For hiring managers

What is a conditional offer of employment? What may lawfully follow it, step by step

On this page
  1. How does a conditional offer work in practice?
  2. How is a conditional offer different from other kinds of offer?
  3. What makes a conditional offer "real"?
  4. What may lawfully happen after a conditional offer?
  5. Which conditions belong in the offer, and how should you word them?
  6. What happens if a condition is not met?
  7. Do staffing agencies make conditional offers?
  8. What should interviewers keep out of the process before the offer?
  9. Which conditional-offer mistakes cause the most trouble?
  10. Questions people ask

A conditional offer of employment is a real job offer that becomes final only if the candidate meets conditions the employer states in the offer, such as passing a background check, a drug test or a post-offer medical exam, proving work authorization, or holding a required license. In US hiring it also marks a legal line: under the Americans with Disabilities Act, an employer may ask disability-related questions or require a medical exam only after making one, and fair chance laws such as California's and New York City's bar criminal history questions until after it. The offer has to be genuine: the EEOC's guidance says it is real if the employer has already evaluated the non-medical information it reasonably could obtain before making it (all as of November 2026).

Not legal advice. This page summarizes federal law (the ADA at 42 U.S.C. 12112, its regulation at 29 CFR 1630.14, GINA at 29 CFR 1635.8, the FCRA, and USCIS Form I-9 rules) and two local fair chance laws, as published by the agencies linked below, as of November 2026. State and city rules differ; check them with employment counsel before relying on this for a specific hire.

How does a conditional offer work in practice?

  1. Assess everything you can first. Interviews, work samples, skills tests, reference checks the candidate allows, and license lookups happen before the offer.
  2. Make the offer in writing, listing each condition. Name the checks, who runs them, and what happens if one is not met. The approved requisition behind it is described in what is a requisition number.
  3. The candidate accepts, subject to the conditions. Many employers ask the candidate not to resign from a current job until the conditions clear; say so in the letter if that is your practice.
  4. Run the post-offer steps in the order the law allows (see the table below), and keep medical information separate from the hiring file.
  5. Confirm in writing that the conditions are met and the offer is final, or follow the required notice steps before withdrawing it.

How is a conditional offer different from other kinds of offer?

TermWhat it meansWhat to watch
Conditional (or contingent) offerA firm offer that depends on stated checksList every condition; vague wording such as "subject to approval" invites disputes
Final or unconditional offerNo conditions left; the start date is setWithdrawing it carries the most risk; see how to rescind a job offer
Verbal offerTerms agreed by phone before the letterSay on the call that the written offer will list the conditions
Exploding offerAn offer with a short acceptance deadlineA deadline is not a condition; see what is an exploding offer
Employment contractA signed agreement on terms, often with notice periodsConditions in a contract are read as contract terms

What makes a conditional offer "real"?

The EEOC's enforcement guidance on pre-employment disability-related questions and medical examinations (October 10, 1995, still on eeoc.gov as of November 2026) says a job offer is real if the employer has evaluated all relevant non-medical information it reasonably could have obtained and analyzed before giving it. The point is to stop employers from making a hollow offer, collecting medical information, and then rejecting the person for a reason they could have found earlier, which hides whether the medical information drove the decision.

The same guidance accepts that some information cannot reasonably be obtained before an offer. Its example is an applicant who asks that a current employer not be contacted for a reference until a conditional offer is made; the offer is still real if the reference check happens afterwards. Plan the order of your checks with that in mind: skills and references first, medical questions last.

What may lawfully happen after a conditional offer?

StepBefore an offerAfter a conditional offerSource
Medical exam or disability-related questionsNot allowed; you may ask whether the applicant can perform job-related functionsAllowed if all entering employees in the same job category get the same exam, regardless of disability; results kept confidential in separate medical files42 U.S.C. 12112(d); 29 CFR 1630.14(b)
Test for illegal drug useNot restricted by the ADA, which says it is not a medical exam; state law may limit itNot restricted by the ADA; state law may limit it42 U.S.C. 12114(d)
Family medical history and other genetic informationNot allowedStill not allowed; tell the clinic not to collect it in the exam29 CFR 1635.8(d)
Criminal history (California, five or more employees)Not allowed, including internet searches and background checksAllowed, with an individualized assessment and written notice before withdrawingCalifornia Civil Rights Department
Criminal history (New York City, four or more employees)Not allowedAllowed; withdrawal needs the Fair Chance ProcessNYC Commission on Human Rights
Background check through a consumer reporting agencyFederal law allows it at any stage with a standalone written disclosure and written authorizationSame; before acting on it, give a copy of the report and the summary of rights15 U.S.C. 1681b(b)
Form I-9Not allowed: you may not ask someone who has not accepted a job offer to complete Section 1Section 1 by the first day of employment; Section 2 within three business days of the start dateM-274 section 3.0; section 4.0
E-Verify caseNot allowed: the User Manual says employers must not use E-Verify to pre-screen an applicantCreated from the completed Form I-9, no later than the third business day after the employee starts work for payE-Verify User Manual 1.5; verification process

The ADA rules apply to employers with 15 or more employees (29 CFR 1630.2(e)); many state disability laws reach smaller employers. The full medical-exam procedure is in pre-employment medical exams under the ADA, and the I-9 timeline in Form I-9 timing in hiring. State drug-testing limits are summarized in drug testing laws in hiring.

Which conditions belong in the offer, and how should you word them?

Only conditions you will actually check, that apply to everyone hired into the same job, and that you can explain. Common ones: a background check, a drug test where lawful, a post-offer medical exam for physically demanding jobs, verification of a license or certification the job requires, proof of identity and work authorization on Form I-9, and signing standard agreements. Each condition should say what is checked and by when.

Sample conditional-offer clause (an example to review with counsel, not a template to use as is):

This offer is conditional on the following, each completed
before your start date of [date]:
  1. A background check by [consumer reporting agency], run only
     after you sign the separate disclosure and authorization form.
     [In California or New York City: criminal history is checked
     only now, after this conditional offer.]
  2. A drug test at [clinic], given to everyone hired into
     [job title]. [Delete if not used or not lawful for this role.]
  3. A post-offer medical examination at [clinic], given to
     everyone hired into [job title], to confirm you can perform
     the essential functions of the job with or without reasonable
     accommodation. Results go only to [HR contact] and are kept
     in a confidential medical file.
  4. Verification of your [license name and number] with
     [issuing board].
On your first day you will complete Form I-9 and present
documents of your choice from the Lists of Acceptable Documents.

If any check raises a concern, we will contact you before making
a decision and tell you how to respond. Please do not resign from
your current job until we confirm in writing that these
conditions are met.

Note what the clause leaves out: it never names which identity documents to bring, because choosing them is the employee's right, and it never ties the medical exam to anything but the essential functions of the job. For full letters, see the offer letter template.

What happens if a condition is not met?

  • Medical exam results. A withdrawal that screens out someone with a disability must be job-related and consistent with business necessity, and only if the essential functions cannot be performed with reasonable accommodation (29 CFR 1630.14(b)(3)).
  • A consumer report. Before acting, give the candidate a copy of the report and the FCRA summary of rights (15 U.S.C. 1681b(b)(3)); after deciding, send the adverse action notice naming the reporting agency and the right to a free copy and to dispute (15 U.S.C. 1681m). The step-by-step process is in the FCRA background check process for recruiters.
  • Criminal history in California. The Civil Rights Department's Fair Chance Act fact sheet (June 2025) requires an individualized assessment, then a written preliminary notice with the convictions, a copy of the report and at least five business days from receipt to respond, before any final decision. Details: California's Fair Chance Act.
  • Criminal history in New York City. The employer must give a written copy of its inquiry and its analysis, and at least five business days to respond. Details: the NYC Fair Chance Act. Other cities, including Los Angeles and Philadelphia, have their own procedures.

Federal Title VII still applies to criminal-history decisions. The EEOC rescinded its 2012 arrest and conviction records guidance on October 28, 2026, so do not cite it; a documented, job-related review using the nature of the offense, the time since it and the nature of the job (the Green factors from the 1975 Eighth Circuit case) remains a sound practice, alongside any state or city steps.

Do staffing agencies make conditional offers?

Yes, and the agency is usually the employer making them when it hires a worker onto its own payroll for a client placement. The same rules follow it: California's fact sheet names temporary employment agencies and labor contractors among covered employers, and a post-offer medical exam has to be given to every worker entering the same job category, not only to placements for one demanding client. Agree in writing with each client who runs which check and who sends which notice, so a candidate never gets two conflicting letters or none.

What should interviewers keep out of the process before the offer?

Anything the law reserves for after the offer: questions about health, medications, past workers' compensation claims or disability, and, in fair chance jurisdictions, criminal history, including what a web search turns up. If a candidate volunteers such information, do not follow up and do not write it in your notes. See illegal interview questions for the full list.

Which conditional-offer mistakes cause the most trouble?

MistakeWhy it is a problemFix
Medical questionnaire sent with the applicationPre-offer disability questions break the ADASend it only after the written conditional offer
Exam given only to some new hires in a jobThe ADA requires the same exam for all entering employees in that job categorySet the rule per job category and apply it to everyone
References checked only after the medical examThe offer may not count as real, and a later rejection looks medicalFinish non-medical checks first unless the candidate asks otherwise
Offer withdrawn the day a report arrivesSkips FCRA and fair chance notice periodsSend the required notices and wait the stated period
"Bring your passport" in the offer letterSpecifying I-9 documents can be document abuse; see I-9 document abuseLet the employee choose from the Lists of Acceptable Documents

Questions people ask

Is a conditional job offer a real job offer?

Yes, if it is made in good faith. The EEOC's 1995 guidance on pre-employment medical questions says an offer is real if the employer has evaluated all relevant non-medical information it reasonably could have obtained before making it. The job is yours unless you fail one of the conditions stated in the offer, such as a background check, drug test or post-offer medical exam.

Can an employer take back a conditional offer?

Yes, if a stated condition is not met, but the reason and the steps matter. A withdrawal based on a post-offer medical exam must be job-related and consistent with business necessity under the ADA, one based on a consumer report needs the FCRA's pre-adverse and adverse action notices, and in places such as California and New York City one based on criminal history needs the local fair chance process first. Whether a withdrawal creates other liability depends on the offer letter and state law.

Can an employer ask about my health after a conditional offer?

Yes. Under the ADA, after a conditional offer and before you start work, an employer with 15 or more employees may ask disability-related questions or require a medical exam, as long as everyone entering the same job category gets the same exam. The answers must be kept confidential in separate medical files, and the employer may not ask for family medical history, which GINA treats as genetic information.

When can a California employer run a criminal background check?

Only after a conditional offer, for employers with five or more employees. California's Civil Rights Department says the Fair Chance Act bars asking about or considering conviction history before a job offer, and that after a conditional offer the employer may run a background check, with an individualized assessment and written notice before withdrawing the offer.

Do I complete Form I-9 when I get a conditional offer?

Only once you have accepted the offer. USCIS says an employer may not ask someone who has not accepted a job offer to complete Section 1 of Form I-9; the employee must complete Section 1 by the first day of employment and the employer completes Section 2 within three business days of the start date.