How to choose a background check company: FCRA duties, PBSA accreditation, questions to ask and contract terms (2026)
On this page
- How do you choose a background check company, step by step?
- What does the FCRA require of the screening company?
- Is there an "FCRA certification" for background check companies?
- Which questions should you ask every finalist?
- What should the contract say?
- What are the red flags?
- How do you compare finalists side by side?
- What federal guidance changed recently?
- Questions people ask
To choose a background check company, define the checks each role needs, then compare a shortlist on four things: how it meets its own Fair Credit Reporting Act duties (verifying users, reasonable procedures for "maximum possible accuracy," public-record rules and 30-day dispute reinvestigations), whether it holds the Professional Background Screening Association's accreditation, how it answers the same written questions about sources, identity matching, local notices and data security, and what it will put in the contract. As of November 2026 there is no government license or "FCRA certification" for screening companies, so the evidence has to come from the company and the audit.
This page is the selection process. It names no vendors. The checks themselves are explained on county criminal records searches, national criminal database searches and federal criminal records searches; your duties as the employer are on the FCRA background check process.
Not legal advice. This summarizes the Fair Credit Reporting Act, FTC staff guidance and the PBSA accreditation materials linked below as we read them in November 2026. Have counsel review the contract.
How do you choose a background check company, step by step?
- Write down the checks by role family first (criminal searches, driving records, verifications, credit where the law allows), using the background check policy template. Vendors quote and configure against that list, and it stops a sales demo from deciding what you check.
- List where you hire: states, cities, countries. Local fair chance notices and international checks are where companies differ most; see international background checks.
- Shortlist three or four companies that cover those places and your volume, and check each on PBSA's Accredited Firms list.
- Send every finalist the same written questions (below) and score the answers on the same sheet.
- Run a short pilot on real orders, with each candidate's normal disclosure and authorization, and compare what you received against what was promised.
- Negotiate the contract using the answers, then set up one package per role family and your adjudication criteria.
What does the FCRA require of the screening company?
A screening company that assembles reports for employers is a consumer reporting agency, and these duties are its own. Ask each finalist to show you how it meets them.
| Duty | Section | What to ask for |
|---|---|---|
| Require users to identify themselves and certify their purpose; verify new users | 15 U.S.C. § 1681e(a) | Its onboarding and credentialing steps for your account |
| Follow "reasonable procedures to assure maximum possible accuracy" | § 1681e(b) | Its identity-matching rules and quality checks, in writing |
| Give users a notice of their responsibilities | § 1681e(d); CFPB Regulation V, appendix N | The current notice it gives clients |
| Provide the summary of consumer rights with the report or before | § 1681b(b)(1)(B) | The current CFPB form it supplies for your pre-adverse notices |
| Public records for employment: notify the consumer at the time, or keep "strict procedures" so records are complete and up to date | § 1681k(a) | Which of the two it uses, and how it confirms database hits |
| Reinvestigate disputes free of charge within 30 days (up to 45) | § 1681i | Its dispute procedure and how it tells you the outcome |
| Observe the reporting limits on older items | § 1681c | How it applies them, including state limits; see the seven-year rule |
| Investigative reports: verify public-record items within 30 days before furnishing; confirm adverse interview information with an independent source unless the person interviewed is the best possible source | § 1681d(d)(3)–(4) | Its process for reference and character interviews |
| May not stop you from showing the report to the candidate after adverse action | § 1681e(c) | Contract language that does not restrict this |
The duties that stay with you include the standalone disclosure and authorization, the certification you give the company, the pre-adverse and adverse action notices, local fair chance steps, and secure disposal of reports (16 CFR § 682.3). FTC staff say you may have the company send notices for you, but "the employer is liable if the CRA does not provide the notices" (FTC staff report, July 2011, p. 53).
Is there an "FCRA certification" for background check companies?
No. The FCRA does not license or certify screening companies. The certifications it describes run from the employer to the screening company: that you made the disclosure, will follow the adverse action steps, and will not use the report "in violation of any applicable Federal or State equal employment opportunity law" (§ 1681b(b)(1)(A)). A company that calls itself "FCRA certified" may mean a staff training certificate or the accreditation below; ask which.
The industry credential is PBSA's Background Screening Organization Accreditation Program (BSOAP). According to PBSA's accreditation FAQ, as of November 2026:
- The Background Screening Credentialing Council, made up of PBSA members and community members, oversees the program and selects and oversees a third-party auditor.
- An applicant goes through a desk audit of its documents, then an onsite or virtual review; PBSA says all audits have moved to a virtual format.
- The U.S. Employment Screening Standard focuses on FCRA and Driver's Privacy Protection Act compliance; a separate General Background Screening Standard covers screening delivered outside the United States. Neither applies to drug testing or tenant screening.
- Accreditation is valid for five years if the firm completes an interim surveillance audit in its third year.
The U.S. standard, version 3.0, which PBSA's program page lists as effective from July 1, 2024, has clauses on information security, legal compliance, client education, public record researchers, verification services and business practices, including written dispute procedures (clause 2.13) and matching at least two identifiers before reporting a record (clause 2.15). Accreditation shows a company passed an audit against that standard; it does not guarantee any single report, so still ask the questions below.
Which questions should you ask every finalist?
Sources and accuracy
- For each criminal search you sell, where does the record come from: the county court, a statewide repository, federal courts, or a multi-jurisdiction database?
- Before you report a database hit, do you confirm it with the court record? Which of the two § 1681k options do you use?
- Which identifiers must match before you attribute a record to my candidate? What happens when only the name matches?
- Who searches courthouses for you, and how are those researchers vetted? (PBSA's standard asks for verification of any required private investigator license.)
Disputes, notices and local law
- Walk me through a candidate dispute: intake, reinvestigation, how you tell the candidate and how you tell us.
- Which state and city notices and fair chance steps does your platform support for the places we hire, and who updates them when a law changes?
- If you send pre-adverse and adverse notices for us, can we see the templates and the delivery record for each candidate?
- If you grade reports against our criteria, can the grade say "needs review" rather than "fail"? See building an adjudication matrix.
Data security and privacy
- Which information security certification or third-party audit do you hold, and when was it last completed?
- Where is candidate data stored and processed, including by subcontractors and offshore teams?
- How long do you keep reports and supporting documents, and how do we have them deleted?
- For international checks, how do you meet the data-protection law of each country? See the GDPR checklist for recruiters.
Turnaround, service and price
- What is your measured turnaround by search type and by jurisdiction over the last quarter, and what most often delays a report? (The legal clocks are on how long a background check takes.)
- What is included in each package price, and which court, state or third-party fees are passed through?
- Who supports our recruiters and candidates, and through which channels?
What should the contract say?
- Your permissible-purpose certification, and the company's obligation to supply current FCRA notices and forms.
- Data security duties, breach notice to you within a stated time, and your right to audit or receive audit reports.
- Retention and deletion periods for reports and documents, and return or deletion of data when the contract ends.
- A list of subcontractors and offshore processing, and notice before it changes.
- The dispute process and how you are told outcomes, plus cooperation when a candidate or agency asks questions.
- Who sends which notices, and who bears the cost of an error in a notice the company sends.
- Service levels the company defines and measures, with what happens when they are missed.
- For staffing agencies: whether reports may be shared with clients, and on what terms; see background checks for staffing agencies.
What are the red flags?
- A database search sold as a complete "nationwide criminal check," with no confirmation at the court.
- No written identity-matching rule, or reports attributed on name alone.
- Advice to put the FCRA disclosure inside the application, or to skip the pre-adverse notice when a record is "automatic."
- Job-ad or screening language such as "no felons," which several states and cities prohibit.
- "FCRA certified" claims that cannot be explained, or an accreditation that is not on PBSA's list.
- No clear answer on where data is stored or how long it is kept.
How do you compare finalists side by side?
An example scoring sheet; the weights are examples to adjust to your priorities.
| Area | Example weight | What a top score looks like |
|---|---|---|
| Accuracy and sources | 30% | Written matching rule, database hits confirmed at the court, named researcher vetting |
| Compliance support | 25% | Current notices for every place you hire, dispute process shown end to end, accreditation current |
| Data security and privacy | 20% | Recent third-party audit, stated retention, subcontractors listed |
| Turnaround and service | 15% | Measured turnaround by search and jurisdiction, clear escalation path |
| Price | 10% | Itemized package prices and pass-through fees, no unexplained extras |
The same discipline (one question list, one scoring sheet, a pilot before signing) is described for testing tools on how to evaluate pre-employment assessment vendors.
What federal guidance changed recently?
On May 12, 2025 the CFPB withdrew its 2024 advisory opinion on background screening, its 2021 advisory opinion on name-only matching and its 2024 circular on background dossiers and algorithmic scores for hiring (90 FR 20084). The statute those documents interpreted did not change: § 1681e(b)'s accuracy duty and § 1681k's public-record rule still apply, which is why the matching and source questions above matter. If a candidate disputes a report, the steps are on when a candidate disputes a background check.
Questions people ask
How do I choose a background check company?
Define the checks each role needs first, then shortlist companies that cover your locations. Confirm each one meets its FCRA duties (verifying users and purposes, reasonable procedures for maximum possible accuracy, reinvestigating disputes within 30 days, supplying the summary of rights and the notice of user responsibilities), check PBSA's list of accredited firms, ask the same written questions about sources, identity matching, disputes, local notices and data security, and put the answers into the contract.
Is there an FCRA certification for background check companies?
No. The FCRA does not license or certify screening companies. The certifications it describes run the other way: the employer certifies to the screening company that it gave the disclosure, will follow the adverse action steps and will not use the report in violation of equal employment law (15 U.S.C. 1681b(b)(1)). The closest industry credential is the Professional Background Screening Association's accreditation, an audit against a published standard.
What does PBSA accreditation mean for a background screening company?
It means the company passed an audit by a third-party auditor, overseen by PBSA's Background Screening Credentialing Council, against PBSA's published standard; the U.S. Employment Screening Standard focuses on FCRA and Driver's Privacy Protection Act compliance. PBSA says accreditation is valid for five years if the firm completes an interim surveillance audit in its third year, and the standards do not apply to drug testing or tenant screening. Check PBSA's Accredited Firms list.
What questions should I ask a background check company before signing?
Ask where each criminal search comes from and whether database results are confirmed with the court before they are reported; how records are matched to the right person; how disputes are handled and how you are told the outcome; which state and city notices and fair chance steps the platform supports; where data is stored, for how long and who can see it; which subcontractors and court researchers it uses; and how it measures its own turnaround by search type.
Can a background check company send adverse action notices for us?
Yes, by arrangement, but FTC staff say the employer is liable if the screening company does not provide the notices. Review the templates, confirm they include the state and city items for every place you hire, and make sure you can see proof of delivery for each candidate.