainee exception. The FLSA Advisor page on trainees lists six criteria that must all apply for trainees not to be employees, among them that "the trainees or students do not displace regular employees, but work under close supervision" and that the employer "receives no immediate advantage from the activities of the trainees or students." A working interview built to see whether someone can do your real work for your real customers rarely meets all six.
- Enforcement. In a December 14, 2018 news release, the Wage and Hour Division said Smiley Dental Associates Inc. of Nashville violated the federal minimum wage requirements "by requiring candidates for hire to perform a 'working interview' to conclude their application but failed to pay the individuals for those hours worked." The U.S. District Court for the Middle District of Tennessee ordered the practice to pay $50,000 in back wages and liquidated damages to 10 employees, covering that and other violations.
The floor is the minimum wage for each hour: the federal rate is "$7.25 per hour effective July 24, 2009" (Labor Department), and many states and cities set a higher one (state minimum wage laws). Unpaid internships follow a separate test, the primary beneficiary test in Fact Sheet #71, which is built around educational programs and does not fit a job applicant; see unpaid internship rules for employers.
What does California say about unpaid "try out time"?
California is one state that has written the line down. Its Division of Labor Standards Enforcement holds that "all pre-employment training time is compensable," and it will accept "try out time" as non-compensable only if all three conditions are met (DLSE opinion letter, November 29, 1993, repeated in the DLSE Enforcement Policies and Interpretations Manual, section 46, revised August 2019):
- the time "is not, in fact, training as opposed to testing skills";
- "there is no productivity derived from the work performed by the prospective employee"; and
- "the period of time is reasonable under the circumstances."
The manual adds that "each case must be reviewed on its facts": testing a sewing machine operator takes much less time than testing a computer programmer, and the rate of pay for the occupation "can usually be used as a guide" to how long a try-out may reasonably run. In the 1993 letter, 16 to 18 hours of required, unpaid pre-hire training failed the test. Other states have their own minimum wage and hours-worked rules; check the labor department where the trial takes place.
How is a working interview different from a trial day, a work sample and similar steps?
| Step | What the candidate does | Paid? | Read more |
|---|---|---|---|
| Working interview (paid trial shift, job tryout) | Real tasks on the real business, usually for hours or a shift, before any offer | Generally yes, when the work is productive | This page |
| Job trial day | The same thing, planned as the final step with set tasks and a scoring sheet | Plan it as paid | How to run a job trial day |
| Work sample test | A defined task taken from the job, often on practice material, scored against a rubric | Short tests on practice material are usually unpaid; longer tasks are often paid | What is a work sample test |
| Skills demonstration | A brief test such as typing or running a machine, producing nothing the business keeps | Can be unpaid if it meets tests like California's three conditions | DLSE 1993 letter |
| Realistic job preview | Watches or hears what the job is really like; does no work | No work, so no wage question | What is a realistic job preview |
| Unpaid internship | A learning program judged by the primary beneficiary test | Only if the intern is the primary beneficiary | Unpaid internship rules |
| Probationary period | Works as a hired employee during an early review window | Yes, it is employment | What is a probationary period |
What are some examples of working interviews?
These examples are illustrations, not rulings; the facts of a real trial decide the answer.
- Example: a dental assistant candidate spends four hours assisting chairside on scheduled patients. The practice gets the benefit of the work, so treat the time as paid work, with the patients' consent and a licensed supervisor where the state requires one.
- Example: a line cook candidate runs the grill station through a lunch service. The food is sold, so the time is productive work.
- Example: an office candidate takes a 15-minute typing test on a practice letter that is thrown away afterward. Nothing is kept or used, which is the kind of skills test California's policy treats as unpaid try-out time.
- Example: a software candidate is asked to fix a real bug in the product "as a test" over a weekend. The business could ship the fix, so it looks like productive work; a scoped exercise on practice code is the safer design (see how to evaluate a take-home assignment).
What paperwork comes with a paid working interview?
Paying the candidate makes them an employee for the day, so the normal hiring paperwork follows. Form I-9 is required, and when the job lasts less than three business days both sections are due no later than the first day of work, with no receipts allowed (Form I-9 for jobs under three days). Run the pay through payroll with the usual withholding, check your state's new hire reporting rule, and ask your insurer whether workers' compensation covers the trial. Paying the candidate as a contractor to avoid payroll creates a misclassification risk; see what is a 1099 contractor.
The rest of the hiring rules apply on the shop floor too. Anything you could not ask in an interview stays off limits during the shift (illegal interview questions), and a candidate who needs an adjustment to take part is entitled to ask for one (ADA accommodations in interviews).
What should staffing agencies know about working interviews?
When an agency introduces the candidate, a client that wants a trial shift is asking for work, and someone has to be the employer for those hours. Usually the cleanest route is for the agency to place the candidate on its own payroll for the trial, the same way it employs any temporary worker (see what is a staffing agency and Form I-9 for staffing agencies). Check the client agreement first: a direct trial arranged by the client can trigger the conversion or placement terms (temp-to-perm conversion fees). Never tell a candidate that an unpaid trial is "normal for this client"; the wage rule does not change because an agency is involved.
A copy-ready working interview pay check
WORKING INTERVIEW PAY CHECK (example; complete before inviting anyone)
Role: ________________ Location (state/city): ________________
Planned tasks: _________________________________________________
Length: ____ hours Date: __/__/____
1. Will the candidate work on real customers, patients,
products, code or records? [ ] no [ ] yes -> pay
2. Will the business keep, sell, bill or use
anything the candidate produces? [ ] no [ ] yes -> pay
3. Is any part of it training in our own methods
rather than testing a skill they already have? [ ] no [ ] yes -> pay
4. Is the length reasonable for the skill tested? [ ] yes [ ] no -> pay or shorten
5. If paid: rate $____/hour (at least the higher of federal,
state and local minimum wage), through payroll [ ] set up
6. Form I-9 both sections by day one (job under 3 days),
new hire reporting, insurer check [ ] done
7. Agency candidate? Agency is employer for the trial,
client agreement checked [ ] yes [ ] n/a
Approved by: __________ Date: __/__/____
The check is an example to adapt with your counsel or payroll provider. If any answer in lines 1 to 4 points to pay, pay for the whole trial, and offer every finalist for the role the same arrangement.
Questions people ask
Do you get paid for a working interview?
Usually, yes, when the candidate does productive work. Under the Fair Labor Standards Act, 'employ' includes 'to suffer or permit to work', and the Labor Department says work suffered or permitted is work time the employer must pay for. In 2018 the department recovered back wages from a Nashville dental practice that required unpaid working interviews. A short skills demonstration that produces nothing the business uses is treated differently.
Can a candidate volunteer for an unpaid trial shift?
Not at a for-profit business. The Labor Department's FLSA Advisor states that under the FLSA, employees may not volunteer services to for-profit private sector employers. Volunteering is recognized for public service, religious or humanitarian work for nonprofits and public agencies, not for doing a company's regular work as part of a job application.
Is a typing test or a short skills test a working interview?
Not in the legal sense. California's Division of Labor Standards Enforcement, for example, accepts unpaid 'try out time' for skills such as typing or operating machinery only if it tests skills rather than training the applicant, the employer gets no productivity from it, and the time is reasonable. A short test on a practice task usually meets that; serving real customers or patients usually does not.
Does a paid working interview need a Form I-9?
Yes. A paid working interview is employment, and Form I-9 is required for every person hired for wages, however short the job. When the job lasts less than three business days, both Section 1 and Section 2 are due no later than the first day of work, and receipts are not accepted.
How much do you have to pay for a working interview?
At least the minimum wage that applies for every hour worked: the federal minimum is $7.25 per hour, and many states and cities set a higher rate. Many employers pay the rate the job would pay, through normal payroll, which also covers the tax and paperwork duties that come with paying someone.