For hiring managers

What is a 1099 contractor? How it differs from a W-2 employee when you hire

On this page
  1. What makes someone a 1099 contractor rather than an employee?
  2. How does a 1099 contractor differ from a W-2 employee at each hiring step?
  3. What are the 1099 rules for 2026?
  4. Why do 1099 contractors charge more per hour?
  5. When does a 1099 arrangement fit, and when is it risky?
  6. What changes for staffing agencies and contingent programs?
  7. A copy-ready 1099 engagement checklist
  8. Which 1099 mistakes cost the most?
  9. Questions people ask

A 1099 contractor is a self-employed independent contractor whom a business pays without withholding income tax or paying payroll taxes, and who receives a Form 1099-NEC instead of a Form W-2. For payments made in 2026, the business must issue the form once it pays the contractor $2,000 or more in the year (the threshold was $600 before 2026). The name comes from the tax form, but the classification comes from the facts: under the IRS general rule, a worker is an independent contractor only if the business controls just the result of the work, not what is done and how it is done. A W-2 employee, by contrast, is on payroll with withholding, overtime rules and Form I-9 (all as of November 2026).

Not legal or tax advice. This page summarizes IRS, Labor Department, USCIS and state sources linked below, as published in November 2026. Classification depends on the facts of each engagement and on which law is asking. Confirm a specific arrangement with an employment or tax adviser.

What makes someone a 1099 contractor rather than an employee?

The tax form does not decide it. Three different tests can apply to the same worker, and a worker can pass one and fail another:

  • The IRS common-law test (federal income and payroll tax). The IRS states the general rule as control: an individual is an independent contractor if the business "has the right to control or direct only the result of the work" and not what will be done and how. The evidence falls into behavioral control, financial control and the relationship of the parties (IRS Topic no. 762). Either side can ask the IRS to decide with Form SS-8.
  • The Labor Department's economic reality test (federal minimum wage and overtime). The question is whether the worker is economically dependent on the business or in business for themselves. As of November 2026 the standard is in transition: the January 2024 rule is still in the regulations and is still used in private lawsuits, but under Field Assistance Bulletin 2025-1 (May 1, 2025) the Wage and Hour Division enforces using Fact Sheet #13. A replacement rule was proposed on February 27, 2026 (91 FR 9932); comments closed April 28, 2026, and no final rule had been published in the Federal Register as of November 2026.
  • State tests (state wage law, unemployment insurance, workers' compensation). Several states presume employment unless all three parts of an ABC test are met. Massachusetts, for example, treats a worker as an employee unless the worker is free from control, the service is "performed outside the usual course of the business of the employer," and the worker is customarily engaged in an independent business of the same kind (M.G.L. c. 149, s. 148B). California's version is Labor Code 2775.

How these tests play out for agencies, and what misclassification costs, is covered in worker misclassification for staffing agencies. This page stays with the definition and what it changes when you hire.

How does a 1099 contractor differ from a W-2 employee at each hiring step?

StepW-2 employee1099 contractor
What you publishA job posting with a pay range where the law requires oneA scope of work or request for proposals: the deliverable, timeline and budget
InterviewSkills, behaviors and fit for a role you will directTheir business, past deliverables, method and capacity; see how to interview a freelancer
AgreementOffer letter; usually at-will (see what is at-will employment)A services contract with scope, fee, term and termination terms
Tax form collectedForm W-4Form W-9 with the contractor's taxpayer identification number
Form I-9RequiredNot required for a genuine independent contractor (M-274, 2.0); see I-9 for independent contractors
State new hire reportRequired in every stateOnly in states that require contractor reports; see new hire reporting for independent contractors
Background checkFCRA steps when a screening company runs itTreat it the same way; see background checks for independent contractors
Withholding and payroll taxesEmployer withholds income tax and pays 7.65% Social Security and Medicare on top (Social Security up to the wage base)None; the contractor pays self-employment tax and estimated tax
Minimum wage and overtimeApply unless the job is exempt; see exempt vs non-exemptDo not apply to a genuine contractor
Unemployment and workers' compEmployer pays or carries themNot covered by yours; ask for the contractor's own insurance where it matters
Year-end formForm W-2Form 1099-NEC by January 31 if paid $2,000 or more in 2026

What are the 1099 rules for 2026?

  • Threshold. The IRS says that for payments made in 2026, the Form 1099-NEC reporting threshold is $2,000; for payments made before 2026 it was $600 (IRS, "Am I required to file a Form 1099", reviewed July 2026). The instructions for Forms 1099-MISC and 1099-NEC say the amount may be adjusted for inflation for later years.
  • Deadline. Furnish the form to the contractor and file it with the IRS by January 31.
  • Corporations. Payments to an incorporated business are generally not reported, except payments for legal services (and medical payments on Form 1099-MISC), per the same IRS page and instructions. A sole proprietor or a partnership still gets a form.
  • Backup withholding. If the contractor does not provide a correct taxpayer identification number, the payer must withhold at 24% (IRS, backup withholding). Collect the W-9 before the first payment.

Why do 1099 contractors charge more per hour?

Because they pay costs an employer would otherwise carry. A contractor's net earnings are subject to self-employment tax of 15.3% (12.4% Social Security on the first $184,500 of combined earnings in 2026, plus 2.9% Medicare), both halves of what an employer and employee split on a W-2 job. They also fund their own health cover, retirement, equipment, insurance, unpaid gaps between projects and time spent finding work.

Example only: a business paying an employee $50 an hour also pays 7.65% employer Social Security and Medicare, about $3.83 an hour, plus unemployment insurance, workers' compensation and benefits. A contractor quoting $65 an hour for the same skills is not necessarily expensive; compare the fully loaded cost, which is what a burden rate measures.

When does a 1099 arrangement fit, and when is it risky?

Points toward a genuine contractorPoints toward an employee
A defined deliverable or project, paid by milestone or fixed feeOpen-ended work, paid by the hour with no end date
The worker decides how, when and where the work is doneSet hours, a manager directing the work, required meetings and training
Own tools, equipment, software licences and insuranceYour laptop, your systems, your email address
Other clients, marketing, a business entity, the chance of profit or lossWorks only for you, with no business of their own
Work outside your usual line of businessThe same work your employees do, side by side with them

One federal rule matters to IT and engineering staffing in particular. Section 530 relief, which can shield a business from back employment taxes if it had a reasonable basis for contractor treatment, does not apply when a firm places an engineer, designer, drafter, computer programmer, systems analyst or similarly skilled worker with a client; those cases are decided under the usual common-law rules (Rev. Proc. 2025-10, section 3.09). That is one reason IT staffing uses W-2 or corp-to-corp arrangements more than individual 1099s.

What changes for staffing agencies and contingent programs?

  • Agency temps are W-2 by default. The agency is the employer; see W-2 contractor onboarding. "Contractor" in "W-2 contractor" describes the assignment, not the tax status.
  • Client contracts set their own rules. Staffing agreements and managed programs often say which worker types a supplier may submit; check before you put forward a 1099 candidate, and see what is a contingent worker for how programs group them.
  • Asking "W-2, 1099 or C2C?" is the first screening question on contract desks; see IT contractor screening questions.

A copy-ready 1099 engagement checklist

An example to adapt, to review with your adviser before use:

1099 ENGAGEMENT RECORD (example)
Contractor / business name: __________  Entity type: __________
Classification review done by: ________  Date: ______
  [ ] Defined scope and deliverables in a written services agreement
  [ ] Contractor controls method, hours and location
  [ ] Contractor supplies own tools and insurance (certificate on file)
  [ ] Contractor serves other clients / operates a business
  [ ] Work is outside our usual line of business (state ABC test)
  [ ] Form W-9 received before first payment
  [ ] State contractor new hire report filed (if the state requires it)
  [ ] Background check: FCRA disclosure and authorization (if used)
  [ ] Confidentiality and IP assignment signed
  [ ] 1099-NEC tracking set up ($2,000 threshold for 2026 payments)
Review again if: hours become fixed, a manager starts directing the
work, the engagement passes its end date, or the scope becomes ongoing.

Which 1099 mistakes cost the most?

  • Choosing the form first and the facts later. Decide classification before the interview loop is designed, because the interview, agreement and onboarding all differ.
  • Converting an employee to a contractor for the same job. Same work, same manager and same hours usually means the same classification.
  • Relying on the contract's label. The IRS, the Labor Department and state agencies look at what happens day to day.
  • Missing state rules. An ABC state can treat a worker as an employee for unemployment insurance even where the IRS test points the other way.
  • Using last year's threshold. The $600 figure applies to payments made before 2026 only.

Questions people ask

What is the difference between a 1099 contractor and a W-2 employee?

A W-2 employee is on the employer's payroll: the employer withholds income tax, pays its share of Social Security and Medicare, follows wage and overtime rules, completes Form I-9 and issues a Form W-2. A 1099 contractor runs their own business, controls how the work is done, pays self-employment tax themselves and receives a Form 1099-NEC if paid enough in the year. Which one a worker is depends on the facts of the relationship, not on the form the business chooses.

Do I have to send a 1099-NEC to a contractor I paid $1,500 in 2026?

Generally no. For payments made in 2026, the IRS reporting threshold for Form 1099-NEC is $2,000 in the calendar year; for payments made before 2026 it was $600. The IRS says the threshold may be adjusted for inflation for payments made after 2026, so check the current instructions each year.

Does a 1099 contractor fill out Form I-9?

No, if they are genuinely an independent contractor. USCIS lists independent contractors among the people for whom an employer does not complete Form I-9. The catch is that the Form I-9 rules use their own definition of an independent contractor, so a worker labelled 1099 who is really an employee needed one.

Can a staffing agency place someone as a 1099 contractor?

It is risky. Supplying workers is the agency's own business, which works against contractor status under state ABC tests, and the agency's control over the assignment, schedule and pay points toward employment under federal tests. Most agency placements are W-2, or corp-to-corp through the consultant's own company.

Is the Labor Department's 2026 independent contractor rule final?

Not as of November 2026. The Department proposed a new rule on February 27, 2026 (91 FR 9932) and took comments until April 28, 2026, but no final rule has been published in the Federal Register. Its investigators apply Fact Sheet #13 under a May 2025 field bulletin, while the 2024 rule remains on the books for private lawsuits.