Candidate fraud in childcare hiring: background check gaps, fake CDA and CPR cards, references and the federal CCDBG rules
On this page
- What fraud and gap patterns have official sources documented?
- Where do background check gaps come from, and how do you close them?
- How do fake CPR and first aid cards show up, and how do you check?
- How do you check a CDA claim?
- How do you check references for child care roles?
- What checks should a child care provider or staffing agency run?
- What should you ask on the screen?
- What should you do when something doesn't match?
- How do you keep these checks fair?
- What changes for staffing agencies placing child care staff?
- Child care hiring fraud checklist
- Questions people ask
In child care, the gaps federal auditors document, as of November 2026, are less often forged papers than checks that were never completed: HHS Inspector General audits found 107 of 679 people at 30 Colorado providers (April 2021) and 15 of 377 at 30 Virginia providers (February 2021) without one or more required background checks. The Child Care and Development Block Grant Act and its rule (42 U.S.C. 9858f, 45 CFR 98.43) require a comprehensive check for every staff member, including contract staff, before they start, and a person who knowingly makes a materially false statement in connection with the check is ineligible. Around those gaps sit credentials that are easy to fake or misread: CPR cards from sites the American Heart Association says are not authorized, CDA training certificates presented as the credential, and references that loop back to the candidate. The checks that close them are the state's own background check before the first shift, the issuer's lookup for every card, and references reached through contacts you find yourself.
The federal rules in full are on child care worker background checks, and the card lookups on how to verify a CDA credential and how to verify a CPR certification. This page is about the fraud and gap patterns and how a provider's or agency's process catches them.
What fraud and gap patterns have official sources documented?
| Pattern | What the source says | What catches it | Source |
|---|---|---|---|
| Staff without required checks (Colorado) | "107 of 679 individuals requiring a background check did not obtain 1 or more of the required criminal background checks"; providers "did not always inform the State and properly obtain background checks when hiring individuals or when new individuals began to reside in family homes" | A roster built from payroll and household records, checked before anyone starts | HHS OIG, A-07-19-06084, April 2021 |
| Staff without current checks (Virginia) | "15 of the 377 household members and employees reviewed did not have a current and completed background check"; OIG recommended that inspectors use "verified information, such as payroll data" | The same roster; five-year re-check dates | HHS OIG, A-03-19-00253, February 2021 |
| False statements in the check | The state must find a staff member ineligible if the person "Knowingly makes a materially false statement in connection with such criminal background check" | The state's check, covering every state lived in for five years | 45 CFR 98.43(c)(1)(ii) |
| CPR training with no skills check | Websites claim training that is "American Heart Association Compliant" but are "not American Heart Association-authorized training centers," offering training "with no skills checks or instant electronic course cards" | The issuer's eCard lookup | AHA fraud warning |
| Fake and sold CPR cards | An employer received "a fillable PDF card" that "is not a valid Laerdal or American Heart Association Training Center course completion card"; people were found "selling training course completion cards to individuals who had not taken the courses," and "Several arrests were made" | The issuer's lookup, never the card image | AHA fraud warning |
The audits are a few years old and covered state monitoring, not fraud by applicants. They matter for hiring because they show where people slip through: someone who starts before the result, a new household member, a cook or driver left off the list.
Where do background check gaps come from, and how do you close them?
- People left off the list. A child care staff member includes anyone employed for compensation, "including contract employees or self-employed individuals," anyone with unsupervised access to children, and anyone 18 or older living in a family child care home (98.43(a)(2)(ii)). Build the list from payroll, contracts and household records, as the Virginia audit recommended for inspectors.
- Starting too early. A prospective staff member may begin work only "after receiving qualifying results" for either the FBI fingerprint check or the state fingerprint-based check where they live, and must then be "supervised at all times" by someone with a full qualifying check in the past five years (98.43(d)(4)). ACF's brief on provisional hires says submitting fingerprints without results "is not sufficient" (details on our CCDBG page).
- A missing state. The state registry searches cover each state the person lived in during the past five years (98.43(b)(3)). Ask every applicant for every state at application; leaving one out knowingly is a materially false statement that makes the person ineligible.
- The five-year re-check and portability. Checks repeat at least every five years, and an earlier in-state result carries over only within the limits the rule sets; track both dates.
Fingerprints tie a record to the fingers presented, so make sure the person at the fingerprint appointment is the person you are hiring; general fingerprint rules are on fingerprint background checks for employers, and registry searches you run yourself on sex offender registry checks.
How do fake CPR and first aid cards show up, and how do you check?
Pediatric first aid and CPR is one of the minimum health and safety topics CCDF rules require (45 CFR 98.41(a)(1)(x)), with pre-service or orientation training "to be completed within three months" under the state's plan (98.44(b)); your state licensing rule sets the details. The fake cards the AHA describes fall into three groups: online-only "compliant" training with no hands-on skills test, cards filled in on a computer, and cards sold to people who never took the course. All three fail the same check: look the card up with the issuer (the AHA eCard search or the Training Center on the card; the Red Cross's Find My Certificate), never from a photo. The steps, and why online-only cards often fall short, are in how to verify a CPR certification.
How do you check a CDA claim?
Ask for the certificate number and look it up in the Council for Professional Recognition's CDA Certificate Lookup, which shows the credential as Active, Expired or Revoked. The two common misreadings are a training certificate for the coursework presented as the credential, and a credential earned in a different setting (Infant-Toddler versus Preschool, for example) from the room you are hiring for. Head Start roles add their own minimums under 45 CFR 1302.91. All of it is in how to verify a CDA credential; degrees behind lead teacher roles are checked as in how to verify a candidate's degree.
How do you check references for child care roles?
Head Start programs must verify references before hiring under 45 CFR 1302.90(b), which remains in effect as of November 2026 although ACF has proposed replacing the Head Start performance standards (see our CCDBG page for the proposal's status). For every provider, the useful reference is a previous child care employer reached through its own published number or the state's child care provider search where one exists, confirming dates, the role and the age group. A referee reachable only through a mobile number the candidate supplied is not verified; the warning signs are in how to spot fake references.
What checks should a child care provider or staffing agency run?
- Application: every state lived in during the past five years, every name used, consent to the state's check.
- Submit the state's background check request before the person becomes a staff member, through the agency your state names.
- Identity: a live government photo ID check, matched to the name on the check request and the fingerprint appointment.
- Credentials: CPR and first aid cards on the issuer's lookup; CDA on the Council's lookup; degrees with the registrar.
- References through previous child care employers you contact independently.
- No start until the state's result, or a provisional start under 98.43(d)(4) with constant supervision recorded on the schedule.
- Re-check: five-year background checks, CPR expirations, CDA expirations, and anyone new living in a family child care home.
- Document each check: date, source, who ran it, result.
What should you ask on the screen?
Lawful, job-related questions, asked of every candidate:
"The state background check covers every state you've lived in
during the past five years. Which states are those?"
"Do you hold a CPR and pediatric first aid card? Which organization
issued it, and when does it expire?"
"Do you hold a CDA? Which setting, and what is the certificate
number? We look it up with the Council."
"Who supervised you at your last child care job? I'll contact the
center directly."
More questions are in the interview guide for child care roles and, for private family placements, nanny screening questions.
What should you do when something doesn't match?
- Keep the person away from unsupervised contact with children. Child safety comes first, and the rule already requires supervision until checks are complete.
- Verify through the source: the state agency running the check, the card issuer, the Council, the previous employer.
- Ask the candidate neutrally, for example about a name change or a card that has not been issued yet.
- Let the state decide eligibility. Providers receive only an eligible or ineligible statement; details and appeal rights go to the worker.
- Report fake CPR cards to the AHA (1-800-242-8721, as its fraud page lists) or the issuer, and keep the record; how to report candidate fraud lists what to keep.
How do you keep these checks fair?
- Same checks, same stage, every candidate, including long-time acquaintances and family referrals.
- Never screen on national origin, accent or citizenship status (citizenship status discrimination in hiring).
- Use the FCRA when you add a screening company's report to the state's check (the FCRA process).
What changes for staffing agencies placing child care staff?
- Temps are staff members. Contract employees are covered, so the check must be requested and the start rule met before the first shift at each provider.
- Agree who submits the request, pays the fees and keeps the eligibility statement; check your contract rather than assuming.
- Re-verify per placement where a state or city requires a check per site.
- Private family placements fall outside the federal rule unless the caregiver is licensed, regulated, registered or paid with CCDF assistance; state law may still apply.
Child care hiring fraud checklist
[ ] Roster of everyone covered: staff, contract staff, household 18+
[ ] Every state lived in for five years listed by the applicant
[ ] State background check requested before the first day
[ ] Government photo ID checked live; name matches the request
[ ] No start before results, or provisional start under 98.43(d)(4)
[ ] Constant supervision recorded while checks are pending
[ ] CPR and first aid card verified with the issuer
[ ] CDA verified on the Council's lookup; setting matches the room
[ ] References from previous child care employers, found independently
[ ] Re-check dates: five-year check, CPR, CDA, new household members
[ ] Each check documented: date, source, who, result
Not legal advice. HHS Inspector General, eCFR (45 CFR parts 98 and 1302), and American Heart Association sources checked as of November 2026.
Questions people ask
Can a new child care employee start work before the background check comes back?
Only on the terms in 45 CFR 98.43(d)(4): a prospective staff member may begin work after receiving qualifying results for either the FBI fingerprint check or the fingerprint-based check of the state criminal repository where they live, and until every component is complete they must be supervised at all times by someone with a qualifying full check in the past five years. Submitting fingerprints is not enough, and some states and cities are stricter.
What happens if a child care applicant lies during the background check?
Under 45 CFR 98.43(c)(1)(ii), the state must find a child care staff member ineligible if the person knowingly makes a materially false statement in connection with the criminal background check. That includes leaving out a state they lived in during the past five years, since the check must cover every one. The provider receives only an eligible or ineligible result from the state.
How can I tell if a CPR card for a child care job is fake?
Check it with the issuer. For an American Heart Association card, enter the eCard code in the AHA's eCard search or contact the Training Center on the card; for the American Red Cross, use its Find My Certificate page. The AHA warns about sites that sell 'AHA compliant' training with no skills check or instant cards, and about a fillable PDF card that is not a valid course completion card.
Does a CDA training certificate count as a CDA credential?
No. The Child Development Associate credential is awarded by the Council for Professional Recognition, and the Council's CDA Certificate Lookup shows each credential as Active, Expired or Revoked by certificate number. A certificate for the 120 hours of training that come before the credential shows coursework, not the credential, so ask for the CDA certificate number and look it up yourself.