What to do if an employee lied on their resume: verify, document, hear them out and decide consistently
On this page
- Is it a lie, an error or polish?
- What should you do first?
- Can you fire an employee for lying on their resume?
- What did the Supreme Court say about lies discovered later?
- Does the FCRA apply when you re-check a current employee?
- How should the conversation with the employee go?
- What should the file say?
- What if the employee is a temp placed by a staffing agency?
- Can you take legal action or report it?
- How do you stop it happening again?
- Checklist: employee lied on resume
- Questions people ask
If you learn after hire that an employee lied on their resume, do not act on the discovery alone. Verify the claim through the original source (the school, licensing board or former employer), write down exactly what the resume or application said and what the source shows, give the employee a private chance to explain, and then apply the same outcome you have applied, or would apply, to anyone else with the same misstatement. Whether to end employment turns on how material the claim was (a required degree or license, or a minor date), your written policy and past practice, any contract or union agreement, and state law. Two federal rules shape the decision as of November 2026: under McKennon v. Nashville Banner Publishing Co. (1995), misconduct found after a discriminatory firing does not erase the violation, and the Fair Credit Reporting Act covers checks on current employees when a screening company runs them.
Catching lies before an offer is covered in resume fraud red flags, and handling one in the interview room in how to handle a candidate who lies in an interview. If the person at work is not the person you hired, that is an identity problem with its own playbook: what to do when a new hire is not the person you interviewed. This page is the after-hire procedure.
Not legal advice. This page summarizes Supreme Court opinions (on the Cornell LII), the EEOC's after-acquired evidence guidance and the FCRA (15 U.S.C. 1681a and 1681b), read in November 2026. Employment decisions depend on your contracts, policies and state law; involve HR and counsel before you act.
Is it a lie, an error or polish?
Start by sorting what you found. The same word, "lied," covers a forged diploma and a rounded-up start date, and they do not deserve the same response. The examples below are illustrations, not rules.
| What turned up (examples) | How to verify it | Questions that decide how much it matters |
|---|---|---|
| A degree that was never awarded, or one from a diploma mill | The registrar or the National Student Clearinghouse (how to verify a degree); accreditation checks in how to spot a diploma mill | Was the degree a stated requirement? Did it decide the hire or the pay grade? |
| A license or certification the job requires | The issuing board's own lookup (professional license verification) | Is the person working unlicensed today? That is a stop-work issue before it is a resume issue. |
| An employer that does not exist, or a job never held | Records you find yourself, not numbers on the resume (how to spot a fake employer) | Was the experience the reason for the hire? |
| An inflated title or stretched dates | The former employer's HR or a verification service (how to verify employment history) | Is it a material change in level, or a rounding that many resumes contain? |
| A false "no" to a criminal history question | The background check report and the court record | Was the question one the law allowed you to ask at that stage? Fair-chance rules limit both the question and the use (individualized assessment) |
| Overstated skills | The work itself | This is usually a performance matter, handled through feedback and your performance process |
What should you do first?
- Pause before acting on a tip. A coworker's comment or an anonymous email is a reason to check, not a finding.
- Get the exact claim. Pull the resume version you received, the signed application (including any statement that false information may lead to dismissal), the job posting's requirements and the interview notes. You need to know what was said and whether you relied on it.
- Verify through the original source, using contact details you find yourself. A diploma image, a reference the employee supplies or a profile page is not verification.
- Use the FCRA route if a screening company checks. See the FCRA section below before you order anything.
- Check your own record. Did you verify this item at hire? Was it a requirement or a nice-to-have? Have you dismissed, disciplined or excused anyone else for the same thing? The EEOC tells its investigators to look at exactly that (below).
- Check the employment terms: the offer letter, handbook, any employment contract, and a union agreement if one applies. A contract that allows dismissal only "for cause" or a grievance procedure changes the process.
- Meet the employee privately with HR present, show the specific discrepancy, ask for an explanation and any documents, and set a short, reasonable deadline.
- Decide with HR and counsel, using the same standard you would apply to anyone else, and write down the reason.
- Close the loop: access, payroll, any regulator or licensing board report your field requires, and what you will say in future reference checks (see reference check laws by state).
Can you fire an employee for lying on their resume?
Usually, yes. Most US employment is at will: either side may end it for any lawful reason, and Montana is the state whose statute requires good cause after a probationary period (see what is at-will employment). The limits are the usual ones. The reason must not be a cover for discrimination or retaliation; a contract or union agreement may require cause and a process; and some employers owe a hearing.
Public employers in particular. In Cleveland Board of Education v. Loudermill, 470 U.S. 532 (decided March 19, 1985), a school board dismissed a security guard "because of his dishonesty in filling out the employment application" after finding a grand larceny conviction he had denied, without letting him respond. Because Ohio civil-service law let him be dismissed only for cause, the Court held that "The tenured public employee is entitled to oral or written notice of the charges against him, an explanation of the employer's evidence, and an opportunity to present his side of the story." Private employers are not bound by that due-process rule, but the same three steps are a sound process for anyone.
Dismissal is not the only option. Depending on what you find, employers also correct the personnel record, move the person to a role whose requirements they meet, give a written warning, or decide the item was immaterial. Whatever you choose, choose it the way you would for anyone else.
What did the Supreme Court say about lies discovered later?
McKennon v. Nashville Banner Publishing Co., 513 U.S. 352 (decided January 23, 1995), is the case on "after-acquired evidence." The employee sued under the Age Discrimination in Employment Act; in her deposition she admitted that "during her final year of employment, she had copied several confidential documents." The employer argued that this misconduct defeated her claim. The Court disagreed: "We conclude that a violation of the ADEA cannot be so altogether disregarded." It then limited the remedies:
- "as a general rule in cases of this type, neither reinstatement nor front pay is an appropriate remedy";
- "The beginning point in the trial court's formulation of a remedy should be calculation of backpay from the date of the unlawful discharge to the date the new information was discovered";
- and the employer carries the burden: it "must first establish that the wrongdoing was of such severity that the employee in fact would have been terminated on those grounds alone if the employer had known of it at the time of the discharge."
The EEOC's Enforcement Guidance on After-Acquired Evidence (Notice 915.002, December 14, 1995, still posted without a rescission notice as of November 2026) applies the case to charges and uses falsified applications and resumes as its examples. Two points matter for a manager:
- Consistency is the evidence. Investigators "should analyze whether other applicants were rejected or other employees were dismissed, reprimanded, suspended or forgiven for similar behavior." If you have excused the same lie before, you will struggle to show you would have fired this person for it.
- Do not go digging because someone complained. The guidance treats evidence found in a "retaliatory investigation," one started in response to a discrimination complaint "in an attempt to uncover derogatory information," as a reason to extend back pay to the date the complaint is resolved, and notes that retaliation is an independent violation.
In practice: if a resume lie is the real reason for a decision, make it on its own facts, document it, and make sure your record shows the same response to the same lie in others.
Does the FCRA apply when you re-check a current employee?
If you call the registrar or a licensing board yourself, the Fair Credit Reporting Act does not come into it. If a screening company does the checking, it does: the FCRA defines "employment purposes" as "evaluating a consumer for employment, promotion, reassignment or retention as an employee" (15 U.S.C. 1681a(h)). That brings in the stand-alone disclosure and written authorization before the report (FCRA disclosure and authorization form; check with counsel whether the authorization you collected at hire covers checks during employment), and the pre-adverse action notice and adverse action notice if the report contributes to a dismissal.
One exception is built for workplace investigations. A communication made to an employer "in connection with an investigation of" suspected misconduct relating to employment, or compliance with law or "any preexisting written policies of the employer," is not a consumer report if it is not about creditworthiness and is shared only with the people the statute lists (15 U.S.C. 1681a(y)). After taking adverse action based on it, "the employer shall disclose to the consumer a summary containing the nature and substance of the communication upon which the adverse action is based." Whether your vendor's work fits this exception is a question for counsel.
How should the conversation with the employee go?
An example script to adapt with HR:
"Thanks for meeting with us. We've found a difference between your
application and what [the university / the licensing board / your
former employer] confirmed, and we want to hear from you before we
decide anything.
Your application says: [exact words].
[Source] tells us: [exact result], on [date].
Is there something we're missing, for example a different name on
the record, a merged company or a records error? If you have
documents that show it, please send them by [date]. We'll make a
decision after that and tell you in person."
Keep it to facts. Do not speculate about motives, ask about unrelated history, or let the meeting become a debate; write down what the employee says, in their words.
What should the file say?
Resume discrepancy record (example; adapt to your policy)
Employee: ________________ Role: ________________ Hire date: ________
Claim as made (document, version, date): _____________________________
Source checked, by whom, how, date: __________________________________
Source result (attach): _____________________________________________
Was the item a stated job requirement? [ ] yes [ ] no (posting attached)
Was it relied on at hire (notes, pay grade)? ________________________
Third-party report used? [ ] no [ ] yes: FCRA disclosure/authorization on file [ ]
Employee told of discrepancy (date, who present): ____________________
Employee's explanation and documents (date received): ________________
Comparable past cases and outcomes: __________________________________
Decision, reason, decision-makers, date: _____________________________
Adverse action notices sent (if a report was used): __________________
What if the employee is a temp placed by a staffing agency?
For a temp on the agency's payroll, the agency is the employer and makes the employment decision; the client decides whether the person stays on its assignment. A client that learns of a false claim should tell the agency the facts and let the agency verify, rather than ordering its own report on the worker, which would make the client the user of a consumer report with its own FCRA duties. Agencies should run the same steps above and check the client contract for who must verify which credentials (see background checks for staffing agencies).
Can you take legal action or report it?
Most resume lies are handled as employment matters. Some states make using a fake or unaccredited degree to get a job a crime or civil violation (diploma fraud laws by state), and federal prosecutions have involved identity theft and wire fraud schemes rather than one person's embellishment (is interview fraud a crime?). A forged professional license belongs with the issuing board. Recovering pay or bringing a civil claim depends on state law; ask counsel.
How do you stop it happening again?
- Verify what you rely on, before the offer is final, for every hire in the role: required degrees, licenses and key employers.
- Put an accuracy statement on the application that the candidate signs, and keep the version they submitted.
- Write the response down in a policy, so the next decision matches the last; the candidate fraud policy template has a section for it.
- Separate requirements from preferences in job postings, so you know later which claims mattered.
Checklist: employee lied on resume
[ ] Exact claim and document version saved
[ ] Verified with the original source (contact found independently)
[ ] FCRA steps followed if a screening company was used
[ ] Materiality: requirement? relied on at hire?
[ ] Policy, contract, union agreement and past cases reviewed
[ ] Employee shown the discrepancy and given time to respond
[ ] Decision made by HR/counsel on the same standard as others
[ ] Not prompted by, or timed against, a complaint the employee made
[ ] Decision, reasons and notices documented
[ ] Access, payroll, licensing board and reference policy handled
Not legal advice. Sources checked as of November 2026.
Questions people ask
Can I fire an employee for lying on their resume?
Often yes, but check four things first: that the claim is really false, verified through the original source; that it mattered, for example a degree or license the job required; that your policy and past practice treat the same lie the same way for everyone; and that no contract, union agreement or public-employment rule requires cause or a hearing. Most US jobs are at will, so an employer may end employment for any lawful reason, but the reason must not be a cover for discrimination or retaliation. This is not legal advice.
What if we only find out about the resume lie years later?
Time does not cure a false statement, but it changes what is fair and material. Someone who has done the job well for years without the degree they claimed may still be dismissed under a consistent policy, or the employer may decide the requirement no longer matters for that role. Decide on the facts, apply the outcome you have applied to others, and document why.
Do I have to let the employee explain before I act?
For most private employers no law requires it, but it is the step that most often prevents mistakes, because a mismatch can come from a name change, a merged employer or a records error. Public employees who can only be dismissed for cause are different: in Cleveland Board of Education v. Loudermill (1985), a case about a security guard who denied a felony conviction on his application, the Supreme Court held that such an employee is entitled to notice, an explanation of the evidence and a chance to respond before dismissal.
Can an employee fired for resume fraud still win a discrimination lawsuit?
Yes, if the real reason for the firing was discriminatory. In McKennon v. Nashville Banner Publishing Co. (1995), the Supreme Court held that wrongdoing discovered after a discriminatory discharge does not erase the violation; it generally rules out reinstatement and front pay, and back pay normally runs from the discharge to the date the employer discovered the wrongdoing, if the employer proves it would have fired the employee for that wrongdoing alone.
Does the FCRA apply if we re-check a current employee's background?
Yes, if a consumer reporting agency does the checking. The Fair Credit Reporting Act defines employment purposes to include evaluating someone for retention as an employee, so the disclosure, authorization and adverse action steps apply to current employees too. A narrow exception covers reports made to an employer in an investigation of suspected misconduct; after acting on one, the employer must give the employee a summary of its nature and substance.