National criminal database search: what it covers, its gaps, and the FCRA 1681k rule (2026)
On this page
- What is in a national criminal database?
- Is it the FBI's database?
- What does a national criminal database search miss?
- What does FCRA section 1681k require?
- What should you ask your screening company?
- How should you read a national database hit?
- When does a national database search make sense?
- Summary table
- Questions people ask
A national criminal database search is a screening company's search of its own compiled database of criminal records gathered from county and state courts, corrections departments and sex offender registries. Despite the name, it is not the FBI's database, which screening companies cannot use for ordinary employment checks, and it does not cover every court: the CFPB noted in 2019 that federal court records are typically not included in national private databases. Screening companies treat it as a pointer to records that must be confirmed at the source court, which matches the FCRA rule in 15 U.S.C. § 1681k: before reporting a public record likely to cost someone a job, the company must either notify the person at the time or keep strict procedures so the record is complete and up to date.
This page covers what the database holds, what it misses, what section 1681k requires, and how to read a "hit." The employer's own notice steps are on the FCRA background check process, and which records are too old to report is on the seven-year rule.
Not legal advice. This summarizes the FCRA, federal regulations, CFPB, FTC and GAO publications, and what named screening companies say about their own products, as published on the linked pages and checked in November 2026. State laws add reporting limits and notice steps; confirm the rules for your locations with counsel.
What is in a national criminal database?
Whatever the screening company, or the data vendor it buys from, has been able to collect. The CFPB's 2019 market snapshot on background screening describes private databases that "collect public records, including from law enforcement agencies, state courts, corrections offices, and state criminal record repositories where available." Vendors describe their products the same way as of November 2026:
- First Advantage says its Enhanced Nationwide Criminal Database covers "State, County and Corrections records from across the nation" and that possible convictions and pending cases "are validated against primary source court records" before any findings are reported (First Advantage).
- HireRight says "No single background check covers records everywhere," and that potential records found through its Widescreen Plus tip-and-lead service "are verified directly with the original source before being reported" (HireRight).
Many packages bundle a sex offender registry search. The Justice Department's Dru Sjodin National Sex Offender Public Website searches registries for all 50 states, the District of Columbia, U.S. territories and Indian Country, run as a partnership with state, territorial and tribal governments. A registry match by name alone is a lead, not a finding: in 2014 the FTC settled charges that a screening company, InfoTrack, provided "inaccurate information suggesting that job applicants potentially were registered sex offenders" (FTC, April 9, 2014).
Is it the FBI's database?
No. FBI criminal history records go to criminal justice agencies, to federal agencies authorized by statute or executive order, and "for use in connection with licensing or employment, pursuant to Public Law 92-544 ... or other federal legislation" (28 CFR 20.33(a)). That means fingerprint checks for jobs a specific law covers, run through a government channel; see fingerprint background checks for employers. Commercial databases are built from what states and courts make available, and GAO reported in 2015 that "not all states make their criminal record information accessible for private companies to search" (GAO-15-162).
What does a national criminal database search miss?
| Gap | Why it happens | Source |
|---|---|---|
| Federal cases | Federal court records sit in PACER and "are typically not included in national private databases" | CFPB 2019 |
| Courts that do not sell bulk data | Some courts give remote access only one record at a time, from the individual court, and courts differ on whether they sell bulk data at all | CFPB 2019 |
| Recent cases and recent updates | If the database's update schedule does not match the court's, it can miss new cases or keep "expunged or dropped cases" | CFPB 2019 |
| Weak identifiers | Courts that remove dates of birth or partial SSNs from public records make matching harder and false matches more likely | CFPB 2019 |
| Missing outcomes | Arrest records often lack a final disposition; GAO found 20 states had dispositions on more than 75 percent of arrest records in 2012 | GAO 2015 |
| Records that may not be reported | Age limits under federal and state law, and sealed or expunged records | Seven-year rule |
The federal gap is the one employers most often miss. Federal cases are searchable through PACER, whose Case Locator offers a national index; as of November 2026 PACER charges $0.10 per page and waives fees for users who spend $30 or less in a quarter (PACER pricing). Ask your screening company whether a federal search is in your package or must be added. Our pages on the federal criminal records search and the county criminal records search cover each in detail.
What does FCRA section 1681k require?
Section 1681k applies to a consumer reporting agency that, for employment purposes, "compiles and reports items of information on consumers which are matters of public record and are likely to have an adverse effect upon a consumer's ability to obtain employment." It must do one of two things (15 U.S.C. § 1681k(a)):
- Notice at the time. Notify the person, when the record is reported, "that public record information is being reported" and give the name and address of the employer receiving it; or
- Strict procedures. "Maintain strict procedures designed to insure" that the public record information "is complete and up to date." For arrests, indictments, convictions, suits, tax liens and judgments, a record counts as up to date "if the current public record status of the item at the time of the report is reported."
On top of that, every consumer report must be prepared with "reasonable procedures to assure maximum possible accuracy" (15 U.S.C. § 1681e(b)). A raw database hit can fail both tests: it may show an old status, or belong to someone with the same name. That is why the vendors quoted above confirm hits at the source court before they report them, and why some send candidates the notice letter instead. If a candidate tells you they received a letter saying public record information was reported to you, that is the first option at work.
What enforcement shows
- In 2015 the CFPB found that two large screening companies "failed to use basic procedures for matching public records information to the correct consumer," including not requiring middle names, and that between 2010 and 2014 nearly 70 percent of criminal history disputes filed with one of them led to a change or correction; the order required $10.5 million in consumer relief and a $2.5 million penalty (CFPB, October 29, 2015).
- In 2012 the FTC obtained a $2.6 million civil penalty from HireRight Solutions over reports that did not reflect expungements, listed the same offense more than once and in numerous cases included the records of the wrong person (FTC, August 8, 2012).
- The CFPB's 2021 advisory opinion on name-only matching was withdrawn as of May 12, 2025, along with other guidance (90 FR 20084). The statute's accuracy duty did not change.
What should you ask your screening company?
Get the answers in writing before you rely on a national search:
- Which sources feed the database, by state, and how often each is updated?
- Is every potential record verified at the original court before it is reported, and which section 1681k option do you use?
- What identifiers must match before a record is attributed to a candidate (full name, middle name, date of birth), and how do you handle common names?
- Does the package include a federal search and a sex offender registry search, and how are registry matches confirmed?
- How do you remove expunged, sealed and dismissed cases, and which state lookback limits do you apply by work location?
- How are candidate disputes handled, and how quickly do corrections reach us?
How should you read a national database hit?
- Check it was confirmed at the source. The report should show the court, case number, the date it was verified and the current status. An unverified "possible record" is not a basis for a decision.
- Check the identifiers. Compare the date of birth and full name with the candidate's. A match on name alone is a lead.
- Check the outcome. An arrest without a disposition is not a conviction; dismissed and diverted cases mean something different from convictions.
- Check it may be used. State and city laws bar some records entirely and set lookback limits; see the seven-year rule and ban-the-box interview questions for timing.
- Assess it against the job. The EEOC rescinded its 2012 guidance on arrest and conviction records on October 28, 2026, but Title VII still applies, and weighing the Green factors from the 1975 Eighth Circuit case (the nature and gravity of the offense, the time since it and the nature of the job) remains a sound way to decide and document. Follow any state or city assessment form.
- Send the pre-adverse action notice before deciding. Include a copy of the report and the summary of rights, and give the candidate time to respond or dispute; wording is on background check notification emails.
When does a national database search make sense?
As a wide net in a package that also searches the counties where the candidate has lived, found through the SSN trace, plus a federal search where the role warrants it. On its own, it is neither complete nor final. Write the package by role family into your background check policy, so every candidate for a role gets the same searches.
Summary table
| Item | The rule or fact, as of November 2026 | Source |
|---|---|---|
| What it is | A screening company's compiled database of court, corrections and registry records | CFPB 2019 |
| FBI records | Not available for ordinary employment checks; only under specific laws | 28 CFR 20.33 |
| Federal cases | Typically not included; searchable through PACER | CFPB 2019, PACER |
| Public records for employment | Notice at the time, or strict procedures for complete and up-to-date records | 15 U.S.C. § 1681k |
| Accuracy | Reasonable procedures to assure maximum possible accuracy | 15 U.S.C. § 1681e(b) |
| Employer before rejecting | Pre-adverse notice with report and summary of rights, then adverse action notice | 15 U.S.C. § 1681b(b)(3), § 1681m |
Questions people ask
Is a national criminal database search the same as an FBI background check?
No. A national criminal database search is a screening company's own compiled database of court, corrections and registry records. The FBI's criminal history records are released for employment only where a federal law or an FBI-approved state statute authorizes a fingerprint check for that kind of job, under 28 CFR 20.33, so ordinary employers and screening companies cannot search them.
What does a national criminal database search miss?
It misses records from courts that do not sell or publish data in bulk, records added after the database's last update, and usually federal cases: the CFPB noted in 2019 that federal court records are typically not included in national private databases. It can also carry stale entries, such as cases later expunged or dismissed, and records with too few identifiers to match reliably.
What does FCRA section 1681k require for criminal records?
When a screening company reports public record information likely to hurt a person's chance of getting a job, 15 U.S.C. 1681k requires it either to notify the person at the time, with the name and address of the employer receiving it, or to keep strict procedures so the record is complete and up to date. A criminal record counts as up to date if it shows the case's current public record status at the time of the report.
Can an employer reject a candidate based only on a national database hit?
It should not. Screening companies such as First Advantage and HireRight say they verify database hits against the original court source before reporting them, because database records can be outdated or belong to someone else. Rely only on a record confirmed at the source, check that it belongs to the candidate and may lawfully be reported, apply any fair chance assessment, and send the FCRA pre-adverse action notice before deciding.