For hiring managers

What is a hiring manager? The role, the decisions it owns, and how it divides work with recruiters

On this page
  1. What does a hiring manager do in the hiring process?
  2. How does a hiring manager divide work with the recruiter?
  3. How is a hiring manager different from other people in the process?
  4. What does the ATS call the hiring manager?
  5. What legal points does a hiring manager need to know?
  6. What makes a hiring manager easy or hard to work with?
  7. Who is the hiring manager when an agency is involved?
  8. A copy-ready hiring manager kickoff summary
  9. Questions people ask

A hiring manager is the person who asked for a new hire and will manage that person once they start. They define what the job must deliver, agree the must-haves with the recruiter, interview the finalists, and make (or recommend) the final hiring decision, while the recruiter runs the search and the process from posting to offer. Greenhouse's help center, for example, describes hiring managers as people who "typically act as subject matter experts for a role" and gives them the task of reviewing applications at the hiring manager review stage (as of November 2026). Legally, the hiring manager acts for the employer: Title VII's definition of an employer includes "any agent of such a person," so what the hiring manager asks and decides is the employer's responsibility.

Not legal advice. The legal points below summarize the federal statutes and EEOC pages linked, as published in November 2026. State and city laws add their own rules; check them for each location you hire in.

What does a hiring manager do in the hiring process?

  1. Makes the case for the hire and raises the requisition against an approved headcount plan; see what is a requisition number and the headcount planning template.
  2. Defines the job: the outcomes for the first year, the must-have skills, the level and the pay range, usually in the job description and at the intake meeting (see intake meeting questions).
  3. Designs the interview with the recruiter: the stages, who interviews for what, and the scorecard each interviewer fills in.
  4. Reviews candidates the recruiter presents and gives fast, specific feedback on each.
  5. Interviews, often last in the loop so the earlier interviewers' evidence is in.
  6. Runs or joins the debrief and makes the decision or recommendation; see what is a hiring debrief.
  7. Helps close the candidate: a call about the work and the team often matters more than the recruiter's call about the package.
  8. Owns the start: day one, the onboarding plan and the 30, 60 and 90-day check-ins.

How does a hiring manager divide work with the recruiter?

Decision or taskHiring managerRecruiter
What the role must deliver and the must-havesOwnsChallenges and tests against the market
Where and how to find candidatesSuggestsOwns
First screenAgrees the knockout criteriaRuns it
Interview plan and scorecardOwns the contentOwns the structure and consistency
Scheduling and candidate updatesKeeps the calendar openOwns, often through a recruiting coordinator
Feedback after each stageGives it within the agreed windowChases it and passes it on
Hiring decisionMakes or recommends itAdvises, and checks the evidence supports it
Offer terms and negotiationAgrees the range and the case for exceptionsRuns the conversation

This is the usual split, not a rule. The full chart from requisition to start date, with HR, finance, the coordinator and interviewers, is the hiring process RACI template; the response times both sides commit to are in the recruiting SLA with hiring managers. Greenhouse's glossary draws the same line in one sentence each: recruiters "typically guide and provide structure for the overall hiring process," hiring managers are the subject matter experts (Greenhouse Recruiting glossary, as of November 2026).

How is a hiring manager different from other people in the process?

RoleWhat they ownHow they differ from the hiring manager
RecruiterThe search and the processDoes not manage the hire after the start date
Interviewer or panelistOne part of the assessmentScores evidence; does not own the decision. See interview panel roles
Approver (the manager's leader, finance)The budget and the final sign-offMay never meet the candidate
HR business partnerPolicy, leveling, pay equity and complianceAdvises; rarely decides who is hired
Hiring committeeThe decision, in organizations that use oneReplaces a single decider; see the hiring committee packet
Client hiring manager (agency work)The decision on agency candidatesWorks for the client; the agency recruiter never decides

What does the ATS call the hiring manager?

Most applicant tracking systems name a hiring manager on each job. In Greenhouse, hiring manager is one of four hiring team roles (with recruiter, coordinator and sourcer). Users assigned as hiring managers are responsible for "reviewing applications in the hiring manager review stage," see an Applications to Review panel on their dashboard while candidates are in that stage, and need Job Admin permissions or above to be assigned (Greenhouse, "Hiring team role: Hiring manager", as of November 2026). Greenhouse's article gives the hiring manager the job-specific parts of the interview, such as take-home exercises, code reviews and finance-specific behavioral questions. Assigning the role correctly is what sends review tasks to the right person instead of leaving them in a recruiter's inbox.

What makes a hiring manager easy or hard to work with?

From the recruiter's side, the difference is rarely about seniority. It is whether the hiring manager:

  • agrees the must-haves at intake and does not add new ones after seeing the first candidates;
  • gives feedback within the agreed window, with a reason a recruiter can act on ("no evidence of running a budget," not "not a fit");
  • keeps interview slots open in the weeks the role is active;
  • scores before the debrief instead of being swayed by the loudest voice in it;
  • closes the candidate personally when it matters.

When those break down, the recruiter's options are in how to push back on a hiring manager. For a manager hiring for the first time, the first-time hiring manager interview guide and the hiring manager interview checklist cover the interview itself, and should the hiring manager do the phone screen covers the most common question about the first stage. Interview Signal, which we make, is a desktop app for the person running the interview, hiring managers included: it builds a question guide from the job description and fills a scorecard with the candidate's own quotes, and it has no ATS integration, so notes are pasted in (see Interview Signal for hiring managers).

Who is the hiring manager when an agency is involved?

When a staffing or search agency fills the role, the hiring manager is the client's manager who needs the person. The agency recruiter takes the brief from them on a client intake call, presents candidates in a submittal, and passes the hiring manager's feedback back to the candidate. The decision stays with the client. For temporary workers the agency is the employer, but the client's hiring manager still directs the daily work; the split of duties is in what is a staffing agency.

A copy-ready hiring manager kickoff summary

HIRING MANAGER KICKOFF SUMMARY (example)
Role: ____________   Req #: ______   Hiring manager: ____________
Why the role is open: [ ] new headcount  [ ] backfill  [ ] other ____
What this person must deliver in year one:
  1. ________________________________
  2. ________________________________
Must-haves (screen-out if missing):  ________________________________
Nice-to-haves:  ________________________________
Pay range approved: $______ - $______   Approved by: ________
Interview stages and owners:
  Screen: recruiter   Stage 2: ________   Final: hiring manager
Scorecard agreed:  [ ] yes  (link: ________)
Feedback window after each interview: __ business hours
Decision made by: [ ] hiring manager  [ ] committee  [ ] other ____
Interview time blocked on calendar: ______________________
Target start date: __/__/____

The summary is an example to adapt. Fill it in at the end of the intake meeting and send it to both sides the same day; most later disagreements trace back to a line that was left blank. General information as of November 2026; not legal advice.

Questions people ask

What is a hiring manager?

A hiring manager is the person who asked for a new hire and will manage that person once they start. They define what the job needs, take part in or lead the interviews, and make or recommend the final hiring decision, while a recruiter runs the search and the process. In a small company the hiring manager may also be the owner or a team lead who does the recruiting themselves.

Is the hiring manager the same as the recruiter?

No. The recruiter manages the process: posting, sourcing, screening, scheduling through a coordinator, keeping candidates informed and negotiating the offer. The hiring manager owns the job and the decision: what the role must deliver, who meets the bar, and who gets the offer. Agency recruiters work for a client company, so the hiring manager there is the client's manager.

Does the hiring manager make the final decision?

Usually, but not always alone. In most companies the hiring manager makes the decision or recommendation after a debrief with the other interviewers, and the offer still needs approval from finance, HR or the manager's own leader. Some organizations use a hiring committee instead. Whoever decides, the decision is the employer's under anti-discrimination law.

Can a hiring manager ask anything they want in an interview?

No. A hiring manager acts for the employer, and Title VII defines an employer to include its agents, so questions and decisions by a hiring manager are the employer's. Before a conditional job offer, the ADA bars asking whether an applicant has a disability or about its nature or severity, though the manager may ask about the ability to perform job-related functions. State and city laws add limits on topics such as salary history.

Should a candidate contact the hiring manager directly?

A short, polite note after an interview is usually fine, but scheduling, status and pay questions should go to the recruiter, who runs the process. When an agency is involved, the candidate should go through the agency recruiter unless the client asks otherwise.