Consent and compliance

Background check adjudication matrix: how to build one without blanket bans (2026)

On this page
  1. What is a background check adjudication matrix?
  2. Why can't a matrix work as a blanket ban?
  3. How do you build an adjudication matrix, step by step?
  4. An example matrix you can adapt
  5. Which records must stay out of the matrix?
  6. Which cells does another law decide?
  7. Can the screening company apply the matrix for you?
  8. How do staffing agencies use a matrix?
  9. How do you test and maintain the matrix?
  10. Summary
  11. Questions people ask

A background check adjudication matrix is a written grid, set before anyone reads a report, that lists offense categories against role families and says for each combination whether a record is cleared or sent to individual review, and for how many years it matters. Built that way, it speeds up and standardizes the first pass without becoming a blanket ban, because nobody is rejected by the grid alone. As of November 2026, Washington bars any policy that "automatically or categorically excludes" people with a criminal record, New York requires a direct relationship or an unreasonable risk before any denial, and California presumes that bright-line policies reaching convictions seven or more years old are not job-related.

This page is the matrix itself: what goes in it, how to build it, an example to adapt, what must stay out of it, and what happens when a record lands in a "review" cell. The case-by-case review that follows is on running an individualized assessment, and the policy the matrix belongs to (as its appendix of adjudication criteria) is the background check policy template.

Not legal advice. This summarizes Title VII, the Fair Credit Reporting Act, FTC staff guidance and the state and city laws linked below as we read them in November 2026. Have counsel review your matrix for every place you hire before you use it.

What is a background check adjudication matrix?

"Adjudication" is the screening industry's word for deciding what a report means for a particular job. A matrix makes that decision rule-based for the easy cases and routes the hard ones to a trained person. It has three parts:

  • Rows: offense categories, grouped by conduct (theft and fraud, violence, impaired driving, drug distribution) rather than by statute number, because the same conduct carries different labels in different states.
  • Columns: role families, grouped by the duties that create a real risk (driving, handling money or accounts, unsupervised access to patients, children or homes), taken from the job descriptions.
  • Cells: an outcome and a lookback. "Clear" means the record is not relevant to that role family and the file moves on. "Review" means the record may be relevant within the stated number of years and goes to an individualized assessment. "Law decides" marks the few cells where a statute sets the bar or a separate process.

There is no fourth outcome called "reject." That is the line between a matrix and a blanket ban:

ApproachWhat it doesLegal exposure
Blanket ban ("no felonies")Excludes anyone with a type of record, whatever the jobBarred outright in Washington; a "no felonies" job ad is a violation on its own in New York City; hard to show it is job related under Title VII
Adjudication matrixClears records unrelated to the job and routes the rest to review, with lookbacks set in advanceDefensible if every "review" cell is tied to a duty and every review ends in a documented, individual decision
Individualized assessmentA written review of one person's record against one job, with a chance to respondRequired by several state and city laws; the step a matrix feeds into

Why can't a matrix work as a blanket ban?

Federally, Title VII says a practice with a disparate impact on a protected group is unlawful unless the employer shows it is "job related for the position in question and consistent with business necessity" (42 U.S.C. § 2000e-2(k)(1)(A)(i)), and courts decide those claims. The EEOC rescinded its 2012 arrest and conviction records guidance on October 28, 2026; its announcement says the rescission does not require employers to abandon lawful practices they adopted in response to it. The Green factors from the 1975 Eighth Circuit case (the nature and gravity of the offense, the time since it, and the nature of the job) remain a sound way to build the cells and document each decision. You also certify to your screening company that report information "will not be used in violation of any applicable Federal or State equal employment opportunity law" (15 U.S.C. § 1681b(b)(1)(A)(ii)).

State and city laws are more direct, as of November 2026:

PlaceWhat it says about rule-based exclusionSource
WashingtonAn employer "may not implement any policy or practice that automatically or categorically excludes individuals with a criminal record from any employment position"; a decision based on an adult conviction needs a documented "legitimate business reason" weighed against six listed factorsRCW 49.94.010(3), (5); 49.94.005(6)
New York StateNo denial because of a conviction unless there is "a direct relationship" to the job or "an unreasonable risk," after weighing the factors in § 753Correction Law § 752
New York CityThe Commission on Human Rights says employers must make "a reasoned evaluation of each relevant fair chance factor" and "cannot simply engage in a pro forma review"; ads stating "no felonies" or "must have clean record" are violations on their ownCCHR legal enforcement guidance
California"Bright-line conviction disqualification or consideration policies" that include conviction information seven or more years old carry a rebuttable presumption that they are not tailored enough; a narrower list of convictions is named as a less discriminatory alternative2 CCR § 11017.1(f)(4)(C), (f)(5)
HawaiiThe conviction must bear "a rational relationship" to the job; employers may consider only the last seven years of felony and five years of misdemeanor convictions, excluding incarcerationHRS § 378-2.5(a), (c)

Illinois, Philadelphia, Los Angeles and others add their own tests and notice steps; they are compared on the individualized assessment page.

How do you build an adjudication matrix, step by step?

  1. List the role families from your job descriptions, and for each one the duties that create a real risk: driving, cash or account access, access to medication, unsupervised access to patients, children or customers' homes. A role with none of those duties gets its own column, and most of its cells will be "Clear."
  2. List offense categories by conduct, then map the statutes your screening company reports to those categories. Keep a misdemeanor and a felony of the same conduct in the same row with different lookbacks.
  3. Mark a cell "Review" only where the conduct connects to a duty in that column, and write one sentence explaining the connection. A cell you cannot explain in a sentence should be "Clear."
  4. Set a lookback for each "Review" cell, counted from the conviction or from release, and check it against local caps (Hawaii's seven and five years, California's seven-year presumption, Philadelphia's limits on our Philadelphia page).
  5. Add the "Law decides" cells for roles where a statute sets the bar (next section), and name the statute in the cell.
  6. Strike the records you may not consider before the matrix ever sees them (see below).
  7. Send every "Review" to an individualized assessment, with the pre-adverse action notice and the response window, before any decision.
  8. Test the results after the first months of use and at least yearly, and change cells that screen out many people with little connection to the job.

An example matrix you can adapt

This is an example of the format to review with counsel, not a recommendation. The bracketed numbers are placeholder lookbacks in years, counted from conviction or release, whichever is later.

Conduct (convictions only)Drives for workCash, accounts or paymentsUnsupervised access to patients, children or homesNone of these duties
Theft, fraud, forgery, embezzlementClearReview [7]; bank roles: Law decidesReview [7]Clear
Violence against a personReview [7]Review [5]Review [7]Review [5]
Impaired or reckless drivingReview [5]ClearClear unless the role drivesClear
Drug possessionClearClearReview [3] if the role handles medicationClear
Drug sale or distributionReview [5]Review [5]Review [7]Clear
Sexual offensesReview [7]Review [7]Review; state law may require a registry or fingerprint checkReview [7]
Hazardous materials or explosives offensesLaw decides if the role needs a hazmat endorsement or TWICClearClearClear
Other misdemeanors not listedClearClearClearClear

Under the grid, keep a short rationale for each "Review" cell, for example: "Violence against a person, home-visit roles: the worker is alone with clients in their homes." That sentence is what you will rely on if a cell is questioned.

Which records must stay out of the matrix?

  • Arrests that did not lead to a conviction. Washington bars acting on an arrest record, except an adult arrest where the person is out on bail or released pending trial (RCW 49.94.010(4)); New York City treats non-convictions as fully protected; California excludes them too. The list by state is on what shows up on a background check.
  • Sealed, expunged and limited-access records, under state laws such as New York's and Pennsylvania's Clean Slate laws (see New York and Pennsylvania).
  • Juvenile records, which Washington and California exclude.
  • Anything older than a local cap, such as Hawaii's. The separate limits on what a screening company may report at all are on the seven-year rule page.
  • Credit history, which several states and cities restrict on their own terms; see credit check laws.

Which cells does another law decide?

Some jobs have a disqualification written into federal or state law, and the matrix should point to it rather than invent its own rule. Two federal examples:

  • Banks: without the FDIC's prior written consent, a person convicted of a criminal offense "involving dishonesty or a breach of trust or money laundering," or who entered a pretrial diversion program for one, may not participate in the affairs of an insured depository institution, and the institution may not permit it (12 U.S.C. § 1829(a)).
  • Hazardous materials drivers and port workers: TSA's list of permanent and interim disqualifying offenses decides eligibility for the hazmat endorsement and the TWIC card (49 CFR § 1572.103).

California's regulation treats compliance with a law that mandates a screening process as a rebuttable defense to an adverse impact claim (2 CCR § 11017.1(g)). Even in these cells, the FCRA notices still apply when a screening company's report is the basis for the decision.

Can the screening company apply the matrix for you?

Many can grade a report against criteria you supply. The FTC's 2011 staff report treats a screening company's "numerical or other evaluation of data" as part of the consumer report (p. 21), so the grade travels with the report and belongs in the copy you give the candidate. Four rules follow:

  • The pre-adverse action notice is still required "even where the information contained in the consumer report (such as a criminal record) would automatically disqualify the individual" (p. 53). See the pre-adverse action notice.
  • You stay liable if you let the screening company send the notices and it does not (p. 53).
  • The decision must be yours. The final notice must state that the screening company "did not make the decision to take the adverse action" (15 U.S.C. § 1681m(a)(3)(B)). Ask for grades worded as "Meets criteria" and "Needs review," not "Fail."
  • Keep the matrix yours as well. Hand the screening company the version counsel approved and record every change. Questions to ask about adjudication services are on how to choose a background check company.

How do staffing agencies use a matrix?

An agency usually needs one matrix per client role family, because the same worker may go to a warehouse one month and a home-care client the next. California's regulation says an agency that keeps a pool must assess a record against "the specific duties of the jobs for which the applicant may be assigned from the pool," and that a client violates the rule by instructing agencies "to refer only workers without conviction records" unless the position is exempt (2 CCR § 11017.1(d)(2), (d)(4)). Put in the client contract whose matrix applies, who runs the review and who sends the notices; the split of duties is on background checks for staffing agencies.

How do you test and maintain the matrix?

  • Track outcomes by cell: how many records each "Review" cell routes, and how many reviews end in a hire. A cell where nearly every review ends in a hire is probably drawn too wide.
  • Check selection rates by group where you have the data, using the four-fifths comparison as a rule of thumb, not a safe harbor (the four-fifths rule). The two theories of liability are on disparate treatment vs disparate impact.
  • Review the matrix yearly and whenever a law where you hire changes, and keep each version with the dates it was in use.
  • Keep the review file: the cell that applied, the assessment, the notices and the outcome.

Summary

ItemThe rule, as of November 2026Source
Disparate impactA screen with a disparate impact must be job related and consistent with business necessity42 U.S.C. § 2000e-2(k)
EEOC 2012 guidanceRescinded October 28, 2026; Title VII still appliesEEOC
Automatic exclusionBarred in Washington; New York requires a direct relationship or unreasonable riskRCW 49.94.010(3); Correction Law § 752
Old convictionsCalifornia presumes bright-line policies reaching 7+ years are not tailored; Hawaii caps at 7 (felony) and 5 (misdemeanor) years2 CCR § 11017.1(f)(4)(C); HRS § 378-2.5(c)
Screening company gradesPart of the report; pre-adverse notice still required; the employer decidesFTC staff report pp. 21, 53; 15 U.S.C. § 1681m(a)(3)(B)

Questions people ask

What is an adjudication matrix in a background check?

It is a written grid, set before any report is read, that lists offense categories against role families and says for each combination whether a record is cleared or sent to individual review, and for how many years it is relevant. It standardizes the first pass. It should not reject anyone on its own, because Title VII's disparate impact rule and state and city fair chance laws require a job-related, case-by-case decision.

Is it legal to automatically disqualify candidates who have a felony?

It is risky everywhere and unlawful in some places as of November 2026. Washington bars any policy that automatically or categorically excludes people with a criminal record (RCW 49.94.010(3)); New York Correction Law 752 bars a denial for a conviction unless there is a direct relationship to the job or an unreasonable risk; and California's regulation presumes that bright-line policies reaching convictions seven or more years old are not job-related. Where another law sets the bar, such as Section 19 of the Federal Deposit Insurance Act for bank roles, follow that law.

Does the EEOC still require an individualized assessment of criminal records?

The EEOC rescinded its 2012 arrest and conviction records guidance on October 28, 2026. Title VII still applies, including its disparate impact provision at 42 U.S.C. 2000e-2(k), and courts decide those claims. Weighing the Green factors from the 1975 Eighth Circuit case (the nature and gravity of the offense, the time since it and the nature of the job) remains a sound way to make and document a decision, and state and city laws such as California's, New York's and Washington's still require a case-by-case review.

Can a background check company apply our adjudication matrix for us?

Yes, many screening companies can grade a report against criteria the employer supplies, but the employer still makes the decision. The FTC's 2011 staff report says the pre-adverse action notice is required even when a record would automatically disqualify the person, and the final adverse action notice must state that the screening company did not make the decision. Treat a grade such as 'does not meet criteria' as a flag for review.

How many years back should an adjudication matrix look?

Federal law sets no lookback for convictions an employer considers, but some states do. Hawaii lets employers consider only the most recent seven years of felony convictions and five years of misdemeanor convictions, excluding time incarcerated, and California presumes that bright-line policies reaching convictions seven or more years old are not tailored to the job. Set each lookback by offense and job, check the local caps, and write down why.