Consent and compliance

Form I-9 for dual citizens: the U.S. citizen box, any document from the Lists, and why the other passport does not count

On this page
  1. Which Section 1 box does a dual citizen check?
  2. Which documents can a dual citizen present?
  3. Why doesn't the other country's passport count?
  4. How do you complete Form I-9 for a dual citizen, step by step?
  5. What changes for E-Verify employers?
  6. Can you ask about the other citizenship?
  7. Does a dual citizen ever need reverification?
  8. What should recruiters and staffing agencies watch for?
  9. A dual-citizen Form I-9 checklist
  10. Questions people ask

A dual citizen who holds U.S. citizenship completes Form I-9 exactly as any other U.S. citizen does. In Section 1 they check "A citizen of the United States," and in Section 2 they may present any document, or combination, from the Lists of Acceptable Documents: a U.S. passport or passport card, or a List B identity document (such as a state driver's license, or a Canadian one) with a List C document (such as a U.S. birth certificate, an unrestricted Social Security card or a Consular Report of Birth Abroad). The other country's passport does not work on its own, because every foreign passport on List A must be paired with an immigration stamp or record that, by USCIS's own chart, goes only to noncitizens. The second citizenship plays no part in Form I-9, and an employer may not ask about it or ask for proof of U.S. citizenship. This reflects the Form I-9 edition dated 01/20/25 and USCIS guidance as of November 2026.

The full document lists are in I-9 List A, B and C documents. Dual citizens born abroad to a U.S. citizen parent may hold one of the citizenship documents covered in the Consular Report of Birth Abroad (FS-240) and Certificates of Citizenship and Naturalization; this page covers what is specific to holding a second nationality.

Not legal advice. This summarizes the Handbook for Employers (M-274), Section 3.0 (last updated April 2, 2025), Section 4.0 (July 15, 2025), Section 6.0 and Section 14.0 (February 4, 2025); the Form I-9, its Lists of Acceptable Documents and its instructions, edition 01/20/25; USCIS's Who Is Issued This Document? chart (September 18, 2026); and Justice Department and E-Verify pages linked below, as checked in November 2026.

Which Section 1 box does a dual citizen check?

The first one: "A citizen of the United States." Holding a second nationality does not change it. The other three boxes are defined so that a U.S. citizen cannot fit them: the Form I-9 instructions describe a lawful permanent resident as "An individual who is not a U.S. citizen" and an alien authorized to work as someone who "is not a U.S. citizen, noncitizen national, or lawful permanent resident." M-274 Section 14.0 adds that U.S. citizens "include persons born in the United States, Puerto Rico, Guam, the U.S. Virgin Islands, and the Commonwealth of the Northern Mariana Islands," and that citizens "too must present the required documents and complete Form I-9."

The box is the employee's choice and the employee's attestation, signed under penalty of perjury. If a new hire asks which box fits, hand them the instructions' definitions rather than choosing for them. Section 1 has no place for a second citizenship, a foreign passport number (that field belongs to the fourth box only) or a country of birth, so nothing about the other nationality goes on the form. Field-by-field help is in Form I-9 Section 1 instructions.

Which documents can a dual citizen present?

Any acceptable document or combination, at the employee's choice. The instructions allow "one selection from List A" or "a combination of one selection from List B and one selection from List C," and the employer "cannot specify which documentation an employee may present."

What the dual citizen presentsAcceptable?Why
Unexpired U.S. passport or U.S. passport cardYesList A item 1; see the U.S. passport card
State driver's license and U.S. birth certificateYesList B item 1 and List C item 3; the birth certificate must be issued by a U.S. state, county, municipal authority or territory and bear an official seal
Canadian driver's license and an unrestricted Social Security cardYesList B item 9 and List C item 1; see the Canadian driver's license
Any List B document and a Consular Report of Birth Abroad (FS-240)YesList C item 2, issued by the State Department to U.S. citizens born abroad
Any List B document and a Certificate of Citizenship or NaturalizationYesList C item 7 under M-274 Section 13.3, not List A
The other country's passport, by itselfNoNot a List B document, and every List A foreign passport needs an immigration stamp or Form I-94 that USCIS's chart marks for noncitizens only
The other country's national ID cardNoList B item 2 covers ID cards from U.S. federal, state or local government agencies, as USCIS's chart words it
A birth certificate issued abroad by the other countryNoList C item 3 covers only birth certificates issued by a U.S. state, county, municipal authority or territory

Why doesn't the other country's passport count?

Because List A names a foreign passport only in three combinations: a foreign passport "that contains a temporary I-551 stamp or temporary I-551 printed notation on a machine-readable immigrant visa" (item 3); a foreign passport with a Form I-94 or I-94A endorsing "the individual's status or parole" for someone "temporarily authorized to work for a specific employer" (item 5); and a passport from the Federated States of Micronesia or the Marshall Islands with a Form I-94 showing admission under the Compact of Free Association (item 6). USCIS's Who Is Issued This Document? chart marks the first combination for lawful permanent residents only and the other two for noncitizens authorized to work only; none is marked for U.S. citizens. For the combinations themselves, see the foreign passport with Form I-94 and Form I-9 for citizens of the Freely Associated States.

If a dual citizen offers only a foreign passport, do not name a replacement. Explain that this passport is not on the Lists for them, give them the Lists of Acceptable Documents, and let them choose. M-274 Section 4.0 says you "must allow the employee to choose which documentation they will present." If they need time to find a document, the deadline is the end of the third business day after the first day of work; if a document was lost, stolen or damaged, a receipt for its replacement can hold the place under the I-9 receipt rule.

How do you complete Form I-9 for a dual citizen, step by step?

  1. After the offer is accepted, give the new hire Form I-9, its instructions and the Lists of Acceptable Documents. M-274 Section 3.0 says you "may not ask an individual who has not accepted a job offer to complete Section 1."
  2. The employee completes Section 1 by the first day of work for pay, checks "A citizen of the United States" and signs. The Social Security number is voluntary unless you use E-Verify.
  3. Review Section 1 for completeness only. The instructions say employers "cannot ask employees for documentation to verify information entered in Section 1."
  4. Within three business days of the first day of work, examine the original documents the employee chooses and decide whether they reasonably appear to be genuine and to relate to the employee. Photocopies are not acceptable, except certified copies of birth certificates.
  5. Record them in Section 2 in the List A column, or in the List B and List C columns, with the title, issuing authority, number and expiration date, if any. Help is in Form I-9 Section 2 instructions.
  6. If you use E-Verify, create the case no later than the third business day after the employee starts work for pay; see the E-Verify three-day rule.
  7. Return the originals. If your company photocopies documents, do it for every employee, not only for those with a second nationality.

What changes for E-Verify employers?

  • List B needs a photo. The instructions say E-Verify employers "must only accept List B documentation that contains a photograph." A Canadian or state driver's license with a photo works.
  • A U.S. passport triggers photo matching. E-Verify's photo matching applies to the U.S. passport and passport card, the Permanent Resident Card and the Employment Authorization Document; see E-Verify photo matching.
  • Naturalized citizens may get an SSA mismatch. A dual citizen who naturalized may still appear as a noncitizen in Social Security records. E-Verify's FAQ on this mismatch says that if the Further Action Notice states "SSA is unable to confirm U.S. citizenship," the employee can call DHS within eight federal government working days with the case number and their "Naturalization Certificate Number or Alien Number (A-Number)," and is "strongly" encouraged to update the SSA record as well. Follow the normal steps in the E-Verify Further Action Notice; do not ask for the naturalization certificate to settle it.

Can you ask about the other citizenship?

Not as part of Form I-9. The instructions say employees "do NOT need to prove their citizenship, immigration status, or national origin," and that requesting such proof "based on their citizenship, immigration status, or national origin, may be illegal." The Justice Department's Immigrant and Employee Rights Section (IER) gives a pointed example on its Form I-9 and E-Verify page: employers "must not require U.S. citizens who appear 'foreign' to produce a birth certificate." A second passport, an accent or a foreign birthplace is never a reason to ask for more or different documents; see I-9 document abuse and citizenship status discrimination in hiring.

Some jobs do involve a nationality review outside Form I-9, such as access to export-controlled technology. IER's fact sheet How to Avoid Immigration-Related Discrimination when Complying with U.S. Export Control Laws (revised March 2024) says employers "should not combine export compliance assessment with the Form I-9 process," should do that assessment only for workers whose positions require it, and should tell those workers why they are being asked. It also lists U.S. citizens first among "U.S. persons." Clearance jobs have their own federal process; see how to verify a security clearance.

Does a dual citizen ever need reverification?

No. M-274 Section 6.0 says "Reverification is never required for U.S. citizens or noncitizen nationals," and never when U.S. passports, U.S. passport cards or List B documents expire. An expired U.S. passport later on changes nothing on the Form I-9 already completed.

The one case that needs care is an employee who was hired as a noncitizen, presented an Employment Authorization Document and later naturalized. If that EAD's expiration date arrives, reverification is still due on Supplement B, but the employee may present any List A or List C document, such as a new U.S. passport or an unrestricted Social Security card (M-274 Section 6.1). Do not ask them to redo Section 1 to record the new citizenship. In a 2011 technical assistance letter, the office now called IER said it was "unaware of any guidance that permits an employer to ask an employee to complete all of Section 1 on a new Form I-9 at the time of reverification," and recommended keeping any citizenship review for government contracts "separate and apart from the I-9 process." More on Supplement B is in I-9 reverification.

What should recruiters and staffing agencies watch for?

  • Job orders. A client's "U.S. citizens only" line is lawful only where a law, regulation, executive order or government contract requires it (8 U.S.C. 1324b(a)(2)(C)); see U.S. citizenship requirements in job postings. A dual citizen holds U.S. citizenship; if a contract or program has its own written rule on other nationalities, follow that rule in its own process, not on Form I-9.
  • Interview questions. Ask whether the candidate is authorized to work and whether they will need sponsorship, the same way for everyone; never ask which passports they hold. See work authorization questions in interviews.
  • Who completes the form. USCIS's Exceptions page says the staffing agency "completes Form I-9 for each worker they provide to your company," so a client has no Form I-9 reason to ask a placed dual citizen for documents. See Form I-9 for staffing agencies.

A dual-citizen Form I-9 checklist

  • Section 1: "A citizen of the United States" checked by the employee, signed and dated by the first day of work.
  • No question about, and no record of, the other nationality on the form or its attachments.
  • Documents chosen by the employee: one List A, or one List B plus one List C; a foreign passport alone declined politely, with the Lists handed over.
  • U.S.-issued birth certificate only; certified copies are acceptable, photocopies are not.
  • Photo List B document if you use E-Verify; an SSA citizenship mismatch handled through the normal notice process.
  • No reverification date, unless an earlier EAD is on file from before naturalization.
  • Any export-control or contract citizenship review kept separate from Form I-9 and limited to the jobs that need it.

Questions people ask

How does a dual citizen fill out Form I-9?

A dual citizen who holds U.S. citizenship checks the first box in Section 1, A citizen of the United States, and signs by the first day of work. The other citizenship is not recorded anywhere on Form I-9. Within three business days the employee presents any one List A document, such as a U.S. passport, or one List B and one List C document, such as a driver's license and a U.S. birth certificate, as of November 2026.

Can a dual citizen use their foreign passport for Form I-9?

Not on its own. The foreign passports on List A count only with a temporary I-551 stamp, with a Form I-94 showing a nonimmigrant status or parole, or as a Micronesian or Marshallese passport with a Compact Form I-94, and USCIS's Who Is Issued This Document chart marks none of them for U.S. citizens. A foreign passport is not a List B document either, so the employee chooses a different document from the Lists.

Can an employer ask a new hire whether they hold another citizenship?

Not as part of Form I-9. The Form I-9 instructions say employees do not need to prove their citizenship, immigration status or national origin, and the Justice Department's Immigrant and Employee Rights Section warns employers not to combine export-control or government-contract checks with the Form I-9 process. If a job truly requires such a review, run it separately, only for the jobs that need it, and say why.

Why did E-Verify return a mismatch for a naturalized dual citizen?

Often because the Social Security Administration's record still shows the person as a noncitizen. E-Verify says a naturalized citizen whose Further Action Notice reads that SSA is unable to confirm U.S. citizenship can call DHS within eight federal government working days with the case number and their naturalization certificate number or A-Number, and should also update their SSA record.

Does a dual citizen ever need Form I-9 reverification?

No. USCIS's Handbook for Employers, Section 6.0, says reverification is never required for U.S. citizens or noncitizen nationals, and never when a U.S. passport, U.S. passport card or List B document expires. Do not set a reverification date for a dual citizen who attested to U.S. citizenship.