Expunged and sealed records in background checks: do they show up, and can employers use them? (2026)
On this page
- What do expunged, sealed and set aside mean?
- Do expunged or sealed records show up on background checks?
- Can employers use expunged or sealed records?
- How should your application and post-offer question be worded?
- What should you do if a report shows an expunged or sealed record?
- What should recruiters and staffing agencies do?
- A quick checklist
- Questions people ask
Expunged and sealed records should not appear on an employment background check, and in most states that address them, employers may not ask about or use them. Once a court or state repository seals or expunges a case, official searches stop returning it, but commercial databases may still hold an older copy, so they do sometimes show up; when they do, the federal Fair Credit Reporting Act treats reporting the wrong status as an accuracy problem the candidate can dispute (15 U.S.C. § 1681e(b); § 1681k). As of November 2026, California, New York, Illinois, Massachusetts, Pennsylvania and Michigan all bar or limit employer use and let candidates leave these records off, with exceptions for jobs where a law requires a fingerprint check.
This page explains the terms, why old records leak into reports, what each of those states says, and what to do when one appears. Records that are open rather than closed are on pending charges in background checks, and the general time limits are on the seven-year rule.
Not legal advice. This summarizes the federal statutes and the state laws linked below as published in November 2026. Each state's relief works differently and laws change; confirm the current text and get advice from an employment lawyer before acting on a specific record.
What do expunged, sealed and set aside mean?
Each state uses its own words for clearing a record, and the employer rules follow those words. The common ones:
| Term | What it usually means | Examples in state law |
|---|---|---|
| Expunged | The record is removed or destroyed from official files | Pennsylvania expungement (18 Pa.C.S. 9122); Illinois "expunged" records under the Criminal Identification Act |
| Sealed | The record still exists but is closed to most of the public, including most employers | New York sealing, including automatic sealing under the Clean Slate Act (CPL 160.57); Massachusetts sealing (c. 276, § 100A) |
| Limited access | Pennsylvania's form of sealing: the record is withheld from most non-criminal-justice requesters | 18 Pa.C.S. 9122.1 (petition) and 9122.2 (Clean Slate) |
| Set aside | The conviction is treated as if it did not happen for most purposes | Michigan, including automatic set-aside (MCL 780.621g, 780.622) |
| Dismissed or relief granted | The conviction is judicially dismissed after the sentence, or relief is granted automatically | California Penal Code 1203.4 and 1203.425, both named in Labor Code 432.7 |
Do expunged or sealed records show up on background checks?
Official searches should not return them. Massachusetts, for example, directs its records office to "report that no record exists" when an authorized requester asks about a sealed record (c. 276, § 100A). The leaks come from three places:
- Old copies. A screening company's database, or a data broker it buys from, may have copied a court record before it was sealed. Why database hits need checking at the source is explained on national criminal database searches.
- Relief not yet processed. New York's Clean Slate Act took effect November 16, 2024 (the bill was signed November 16, 2023 and took effect one year later), and the court system must finish sealing older eligible convictions "no later than three years after such effective date," that is, by November 16, 2027 (CPL 160.57(6); S7551A, chapter 631). Until a record is sealed it can still appear.
- Fingerprint checks required by law. Sealing does not hide a record from everyone. New York lets employers that a state or federal law requires to run a fingerprint-based check receive convictions sealed under the Clean Slate Act (CPL 160.57(1)(d)(vii)), and Illinois allows sealed felony convictions to be requested and used where state or federal law requires a background check (775 ILCS 5/2-103(A)).
Under federal law, a screening company must "follow reasonable procedures to assure maximum possible accuracy" (§ 1681e(b)), and one that reports public records for employment must either notify the candidate at the time or keep strict procedures so the records are "complete and up to date," which for convictions means reporting their "current public record status" (§ 1681k(a)). The CFPB's 2024 advisory opinion that said screening companies need procedures to keep expunged and sealed records out of reports was withdrawn on May 12, 2025 (90 FR 20084); the statute itself did not change.
Can employers use expunged or sealed records?
No federal statute speaks to expunged records in hiring, and Title VII still applies to criminal history decisions after the EEOC rescinded its 2012 guidance on October 28, 2026. The real limits are in state law. Each row was checked in the state's official code in November 2026; it is not a survey of every state.
| State | What employers may not do | What the candidate may answer | Main exceptions | Source |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| California | Ask about, "seek from any source whatsoever, or utilize" a conviction "judicially dismissed or ordered sealed," including under Penal Code 1203.4, 1203.4a, 1203.425, 1203.45 and 1210.1 | The question may not be asked | Peace officer and criminal justice agency jobs (432.7(e)) | Lab. Code 432.7 |
| Illinois | Inquire into or use an "arrest record," which includes records "ordered expunged, sealed, or impounded" | The question may not be asked | Sealed felony convictions where state or federal law requires a background check | 775 ILCS 5/1-103(B-5); 5/2-103 |
| Massachusetts | Request or keep information about "a criminal record, or anything related to a criminal record, that has been sealed or expunged" | "No record"; an application that asks about arrests or convictions must say so | Law enforcement agencies, courts and public appointing authorities can still get sealed records from the records office (c. 276, § 100A) | c. 151B, § 4(9)(iv); c. 276, § 100A |
| Michigan | Treat the person as convicted: after a set-aside order or an automatic set-aside, the person "is considered not to have been previously convicted" | Not previously convicted, for most purposes | Those listed in MCL 780.622 and 780.623 | MCL 780.622(1) |
| New York | Ask about or act on sealed convictions (CPL 160.55, 160.58, 160.59 and Clean Slate 160.57), favorable terminations, adjournments in contemplation of dismissal and youthful offender findings | "May respond as if the arrest, criminal accusation, or disposition ... did not occur" | Police and peace officer jobs; Clean Slate records accessed through a legally required fingerprint check | Exec. Law § 296(16) |
| Pennsylvania | Require or request disclosure of expunged or limited-access records, or use them "for employment" | "May respond as if the offense did not occur" | Where federal law requires considering criminal history | 18 Pa.C.S. § 9122.5 |
Pennsylvania also protects employers: one that hires a person whose record was expunged or given limited access is immune from claims arising from that person's misconduct when it relates to the cleared record, and an employer is immune from claims under the use ban for otherwise lawful use of information the person disclosed voluntarily (18 Pa.C.S. § 9122.6). The state-by-state detail is on each state's page, for example New York and Pennsylvania background check laws.
How should your application and post-offer question be worded?
Most problems start with a question that is too broad. Ask only what the job's location allows, at the stage it allows, and tell candidates what to leave out. Massachusetts goes further: any application that asks about prior arrests or convictions must include the statute's statement that an applicant with a sealed record "may answer 'no record'" (c. 276, § 100A). An example to adapt with counsel:
CRIMINAL HISTORY QUESTION (example; ask only where and when the law allows)
Have you been convicted of a crime?
[ ] No [ ] Yes
Do not include: arrests that did not lead to a conviction; cases that
were dismissed, expunged, sealed, set aside, given limited access or
otherwise cleared by a court or by law; juvenile or youthful offender
matters. You may answer as if those matters did not occur.
[Massachusetts applications: add the sealed-record statement required
by G.L. c. 276, section 100A, word for word.]
A conviction does not automatically disqualify you. We consider it only
as it relates to this job, and you will have a chance to respond.
What should you do if a report shows an expunged or sealed record?
- Stop and set it aside. Do not factor it in while you check. In California, New York, Illinois, Massachusetts and Pennsylvania the use itself is the violation.
- Ask the screening company to re-verify at the court. Get the current status in writing.
- Tell the candidate if the report is leaning you toward a no. Send the FCRA pre-adverse action notice with a copy of the report and the summary of rights (see the FCRA background check process). The candidate can dispute the item with the screening company, which must reinvestigate and record the current status or delete the item within 30 days of receiving the dispute (15 U.S.C. § 1681i(a)(1)).
- Do not ask the candidate to prove the expungement in states where you may not ask about the record at all; let the screening company and the court records settle it.
- Record the correction, not the record. Note that the item was reported in error and removed, without copying its details into your ATS.
What should recruiters and staffing agencies do?
- Scrub your scripts. Phone-screen and intake questions should not ask "have you ever been arrested" or "has any record been expunged." If a candidate volunteers a cleared record, do not note it.
- Apply the job location's law. A New York placement brings Executive Law 296(16) even if the agency is elsewhere; a Massachusetts application needs the "no record" statement.
- Ask vendors how they handle cleared records. In writing: how often their database is refreshed against court records, whether every hit is verified at the source before it is reported, and how they apply Clean Slate sealing.
- Agree who corrects what. If the client decides on placements, the contract should say who receives a dispute and who re-runs the check, so a corrected report reaches the person deciding.
A quick checklist
[ ] Application and post-offer questions exclude cleared records
[ ] Massachusetts applications carry the c. 276, s. 100A statement
[ ] Screening vendor verifies database hits at the court before reporting
[ ] Any expunged or sealed item on a report is set aside, not used
[ ] Pre-adverse notice, report copy and summary of rights before any no
[ ] Dispute outcome recorded; corrected report sent to the decision maker
[ ] Fingerprint-required roles identified (sealed records may be visible)
Questions people ask
Do expunged records show up on employment background checks?
They should not, but they sometimes do. Once a court or state repository seals or expunges a record, official searches stop returning it, but commercial databases may hold copies made earlier. The FCRA requires screening companies to follow reasonable procedures for maximum possible accuracy and to report the current status of public records they use for employment, so an expunged case that appears is an error the candidate can dispute.
Can an employer use a sealed conviction if it appears on a background report?
In many states, no. California Labor Code 432.7 bars employers from seeking or using convictions that were judicially dismissed or ordered sealed, New York Executive Law 296(16) bars acting on sealed convictions, Illinois treats expunged and sealed records as a protected arrest record, and Pennsylvania says expunged and limited-access records may not be used for employment unless federal law requires it. This is general information as of November 2026, not legal advice.
Do I have to disclose an expunged record on a job application?
Usually not, in the states that address it. New York and Pennsylvania let a person respond as if the matter did not occur, Michigan treats a person whose conviction was set aside as not previously convicted, and Massachusetts requires applications that ask about criminal history to tell applicants with sealed records they may answer 'no record.' Jobs that require fingerprint-based checks by law can be an exception.
What should an employer do if a background check shows an expunged conviction?
Do not use it. Ask the screening company to re-verify the record with the court, and if you were leaning toward a no for any reason tied to the report, send the FCRA pre-adverse action notice with a copy of the report and the summary of rights so the candidate can dispute it. The screening company must reinvestigate a dispute within 30 days under 15 U.S.C. 1681i.