What is a reference check? What employers may ask, and how it differs from employment verification
On this page
- How does a reference check work?
- How is a reference check different from employment verification and a background check?
- What may employers ask in a reference check?
- Does the FCRA apply to reference checks?
- When should references be checked?
- What should staffing agencies know about reference checks?
- A copy-ready reference check policy paragraph
- Questions people ask
A reference check is a conversation, usually by phone, with people who have worked with a candidate, most often former managers, to learn how the candidate actually performed: the quality of their work, how they handled problems and people, and whether the referee would hire them again. It is different from employment verification, which only confirms facts such as dates of employment and job title from the employer's records. Employers may ask references only what they could lawfully ask the candidate: the EEOC says an employer "may not ask a third party (such as ... an applicant's friends, family, or former employers) any questions that it could not directly ask the applicant." If a screening company makes the calls, the Fair Credit Reporting Act applies, as of November 2026.
Not legal advice. This page summarizes the federal statutes, the EEOC guidance and the state law linked below, as checked in November 2026. What a former employer may say, state by state, is on employment reference laws; check the law where the job is located.
How does a reference check work?
- Ask the candidate for referees late in the process: people who managed them or worked closely with them, ideally including a recent manager. Ask for permission to call, and whether the current employer may be contacted yet.
- Set the questions in advance, tied to the job's requirements and to what the interviews left open, and use the same core questions for every finalist.
- Make the calls, confirm how the referee knows the candidate, and ask for examples rather than adjectives; the call itself is on the candidate reference call script.
- Write down what was said, separating what the referee saw from what they heard secondhand.
- Weigh it with the rest of the evidence, and follow up with the candidate if a concern comes up rather than deciding on one call.
The full question set and a client write-up are on the reference check template, and the email to set up calls is on the reference request email template.
How is a reference check different from employment verification and a background check?
| Check | Question it answers | Who provides it | FCRA? |
|---|---|---|---|
| Reference check | How well did the candidate do the job? | Former managers and colleagues, speaking for themselves | Only if a screening company conducts it |
| Employment verification | Did they work there, when, and in what title? | The employer's HR or payroll records, or a verification service; see employment verification services | Yes when a third-party service supplies it |
| Background check | What do the records say: criminal history, education, licences? | A screening company searching records; see what is a background check | Yes when a screening company prepares it |
| Backdoor reference | The same as a reference check, from someone the candidate did not name | Mutual contacts | Only if a screening company conducts it |
| DOT safety performance history | The driver's safety and drug and alcohol testing history with DOT-regulated employers in the past three years | Previous DOT-regulated employers, as required by 49 CFR 391.23 | A separate federal rule for commercial drivers |
The practical difference is that many employers limit what HR will say to dates and title, so verification is easy to get and a substantive reference depends on individual managers who agree to talk. Why so many employers take that line, and the state laws that protect good-faith references, are on employment reference laws.
What may employers ask in a reference check?
The rule of thumb comes from the EEOC's guidance on preemployment disability-related questions: an employer "may not ask a third party ... any questions that it could not directly ask the applicant." The same guidance allows a question about prior attendance, such as how many days the applicant was absent, but not about how many sick days they took, because that relates to the severity of an impairment.
| Ask about | Do not ask about | Why |
|---|---|---|
| Their role, responsibilities and results | Health, disability, injuries or sick days | ADA limits on disability-related questions apply to third parties too (EEOC guidance) |
| Examples of how they handled a hard problem | Family medical history or genetic conditions | GINA bars requesting genetic information; see genetic information in hiring |
| Reliability and attendance in general terms | Age, pregnancy, children, marriage, religion, national origin | Questions about protected traits suggest the answer mattered; see illegal interview questions |
| Whether they would rehire or work with the candidate again | Pay history, in states and cities that ban salary history questions | For example New York Labor Law 194-a (below) |
| Areas where the candidate needed support | Union activity or complaints the candidate made | Retaliation and labor-law risks |
Salary history is the rule most often missed. New York's law, for example, bars employers from seeking, requesting or requiring "the wage or salary history of an applicant or current employee from a current or former employer," and allows confirmation only when the applicant responds to an offer with prior pay information to support a higher offer (N.Y. Labor Law 194-a). Other states and cities have their own versions; see salary history ban states.
Does the FCRA apply to reference checks?
It depends on who calls. When your own recruiters or managers call references, no consumer reporting agency is involved and the FCRA does not apply. When a screening company calls for you, its report is a consumer report, and if it gathers information "on a consumer's character, general reputation, personal characteristics, or mode of living" through "personal interviews with neighbors, friends, or associates," it is an investigative consumer report (15 U.S.C. 1681a(e)). That adds a written disclosure within three days of requesting it and a right for the candidate to ask about its nature and scope; the detail is on investigative consumer reports for employers. Reference software that sends questionnaires to referees raises the same question about who is gathering the information; check the vendor's own FCRA position before using it (see reference check software).
When should references be checked?
Usually at the finalist stage or after a conditional offer, so referees are contacted only for candidates you would hire and a current employer learns of the job search only when the candidate agrees. The EEOC's guidance recognizes this sequence: where an applicant asks that the current employer not be contacted until an offer is made, "the potential employer could not reasonably obtain and evaluate the non-medical information from the reference at the pre-offer stage," so an offer conditioned on that reference still counts as a real offer for ADA purposes. What a conditional offer is, and what may follow it, is on what is a conditional offer of employment.
What should staffing agencies know about reference checks?
- The agency is asking, so the agency's rules apply. Never ask a referee something for a client that the client could not lawfully ask the candidate.
- Send the client evidence, not impressions. Summarize what the referee saw, with examples, and leave out anything about health, family or other protected traits even if the referee volunteered it.
- Verify the referee. A reference you can reach only through the candidate is a warning sign; see how to spot fake references.
- Outsourced calls are a consumer report. If the agency uses a screening company for references, the FCRA disclosure and authorization come first.
A copy-ready reference check policy paragraph
REFERENCE CHECKS (example policy text; review with counsel)
1. Who: references are checked by [recruiting / the hiring manager] for
finalists, or after a conditional offer, for every hire into [roles].
2. Consent: we ask the candidate for at least [two] referees, including a
recent manager where possible, and for permission to call. We contact a
current employer only with the candidate's agreement.
3. Questions: the same core questions for every finalist, tied to the job.
We do not ask about health, disability, sick days, family medical history,
age, pregnancy, family status, religion, national origin or other
protected traits, and we do not ask for pay history where [state/city]
law bars it.
4. Vendors: if a screening company checks references, we give the FCRA
disclosure and get written authorization first.
5. Records: notes record what the referee said about the work, are kept
with the hiring file for at least one year, and are shared only with
the hiring team.
6. Concerns: a concern from a reference is discussed with the candidate
before any decision.
The paragraph is an example to adapt. Keep the hiring file for at least the federal one-year period (29 CFR 1602.14), and see what not to write in interview notes before saving reference notes.
Questions people ask
What is the difference between a reference check and employment verification?
Employment verification confirms facts: whether the person worked there, the dates and the job title, usually from the employer's HR or payroll records or a verification service. A reference check asks people who worked with the candidate, usually former managers, how well they did the job, how they worked with others and whether they would work with them again. Many employers will only verify, so a reference check often relies on individual managers who agree to talk.
What questions are employers not allowed to ask a reference?
Anything the employer could not ask the candidate directly. The EEOC says an employer may not ask a third party, including former employers, any questions it could not directly ask the applicant, which rules out questions about disability, illness, sick days, family medical history, age, pregnancy, religion or national origin. In states and cities with salary history bans, such as New York, employers also may not ask a current or former employer for the candidate's pay history.
Do you need the candidate's permission to check references?
If a background screening company calls the references for you, yes: that is a consumer report under the Fair Credit Reporting Act, and interviews about character or performance can make it an investigative consumer report with extra disclosure rules. When your own staff call references, the FCRA does not apply, but asking the candidate for permission and for the names to call is the practical norm and protects a current job search.
Can a job offer be conditional on a reference check?
Yes. Many employers make an offer conditional on satisfactory references, especially from a current employer the candidate does not want contacted earlier. The EEOC's guidance recognizes that an employer may not be able to obtain a current employer's reference before an offer, and treats an offer conditioned on that reference as a real offer for ADA purposes.
Can a former employer give a bad reference?
A former employer may give a truthful, job-related reference, and many states protect employers who give good-faith references from liability. What it may not do is give false information, blacklist someone or retaliate for protected activity. Many employers limit references to dates and job titles by policy, which is a choice, not a legal requirement in most states.