Candidate fraud in construction hiring: fake OSHA and SST cards, borrowed trade licenses, identity and subcontractor crews
On this page
- What fraud patterns have official sources documented?
- Why doesn't a genuine-looking card settle it?
- How do borrowed trade licenses work, and how do you check?
- Who checks identity and work authorization when crews come through subcontractors?
- What checks should a contractor or construction staffing agency run?
- What should recruiters ask on the screen?
- What should you do when something doesn't match?
- How do you keep these checks fair?
- What changes for construction staffing agencies?
- Construction hiring fraud checklist
- Questions people ask
The best-documented candidate fraud in construction hiring, as of November 2026, is in safety training cards. New York City cases show two kinds: counterfeit OSHA and Site Safety Training (SST) cards printed and sold for $200 to $650 (a 2023 Brooklyn indictment), and genuine cards issued after training that never happened, which prosecutors allege an authorized provider sold for $500 each (a September 2026 indictment). Around them sit three older risks: trade licenses lent to or used by someone who does not hold them, identity documents that belong to someone else, and crews supplied through shell subcontractors so that no one checks work authorization. A card or license lookup catches the counterfeit, not the borrowed license or the class nobody attended. What catches the rest is identity matched to every credential, the issuer's own verification channel, your own site orientation and skills check, and subcontract terms you actually enforce.
How to run each lookup is covered elsewhere: how to verify an OSHA 10 or OSHA 30 card (including the state and city laws that require one) and how to verify a contractor license. This page is about the fraud patterns and how a contractor's or construction staffing agency's process catches them.
What fraud patterns have official sources documented?
| Pattern | What the source says | Would a card or license lookup catch it? | Source |
|---|---|---|---|
| Counterfeit OSHA and SST cards (New York City) | Investigators recovered "computers, a card printer, and various counterfeit OSHA and SST cards"; one defendant allegedly made fake cards sold "for between $200 and $650 per card." Two co-defendants were authorized OSHA trainers who, according to the investigation, did not provide the required trainings. The case began when NYCHA found cards with discrepancies "as part of a routine check" | Yes, if you verify with the issuer rather than the card | Brooklyn DA and NYC DOI, April 17, 2023 |
| Genuine cards for training that never happened (New York City) | An authorized provider's owner and an associate allegedly agreed to provide SST and OSHA cards "for $500 each" without the training, had undercover investigators sign attendance sheets, and reported false completions, so "OSHA's intermediary issued the 'students' OSHA cards and DOB issued SST cards" | No: the card is real until the issuer acts | Brooklyn DA and NYC DOI, September 8, 2026 |
| Invalidation after the fact | The Department of Buildings is "immediately invalidating all Site Safety Training (SST) certificates issued by Redcode Inc.," with a grace period "through December 7, 2026" to retrain | Only if you re-check after hire | NYC DOB SST worker information |
| Unauthorized "OSHA" courses | OSHA: "there has been an increase in fraudulent activity related to these courses over the past several years," and "only OSHA-authorized trainers can issue course completion cards" | Yes, against OSHA's list of authorized providers | OSHA, The Facts About Obtaining an OSHA Card |
| A trade license used by someone else (Maryland) | A master electrician "allowed the unlicensed individual to use his license to obtain permits for electrical jobs in which the master was not involved"; the board adopted a recommended revocation and a $20,000 civil penalty, and $5,000 for the unlicensed individual | No: the license itself is valid | Maryland State Board of Electricians, February 24, 2026 minutes |
| Crews supplied through shell companies (Florida) | Shell companies supplied mostly undocumented workers to contractors and subcontractors and "rented" workers' compensation policies to them; paying through the shells let the firms "disclaim responsibility for ensuring the workers were legally authorized to work in the U.S." Two people were sentenced | No: nothing about the worker's card is wrong | ICE, May 31, 2018 (archived) |
The 2023 and 2026 New York cases are indictments; an indictment is an accusation, and everyone charged is presumed innocent. What they show for hiring is the mechanism. In the 2026 case the fraud happened at the training provider, so the cards that resulted pass every check a contractor could run on the card itself.
Why doesn't a genuine-looking card settle it?
Because the card answers "was a card issued?", not "did this person learn this?" or even "is this the person it was issued to?" Three habits close most of the gap:
- Verify through the issuer, and match the face. OSHA does not keep a national database; its Outreach FAQ says to "scan the QR code on the back of the card to verify the training," which leads to the Education Center that processed it. In New York City, the SST card's QR code, when scanned, "displays a photograph of the holder, the SST ID number and other information regarding the training" (2023 release above), so compare that photo to the worker in front of you.
- Treat the card as a floor, not proof of skill. OSHA's Outreach courses are hazard awareness training, and the employer still has to instruct each worker on its own site's hazards under 29 CFR 1926.21(b)(2). Your site orientation and a supervised first shift are where untrained workers show.
- Re-check after hire. When a provider's cards are invalidated, a card you accepted in the spring can be void by the fall. Workers who paid a provider in good faith may be victims too; treat an invalidation as a retraining deadline, not an accusation.
How do borrowed trade licenses work, and how do you check?
A trade license belongs to a person and, for contractors, to a business. The fraud is rarely a forged license; it is a valid license number used by someone else, a journeyman presented as a master, or an apprentice working outside supervision. The check is the same in every state: get the license number, look it up on the state board's own site, and confirm that the name, license class, status and any discipline match the person you are hiring and the work you are assigning. The state-by-state routes are in how to verify an electrician license, plumber license and HVAC license. Crane operators and welders are certified by national bodies with their own lookups: see how to verify an NCCCO certification and how to verify a welding certification.
Who checks identity and work authorization when crews come through subcontractors?
For your own hires, you do: Form I-9 by the third business day of work, accepting documents that reasonably appear to be genuine and to relate to the person, without asking for particular documents (see how to spot fake I-9 documents and I-9 document abuse). If you use E-Verify, its photo matching step compares the photo on certain List A documents with the photo DHS holds (E-Verify photo matching), and some states require E-Verify for public contracts or for private employers above a set size (E-Verify requirements by state).
For a subcontractor's crew, the subcontractor completes Form I-9 for its own employees (see Form I-9 for independent contractors and subcontractors). The limit is in 8 U.S.C. 1324a(a)(4): a company that "uses a contract, subcontract, or exchange ... to obtain the labor of an alien in the United States knowing that the alien is an unauthorized alien" is treated as having hired that worker unlawfully. The Florida case in the table shows why "they are the sub's people" is not a defense when the paperwork is a shell. Practical diligence that does not require you to inspect anyone's immigration documents:
- Put Form I-9 (and E-Verify where your state or contract requires it) in the subcontract, with a right to request compliance confirmation.
- Confirm a sub's workers' compensation coverage with the insurer or the state's coverage lookup, not only from a certificate the sub sends.
- Compare the crew on site with the sub's roster and badges every day, using the same photo ID check for everyone who enters.
- Act on what you learn. Knowledge is the trigger in 1324a(a)(4), so a tip or a document problem needs a documented response, not silence.
What checks should a contractor or construction staffing agency run?
- Screen: ask for each card and license by name and number, with the trainer or issuing board.
- Before the offer or start: verify every card with its issuer (QR code, trainer, Education Center, DOB for SST cards) and every license on the state board's lookup.
- Identity: check a government photo ID live at a fixed stage for every hire, and match the exact name on each card and license to it.
- Form I-9 by day three of work, and E-Verify within its own deadline if you are enrolled (the E-Verify three-day rule).
- First shift: site orientation and a supervised skills check before anyone runs equipment or works unsupervised at height.
- Subcontractors: written compliance terms, insurance confirmed independently, roster checked against the site.
- Re-check: card dates against the state or city rule, license renewal dates, and issuer invalidation notices.
- Document each check: date, source, who ran it, result.
What should recruiters ask on the screen?
Lawful, job-related questions, asked of every candidate for the role:
"Which safety cards do you hold: OSHA 10 or 30, and which course
(Construction or General Industry)? Who was the trainer?"
"For New York City sites: do you have an SST card, and when does
it expire?"
"Which trade license do you hold, in which state, at what level,
and what is the number? We look every license up with the board."
"Before your first shift we verify each card and license with the
issuer and complete Form I-9. Is there anything that would delay
that for you?"
More role questions are in construction laborer screening questions and the interview guide for construction roles.
What should you do when something doesn't match?
- Hold the assignment that depends on the credential, without accusing anyone. Cards can take time to arrive and people lose wallets.
- Verify through an independent channel: the QR code, the trainer, the Education Center, DOB for SST cards, the state board for licenses.
- Ask the worker neutrally for an explanation, such as a replacement card, a name change or a recent class.
- Report card fraud through OSHA's routes: its FAQ lists [email protected] and the outreach fraud hotline, 847-725-7804, and its card facts page points to the Labor Department's Office of Inspector General. Report license misuse to the state licensing board.
- Keep the record of what you saw and when; how to report candidate fraud lists what to keep.
How do you keep these checks fair?
- Same checks, same stage, every candidate. Not only for workers who trained at a particular school or came through a particular sub.
- Never screen on national origin, accent or citizenship status. Form I-9 rules are the same for everyone, and asking some workers for more or different documents is unlawful (citizenship status discrimination in hiring).
- Use the FCRA when a screening company verifies for you. A call you make to a trainer or a board lookup is your own check; a vendor's report is a consumer report (the FCRA process).
What changes for construction staffing agencies?
- Both of you are responsible for safety. OSHA treats the agency and the host contractor as joint employers of temps (OSHA rules for temporary workers). Agree in writing who verifies which card and who runs site training; check your contract rather than assuming.
- The agency is the employer for Form I-9 and, where it is enrolled or required, E-Verify.
- Never place a temp on licensed work (electrical, plumbing, crane operation) until the license or certification is verified for that person.
- Send facts, not documents: "OSHA 10 Construction, issued [date] by [trainer], confirmed with [Education Center] on [date]."
Construction hiring fraud checklist
[ ] Government photo ID checked live; exact legal name recorded
[ ] Each OSHA card verified with the issuer (QR code or trainer)
[ ] Course matches the work (Construction vs General Industry)
[ ] NYC sites: SST card scanned; photo matches the worker
[ ] Trade license found on the state board under that name
[ ] License class and status match the assigned work
[ ] Crane, welding or other certifications checked with the issuer
[ ] Form I-9 complete by day three; E-Verify if enrolled
[ ] Site orientation and supervised skills check before solo work
[ ] Subcontract: I-9 and E-Verify terms; insurance confirmed
[ ] Site roster matched to badges daily
[ ] Re-check dates set: card rules, license renewals, invalidations
[ ] Each check documented: date, source, who, result
Not legal advice. Brooklyn District Attorney and NYC Department of Investigation releases, NYC Department of Buildings, OSHA, Maryland State Board of Electricians, ICE and U.S. Code sources checked as of November 2026.
Questions people ask
How can I tell if a construction worker's OSHA 10 card is fake?
Verify it with the issuer, not by looking at it. OSHA does not run a national card database; for a plastic card, scan the QR code on the back, which leads to the OSHA Training Institute Education Center that processed the card, or contact the authorized trainer who issued it. Check that the course matches the work (Construction, not General Industry) and that any online provider is on OSHA's list of authorized online providers. In New York City sites that need Site Safety Training, the SST card is the one that matters, and scanning its QR code shows the holder's photograph.
Can a worker have a real SST or OSHA card without doing the training?
Yes, according to a September 2026 Brooklyn indictment. Prosecutors allege that an authorized training company sold SST and OSHA cards for $500 each to undercover investigators who never took the classes, then reported false completions, so OSHA's intermediary and the New York City Department of Buildings issued genuine cards. The Department of Buildings invalidated that company's SST certificates, with a grace period through December 7, 2026 for workers to retrain. An indictment is an accusation, not proof of guilt.
Do I have to complete Form I-9 for my subcontractor's workers?
No. Each employer completes Form I-9 for its own employees, so a subcontractor completes it for its crew. The limit is in 8 U.S.C. 1324a(a)(4): a company that uses a contract or subcontract to obtain the labor of a worker it knows is not authorized to work is treated as having hired that worker unlawfully. Put compliance duties in the subcontract and act on what you learn.
Can an electrician let someone else work under their license?
State licensing boards treat it as a serious violation. In a case in the Maryland State Board of Electricians' minutes for February 24, 2026, a master electrician allowed an unlicensed person to use his license to obtain permits for jobs he was not involved in; the board adopted a recommended revocation and a $20,000 civil penalty, plus a $5,000 penalty for the unlicensed person. For hiring, look the license up on the state board and confirm it belongs to the person doing the work.