For hiring managers

What is a staffing agency? How it works and how it differs from a recruiting agency and a PEO

On this page
  1. How does a staffing agency work?
  2. How is a staffing agency different from a recruiting agency and a PEO?
  3. What kinds of staffing arrangements are there?
  4. How do staffing agencies get paid?
  5. Who is responsible for what when you use a staffing agency?
  6. What does using a staffing agency not change?
  7. Does a staffing agency need a license?
  8. How should a hiring manager choose and work with a staffing agency?
  9. A copy-ready staffing agency intake checklist
  10. Questions people ask

A staffing agency is a business that recruits workers, employs them on its own payroll and assigns them to client businesses for limited periods to supplement the client's workforce; the client directs the daily work and pays the agency a bill rate for each hour worked. A recruiting agency (employment placement agency or executive search firm) instead finds candidates the client hires directly, so the people placed are never the agency's employees. A PEO recruits no one: it takes a client's existing employees onto its payroll in a co-employment relationship. These are the distinctions the federal industry classification draws (NAICS 561320, 561311 and 561312, and 561330), and the Bureau of Labor Statistics counted about 2.53 million jobs in temporary help services in October 2026 (preliminary).

Not legal advice. The legal points on this page summarize the federal and state sources linked below, as published in November 2026. Licensing and employer duties vary by state; confirm them for your situation.

How does a staffing agency work?

  1. The client places an order for a role, with dates, shift, pay or bill rate and requirements; see the job order form template.
  2. The agency recruits and screens candidates, often from people it has already employed.
  3. The agency hires the worker onto its payroll: offer, Form I-9, new hire reporting, and E-Verify where it is enrolled or a state requires it (see Form I-9 for staffing agencies).
  4. The worker reports to the client, which assigns and supervises the daily work and approves the hours.
  5. The agency pays the worker and handles withholding, unemployment tax and workers' compensation, then invoices the client.
  6. The assignment ends, extends or converts: the client hires the worker under the agreement's conversion terms, or the agency reassigns them elsewhere.

The federal classification captures the key feature in one line: the workers "are employees of the temporary help services establishment," which does "not provide direct supervision of their employees at the clients' work sites" (2022 NAICS Manual, 561320).

How is a staffing agency different from a recruiting agency and a PEO?

Staffing agencyRecruiting agency or search firmPEO
NAICS code561320 Temporary Help Services561311 Employment Placement Agencies; 561312 Executive Search Services561330 Professional Employer Organizations
Who finds the workerThe agencyThe agencyThe client (they are already its staff)
Whose payrollThe agency'sThe client's, from day oneThe PEO's, in co-employment with the client
Who directs the workThe clientThe clientThe client
How it is paidA bill rate per hour workedA placement fee, or a retainer for retained searchA service fee set in the client service agreement
Typical contractMaster services agreement plus a work order per assignmentPlacement fee or retained search agreementClient service agreement

The NAICS Manual says the people placed by employment placement agencies and executive search firms "are not employees" of those firms, and that PEOs "operate in a co-employment relationship with client businesses." In practice many firms run a staffing desk and a direct-hire desk under one name, so ask which service a quote is for. The shared-employer side is explained in what is co-employment, and the fee side of search work in what is a retainer fee in recruiting.

What kinds of staffing arrangements are there?

  • Temporary staffing: covering absences, peaks and projects; the classic model above.
  • Temp-to-hire: the worker starts on the agency's payroll and the client may hire them after a set period; compare the models in direct hire vs contract-to-hire.
  • Day labor and light industrial: often regulated more closely, for example by Illinois's Day and Temporary Labor Services Act.
  • Professional and IT contracting: consultants placed on longer projects, sometimes billed corp-to-corp; see what is staff augmentation.
  • Payrolling: the client finds the person and the agency only employs and pays them; see payrolling services explained.
  • Managed programs: large clients route orders through a managed service provider and a vendor management system; see MSP vs VMS.

How do staffing agencies get paid?

Mostly by the hour. The client pays a bill rate that covers the worker's pay, the agency's payroll taxes, workers' compensation and benefits, and the agency's gross profit. Example only: a $22.00 pay rate with a 45% markup gives a $31.90 bill rate; the $9.90 spread pays the agency's employment costs first and what is left is its margin. How the pieces fit is in what is a bill rate. Other charges are set in the agreement: a conversion fee if the client hires a temp before an agreed period, a direct-hire fee for permanent placements, and in managed programs a vendor fee deducted from each invoice.

Who is responsible for what when you use a staffing agency?

DutyWho carries itSource
Form I-9The agency; the client does not complete Form I-9 for workers employed by "temporary agencies" and providing labor to itM-274, section 2.0; 8 CFR 274a.1(g)
Payroll and employment taxesThe agency, as the employer that hires and paysThe agreement; the agency's tax registrations
Safety and trainingBoth: OSHA calls the agency and host employer "joint employers of temporary workers"OSHA
Non-discriminationBoth: the agency in hiring and assigning, the client in how it treats the workerEEOC Notice 915.002 (1997)
FMLA leaveThe agency, as the primary employer; the client counts the temps for coverage and must not interfere29 CFR 825.106
Wages, in IllinoisThe client "shall share all legal responsibility and liability for the payment of wages"820 ILCS 175/85(b)
Daily supervisionThe clientThe agreement and the work order

What does using a staffing agency not change?

Putting a worker on an agency's payroll moves the paperwork, not every obligation. The client still decides how the work is done and so still answers for how its managers treat the worker, for site-specific safety training and protective equipment, and, in states like Illinois, for unpaid wages alongside the agency. A temp who works full time for more than a year under the client's direction can also start to count for the client's retirement plan testing; see what is a leased employee. And the agency's contract language does not decide who is an employer under the wage-hour, labor or discrimination laws, which look at what actually happens on the job.

Does a staffing agency need a license?

It depends on the state and the kind of work. Some states license employment agencies, some register temporary labor firms, and some regulate neither. Illinois shows how a rule can reach the client too: a client must check a day and temporary labor service agency's registration with the state Department of Labor before contracting and again on March 1 and September 1, and its contracts are void from the date the agency's registration is denied, suspended or revoked until it is registered again (820 ILCS 175/85(a)). Checked state examples are in employment agency license requirements and in each state's page, such as staffing agency license in Illinois; starting one is covered in how to start a staffing agency.

How should a hiring manager choose and work with a staffing agency?

  • Ask for the pay rate inside the bill rate, not just the bill rate: the pay rate decides whether the agency can attract and keep the person.
  • Ask how it recruits and screens for this kind of role, and what it checks before the first shift (licences, background checks, drug tests).
  • Read the conversion terms before the first temp starts.
  • Check its insurance: workers' compensation for the actual duties and the endorsements your contract needs; see staffing agency insurance requirements.
  • Agree who does what in writing, in the master services agreement, and route discipline and assignment changes through the agency.
  • Compare several agencies on the same terms; the agency comparison scorecard works for staffing too.

A copy-ready staffing agency intake checklist

STAFFING AGENCY INTAKE (example)
Agency: ____________  Contact: ____________  Date: __/__/____
Service quoted:  [ ] temp  [ ] temp-to-hire  [ ] direct hire  [ ] payrolling
State license / registration checked:  [ ] yes  [ ] n/a   Source: ________
Role: ________  Work state: ____  Shift: ________  Start: __/__/____
Pay rate: $____/hr   Bill rate: $____/hr   OT bill basis: ________
Classification:  [ ] non-exempt  [ ] exempt
Screening before first shift: ______________________________
Workers' comp class and carrier: ________  Certificate received: [ ]
Who supervises daily: ________  Who handles discipline: agency
Timesheet approver: ________  Invoice cycle: ________
Conversion: fee $______ or after ____ hours/weeks
Agreement signed:  [ ] MSA  [ ] work order  [ ] rate schedule

The checklist is an example to adapt. Agency workers in the BLS count above are measured in the Current Employment Statistics series for temporary help services (CES6056132001, seasonally adjusted: 2,526,000 in October 2026, preliminary, against 2,451,800 in October 2025), part of about 3.23 million jobs in employment services as a whole (CES6056130001).

Questions people ask

What is the difference between a staffing agency and a recruiting agency?

A staffing agency employs the workers it supplies: they are on the agency's payroll while the client directs their work, and the client pays the agency an hourly bill rate. A recruiting agency, including an executive search firm, finds candidates whom the client then hires onto its own payroll; the people placed are never the agency's employees, and the agency earns a placement fee. Many firms run both desks.

Who is the employer of a temp worker from a staffing agency?

The staffing agency is the employer that hires, pays and withholds taxes, completes Form I-9 and carries workers' compensation. Several federal laws also treat the client as an employer during the assignment: OSHA calls the agency and host employer joint employers, the EEOC says a supervising client usually qualifies as an employer, and the FMLA rules ordinarily find joint employment, with the agency as the primary employer.

Is a PEO a staffing agency?

No. A PEO does not recruit or supply workers. It takes a client's existing employees onto its payroll for payroll, tax, benefits and HR administration in a co-employment relationship. A staffing agency recruits its own employees and assigns them to clients for limited periods. The federal industry classification puts them in different codes: 561330 for PEOs and 561320 for temporary help services.

How much does a staffing agency charge?

A staffing agency charges a bill rate for each hour the worker works, which covers the worker's pay, the agency's payroll taxes, workers' compensation and benefits, and its margin. There is no reliable public benchmark for the markup, because it depends on the role, the state, insurance costs and volume. Conversion and direct-hire fees are separate and set in the agreement.

Does a staffing agency need a license?

It depends on the state and the type of work. Some states license employment agencies or register temporary labor firms, and Illinois requires clients to check a day and temporary labor agency's registration before contracting and twice a year. Check the state's own rule before using or starting an agency.