Candidate fraud in insurance hiring: licenses, exam cheating and prohibited persons under 18 U.S.C. 1033, and how insurers check
On this page
- What fraud patterns show up in insurance hiring?
- What does 18 U.S.C. 1033 actually prohibit?
- What does the 1033 consent process look like for an employer?
- When can you ask about criminal history for an insurance job?
- How do regulators treat licensing exam cheating?
- What should recruiters ask on the screen?
- What checks should an insurer or agency run, by stage?
- What should staffing agencies placing insurance workers do?
- What should you do when something doesn't match?
- Insurance hiring fraud checklist
- Questions people ask
Candidate fraud in insurance hiring falls into three groups, as of November 2026: licenses that are fake, lapsed or narrower than claimed; licenses obtained by cheating on the state exam; and undisclosed criminal history that makes a candidate a "prohibited person" under federal law. Under 18 U.S.C. 1033(e), a person convicted of a felony involving dishonesty or breach of trust may not willfully work in the business of insurance without a regulator's written consent, and an individual in the business who willfully permits it faces up to five years in prison, plus civil penalties of up to $50,000 per violation, or the compensation involved if greater, under 18 U.S.C. 1034. Insurers check with the state license lookups, a background check run at the stage fair chance laws allow, a 1033 consent check for anyone with a qualifying conviction, and an identity check matched to the license.
How to run the license lookup itself (NIPR, the NAIC lookup, state department sites, appointments) is in how to verify an insurance license; securities registrations for variable products are in how to verify a securities license on BrokerCheck. This page is about the fraud patterns and the federal prohibited-person rule.
What fraud patterns show up in insurance hiring?
| Pattern | What it looks like | The check that catches it | Source |
|---|---|---|---|
| Fake, lapsed or narrower license | A screenshot or printout instead of a record you find yourself; lines of authority that do not cover the job; a resident license only | Your own lookup on the state or national producer database, matched to verified identity | License verification steps |
| Exam cheating or a proxy test-taker | A genuine license obtained by cheating; the license looks normal until the regulator acts | Re-checks of license status; performance against what the exam tests; regulator actions | Rhode Island DBR consent agreement 2025-IN-009 |
| Undisclosed prohibited-person status | A felony conviction involving dishonesty or breach of trust, and no written consent from a regulator | Background check at the lawful stage; a 1033 question and consent check | 18 U.S.C. 1033(e) |
| Borrowed identity for remote roles | A different person on the call, in onboarding or at the licensing exam than on the application | Identity check at a fixed stage; the same person confirmed at each step | Identity verification checklist |
What does 18 U.S.C. 1033 actually prohibit?
- The prohibited person. "Any individual who has been convicted of any criminal felony involving dishonesty or a breach of trust, or who has been convicted of an offense under this section, and who willfully engages in the business of insurance whose activities affect interstate commerce or participates in such business" faces a fine, up to 5 years in prison, or both (1033(e)(1)(A)).
- The person who lets it happen. Any individual "engaged in the business of insurance" who "willfully permits the participation" faces the same penalty (1033(e)(1)(B)).
- The consent. A prohibited person may work in the business with "the written consent of any insurance regulatory official authorized to regulate the insurer, which consent specifically refers to this subsection" (1033(e)(2)).
- Who is covered. The "business of insurance" includes the activities of persons who act as or are "officers, directors, agents, or employees of insurers" (1033(f)(1)), so the rule reaches beyond licensed producers.
- Civil penalties. The Attorney General may seek "a civil penalty of not more than $50,000 for each violation or the amount of compensation which the person received or offered for the prohibited conduct, whichever amount is greater" (18 U.S.C. 1034(a)).
The statute does not list which felonies involve "dishonesty or a breach of trust." State regulators describe the categories. California's Department of Insurance says dishonesty includes "any offense involving perjury, bribery, forgery" and that breach of trust covers misuse or misappropriation of property held as a fiduciary; it also counts a qualifying felony conviction set aside under Penal Code 1203.4, while treating completed deferred adjudication as not a conviction (CDI definitions). Other states define it their own way, so use the consenting state's page.
What does the 1033 consent process look like for an employer?
State insurance departments run it, and their pages say more about employers than the statute does:
- California. A prohibited person "must file a 1033 consent waiver application" and pay the fee before engaging in the business of insurance in California, and insurers and producers must "make a diligent effort to identify employees or prospective employees who may be prohibited persons." The department lists officers, directors, employees, agents, brokers, consultants, third-party administrators, managing general agents and subcontractors among those who may need consent (CDI filing requirement).
- Idaho. Felony convictions involving dishonesty or breach of trust require a 1033 review "PRIOR to submission of application" to the department, and applicants "should not test or fingerprint or submit a licensing application" until then; the request includes legal documentation for all criminal matters and at least three letters of recommendation (Idaho Department of Insurance).
For hiring, that means: build the 1033 step into the offer timeline, because the consent comes from the regulator, not from you, and the person may not start in the business until they have it.
When can you ask about criminal history for an insurance job?
Only at the stage your state and city allow. Fair chance laws still apply to insurance employers unless an exception fits. California's Fair Chance Act, for example, excludes positions where an employer is required by state, federal or local law to run criminal background checks or to restrict employment based on criminal history (Government Code 12952(d), summarized in ban the box in California); whether a given insurance role fits that kind of exception is a question for counsel. Where a state or city requires an individualized assessment and notice, follow it (see individualized assessment for criminal history). The EEOC rescinded its 2012 arrest and conviction records guidance on October 28, 2026 (EEOC press release); Title VII still applies, and state and city fair chance rules are untouched. When a screening company runs the check, follow the FCRA (see the FCRA background check process).
How do regulators treat licensing exam cheating?
As a reason to refuse or revoke a license. Rhode Island's producer licensing law lists "Cheating on an examination for an insurance license" among the causes for license action (R.I. Gen. Laws 27-2.4-16(a)(11), quoted in the agreement below). In consent agreement 2025-IN-009, the Rhode Island Department of Business Regulation reviewed remote proctoring video showing "a third-party individual in the room during the exam holding a cellphone up to the computer screen"; the person agreed not to take the state's licensing exams or apply for a license for two years, and afterwards to test only in person (Rhode Island DBR, 2025).
The lesson for employers is the one from other licensed fields: when the cheating happens at the exam, the license that results can look valid. Re-check status on the state lookup at hire, at each appointment and on a schedule, and treat a regulator's action as the trigger, not your own suspicion.
What should recruiters ask on the screen?
Lawful, job-related questions, asked of every candidate, that make the later checks easier:
"Which insurance licenses do you hold, in which states, and with
which lines of authority? What is your National Producer Number?"
"Please give me your full legal name as it appears on your
license, and any previous names on your licensing record."
"This role is in the business of insurance. After an offer, we run
a background check and, where it applies, confirm any written
consent required under federal law before your start date."
Do not ask about criminal history before the stage your fair chance law allows. More role questions are in insurance agent screening questions and claims adjuster screening questions.
What checks should an insurer or agency run, by stage?
- Application: collect the license claims, NPN and legal name.
- Before the offer: look up each license yourself and confirm the lines of authority match the job.
- At the lawful stage: run the background check, and for anyone with a felony conviction involving dishonesty or breach of trust, confirm written consent under 1033(e)(2) or start the state's consent process.
- Before the start date: verify identity live and match it to the license record; complete appointments where the state requires them.
- After hire: re-check license status on a schedule and at renewal.
- Document each check: date, source, who, result.
What should staffing agencies placing insurance workers do?
- Agree who runs which check with the client: license lookups, the background check, the 1033 consent step. Check your contract rather than assuming.
- Remember 1033 reaches employees, not only producers: a temp in claims or operations at an insurer can be covered.
- Re-verify per assignment, because lines of authority and nonresident licenses vary by state.
- Report facts to the client when a check changes.
What should you do when something doesn't match?
- Hold the start or the appointment, without accusing anyone.
- Verify through an independent channel: the state department's lookup again, the national producer database, the court record behind a background check result.
- Ask the candidate neutrally for an explanation, and give the notices your fair chance law and the FCRA require before any adverse decision.
- Report a forged license to the insurance department of the state named on it; see how to report candidate fraud.
Insurance hiring fraud checklist
[ ] License claims, NPN and legal name collected
[ ] Each license looked up yourself; lines of authority match the job
[ ] Government photo ID checked live and matched to the license record
[ ] Background check run at the stage fair chance laws allow
[ ] Felony involving dishonesty or breach of trust: 1033 written consent
confirmed, or the state consent process started before the start date
[ ] FCRA disclosure, authorization and adverse action steps followed
[ ] Appointments completed where the state requires them
[ ] Re-check dates set: renewal, new assignment, periodic review
[ ] Each check documented: date, source, who, result
Not legal advice. Federal statutes, state insurance department pages and the regulator's order checked as of November 2026.
Questions people ask
What is a 1033 waiver in insurance?
It is the written consent described in 18 U.S.C. 1033(e)(2). A person convicted of a felony involving dishonesty or breach of trust, or of an offense under section 1033, commits a federal crime by willfully engaging or participating in the business of insurance affecting interstate commerce, unless they have the written consent of an insurance regulatory official authorized to regulate the insurer. State insurance departments run the consent process; California, for example, requires a prohibited person to file a 1033 consent waiver application and pay the fee before engaging in the business of insurance there.
Can an insurer be penalized for hiring someone who needs 1033 consent?
Yes. Section 1033(e)(1)(B) makes it a crime, with up to five years in prison, for an individual engaged in the business of insurance to willfully permit a prohibited person's participation, and 18 U.S.C. 1034 lets the Attorney General seek, against any person whose conduct is a 1033 offense, a civil penalty of up to $50,000 per violation or the compensation involved, whichever is greater. California's Department of Insurance says insurers and producers must make a diligent effort to identify employees or prospective employees who may be prohibited persons.
Does 18 U.S.C. 1033 apply only to licensed insurance agents?
No. The statute defines the business of insurance to include the activities of officers, directors, agents and employees of insurers, so it can reach unlicensed staff such as claims, underwriting and operations employees. California's Department of Insurance lists officers, directors, employees, agents, brokers, consultants, third-party administrators, managing general agents and subcontractors among those who may be prohibited persons.
What happens if a candidate cheats on an insurance licensing exam?
State regulators treat it as grounds to refuse or revoke a license. Rhode Island's law lists cheating on an examination for an insurance license among the causes for license action, and in a 2025 consent agreement the Rhode Island Department of Business Regulation barred a person, whose remote exam video showed a third party holding a phone up to the screen, from taking the state's licensing exams or applying for a license for two years.