Consent and compliance

Pending charges in background checks: what employers may consider, and the state and city limits (2026)

On this page
  1. What counts as a pending charge?
  2. What does federal law allow?
  3. Which states and cities limit the use of pending charges?
  4. How should you evaluate a pending charge you are allowed to consider?
  5. What should recruiters and staffing agencies do?
  6. An example post-offer question, where the law allows it
  7. Pending charges at a glance
  8. Questions people ask

A pending charge is a criminal case that has been filed but not yet resolved. Under federal law a background screening company may report it, because the Fair Credit Reporting Act allows records of arrest for seven years from the date of entry (15 U.S.C. § 1681c(a)(2)), and no federal statute forbids an employer from considering it, though Title VII still applies and a charge is not a conviction. As of November 2026, state and city laws decide most of the answer: Wisconsin allows a refusal to hire only when the charge "substantially relate[s]" to the job, New York City requires its Fair Chance Process after a conditional offer, California lets employers ask about an arrest pending trial, and Hawaii and Pennsylvania limit employers to convictions.

This page covers hiring decisions about job candidates. The time limits for older records are on the seven-year rule, charges filed against people you already employ are on continuous criminal monitoring, and the review you write up before a decision is on individualized assessments.

Not legal advice. This summarizes the federal statutes and the state and city laws linked below as published in November 2026. Criminal history rules vary by state and city and change often; confirm the current text and get advice from an employment lawyer before acting on a specific case.

What counts as a pending charge?

Any criminal accusation that has not reached a final outcome: an arrest the prosecutor has not yet declined, a complaint or indictment awaiting trial, or a case on appeal. Some laws define it more closely. New York City's Commission on Human Rights treats a "pending case" as a criminal action not concluded at the time of the employer's review, and says a case adjourned in contemplation of dismissal is not pending unless the adjournment is revoked and the case restored to the calendar (NYC Commission on Human Rights, Fair Chance Act legal guidance). New York State uses the same rule for adjournments in Executive Law § 296(16).

The distinction matters because a pending case can end in dismissal or acquittal. In a 1957 bar admission case the Supreme Court said "the mere fact that a man has been arrested has very little, if any, probative value in showing that he has engaged in any misconduct" (Schware v. Board of Bar Examiners). A filed charge carries more weight than a bare arrest, but it is still an accusation, which is why several laws below allow action only when the alleged offense relates closely to the job.

What does federal law allow?

  • Reporting. A screening company may report records of arrest that are less than seven years old from the date of entry, or older if the statute of limitations has not run (§ 1681c(a)(2)). The limit does not apply at all to a job paying $75,000 a year or more (§ 1681c(b)(3)).
  • Current status. A screening company that reports public records for employment must either tell the candidate at the time or keep strict procedures so the record is complete and up to date; arrests and indictments count as up to date only "if the current public record status of the item at the time of the report is reported" (15 U.S.C. § 1681k(a)). A charge that was dismissed last month should not appear as pending.
  • Notices. If the report leads you toward a no, the FCRA's pre-adverse and adverse action steps apply, as for any other item (see the FCRA background check process).
  • Title VII. The EEOC rescinded its 2012 guidance on arrest and conviction records on October 28, 2026. Title VII itself, including its disparate impact provision (42 U.S.C. § 2000e-2(k)), still applies, and courts decide those claims. Weighing the Green factors from the 1975 Eighth Circuit case (the nature and gravity of the offense, the time since it, and the nature of the job) remains a sound way to make and document a decision.

Which states and cities limit the use of pending charges?

Each row was checked in the official code or the enforcing agency's guidance in November 2026. It covers the laws we confirmed and is not a survey of every state; many states have no rule on pending charges at all.

PlaceRule on pending charges for applicantsSource
CaliforniaNo asking about, seeking or using arrests that did not lead to conviction, but the law "shall not prevent an employer from asking" about an arrest for which the person is out on bail or on their own recognizance pending trial; conviction-history questions wait until after a conditional offer under the Fair Chance ActLab. Code 432.7(a)(1)
Hawaii"Arrest and court record" is a protected basis and includes being "charged with an offense"; employers may consider only conviction records with a rational relationship to the job, after a conditional offerHRS 378-1; HRS 378-2.5
IllinoisNo inquiring into or using "an arrest not leading to a conviction"; the Act has no stated pending-charge exception, but does not stop an employer from using "other information which indicates that a person actually engaged in the conduct"775 ILCS 5/2-103; 5/1-103(B-5)
MassachusettsEmployers may not ask about an arrest or disposition "in which no conviction resulted"; the state's standard-access CORI report for employers includes "pending criminal charges," including cases continued without a finding until dismissedc. 151B, § 4(9); c. 6, § 172(a)(3)
MichiganNo requesting or keeping records of a misdemeanor arrest or disposition without conviction; the section "does not apply to information relative to a felony charge before conviction or dismissal"MCL 37.2205a(1)
New York StateThe ban on asking about or acting on arrests covers those "not then pending" that ended in the person's favor or were sealed; pending cases fall outside that banExec. Law § 296(16)
New York CityNo questions about pending cases until after a conditional offer; to withdraw an offer over a pending case, the employer must apply the NYC Fair Chance Factors and follow the Fair Chance ProcessNYC Commission on Human Rights guidance; NYC Fair Chance Act guide
PennsylvaniaAn employer using state criminal history record information on an applicant may consider "felony and misdemeanor convictions" only, and only as they relate to suitability for the job; written notice if the decision is based on it18 Pa.C.S. § 9125
PhiladelphiaNo inquiry or adverse action over an arrest or accusation "which is not then pending" and did not result in conviction; for current employees, section 9-3503(2) allows questions about a pending charge only with reasonably reliable information that it relates to the job, and adverse action only where continued employment would be an unacceptable riskBill 250373-A, § 9-3503
WisconsinEmployers may ask about "a record of a pending charge" (but no other arrests), and may refuse to hire someone "subject to a pending criminal charge if the circumstances of the charge substantially relate to the circumstances of the particular job"Wis. Stat. 111.335(2)(a)–(b)

Two patterns stand out. Some laws protect "arrests that did not lead to conviction" without saying what happens while a case is open (Illinois, Massachusetts' chapter 151B); others name pending charges and allow them, usually with a job-relatedness test (Wisconsin, Michigan for felonies, New York State outside the city). Where the text is silent, ask counsel before treating a pending case as fair game.

How should you evaluate a pending charge you are allowed to consider?

  1. Check the stage. Under fair chance laws the question waits until after a conditional offer (for example New York City, and California for conviction history). Do not ask in the interview unless the law of the job's location allows it.
  2. Confirm the current status. Pull the court docket or ask the screening company to re-verify. A case can be dismissed, reduced or adjourned between the search and your decision.
  3. Ask the candidate. Give them the report and a chance to explain. New York City requires this as part of its Fair Chance Process; elsewhere it is still the best way to catch a wrong match.
  4. Compare the allegation with the duties. Write down the specific duties, the alleged offense, and why one bears on the other. "Substantially relate" in Wisconsin and the NYC Fair Chance Factors both look at this link, not at the charge in the abstract.
  5. Consider the timing options. Some employers revisit the decision when the case resolves, or fill the role in a way that does not depend on the outcome. Whatever you choose, apply it the same way to every candidate with a similar charge.
  6. Send the notices. FCRA pre-adverse action with the report and the summary of rights, a reasonable wait, then the adverse action notice (see the pre-adverse action notice), plus any state or city notice, such as New York City's Fair Chance Notice.

What should recruiters and staffing agencies do?

  • Keep it out of the screen. Recruiters should not ask about arrests or open cases on a phone screen. If a candidate volunteers one, do not follow up and do not write it in the ATS or in notes shared with the client.
  • Decide by the job location. A placement in New York City, Philadelphia or Wisconsin brings the rules above, whatever state the agency is in.
  • Settle who decides. The client contract should say who orders the report, who reviews a pending case, and who sends each notice. If the client decides, the agency still owes the notices it is responsible for under the contract and the FCRA.
  • Watch for new charges mid-assignment. For workers already placed, follow the current-employee rules on continuous monitoring, which differ from the hiring rules in New York City and Philadelphia.

An example post-offer question, where the law allows it

An example to adapt with counsel, for use only after a conditional offer and only where the job's location permits asking about pending cases (for example New York City under its Fair Chance Process, or Wisconsin):

CONDITIONAL OFFER: CRIMINAL HISTORY QUESTION (example)

Do you have a criminal case that is currently pending against you?
[ ] No   [ ] Yes

If yes, you may describe the charge, the court and its current status,
and anything you want us to consider. Do not include arrests or cases
that ended in your favor, were dismissed, adjourned in contemplation of
dismissal, sealed, or handled in juvenile or youthful offender
proceedings. A pending case does not automatically disqualify you; we
review it against the duties of this job and will give you a chance to
respond before any decision.

Pending charges at a glance

QuestionShort answer (as of November 2026)Source
Can it be reported?Yes, for seven years from entry or longer if the statute of limitations has not run; no limit at $75,000 or more15 U.S.C. 1681c
Must the status be current?Yes, if the screening company relies on strict procedures rather than notifying the candidate15 U.S.C. 1681k
Federal bar on using it?No statute; Title VII applies; the 2012 EEOC guidance was rescinded42 U.S.C. 2000e-2(k); EEOC
Allowed with a job linkWisconsin; New York State; Michigan (felony charges)Wis. Stat. 111.335; Exec. Law 296(16); MCL 37.2205a
Allowed after an offer, with a set processNew York CityNYC Commission on Human Rights
Convictions onlyHawaii; Pennsylvania (state record information)HRS 378-2.5; 18 Pa.C.S. 9125

Questions people ask

Can a pending charge show up on an employment background check?

Yes, under federal law. The FCRA lets a screening company report records of arrest for seven years from the date of entry, or until the statute of limitations runs if that is longer, and with no time limit for jobs paying $75,000 or more (15 U.S.C. 1681c). Some states narrow what may be reported; New York's General Business Law 380-j, for example, allows non-conviction charges only while they are still pending.

Can an employer refuse to hire someone because of a pending charge?

It depends on the state and city. No federal statute bars it, but Title VII still applies and a charge is not a conviction. Wisconsin allows refusing to hire only when the circumstances of the pending charge substantially relate to the job, New York City requires its Fair Chance Process after a conditional offer, and Hawaii and Pennsylvania let employers consider convictions only. Check the law where the job is before deciding. This is not legal advice.

Can California employers ask job applicants about pending charges?

Narrowly. California Labor Code 432.7 bars asking about or using arrests that did not lead to a conviction, but says it does not prevent an employer from asking about an arrest for which the person is out on bail or on their own recognizance pending trial. The Fair Chance Act separately delays conviction-history questions until after a conditional offer for employers with five or more employees.

Does a pending charge count as a conviction?

No. A pending charge is an accusation that has not been resolved, and it may end in dismissal, acquittal, a lesser plea or a conviction. That is why laws such as Wisconsin's and Philadelphia's let employers act on one only when the alleged offense relates closely to the job, and why the FCRA requires a screening company that reports public records to report their current status.

What should a staffing agency do when a candidate has a pending charge?

Apply the rule of the place where the candidate will work, follow the client contract on who decides, and keep the same process as for any other criminal record: wait for the stage the local fair chance law allows, give the candidate the report and a chance to respond, assess the charge against the actual duties of the assignment, and send FCRA pre-adverse and adverse action notices if the answer is no.